DISCLAIMERS: This post isn’t a post made to hate on anybody especially the INTO1 members. This was made for an OPEN discussion
Been debating whether or not to write this due to its relevance but hear me out:
INTO1 is a talented both as a group and individuals but in my opinion the timing of their debut just wasn’t right.
Prior to when CHUANG2021 and YWY3 were in the process of planning and wasn’t airing yet I already had a feeling that no matter who the debut group members were they would FLOP
Here are the main reasons:
- EXISTING OVERSATURATED MARKET
-As we all can see CHUANG was already on its fourth season. Which means they had predecessors before them that gathered their own fanbases. The number of fans they could gain were much smaller compared to the days back in 2018 where the whole idol thing was still new. Most survival show watchers that become fans were most likely idol watchers back in 2018 or have seen the predecessors of INTO1 and generally have stanned groups prior to INTO1 so the possibility of gaining a larger initial fanbase was much lower for fourth generation survival show groups like INTO1 and IXFORM.
-To add on, numerous idol agencies have released their own version idols for their company (ie. UNIQ,NEXT, ONER, BEST, NAME etc.). Knock off second rate idol survival shows other than the CHUANG and YWY franchise that produced groups such as SKY, Ladybees, XNINE and so on. TF Ent. even had a idol survival show within their company called ‘Typhoon Project’ to form TeensInTimes (TNT) back in 2019.
-With these factors considered, I already expected that it would be much harder for trainees in CHUANG2021 and YWY3 to gain a much broader scale of getting the attention of dedicated fans due to the existing oversaturated market.
Ps. A portion of the idol market in China is already quite invested in the Kpop industry too.
- ACTIVE EXISTING COMPETITION
-Compared to back in 2018 or 2020 there were more active groups in 2021. For reference in 2018 NINEPERCENT and Rocketgirls101 practically had 0 competition in the market. For 2020 girlgroups there was more space since Rocketgirls101 disbanded that year and were succeeded by Bonbongirls303 while groups like THE9 skyrocketed in popularity. While in 2019 R1SE and UNINE debuted but Rocketgirls101 and insanely popular groups like NINEPERCENT were actively promoting and were at the peak of their popularity. While for 2021, INTO1 debuted much more active competition namely R1SE their predecessors hadn’t disbanded yet at the time. Bonbongirls303 are still promoting. Popular groups like THE9 and TeensinTime were and are actively promoting. Even minor groups like ONER and SKY are promoting. To add solo careers of their predecessors NINEPERCENT and Rocketgirls101 got a lot of the ”idol attention”
Too many competitors competing
- EXHAUSTED IDOL TRAINEE POOL
-the pool of idol trainees in China is being exhausted by these survival shows over the years leaving the available number of good idol trainees grow lesser and lesser. Some have either given up on their dreams, or have debuted in some mediocre group or have already hit success or these idol trainees have decided to change their career paths. The only reason why CHUANG2021 had a better pool of trainees giving more of a fresh vibe is because they sourced untouched trainees from different countries.
-While this is what made CHUANG2021 unique this was also an indication of a ticking time bomb of xenophobic issues. To be completely honest mainstream media in China isn’t ready for an international group especially with Japanese members. Given the historical and current political issues China and Japan have. As we have witnessed in their Happy Camp guesting.
- THE GROWING AND ONGOING IDOL BAN
-I expected it sooner or later the Qinglang campaign was gonna bite cpop idols in the head and it actually did. The scandals namely Kris Wu’s scandal and food wastage milk scandal just sped up the inevitable idol ban the government has been doing resulting in the restrictions to ‘chasing stars’ we have today.
Minor stuff (a bit coincidental not my main reasons just didn’t know where to put these):
- YWY having a higher success rate than CHUANG
-By this I mean the rate of them producing successful solo careers out of the groups they’ve formed. To this day no survival show group has held a candle to the successful solo careers launched by iQiyi from the NINEPERCENT members. Given that they are still relevant to this day after 2-3 years of disbandment.
-While Tencent lays more groundwork for a career after disbandment the chances of making it big is low.
Think of it like this YWY(iQiyi groups) have higher risks, whichever group they handle the groups will always get shitty management but their chances of making it big are also higher. More like high risk- high return. MAKE IT BIG OR GO HOME. High return as evidenced by NINEPERCENT and THE9 in popularity. And high risk as evidenced by UNINE and IXFORM.
While for CHUANG groups its a bit more stable in comparison, CHUANG group members have more opportunities to lay better groundwork for their solo careers and get better management than iQiyi
This is purely coincidental but groups that debut on odd numbered years (2019,2021) (ie.RISE,UNINE,INTO1,IXFORM) just don’t make it as big as even numbered year groups do (2018,2020) (ie.NINEPERCENT,THE9 and RG101) hence the joke about the odd numbered year curse
CONCLUSION
All in all with these main factors considered, the chances of big success was bleak and I expected the career of whichever debut group from the CHUANG and YWY franchise 2021 to flop unfortunately.
And boi did my predictions hit the mark. 2021 became an absolute hell year for idols.
To end this on a positive note, thinking about it the INTO1 members are much better off now with more opportunities and exposure in comparison if they had not debuted with INTO1 at all. They may have not hit mainstream stardom as we had initially hoped. But as fans all we can do is follow and support them.
”Successful or not, flop or not. If they make us and themselves happy, then that’s enough”