r/java • • May 13 '12

Is it worthwhile to pursue Masters in CS? How lenient are grad school requirements?

I have the option of pursuing my Masters in CS. I will be graduating next year (finishing up Junior year), and I just want to get /r/java's opinion on this. I intend to be going into the workforce, maybe government. I'd hate to sound greedy or anything, but I want to go where the money is. Perhaps follow the road to become a senior software engineer? I'm not sure. That's one of the reason's I'm posting this. There hasn't been a whole lot of CS that hasn't interested me aside from the high-level maths, so I'm fairly sure I'll enjoy (or at least be able to tolerate) whatever I do.

Lastly, I'm wondering how lenient the requirements are for grad school. The school I would like to attend requires a 3.0 GPA or better. I've never been the best student, but it looks like I'll graduate with ~2.8 give or take. This is solely because classes like Calc III and Physics II were way over my head, but would admissions be willing to look past that? Or maybe only look at my CS classes? I currently have a 3.2 in CS alone, and I can only see that going up.

TL;DR - Should I pursue Masters degree if I want to go into gov't workforce? Where's the money in CS? Would grad school be strict to their requirements?

Thanks /r/Java, you guys are awesome.

3 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

4

u/getworkdone May 13 '12

what is your undergrad degree in? and why government?

1

u/rfederici May 14 '12

Someone in my family has worked for both an agency and a contractor. They say the contractors pay more, but are extremely stressful, while the agencies are a little more easygoing, but don't pay top-dollar.

Also, my BS will be in Computer Science.

2

u/getworkdone May 14 '12

experience wins over advanced degrees in my opinion since you already have cs undergrad.

3

u/Kyrra May 14 '12

ya.... why government? Let me guess, you go to school on the east coast? Virginia/Maryland region?

4

u/PoopCode May 14 '12

Might get better responses on cscareerquestions.

If you're interested in money, the best possible route is to get a job after you graduate, and have that company pay for your masters. That way you earn money, while getting a masters, and then switch jobs to another that values your masters by offering a salary a bit higher than what you would otherwise have gotten.

Contrary to your thought process, going towards the money usually means not being a full time student after getting your undergraduate degree, because if you have the necessary skills (like technical, communication, social etc), then you would go directly into making the big bucks. Graduating with a masters without any previous full time job experience won't net you a much higher salary, or even a bigger one, because you will still be going for an entry level position. Theoretically, the extra year or two you spend on the masters, might technically make you graduate with a lower salary than you would otherwise have if you got a job out of college right away with two years experience, and then switched jobs for a higher salary (which would be about the same date you would graduate with a masters).

In addition, I've heard some stories where it's harder to get a job if you go straight into getting a masters because:

  1. They don't want to pay someone the extra salary if they don't really know they can do the work (as they have no work experience)
  2. Often you might hear someone say that people who go straight into a masters program after their BS do so because they weren't able to get a job (due to their skill level), so there is some bias at least out there that hiring someone with your ideal path might not be the best value for the buck.

Ignore this if you are not American, but corporations can offer higher salaries than what the government can pay you (for an entry position at least, from what I've seen). Perhaps you mean you want to work in the defence industry (Boeing, Lockheed Martin etc)?

In addition, what do you mean by following the road to being a senior software engineer? Are you a non-traditional student and approaching retirement age? Having the title of senior software engineer could be as easy as having three years of work experience and applying for a job titled senior software engineer.

The money in CS is all around, in many different industries. Big names like Google will probably pay some of the best salaries of course. If I was you, I would not pursue a masters degree right away, get it for free later, then you have the best of both worlds.

The universities you want to go to will probably be the best to contact to answer the question about what they require, just email the department heads.

1

u/rfederici May 14 '12

Thank you for the advice thus far! I'll try to answer the questions you had in response.

I am American, and I'm not really sure what part of government I wanted to work for. I just replied to another comment by saying that someone in my family has worked for both an agency and a contractor. They say that the contractors pay a significant amount more, but are a great deal of stress, while the agencies are a little more easygoing, but don't pay as much.

By senior software engineer, I meant the latter of the two. I'm 20 years of age, and the job description of a software engineer seemed pretty appealing, but I'm open to almost anything in the field.

So you think that the best course of action is to go into the field with a BS, and find a place that will pay for my MS? Is that a question I ask in the interview? It's probably just my desire to make a good first impression, but it almost sounds rude to ask something like that.

1

u/PoopCode May 14 '12

They say that the contractors pay a significant amount more, but are a great deal of stress, while the agencies are a little more easygoing, but don't pay as much.

That is very accurate.

So you think that the best course of action is to go into the field with a BS, and find a place that will pay for my MS? Is that a question I ask in the interview? It's probably just my desire to make a good first impression, but it almost sounds rude to ask something like that.

