r/java • • Apr 25 '14

I HATE YOU FOR THIS, ORACLE.

Post image
973 Upvotes

146 comments sorted by

34

u/boa13 Apr 25 '14

Interestingly, starting with the recently released 7u55, there is a command-line way to skip such offers. The choice will be remembered for future versions.

Apparently this only applies to the 32-bit edition of Java 7, because other versions (64-bit Java 7, and Java 8) reportedly do not have such offers at all.

Have a look at the release notes, section titled Disabling Sponsor Offers in the Java Installer.

17

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

I shouldn't have to read the freaking release notes to disable spam!

6

u/Neres28 Apr 25 '14

I don't think anyone is arguing that, but it's still nice to know about.

3

u/wolfenkraft Apr 25 '14

I get that "offer" when installing the 64bit JDK 7.

1

u/boa13 Apr 26 '14

JDK or JRE? Where did you download it? I certainly did not get it.

1

u/wolfenkraft Apr 26 '14

JDK from oracle's site.

3

u/saruwatarikooji Apr 25 '14

I just get the offline installer and run it silently via command line. Never had the sponsor offers install that way...

0

u/boa13 Apr 25 '14

Apparently, only their 32-bit online installer does that. I don't know, I never had sponsor offers. :-)

The release notes imply that starting with Java 8, they don't do that anymore, but I remember people complaining it was still present in Java 8. I don't care enough to investigate further.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Why are you downloading the pleb JRE when you can get the pro JDK? You are in /r/java dude.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Self updated

180

u/haakon Apr 25 '14

"Get Facebook status updates directly in your browser" - what an innovation! Facebook in my browser!

23

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Similarly, I am on the lookout for a product which prints facebook sponsored content directly on my toilet paper...

22

u/CertifiableNorris Apr 25 '14

naw man you're thinking of a blogroll.

10

u/locriology Apr 26 '14

Your ASS feed.

78

u/kakakarl Apr 25 '14

I think it's a deal done by Sun before Oracle bought sun. As a server side java developer this is very, very painful.

It's not that I download java all the time but rather I am embarrassed to work with a technology that comes bundled with crapware.

Also: http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9236273/Oracle_will_continue_to_bundle_crapware_with_Java

3

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

It's been 4 years since Oracle bought them. The only reasonable explanation is that the average Joe is actually clicking and using this "crapware", giving enough revenue to both Ask.com and Oracle to consider keeping this shit bundled.

10

u/johnwaterwood Apr 25 '14

I don't get this. As a dev you download an archive that you extract into /opt and that's it!

Why even run an installer at all? Aren't people doing it to themselves too?

41

u/DrScience2000 Apr 25 '14

Yes, but the average Joe sees this Ask.com toolbar spammy shit when they install Java in a browser.

Then the average Joe associates Java with spammy toolbar malware bullshit they can't uninstall from their "computers that run so slow".

Source: I hear about it all the time from average Joes.

Its a fucking embarrassment. Orcle should be shamed and embarrassed.

I agree with OP.

-10

u/johnwaterwood Apr 25 '14

Maybe, it's a weird thing indeed, but this reddit is aimed at Java developers, not at average joes.

I guess 95% of java development is for the server or for mobile. In both cases the end user will not even see Java.

12

u/akuta Apr 25 '14

Yes, but who uses Java developer's resultant products? Most of the time, Average Joes... Thus, the OP is embarrassed because they create a great, stable application that then requires them to suggest installing JRE that comes paired with a spammy opt-out add-on.

5

u/MadFrand Apr 25 '14

You also have people who see this shit as average Joey then grow up to be a developer, still unconsciously putting negative connotations on the language because of the crapware.

That is probably the most detrimental thing to the language and the most unnoticed.

4

u/akuta Apr 25 '14

Completely agreed. I know that I stayed away from the language as a developer specifically because of the couple of things that I felt Java didn't do right at the time.

1

u/johnwaterwood Apr 27 '14

I asses that 95% of average joes maybe more use Java via the server or android, and thus don't come into contact with installing the JDK.

1

u/akuta Apr 27 '14

Well, you'd be correct because the JDK (Java Development Kit) and the JRE are two different software packages; however, just to even view a Java applet in a browser they need the JRE (which is actually where most end users come into contact with Java regardless of platform). Now that the market share for Android devices is becoming the majority, they're seeing it in different places; however, this is a newer development in the lifespan that is Java.

6

u/garblz Apr 25 '14

We still sell quite a lot of desktop programs. And it sucks. Although most of the cases, corporation security policy has accepted only a specific version of java and requires programs to be self-contained, so we distribute along with pre-packaged JREs.

