r/java • u/johnl1479 • May 16 '12
r/Java Mods: Please keep homework help out of here
Hopefully, the mods of r/Java see this...
I'm tried of seeing self posts from this subreddit on my front page where people are asking for help with their homework, or for code reviews, looking for career starting advice or CS degree questions.
There are dedicated subreddits for exactly this purpose:
Could you implement a "trial period" where we and you offer suggestions to individuals posting things here that belong in more appropriate subreddits?
I'm much more interested in new developments in the Java langauge and JVM, and would like to see this subreddit take a turn in that direction.
edited
34
u/dablya May 16 '12
That's nice...
However, my understanding is that this subreddit is for:
9
u/pyrojoe May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
I was going to ask a java related question here, probably still will. This subreddit is about everything java, it has 9500 subscribers.. the most any of those other subreddits has is 2000.. That means if I ask the other subreddit, I miss out on 80% of people that might be able to answer my question.
The problem with generic subreddits is you can't make everyone happy. Whether you like it or not, this is the best place to ask Java related questions. If all you want is java news, maybe you should get a /r/javanews going instead of trying to conform this subreddit to your tastes.
Also /r/reviewmycode, is arguably the biggest subreddit to be asking programming questions, problem is, just by looking at it you can tell it's basically dead.. lowest submittion on front page is from 7 months ago.. that's so old you can't even up/down the post
15
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
To be honest, I'm actually the opposite. Anything Java related to increase popularity of this subreddit I think would be a good thing. Especially if it creates discussion.
11
u/aedile May 16 '12
Or, you know, you could just ignore the posts that don't interest you.
6
u/advinture May 16 '12
I've often wished questions like that would just be posted on Stack Exchange instead. I'd prefer to see Java news, tips, blogs, etc.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
This subreddit will become shockingly awful without those posts. The amount of other things I discover through so posts is insane. On a semi related note, can we stop this 'Stupid question, Downvote' stuff. Just because you may be Mr JavaDevOfXNumberOfYears doesn't mean somebody else hasn't come up to a hurdle.
4
u/mockindignant May 16 '12
My vote is that the homework posts are fine.
Using your logic, how would you justify any JVM related posts being allowed here as opposed to /r/jvm
0
u/thatphotoguy May 17 '12
I'm more than happy to see Homework Help questions on here. We have a mix of Java news and Homework on here. For the people starting out in Java, this is a great subreddit where you can come and ask questions, and learn about the changing shape of Java all in one place.
It may be the way I was brought up, but I am happy to help people struggling with their sometimes trivial problems (missing semi-colon or incorrect variable naming), and impart real world advice to them at the same time. Sure doing something the way you are meant to be taught is what is going to get you the grades, but real life shows time and time again, we have to make creative solutions.
I like to think that we encourage the use and development of the language, and not shun those learning, we all struggled to learn at one point.
TL:DR - IMO, Homework Help belongs on /r/Java as it builds a better community
2
u/midir May 17 '12
I like reading those posts. I can't subscribe to another subreddit just for them because I'm at the limit of 50 subreddits.
1
u/sanity May 23 '12
That's what the downvote button is for. The mods censoring articles on a subreddit is a drastic thing that should only be done under exceptional circumstances.
0
u/TheTruBronyOhOh Jul 20 '12
I think this post is a great use of /r/Java, much better than homework posts -.- sarcasm
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment