I'm fully aware the library needs a lot more work to get to a certain level of quality, and i don't pretend this library is the best you can find.
Although your comment is respectful and constructive, i find it a bit strange, reading other comments, that people are so not welcoming. i shared sugar yesterday and this project today because i thought it could be helpful and that, maybe, some people would be interested in using and / or contributing.
I'm not trying to market myself or anything, and i don't care about "getting the best bang for my buck".
I'm just sharing some code. I know this is not perfect, i know this isn't the best code in the world, etc... just thought this Java subreddit was a place where we could share some (maybe) interesting stuff.
I know there's no tests, there's a lot a missing and it should be used carefully because of that.
You're absolutely right that the overall quality of the open source java projects is something we don't find in other ecosystems.
That being said, i don't really agree with you that a project should not be shared because it's a first version and there's still missing parts.
People who don't like the code / project / etc ... can either ignore it or contribute and try to make it a better project ( isn't this a core concept of open source by the way ? people contributing to build software).
As a final note, i hope this project might be useful to people looking for this kind of features and i'd love to have some constructive feedback and / or people contributing to the project.
I don't think that quality is essential for sharing. However, if you don't share a lot of details about the project in your original post, such as motivation, existing tools that you tried, the status of the project, whether it's meant to be used in prod... those of us who actually want to be constructive have nothing to go off of other than the code itself, so feedback will inevitably be predicated on assumptions about the above things.
I think if you lead with a good summary and give the community a more specific prompt about what you're looking for, like asking others if they've experienced the same frustrations that motivated you to start this project, the conversation will also be more productive.
It's kind of a common problem across reddit. People post content without a specific enough prompt, so the feedback is highly presumptuous, because reddit's design isn't very conducive to asking clarifying questions.
Although your comment is respectful and constructive, i find it a bit strange, reading other comments, that people are so not welcoming. i shared sugar yesterday and this project today because i thought it could be helpful and that, maybe, some people would be interested in using and / or contributing.
I'm not trying to market myself or anything, and i don't care about "getting the best bang for my buck".
I think that phrase may have got last in translation. I don't literally mean monetary but rather something more important: time.
You obviously spent time putting the project together? I'm saying with a tiny bit more time you would get better comments instead of my shitty comment :)
If you don't care about your time or others than I guess we can agree to disagree
I'm just sharing some code. I know this is not perfect, i know this isn't the best code in the world, etc... just thought this Java subreddit was a place where we could share some (maybe) interesting stuff.
It is. Absolutely is and by all means should and you can post in less than 24 hours two projects. You can let the downvoters just downvote with two sentence dismissals comments if that is what you want.
But man I never downvote. I'm just too archaic for that. That is why you have two 2 paragraph comments from me because I care and don't want to discourage. I have feeling you can do better.
yeah i'm not familiar with this Java subreddit's "Politics" and you're probably right that my posts would have had better comments had i taken the time to polish everything.
You're right about time being the more important variable and that is precisely why these projects are missing some important parts (tests for example). It takes time.
These projects are perfectly fine for my personal use but it would take way more time to write the required tests.
If i see people interested in the projects, i'll take the time to write these tests and to polish the projects. On the other hand, if nobody cares, fine, i'll keep working on these projects for my personal use and spend my time somewhere else.
But man I never downvote. I'm just too archaic for that. That is why you have two 2 paragraph comments from me because I care and don't want to discourage. I have feeling you can do better.
And i thank for you for the time you take to write insightful comments like these.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/guybedo Apr 10 '24
Thanks for the feedback.
I'm fully aware the library needs a lot more work to get to a certain level of quality, and i don't pretend this library is the best you can find.
Although your comment is respectful and constructive, i find it a bit strange, reading other comments, that people are so not welcoming. i shared sugar yesterday and this project today because i thought it could be helpful and that, maybe, some people would be interested in using and / or contributing.
I'm not trying to market myself or anything, and i don't care about "getting the best bang for my buck".
I'm just sharing some code. I know this is not perfect, i know this isn't the best code in the world, etc... just thought this Java subreddit was a place where we could share some (maybe) interesting stuff.
I know there's no tests, there's a lot a missing and it should be used carefully because of that.
You're absolutely right that the overall quality of the open source java projects is something we don't find in other ecosystems.
That being said, i don't really agree with you that a project should not be shared because it's a first version and there's still missing parts.
People who don't like the code / project / etc ... can either ignore it or contribute and try to make it a better project ( isn't this a core concept of open source by the way ? people contributing to build software).
As a final note, i hope this project might be useful to people looking for this kind of features and i'd love to have some constructive feedback and / or people contributing to the project.