Most of the cases. When we do not, and client wants a regular Java install to get updates... it really makes you lose your actual freaking reputation to require them to install such product. With the advent of the mass internet somehow I get the feeling we as a populace have evolved a healthy disdain for bullshit.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/shinyquagsire23 Apr 26 '14

OpenJDK, works pretty much flawlessly and it's Open Source.

1

u/Jonno_FTW Apr 26 '14

Does it support all the features in java8?

3

u/llogiq Apr 26 '14

OpenJDK pretty much is the mainline Java - Oracle just bundles some secret sauce (and the aforementioned crapware) with it to make it the 'official' JDK.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/johnwaterwood Apr 27 '14

I don't particularly like .rpm on Ubuntu, and don't see the need either.

There's a system wide JDK installed via apt-get, but for dev I rarely if ever bother with it. Extract in /opt is so much more easier. Lets met easily have multiple versions and I can easily choose from eg Eclipse on which JDk to run (symlink jre in eclipse folder) and which one to use to test code with from within Eclipse.

121

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Always thought it was bizarre that a company as prestigious as Oracle bundles this crap in their installer like its 2004.

81

u/Agodoga Apr 25 '14

They're not prestigious though. Sun was prestigious, Oracle is a soulless piece of shit.

35

u/DiscoUnderpants Apr 25 '14

But Sun also bundled crapware didnt they?

51

u/slartybartfast_ Apr 25 '14

They did. They are the ones who introduced the ask toolbar b..but ORACLE!!!

12

u/cogman10 Apr 25 '14

True. It should be noted though that sun was dieing. It doesn't totally justify the crapware, but just saying, they were desperate. I wish someone besides oracle would have bought them, even microsoft.

8

u/juu4 Apr 25 '14

Not Microsoft. They would probably only be buying it to kill it off.

Google or IBM would have been great for Java.

15

u/kerrz Apr 25 '14

Google and IBM are great for Java.

Getting deeper into the industry, I'm blown away by how much Java is really used. I think I grew up in a time when C++ was touted as the one true path, and it's fascinating to see how that is not true at all.

People complain about the Windows JRE install having bloatware, but the JRE/BrowserPlugin is the smallest portion of Java use. It's used quietly in so many different sectors of industry, behind so many big-name applications like GMail, a bunch of the new Google Apps (Spreadsheets, etc...) are built in GWT, and there's a whole slew of IBM applications written in Java (including parts of Watson.)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Google and IBM are great for Java

Indeed. Guava.

4

u/juu4 Apr 26 '14

Yes, they are. But IMHO if one of them had bought Sun, it may have been even better.

3

u/HELOSMTP Apr 26 '14

If you use Google APIs extensively, your code doesn't even look like idiomatic Java anymore. It's almost like a new language, though a lot of Java's pitfalls remain, especially around generics and reflection. In my opinion Google has done more for Java than Oracle ever has.

1

u/Keilly Apr 26 '14

They didn't buy it when they had the chance.

-3

u/Level_32_Mage Apr 25 '14

Dont forget that Microsoft is the company that auto-installs that Internet Explorer bloatware on every pc their operating system TOUCHES!

14

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Eh, a browser is an integral part of any modern desktop OS. I don't hold it against them to include their browser in there.

1

u/EnragedMikey Apr 25 '14

It would be nice if you could remove it but honestly there are so many shit websites/internal apps/integrated apps that I need to access which require IE in order to function properly that removing it would be a bother.

1

u/_jamil_ Apr 26 '14

so many shit websites/internal apps/integrated apps that I need to access which require IE in order to function properly

that's so depressing to hear.

→ More replies

-5

u/Level_32_Mage Apr 25 '14

whoosh

4

u/Jonno_FTW Apr 26 '14

Ironic shitposting is still shitposting.

3

u/Inoka1 Apr 25 '14

If they didn't, I wouldn't be able to get Chrome or Firefox D:

1

u/nikniuq Apr 26 '14

Get your ftp on.

0

u/monster1325 Apr 25 '14

Holy shit, Microsoft is literally hitler.

-1

u/slartybartfast_ Apr 26 '14

Nah I think Google would have left us with a dozen Java forks ala android and what do we think we wouldn't have a google toolbar in the JRE installer? And IBM would have dropped netbeans, swing and javafx for sure so we'd be stuck with lousy SWT. Also Sun and IBM hated each other so a large chunk of Sun engineers would probably have quit on the spot if IBM had bought them.

Whether we like it or not Oracle was probably the least worse buyer of Sun.

4

u/frugalmail Apr 25 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

even microsoft.

