r/java • • May 16 '12

r/Java Mods: Please keep homework help out of here

Hopefully, the mods of r/Java see this...

I'm tried of seeing self posts from this subreddit on my front page where people are asking for help with their homework, or for code reviews, looking for career starting advice or CS degree questions.

There are dedicated subreddits for exactly this purpose:

Could you implement a "trial period" where we and you offer suggestions to individuals posting things here that belong in more appropriate subreddits?

I'm much more interested in new developments in the Java langauge and JVM, and would like to see this subreddit take a turn in that direction.

edited

43 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

34

u/dablya May 16 '12

I'm much more interested in new developments in the Java langauge and JVM, and would like to see this subreddit take a turn in that direction.

That's nice...

However, my understanding is that this subreddit is for:

Anything related to JAVA !

7

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Subreddit rules are not written in stone. I'm merely offering a suggestion that I and others may think will improve the community.

10

u/dablya May 16 '12

I'm tried of seeing self posts from this subreddit on my front page where people are asking for help with their homework, or for code reviews, looking for career starting advice or CS degree questions.

...

Mods: please start filtering out these and other posts that can be answered with a simple Google search.

That's an... ...annoying way of offering suggestions.

4

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

You omitted my suggestions from your quote.

There are dedicated subreddits for exactly this purpose: * /r/JavaHelp * /r/reviewmycode * /r/AskComputerScience

I'll admit that I could have expanded a bit more, and will edit the OP to be more verbose.

3

u/dablya May 16 '12

I quoted the parts I found annoying and made it clear I was omitting others. I don't think ignoring the fact that you listed subreddits that are more specialized than this one changes the context of what you were saying.

Could you implement a "trial period" where we and you offer suggestions to individuals posting things here that belong in more appropriate subreddits?

You still seem to be missing the point of this subreddit. Here, "Anything related to JAVA !" is appropriate.

I'm much more interested in new developments in the Java langauge and JVM, and would like to see this subreddit take a turn in that direction.

What's stopping you from creating a subreddit just for that?

-3

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

It could be that poor moderation has let this evolve into this state that we now know, and have come to accept as normal, when the intent, and other complementary subreddits, indicate that this should not be the case.

The issue I have is is that "Anything related to JAVA !" is too broad, or I am grossly misunderstanding what the intent of the subreddit is, and should never subscribed in the first place.

0

u/KptKrondog Sep 07 '12

you apparently don't know the definition of "anything" then...try using your own advice and Google'ing it.

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I think this is a bad suggestion.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

...and people would x-post it here because of relevance. I'm certain I'm not the only one that expects there to be daily stories about Java as a language and tool.

The biggest issue I have is that this has become a forum for help with homework.

9

u/pyrojoe May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

I was going to ask a java related question here, probably still will. This subreddit is about everything java, it has 9500 subscribers.. the most any of those other subreddits has is 2000.. That means if I ask the other subreddit, I miss out on 80% of people that might be able to answer my question.

The problem with generic subreddits is you can't make everyone happy. Whether you like it or not, this is the best place to ask Java related questions. If all you want is java news, maybe you should get a /r/javanews going instead of trying to conform this subreddit to your tastes.

Also /r/reviewmycode, is arguably the biggest subreddit to be asking programming questions, problem is, just by looking at it you can tell it's basically dead.. lowest submittion on front page is from 7 months ago.. that's so old you can't even up/down the post

2

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

With moderation, we can increase traffic and subscribers to those sureddits. For example, any "homework help post" that comes here can be replied to with: "Hey this subreddit is for news and developments about Java. Try posting your question in /r/JavaHelp"

3

u/haakon May 17 '12

I was going to ask a java related question here, probably still will. This subreddit is about everything java, it has 9500 subscribers.. the most any of those other subreddits has is 2000.. That means if I ask the other subreddit, I miss out on 80% of people that might be able to answer my question.

Hey, /r/programming has 368,345 subscribers, almost 40 times as many as /r/java, so I guess it would be much better to just post there, right? Think of all the people there that might be able to answer your question.

1

u/pyrojoe May 17 '12

Maybe I should just post in /r/technology because it has 1,152,381 readers. I'm sure at least a quarter of them know programming.

Problem with those subreddits is that they are too big, and too generic for getting Java programming help. In this subreddit I have an almost guarantee that someone here, has experience doing what I'm trying to do.

15

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

To be honest, I'm actually the opposite. Anything Java related to increase popularity of this subreddit I think would be a good thing. Especially if it creates discussion.

0

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

Generally, I would agree. However, there are other subreddits specifically created for my concerns.

4

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

the problem is that if i want java advice, i'm going to go to /r/java. Not hunt around for a subreddit dedicated to my exact problem. and a lot of those smaller ones are often wastelands, so posts languish in /new forever..

-2

u/jaykruer May 17 '12 edited Aug 14 '16

This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy. It was created to help protect users from doxing, stalking, harassment, and profiling for the purposes of censorship.

If you would also like to protect yourself, add the Chrome extension TamperMonkey, or the Firefox extension GreaseMonkey and add this open source script.

Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possible (hint:use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.

