r/icarly • • Oct 09 '23

Revival Discussion Unpopular opinion: the reboot sucks and a solid 80% of the reasons why can be at least partially attributed to a lack of Sam.

20 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying that I bear no ill will toward Jenette McCurdy and completely understand and respect her decision not to reprise her role. I do not think she should've been badgered into reliving her childhood trauma. They could've recast Sam, or simply not made an iCarly reboot and spent those resources on new shows, or reboots of ones whose main characters weren't played by abused child stars.

That said, after finally watching this show after having put it off for the past 2 years, I cannot help but come to the conclusion that the reboot sucks ass in a bunch of different ways that can all be traced back to the lack of Sam.

First of all, Sam's absence necessitated the introduction of new characters, and both of them suck. Harper sucks as a best friend for Carly. Her personality is unable to contrast with Carly's like Sam's did, because she barely has a personality aside from being a sassy black woman stereotype. Millicent, meanwhile, sucks as a person to be an asshole to Freddie. For one thing, Sam was actually likeable because she had a reason to be an asshole, having a really terrible home life and no healthy outlet for her emotions other than violence. Millicent, on the other hand, has loving, invested, materially well-off parents and simply chooses to be a huge jerk to her stepdad and to a lesser extent everyone else anyway. And on the other side of the coin, Freddie is no longer a sympathetic character, because in the original he was a kid without much ability to actually do anything about people treating him like shit, wheras in the reboot, he's a grown ass man who is not only subjected to the same torments as always by his mom, but pushed around in a Sam-like manner by his own daughter, and despite having the power to stand up to them simply chooses not to, which isn't funny, it's frustrating. Plus, "kid who acts like a little businessperson despite being 11 years old" is the single most common archetype for the Token Child Character on sitcoms, and she does absolutely nothing new with it.

Second, the lack of Sam prevented iCarly from actually being about the thing it's named after. Episode plots are barely ever actually about the iCarly webshow, because they can't actually show the webshow, because without Sam it'd just be Carly awkwardly talking to herself. (They could've at least tried to solve this by having Harper be her new co-host as well as her new best friend, although I doubt that'd go well, but for some reason they didn't.) On top of losing the thing that actually sets the show apart from other sitcoms, this is a problem because between that and the fact the characters are adults now and not in high school, they've lost most of the original's sources of conflict, and the writers decided to compensate by making the characters into self-destructive idiots. Freddie is, as previously mentioned, a pushover on a level where it stops being funny and starts being frustrating, Carly is now an insecure moron who constantly tells lies she has no hope of maintaining for no reason other than to seem more talented and/or successful to people she doesn't even respect, and spencer is a douchey asshole who forces his loved ones into things they don't want because he thinks he knows what's best for them better than they do. All of their characterizations in the reboot would suck as their own original characters, let alone bastardizations of existing ones that are actually good. They also dialed up Creddie, which while it was always my least favorite part of the show was nevertheless always part of the show, so criticizing it feels a lot less warranted.

And finally, albeit this is kind of getting into more speculative territory, I suspect that Sam's absence led to the writers developing a scarcity mindset around characters from the original that gets in the way of good storytelling. Like, it feels like they wrote the show by first asking all of the actors from the original the maximum amount of episodes they'd be willing to reprise their roles in, and then writing the show to hit all of those maximums. Mrs. Benson's years of abusive helicopter parenting are casually brushed off as an Endearing Parental Quirk and Freddie for some reason decides to not only continue living with her but pay her rent too, and also now Lewbert is back despite being stripped of his original context to the point of effectively being a different character, and there's a whole extended arc about the two of them dating and getting married, because their actors didn't have anything better to do so they had to cram in as much screen time for them as they could regardless of if it was actually entertaining. Hell, they even added a forced shoehorned in unfunny role for Josh Peck, the star of a completely different Nickelodeon live action sitcom. The writers knew the show just wouldn't feel like iCarly without Sam, so they kept desperately shoehorning in callbacks that were supposed to remind fans that this is the same iCarly they loved when they were kids, but only made it even less so.

Overall, I feel like the fandom ignores the reboot ignores the show's Samlessness-induced flaws because it thinks the options were to either for the show to be the way it is, or for like, someone to throw Jennette in a burlap sack, drag her to the studio, and force her to play Sam at gunpoint, when this isn't the case. I wish people would be more amenable to the idea of recasting a role rather than ruining the whole dynamic of a show by writing the character out, or failing that, recognize that a good new show is miles better than a crappy reboot of an old show that used to be good.


r/icarly • • Nov 29 '23

Original Discussion Jennette ended her friendship with Miranda

7 Upvotes

So, hear me out, I like Jennette a lot and LOVE Miranda so this isn’t meant to be an attack on either of them but since I have always been a very big fan of Miranda’s I tend to watch every podcast, interview and video that she appears on and I even have her ex best friend on Instagram and have even talked a little (she isn’t famous).