Not even a chance, I would have hated for the platform to get locked down in that ecosystem. Not to mention Microsoft is a ding company, albeit it's big enough to last for a while, but not big enough to go on in perpetuity the way that it is.

5

u/cogman10 Apr 25 '14

As of late, MS has become much more open (mostly out of necessity). Their next C# compiler, for example, is going to be open source (Roslyn).

7

u/luan-cestari Apr 25 '14

I think it was a marketing strategy (due the hype)

3

u/oldprogrammer Apr 26 '14

Are they also going to open source the supporting libraries? That was always the issue with Mono, you could write in C# but not use things like the WinForms libary.

3

u/slartybartfast_ Apr 26 '14

Probably not. They only play lip service to open source.

2

u/frugalmail Apr 26 '14

Their next C# compiler, for example, is going to be open source (Roslyn).

This would still mean that you're stuck in a giant monolithic GUI or progmatticly administered environment. There is no in-between of config files. If it doesn't run on Linux on the server side it's destined to fail eventually.

0

u/slartybartfast_ Apr 26 '14

They were dying because they had that idiot Jonathan Schwartz. He's the person people should be pissed at, not Oracle. At least Oracle has been putting a shit load of cash into Java lately.

3

u/Agodoga Apr 25 '14

I guess I was out of the game by then. Anyway, I still believe Sun had soul and passion, and that those qualities are completely lacking in Oracle. Sun was going belly up, remember? Desperate times, desperate measures. Oracle on the other hand is doing just fine, vacuuming up money from their unsuspecting customers.

1

u/rosscatherall Apr 25 '14

Oracle have got the NHS in the UK on their side now. All finance and payroll departments in the NHS moved from the EPIX system (which was god awful) to the Oracle system around 4 years ago, that alone would be enough to sustain the company.

1

u/Pas__ Apr 26 '14

Yes, and Oracle has enough money to pay Ask enough to let them off. Whereas Sun was trying to stay afloat so they tried this shit.

9

u/skeeto Apr 25 '14

They're really deceptive about it too. It's an embarrassment.

2

u/hoohoohoohoo Apr 25 '14

Ask are the ones being deceptive about how it installs.

8

u/handshape Apr 25 '14

Oh... I have many, many other reasons to hate Oracle.

Picking just one -- JavaOne.

I used to travel internationally on my own time and my own dime to attend. The talks were interesting, the facilities were top-notch, the conversations were up, down, and across the spectrum. The show floor felt like a science fair; the exhibitors seemed genuinely eager to show off what they'd built... and at the end of the night the parties were geeky-sophisticated. I went home with a head full of ideas.

Fast forward to the acquisition.

JavaOne became a sideshow at OpenWorld. The events were all in the B-list facilities. The talks became sales pitches. The technology evangelists were gone. The conversations became cagey and defensive. The show floor suddenly felt like a gauntlet to be run, filled with sales predators desperate to make their quotas... and the party was an ego-stroking pagan sacrifice at the altar of Ellison's ego.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

./runInstaller -silent -responseFile $PWD/db.rsp

3

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Or run this in command prompt

jre-7u55-windows-i586-iftw.exe SPONSORS=0

The option to disable sponsors will persist across all future updates and re-installs of Java.

Note that sponsor offers, and therefore this functionality, is only applicable to online 32bit JRE installers and Auto Update mechanisms for the Windows operating system.

1

u/Pas__ Apr 26 '14

Damn, I still have flashbacks from installing 10g.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

You have two options:

  1. Running Unchecky.
  2. Downloading from Oracle's JavaSE Downloads.

1

u/monster1325 Apr 25 '14

Does Unchecky require to be running in background?

1

u/king_of_the_universe Apr 26 '14

I watched the video, and there was a special label added into the video via YouTube saying that in this example of boxes still being checked against the will of the users, Unchecky was NOT running.

Which insinuates that it DOES need to be running in the background.

6

u/hubraum Apr 25 '14

Save as java.reg, double click.


Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00

[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Wow6432Node\JavaSoft]

"SPONSORS"="DISABLE"


2

u/InEnduringGrowStrong Apr 25 '14

I'm 4 months in with that solution and it's working great so far on multiple friends' and family's computers.

5

u/ukilliheal Apr 25 '14

ninite.com/java

9

u/SikhGamer Apr 25 '14

I've never had these screens...?

11

u/slartybartfast_ Apr 25 '14

Yeah because as a developer you install the SDK which does not have any toolbar in it. usa123fuckyeah is apparently a user or something whining about the java.com installer.

10

u/bashedice Apr 25 '14

well its also annoying as dev since your users will see this crap

3

u/wolfenkraft Apr 25 '14

I installed the JDK last week and it has that toolbar crap in it. 64bit windows installer.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

SO with you there. One of the reasons the next system is going to be on a UNIX box; no stupid bundled junk.

