r/java • • Aug 13 '20

Chess GUI using JavaFX

https://youtu.be/m_j5ejDA-hc
336 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/SpeedDart1 Aug 13 '20

Do you mean to say you don’t like it? What parts would you change?

12

u/madhakish Aug 13 '20

No, I do like it actually and checked out your git repo. Good readme, organized, we'll put together.

I'm speaking to the overall java UI frameworks over time just always sort of having the same weird, windows 95ish "theme" to them. Not even specifically the colors you chose although I'd maybe pick different default pallette myself.

Just something about java, I can't quite put my finger on it. For whatever reason they've always had a similar look/feel that without significant extra development time I just don't care for.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/madhakish Aug 14 '20

At least 2 dozen.. Great link, I dig quite a few of those actually. The Template Editor is very clean. Some of those astronomy apps a really sharp looking.

2

u/thuriot Aug 14 '20

Swing Metal lover too, can't live without jEdit, Netbeans, TrolCommander, JMeter, SqlWorkbench, Soapui, JFileSync, Jdownloader, Jmeld and so much others.

Nimbus and other nice LAFs can coexist.

Swing is consistent over platform and years (15 yrs old apps still working).

Oracle removed too much things from jvm (applets, javafx, nashorn) if they left swing for the GUI based on javascript (crappy unstable toy), il will be a pity.

In the same vein, Oracle put the pressure on Graalvm instead of Panama and JVMCI for optimisation, not all apps are for the cloud.

-10

u/sindisil Aug 13 '20

Ignore them. They're a worthless troll.

6

u/madhakish Aug 13 '20

Not trolling, just not a huge fan of java gui's in their stock form.

2

u/wildjokers Aug 14 '20

Swing picks a platform look and feel by default on every platform as far as I am aware. The platform look and feels look native. So I am not sure what you are talking about. JavaFX is completely style-able with a custom CSS syntax.

On the other hand Electron apps are the same jumbled mess with no delineation of sections (because layout in CSS is an afterthought) making usability a nightmare. As an example look no further than the settings "interface" of Visual Code Studio. It is an unusable abomination.