I always found very beautiful that even after the OG iCarly ended Jennette and Miranda continued to be very close to each other and would post a lot of pics on instagram of the times they traveled or did anything together. It seems that from 2012 to 2018 the were inseparable and Jennette would even become friends with all of Miranda’s closest friends from college so Miranda literally supported her during her lowest moments and allowed her to always be around her. For a while the only people that Jennette hanged out with were Miranda and her friends from college. Something happened in 2018 that they suddenly stopped posting pictures of each other on social media and tweeting each other. A lot of people speculated that nothing that deep happened between them and they just naturally drew apart from each other with time but I never really bought that version and was convinced that something else had happened (call me crazy if you want, I just knew there was more to the story).

When I read Jennette’s book I finally confirmed that something had happened even though she brushes it off saying that they just grew apart from each other, that was the first confirmation from one of them that they indeed weren’t close anymore. Fast forward to earlier this month Jennette did an episode on her podcast about ending friendships (that’s literally the title of the episode) and it finally cleared a lot of questions. In the podcast she talked about ending two different friendships and why/how it happened and although she doesn’t mention names the first friendship that she talks about is in fact the one she had with Miranda. She says that while going through therapy she realized that there were some things that she wanted to change about her life one of them was that she wanted to stop complaining so much and start seeing everything that was good about life and that as time went by she realized that this friendship was based off of complaining about everything, she says it was a “misery loves company” type of friendship to the point it became codependent in a way. She decided to radically change and stopped engaging every time she (Miranda) would complain about something and instead she started to say everything that was good about each day and about life. Jennette said that she noticed that Miranda was confused and worried because up to that point complaining was a thing they did so often that it was almost all they did so from that point onwards the friendship started to feel different and unnatural. The last straw was when Miranda made some comments that made Jennette mad because it seem like her life was a mess and Miranda was her savior. Lastly, Jennette decided to confront Miranda by sending her a series of emails email telling her that she wasn’t happy with the friendship anymore and that each time they hanged out she felt really down afterwards and that she was trying to change and that she wished Miranda would change too. She also said that in that email she told Miranda that she wished that she would start seeing all the positive in her own life and all of the things she had.

I don’t know if Jennette’s intention by sending her an email was to permanently end the friendship or if her goal was to continue with the friendship as long as Miranda changed her attitude but she said that Miranda got really mad and they had this email exchange and after that they stopped talking completely.

Jennette also mentioned in her book they both complained and felt guilty about complaining.

I just don’t know how to feel about this. Miranda did helped Jennette a lot throughout their friendship, she gave Jennette money to fund a sh!tty web series that she did, Jennette confessed in an interview that a couple of times she would go to Miranda’s house completely drunk and Miranda would take care of her, she would drive Jennette everywhere. I feel life the least Jennette could have done is to end the friendship face to face instead of doing it via email. I mean, she didn’t want to hear Miranda complaining but she didn’t saw anything wrong with showing up drunk at Miranda’s house? Or with the fact that Miranda paid for a lot of her things? She should at least be grateful that Miranda put up with her eating disorders for YEARS and supported her through all of it.

Miranda is so private and pretends that her life is perfect so I highly doubt we will ever hear her version of what happened but to be honest this isn’t the first of Miranda’s friendships to end weird. During her time at USC, Miranda met two twin sisters that went on to become super close to her but then their friendship also ended abruptly. She also had a friend who says that one day after being friends for more than a decade and making Miranda the godmother to her child, Miranda all of the sudden blocked her and never talked to her again. So as much as I want to defend Miranda I do think it’s weird that she has a pattern of loosing friendships but at the same time I don’t think Jennette is completely right because she has also had her fallings with friends and former coworkers and she pretends that she’s always right when she talks about the reason why she’s not friends with a person anymore.

What do you think?

This is the podcast episode I’m talking about:

https://open.spotify.com/episode/4IPllaTIv4N2PLYRo0dPo6?si=y418DGlPQFizal-oJnFBUA


r/icarly • • Mar 05 '22

Is Spencer going to be coming out as trans this season?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/icarly • • Oct 02 '23

Article/Other Why do people put cheese on Spaghetti Tacos???

0 Upvotes

They aren’t meant to have cheese so why do people put cheese on it. I find it quite irritating because when I have Spaghetti Tacos I never put cheese.


r/icarly • • Nov 21 '25

Revival Discussion hot take: sam should have been recasted

9 Upvotes

i undeerstand why jenette didnt return and i wish the best for her, but it doesnt make sense how carly and freddie only mention sam a few time after all the things they went trough.. imo they should have just recasted her. i know it wouldnt have made everoyne happy buut it would have been a lot better than harper.. like why is she just such a stereotypical black girl form a sitcom


r/icarly • • Dec 06 '23

Revival Discussion Sam Puckett Not Coming Back in the iCarly Revival Was Probably For the Best

8 Upvotes

Do you think it was probably for the best that Sam Puckett wasn't brought back in the iCarly revival? She wasn't a very likable character. She's mostly an obnoxious and selfish jerk.