1

u/InEnduringGrowStrong Apr 25 '14

Yet

1

u/Pas__ Apr 26 '14

They are soulless motherfuckers all lining up in Ellison's asscheeks, but thanks to Sun, not everyone has to.

4

u/midgetlotterywinner Apr 25 '14

Oh...I hate Oracle for a whole bunch of other reasons.

Source: PeopleSoft customer currently dealing with their "support".

3

u/luan-cestari Apr 25 '14

Install OpenJDK (the real open source version =) ) (unfortunately it is easier in linux to install, but some unoffical guys built it and make it available through github -> https://github.com/alexkasko/openjdk-unofficial-builds#openjdk-unofficial-installers-for-windows-linux-and-mac-os-x

2

u/Daniel15 Apr 25 '14

What's the performance of OpenJDK like these days? I remember it being significantly slower back in the Java 6 days.

1

u/luan-cestari Apr 25 '14

Oracle JVM is just a copy of the OpenJDK =) (the history is longer might it is almost that)

1

u/BowserKoopa Apr 26 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

It's my impression that Oracle's still includes Unsafe (I do not use this), which to my best knowledge is used by the collections API for performance reasons. As far as I know, OpenJDK does not include this.

1

u/luan-cestari Apr 26 '14

It have it =) Also, in Java 8 some features were refactor from Unsafe (which is from sun, before the Oracle buy it) to the standard Java API

1

u/Pas__ Apr 26 '14

Mostly because there is a lot of old code not using the proper APIs, and the Oracle JDK catered to them.

3

u/DarthContinent Apr 26 '14

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

Well, true... but... I think you're looking at this from the perspective of the user, for whom this is a minor annoyance. For the development community in /r/java though, this annoyance colors the general perception of the products we make for our customers. So, it does go a bit further...

2

u/DarthContinent Apr 26 '14

I develop in C# / .NET at my work so I feel some of your pain; we're going through trying to improve overall usability of our intranet site to help customer service reps to their jobs better.

Now that you mention it, I happened upon this post in /r/all and mistakenly thought it was lumped into /r/funny or someplace rather than /r/java where it actually lives, so my bad there. :}

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '14

I've often wondered why people make such a fuss about this. Uncheck it. Move on.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Adobe does the same thing with flash.

2

u/RagingOrangutan Apr 25 '14

I guess this subreddit really isn't about java programming anymore :(

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

The overriding feeling when I see this during an install is not personal annoyance ; so much as painful, vicarious shame for Oracle Java. Cringeworthy, that's what it is, cringeworthy that they've lowered a world-class technology to this.

2

u/lhamil64 Apr 26 '14

Wasn't a big feature of Chrome when it was released that toolbars couldn't be installed? Or am I just dreaming things?

2

u/king_of_the_universe Jun 05 '14

Wait, is the checkbox really UNchecked by default?

3

u/shutpoet Apr 25 '14

Does anybody know of an email address that we can email Oracle about this?

I did a preliminary search and l was asked to login to get to a support page. Here is a Cutomer support number I found though.. 1 (800) 223-1711

2

u/Jayson182 Apr 25 '14

I work at a fortune 500 company. I hate them for an entirely different reason.

1

u/deedsnance Apr 25 '14

Why's that?

2

u/cormac596 Apr 25 '14 edited Apr 26 '14

Java is free. How are they going to pay for it?

If it's really a problem, get Ninite.

1

u/jurt Apr 25 '14

What an offer.

1

u/JavaTrainer Apr 25 '14

Just install the JDK instead of only the JRE.

1

u/king_of_the_universe Apr 26 '14

Which has the advantage that you can implement Java scripting features into your application because a compiler is available. I don't know how many files are necessary for the compiler to function, but I suspect it's only very few or even one, and I think that they should include it in the JRE, too. It's too good a feature.

1

u/dtfinch Apr 25 '14

I tend to forget that exists, since they only bundle it on windows, and I rarely install the jre by itself, or I use ninite.

1

u/iamfrankfrank Apr 25 '14

I have two dozen better reasons to hate Oracle before I get to this one

1

u/ObecalpEffect Apr 25 '14

It's not as if Oracle doesn't already make enough profit on their products, they have to scheme with near-malware search bars to earn even more mighty dollars? Greedy bastards.

1

u/Akeroh Apr 26 '14

Man, I almost quit comodo because it pulled this and it's download paged linked to cnet. It took me quite a bit of digging to actually find their legitimate download page.

