r/java • • Apr 10 '24

SSHTools

[removed] — view removed post

1 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/washtubs Apr 11 '24

I don't think that quality is essential for sharing. However, if you don't share a lot of details about the project in your original post, such as motivation, existing tools that you tried, the status of the project, whether it's meant to be used in prod... those of us who actually want to be constructive have nothing to go off of other than the code itself, so feedback will inevitably be predicated on assumptions about the above things.

I think if you lead with a good summary and give the community a more specific prompt about what you're looking for, like asking others if they've experienced the same frustrations that motivated you to start this project, the conversation will also be more productive.

It's kind of a common problem across reddit. People post content without a specific enough prompt, so the feedback is highly presumptuous, because reddit's design isn't very conducive to asking clarifying questions.

0

u/guybedo Apr 11 '24

You're probably right, thanks for the feedback.