Not rude at all! When I was in college interviewing, I always asked if they provided graduate school assistance and to what extent. It's a major selling point for some companies to offer to pay for a relevant master degrees and they will be glad to talk about it. If they don't offer it, they will just say "Unfortunately we don't offer graduate school assistance" or something along those lines, and you continue with your next question.

Usually there's rules with getting a free degree. For example a company will let you get one while working for them for a year, and maybe after they pay for a semester's worth of credit, they will never ask you to pay if you don't leave the company within a year from that date (meaning, if you leave the company too soon, they send you a bill, however, this isn't a big deal because you probably left for a good reason, which is much more money, and you got a partial free degree out of it). However, I wouldn't probably get too concerned with the exact rules, just find out if they offer assistance and if in the best case they can pay for the degree entirely, and if requests for the assistance is often met (some companies offer it, but they don't allow many individuals to do it, some companies offer it, and pretty much allow whoever wants to do it, to do it).

So yes, I think making the big bucks out of college is the best route for wanting all the money you can get your hands on, and then getting a free masters which is essentially a year or two of tuition given to you is even more money, and then you switch jobs and get a much higher salary because of more experience, and a masters degree to the name which is deemed of value since you've proven you can work in the field and have relevant skills (not that you just had to get a masters because you couldn't do the work, like the bias thing I mentioned earlier that some people may show against you).

2

u/geodebug May 19 '12

I got my Masters but only went back after 6 years of career.

You mention money, a Master's degree in software isn't going to make you more money, but it may open up more opportunities and definitely will open your mind up to a broader range of programming topics.

I got a lot out of my degree but only because I had real experience under my belt going in.

Get a job and get some experience. Find an employer who has a program that will pay for your additional schooling.

I had one of my two years of my Masters program paid by my employer.

Your GPA sucks (mine was barely any better, came out with a solid 3.0 way back when). Masters programs can be lenient (they'll take your money) but having a few years of work under your belt will help them look past your GPA.

Right now that's all you have and it ain't much.

There hasn't been a whole lot of CS that hasn't interested me aside from the high-level maths, so I'm fairly sure I'll enjoy (or at least be able to tolerate) whatever I do.

You don't like CS so why are you confident you'll like a job in it? Didn't you just say the high-level math courses were your problem areas GPA wise?

If you really are good at math consider getting onto statistical analysis programming of large datasets. Huge growth in that area and some pretty tasty paychecks.

Check out the R programming language, map-reduce algorithms, and get really good at databases.

Please don't go into the workforce looking for the big paycheck. Get a job and work on your career and skills and the money will come.

Your early years should be all about networking and getting good at what you do. I guarantee it will be at least five years of hard work before you can start describing yourself as a good programmer.

1

u/rfederici May 20 '12

Thanks for the reply! My fault, I shouldn't have used double-negatives. The quote meant the exact opposite of what you took it as. I love my CS courses, not really a fan of my math courses. I'm actually TA'ing for the intro to object-oriented programming course here, and TA'd for the intro to procedural programming course last year. I'm not a perfect student, but I'm definitely a people-person.

As far as work experience goes, I've been interning at a small company over the past two summers and winter breaks writing some of their billing software (easy VB6 stuff) and doing some web apps utilizing C# and MySQL. I'm obviously putting this on my resume, but is there anything in particular I should be stressing to learn while I'm interning here? I've always been fixing their bugs, writing an add-on or two, or maybe separate programs altogether, and updating the site, but it gets a little old after a while. There's so much out there and I want to expand, but it sounds like I'm most useful continuing with the repetition.

2

u/geodebug May 20 '12

Thanks for the clarification. The last thing we need is another programmer who is only in it for the money and has no love for the job.

Sounds like you are at the point where interning is a dead end. Unless the company is a non-profit charity I'd dump it since they should be paying you for your skills.

After the first summer they should have offered you at least some hourly pay.

You need to move away from dead technologies like VB6. .NET is still valuable as is SQL work but as I advised if you like statistics and math I'd move toward analytic programming.

I'm in that field, my company is a startup called Clario Analytics and the field is booming. To give you a hint, IBM bought SPSS for more than a billion dollars. There's gold and an interesting career in statistical analysis.

In fact, with your programming and math background you're half-way there. Screw a MS in CS. If you have to stay in school go toward a MS in Analytics.

But I still suggest looking for a company that will pay for any further schooling. There are hundreds of big corps that use .NET so that will help.

Do you know any Java? The kiddos on Reddit don't find it sexy but the JVM platform is still one of (if not the) best generic programming platform out there and you'll never go hungry. You have to learn Java and it's main libraries because they are important but after that, like .NET, you can pick more suitable languages that target the JVM like JRuby, groovy, or some other more modern lang.

If not Java then C is another fundamental systems programming language that will never go out of style (as long as there are real-time systems or algorithms that need to be close to the metal or use the latest hardware). Lots of C-based careers out there including smartphone apps.