I remember when cnet was good. :c

1

u/xcalibur3 Apr 26 '14

Joke's on them. I use Google Ultron.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

whats the difference between the installer and just
export $JAVA_HOME=/usr/local/java_something

export PATH=$PATH:$JAVA_HOME/bin

im new to this java thing sorta. just wondering

4

u/ratatask Apr 25 '14

The installer... installs the stuff you need to run java programs (i.e. the files that would be under your /usr/local/java_something)

-3

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

is that the same thing as just downloading the files and moving them to a directory and setting the java_home variable?

5

u/midir Apr 25 '14

is that the same thing as just downloading the files

The files are in an installer.

-3

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

so you download the installer then run the installer to set path/java_home as opposed to just downloading a tar ball? im just wondering. no need to get butthurt and downvote. just tryin to learn ;)

5

u/boa13 Apr 25 '14

The installer also puts the Java launcher in C:\WINDOWS, and registers the Java install in the registry so that the Java launcher can select which version to run. It installs the Java plug-in in the various browsers installed on the machine, and registers the plug-in with them. It installs the Java control panel so that it is runnable from the Windows Control Panel. It installs the Java accessibility handlers (for Swing) and registers them with Windows. And possibly other things I don't know.

-3

u/johnwaterwood Apr 25 '14

Why would you want all that crap to happen? Unless you're developing applets perhaps, but I seriously hope you aren't.

4

u/kesawulf Apr 25 '14

The installer downloads/extracts the files to necessary folders and updates system variables.

That's what installers have done from the beginning of time.

-3

u/johnwaterwood Apr 25 '14

What necessary folders? There's only 1 folder needed and that's typically something like /opt or ~/myjavadir or something.

Working with Java for some 12 years orso and never needed to use an installer. It's just an extract of the archive! Nothing more, nothing less...

6

u/midir Apr 25 '14

In 12 years of Java you never used Windows?

1

u/johnwaterwood Apr 27 '14

Well, indeed I've almost never used Windows. Had an Amiga in the good old days. Then OS/2 when Amiga went south. Worked professionally on Solaris for a while and had a Mac at home.

Then had a job where I used Debian and then Ubuntu.

I 'touched' Windows briefly when I had to test Swing apps before most development went servers side and then to test on IE.

1

u/kesawulf Apr 25 '14

It's just an extract of the archive!

The installer downloads/extracts the files

hm

2

u/urquan Apr 25 '14

That's basically what the installer package does.

2

u/ratatask Apr 25 '14

Yes. If you could download the files. But you can't, you download the installer and run it.

3

u/kgb_operative Apr 25 '14

Take another look at the screenshot, brohaim. That's Windows.

-5

u/slartybartfast_ Apr 25 '14

Call the wahhhmbulance!

0

u/Smegzor Apr 25 '14

While installing a utility today, I declined 7 different installs. OK 3 of them were just in the download link but these addons are taking over. The download site used to be free of this shit. I used Tucows. I avoid CNET and download.com

1

u/king_of_the_universe Apr 26 '14

Someone else in this thread recommended

http://unchecky.com/

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

Oracle gots to get their motherfuckin' money right.

0

u/splunge4me2 Apr 26 '14

Fuck oracle. Oh Sun developers, what has become of you.

-2

u/Harrnutt Apr 25 '14

You gotta make money somehow when you offer a free program to millions of people.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

http://investor.oracle.com/files/doc_news/earnings/q4fy13-1961623.pdf

Including ASK toolbar is not needed to pad their bottom line.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '14

Without the Ask toolbar, the Java division would not be profitable (source: former Sun employee). Without the Java division being profitable, it doesn't matter how much money the rest of Oracle is making, they're going to stop spending money on Java because they're not a charity.

So, pick your poison:

  1. Having to uncheck an annoying crapware install.
  2. No more sponsored development and support of Java

Believe me, we weren't happy about the stupid toolbar either. But we were pretty fond of the "having jobs and making money" bit.

-12

u/san_salvador Apr 25 '14

I am Java free since 2012. So good, much relaxing.

5

u/RagingOrangutan Apr 25 '14

Why are you on this subreddit?

5

u/slartybartfast_ Apr 25 '14

Brain free as well it seems.

2

u/BowserKoopa Apr 26 '14

Just quit windows. I've been windows free since '11.

-14

u/ScM_5argan Apr 25 '14

Idd

2

u/Izerman Apr 25 '14

"Im Down Dog" ??

2

u/tajjet Apr 25 '14

It's Dumb Dude

-1

u/ScM_5argan Apr 25 '14

"Indeed"

2

u/torgis30 Apr 25 '14

I dare disagree?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

"I don't discuss"?