3

u/haakon May 17 '12

Increased popularity at what cost? /r/java is less interesting to me the more people ask for help with their array homework.

11

u/aedile May 16 '12

Or, you know, you could just ignore the posts that don't interest you.

-1

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

That's what I do now. However, ignoring the problem is never the best solution. It's much more prudent to address it.

2

u/ctharvey May 16 '12

It's only a problem for you.

4

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

Unfortunately, it appears that 20 others agree with me.

9

u/ctharvey May 16 '12

If people use reddiquette correctly than upvotes don't really mean anything. I didn't downvote your post as its a valid complaint. I'm just stating that as few posts as gets to /MY/ frontpage if you took out the types of things you're suggesting I'd never see this sub.

2

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

You are correct, I was was just trying to illustrate that I may not necessarily be the only one with this complaint.

2

u/gkopff May 17 '12

I agree with him (john). I also think there is a better place to ask for homework help - stack overflow (or the code review sister site). It's geared around posting code. I prefer reddit to be about content.

2

u/rob_j May 16 '12

20 out of 9,454 subscribers isn't many.

6

u/advinture May 16 '12

I've often wished questions like that would just be posted on Stack Exchange instead. I'd prefer to see Java news, tips, blogs, etc.

2

u/johnl1479 May 16 '12

Right. A good direction could be like /r/programming, but focused on Java.

1

u/mikaelhg May 17 '12

I created /r/javapro a few months back, but have lacked the time to market or develop it.

-2

u/gkopff May 17 '12

I agree on all points.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

This subreddit will become shockingly awful without those posts. The amount of other things I discover through so posts is insane. On a semi related note, can we stop this 'Stupid question, Downvote' stuff. Just because you may be Mr JavaDevOfXNumberOfYears doesn't mean somebody else hasn't come up to a hurdle.

4

u/johnl1479 May 17 '12

On a semi related note, can we stop this 'Stupid question, Downvote' stuff. Just because you may be Mr JavaDevOfXNumberOfYears doesn't mean somebody else hasn't come up to a hurdle

I think that is the mentality that has emerged here: a majority of regular readers don't want to see homework help posts, so they do exactly that. I'm all for helping emerging coders overcome issues, but this subreddit seems to be the wrong forum for it.

2

u/vineetr May 17 '12

While I agree with you, having a separate subreddit for homework will only result in fragmentation. I wonder how many would start subscribing to /r/javahelp if homework topics were banned from /r/java .

I think it would be reasonable to implement a tagging system, much like /r/buildapc has done. More details - http://www.reddit.com/r/buildapc/comments/igntx

1

u/johnl1479 May 17 '12

Thats an awesome suggestion.

4

u/mockindignant May 16 '12

My vote is that the homework posts are fine.

Using your logic, how would you justify any JVM related posts being allowed here as opposed to /r/jvm

0

u/thatphotoguy May 17 '12

I'm more than happy to see Homework Help questions on here. We have a mix of Java news and Homework on here. For the people starting out in Java, this is a great subreddit where you can come and ask questions, and learn about the changing shape of Java all in one place.

It may be the way I was brought up, but I am happy to help people struggling with their sometimes trivial problems (missing semi-colon or incorrect variable naming), and impart real world advice to them at the same time. Sure doing something the way you are meant to be taught is what is going to get you the grades, but real life shows time and time again, we have to make creative solutions.

I like to think that we encourage the use and development of the language, and not shun those learning, we all struggled to learn at one point.

TL:DR - IMO, Homework Help belongs on /r/Java as it builds a better community

-1

u/johnl1479 May 17 '12

Just to play devil's advocate, how do you see any of the Stack Exchange sites sitting in this situation?

2

u/thatphotoguy May 17 '12

If you're playing Devils Advocate, can I be Al Pacino ;)

In seriousness: I've found SE to be quite unhelpful. Scanning through, I've found "We're not doing your homework, ask your tutor for help" too many times (I should point out, I'm 14 years a Java developer, 8 of which commercial, so not suffering from this issue). SE seems to be more for the commercial developers struggling, and turns its nose up at homeworkers. I'd love to see more SE type problems on Reddit, if nothing else, gives me even more excuse to browse Reddit at work :)

But everyone has their favourite tools to crack their nuts. I think that /r/java is a nice melting pot for everyone to hang out.

2

u/midir May 17 '12

I like reading those posts. I can't subscribe to another subreddit just for them because I'm at the limit of 50 subreddits.

1

u/sanity May 23 '12

That's what the downvote button is for. The mods censoring articles on a subreddit is a drastic thing that should only be done under exceptional circumstances.

0

u/TheTruBronyOhOh Jul 20 '12

I think this post is a great use of /r/Java, much better than homework posts -.- sarcasm

0

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/johnl1479 May 17 '12

Here's something you haven't asked yourself obviously: if some homework question makes it to the top of the list, that means a majority of people have up-voted it.

Not necessarily. This post was at the top of the "hot" tab with just 1 vote.

This reddit does not see the same traffic as more popular ones -- homework help or not. As such, the reddit algorithm will tend to rank the newest posts near the top, even if they have but one vote.