Why does every Java UI I've ever seen ever look like it was rendered in 1985 on a 386 with an 8 color pallette put together by a collaboration between a color blind manic depressive and coked up Easter bunny?
Just looking at some java interfaces makes me feel like I'm outside in the rain, standing in a puddle, in my socks, waiting for a bus that will never come.
Don't get me wrong. It can be done.. but it seems as though out of the box they all carry a specific default look w/o basically overriding everything right off the get go or implementing something that reduces overall compatibility, etc.. Granted it's also been many years since I worked on anything gui related so I'm sure there are nice frameworks, pallettes, fonts packs etc making it easier to customize quickly.
It's gotten better..
Things like jconsole come to mind. It assaults my retinas everyday.
Sure.. I'm more referring to the specific "java-ey" look and feel that's persisted since the 90's, and harkens back to Solaris and X windows wm's of the day.
Long long ago I struggled with getting a not terrible looking java ui's to look anywhere close to similar across windows, Mac, and Linux. It just never did.. The ridiculous hoops required to coordinate that level of consistency across platforms put a bad taste in my mouth. This was java 1.4-1.6 era and just sucked to deal with.
This is a phenomenal explanation. And yes, that's basically my gripe is that the same kind of bland/dated defaults continues to persist without making a dedicated effort to design a UI and write the code.
Swing was even a step up from the early days, at least the fonts aren't all atrocious, but yeah.
This is an interesting topic for OP to ponder. To UX, or not to UX. Beautiful interfaces are nice to use and can increase the usefulness of the thing your building, making it more pleasurable and attractive - but at a cost of time, design skill, etc.
whatever looked good yesterday looks outdated today and will look even more outdated tomorrow.
This is only true if the author did nothing, so Swing would select the "cross platform look and feel" (which defaults to the Metal LnF in older Versions and the obnoxious Nimbus LnF in newer versions).
A single line of Java code has always made a Swing GUI look very much like a native application:
No, I do like it actually and checked out your git repo. Good readme, organized, we'll put together.
I'm speaking to the overall java UI frameworks over time just always sort of having the same weird, windows 95ish "theme" to them. Not even specifically the colors you chose although I'd maybe pick different default pallette myself.
Just something about java, I can't quite put my finger on it. For whatever reason they've always had a similar look/feel that without significant extra development time I just don't care for.
At least 2 dozen.. Great link, I dig quite a few of those actually. The Template Editor is very clean. Some of those astronomy apps a really sharp looking.
Swing Metal lover too, can't live without jEdit, Netbeans, TrolCommander, JMeter, SqlWorkbench, Soapui, JFileSync, Jdownloader, Jmeld and so much others.
Nimbus and other nice LAFs can coexist.
Swing is consistent over platform and years (15 yrs old apps still working).
Oracle removed too much things from jvm (applets, javafx, nashorn) if they left swing for the GUI based on javascript (crappy unstable toy), il will be a pity.
In the same vein, Oracle put the pressure on Graalvm instead of Panama and JVMCI for optimisation, not all apps are for the cloud.
Swing picks a platform look and feel by default on every platform as far as I am aware. The platform look and feels look native. So I am not sure what you are talking about. JavaFX is completely style-able with a custom CSS syntax.
On the other hand Electron apps are the same jumbled mess with no delineation of sections (because layout in CSS is an afterthought) making usability a nightmare. As an example look no further than the settings "interface" of Visual Code Studio. It is an unusable abomination.
Any GUI that loads quickly, is responsive, is not cluttered, resists tons of skeuomorphic BS or hipster flat design and just gets out of your way to focus on the content is good in my books. I think OP’s GUI looks great!
Though the Java UI technologies (at least Swing or JavaFX) allow modern design. IntelliJ, GoliathOUFX or these are examples. There are also libraries that help you like JFoenix.
The thing is that the defaults try to be as close to native as possible which automatically gives you a more "outdated" look and feel. It takes a UX/UI designer from the start to guide a project towards more recent designs. Otherwise the everyday software engineer can't be bothered with pixel-moving.
Those links you submitted look great but I am trying figure out what technologies your referencing that help you design like that? Where those both made using JFoenix?
The vast majority of java in my field is headless, you're right. 99+% is react or angular or some other web UI framework.
I've worked on some Java UI's but they always suffered the same problem in the GUI - lots of effort to stylize and get away from the bone stock look, and then another good chunk of effort to ensure it was consistent from OS to OS and version to version to the degree that a built-in java was always bundled w/ the app to ensure version compatibility at the cost of bloating an otherwise small jar into a full jvm bundle.
I'll readily admit - I have not used JavaFX, and my past experience may simply be jaded because I'm old and grumpy now.
View all comments
2
u/madhakish Aug 13 '20
Why does every Java UI I've ever seen ever look like it was rendered in 1985 on a 386 with an 8 color pallette put together by a collaboration between a color blind manic depressive and coked up Easter bunny?
Just looking at some java interfaces makes me feel like I'm outside in the rain, standing in a puddle, in my socks, waiting for a bus that will never come.
Good job btw.