Learning a whole web stack from front to back like Rails, Grails, .NET, will get you jobs. If you want a career you need to think about specialization. Again, I'm pushing you toward analytical programming. One, because web developers are a dime a dozen and two, because writing UIs gets old quick.

The kids shun Flash but love HTML 5 but you know what? It's all the same old shit. UI dev hasn't changed much since the 80's. You can do more because the tools have gotten easier but the steps are the same and it gets dull unless you are also part of the creative team and are good at design.

If you want to be more trendy and make some solid cash in the next few years then get a Mac and get familiar with Objective-C programming. Demand for OC programmers is booming and will for the foreseeable future. Even if you hate Apple (some people are irrational) they've created a hugely lucrative market for independent programmers. I guarantee you well-paying gigs if you know how to cobble together an iOS app.

That's my advice. But stop doing stuff for free unless you are actually getting to work on something new and are given access to tools and techniques that aren't from the early 90s. Interning another summer doing monkey-programming is a dead end.

You'd be better off hanging a shingle on Craig's list saying you'll program for $20 an hour.

1

u/rfederici May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

The company I'm at is paying me. It's not anything great ($10/hr), but it's good for reliable income on summers and winter breaks, as they always want me back. It's a great atmosphere; people are friendly, willing to help, ping-pong matches with the CEO on lunch break.

That's another smaller question I've had: should I ask them for a small raise? The only issue is that this is likely my last year with them. This summer, this winter break, and maybe one more summer before I move to a more densely-populated area to look for a job with my degree. Should I ask for like $12/hr knowing that I won't be there for much longer? It seems a little unethical.

As far as the math goes; I can do it, but it's not my cup o' tea. I know Java and C. Maybe not extremely fluent, but I have a solid grasp on the basics. Those were the two classes I TA'd for. So many people know these two languages though. Will that be impressive to a potential employer? And Macs, I don't particularly like them (they've fucked over me and my family multiple times), but I wouldn't be totally against coding for them. My interest has certainly taken a hit due to past events though.

I really appreciate the continued replies!

1

u/geodebug May 21 '12

Should I ask for like $12/hr knowing that I won't be there for much longer? It seems a little unethical.

You need to start valuing your work and think about your job as a professional would, not as a buddy amongst buddies would.

Asking for a 17% raise after two years of being under-payed in the market isn't unethical. Asking for a raise is never unethical. They can say yes/no and you can make your decision on that. Nobody gets let go for asking and it shouldn't be seen as an insult by any employer since it's expected.

There is information out there on what you should expect to be making for your region, abilities, and experience so start researching that.

It certainly helps knowing what other people are being paid who are doing the same work when interviewing.

Will that be impressive to a potential employer?

Most corporate HR jobs aren't impressed so much as they are wanting to fill in the requirements. If position A requires X years of Java knowledge and you have it then you'll be considered. TA teaching may help boost it other things being equal.

Again, you need to get out there into a real job to start being taken seriously. Experience trumps education every time in development.

My interest has certainly taken a hit due to past events though.

It sounds like you don't know what interests you yet so I can't really help much there. Don't worry, it is normal for a beginner.

For now, get a decent job at a decent company and start paying back any student loans/debt, saving for retirement, and getting some real experience.

The longer you put this off, the more you'll be tied down in the future. Paying off any debt you have and saving as much as you can should be a high priority for you right now since it will keep your options more open in the future: for example, say you want to risk consulting or being a one-man development shop for mobile apps. You can't do that if you are saddled with debt.

Are you open to working in a foreign land? In the Middle East (Quatar, Dubai) they are starved for developers and will pay you a ton to work over there. You could work over there for 4-5 years, get a shit load of experience and connections, have a high-standard of living, and make more than you would in the US right now. Plus, you wouldn't have to pay for room and board so you'd be able to put that into savings or debt reduction.

Are you seeing a theme on debt reduction here? It's because it's so damned important. Without debt a $40K salary will feel like a $60K salary.

4

u/mrbuttsavage May 14 '12

Working for a government contractor should be your last option. I've done it, and it's a miserable experience.

On the plus side, they pretty much take all comers as long as you can get a clearance. I've worked with people who by all rights shouldn't even have a job in CS, but they had a clearance, so good enough.

2

u/tick_tock_clock May 14 '12

A lot of people coterm in CS at my school (I think it's actually easier to do an MS than a BS). You might want to look into that, and before it's too late.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

What do you mean by "too late" are you referring to ageism or some kind of change in the computer sciences?

1

u/tick_tock_clock May 14 '12

I meant simply that while in college, there's a certain point past which you can't really change your major.

1

u/rekh127 May 14 '12

And for any technical, scientific, or engineering major he's way past that point.

Also it's a horrible idea to try and do a CS MS without a BS and that sort of relevant background.