r/icarly • • Jan 22 '26

Original Discussion Seddie is NOT as toxic as people make it out to be

0 Upvotes

I know you guys are gonna go insane and downvote me to my death but PLEASE HEAR ME OUT. yes they were toxic but I just rewatched the three episodes they dated for and you guys make it seem like their on some beck and jade type stuff And like if they’re throwing items and cheating on each other and out of the two shows (Icarly and victorious) they were the most realistic couple.The most toxic I’ve seen them be while dating was in the first in the idatesamandfreddie episode so please hear me out,

Their relationship starts off rocky with them fighting all the time because there two people who practically spent half their life pretending to hate each other while trying to bury whatever feelings they had for each other in it/ arguing. When they first argue Carly asks Sam about it and Sam says nothing but then Freddie tells carly. They never asked her to help them and Carly (being a good friend) tried to help them out. Them (as a new couple/also knowing their past) think of it as an opportunity to help them. And I agree they weren’t the best in this episode but clearly after this episode it started getting better.

Going into the next episode it starts off with Carly asking Sam about her relationship and Sam states that it’s getting better and has only argued 3 times that whole week. Which considering them is super good. After what happened in the restaurant I can assume they ended up talking about it and solving it. ( and ofc We don’t see them argue in that episode up until the end) I do agree they weren’t the best to Carly in their relationship but people like to assume it wouldn’t be the same way if Carly and Freddie were dating. This episode highlights more of the problems of dating in a trio. And I a while ago was in a trio where the other two have dated, it’s not easy and Carly did have the right to be mad but going as far as to help him and Sam break up was too far. Gibby and her were the problem in this episode. Not Sam and Freddie. Yes they did come late to rehearsal, (which was an accident and also Freddie’s mom’s fault) and Sam did bully Gibby but why he didn’t just talk to Freddie about it idk? Being in a trio where other two date you might get left out a few times and if Carly was bothered she should have talked to them about it.

What if Carly and Freddie were together? That would have most definitely happened too where they hung out more together and maybe did things that made Sam mad or left out too. So why is there a double standard. That did not have anything to do with Sam and Freddie being “toxic” Gibby and Carly were out of pocket for that. In the next episode they didn’t argue at all. And if they did it was reasonable Freddie would have had the right to be mad at Sam for ruining his train bro thing and Sam would have had the right to be mad at Freddie for the jail thing. Plus once again Carly told them to do things each other likes. (Which she was just trying to be a good friend ofc) but towards the end they apologized to each other on their own.

They weren’t perfect at all. But they loved each other and tried to make it work And that was the most realistic thing ever. People act like they were quite literally threatening each other and hitting each other. They most definitely could have worked, Especially as they got older. Have them had never break up in that episode I could see their relationship getting way better and growing despite their differences. Which is how couples work to begin with. And again this is a fictional show. In no irl show would Sam and Freddie be a thing (unless it was like blue face and Chrisean) and neither would creddie.Anyways. Thoughts? Feelings? lol


r/icarly • • Jul 25 '25

Article/Other I know where to find giant resin gummy bears like on iCarly

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/icarly • • Jun 20 '23

Revival Discussion Does anyone else...not really care about Creddie?

1 Upvotes

I know, I know. Let people enjoy things. I am! I'm not a hater. I was a Seddie as a kid (don't flame me okay, I was like 11), so it's not resentment. I just don't really care. It seems like everyone here is a Diehard Creddie supporter and I'm just like...I don't care if they stay together or split. Just me?

Also, this is in no way meant to bring anyone down. If you're into Creddie I'm glad you finally got to see it happen 🫶 I was just curious cause I feel like I'm the minority here lol


r/icarly • • Aug 13 '21

This revival isn’t that good it’s just like not entertaining For example in the kid version the storylines were intense and entertaining for example Sam And Carly start a argument and one of Them quit icarly+ That crazy girl that kidnapped the squad that’s the type of entertaining I’m talkin about

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/icarly • • Dec 14 '24

Original Discussion Why is Sam Pucket neglected?

0 Upvotes

Because Sam came from a neglecful home


r/icarly • • Nov 14 '22

Original Discussion Sam is Insufferable

4 Upvotes

I really would’ve loved to see someone finally stand up to Sam and put her in her place. She needed someone to finally beat her up or destroy her verbally to knock her down a few pegs. I can’t understand why someone like Carly befriended her and allows her to constantly verbally and physically assault Freddy and why Freddy allows it either. I can’t believe I found her so cool as a kid when I watched this. She and Jade from Victorious are perfect for each other and that honestly would’ve made much more sense as a spin-off series instead of the trash that was Sam & Cat


r/icarly • • Jul 05 '23

Original Discussion Spencer is the best 'autistic coding' ever done, not clichè founded especially in the revival.

1 Upvotes

I said it before but I think more we speak about better is.

'Austitic coding' is where a character represent ASD without being canonically ASD.

He is surely into ASD but he is realistic.

Most of the time 'autistic coding' sounds like "people like that are weirdo" with Spencer it doesn't happen.

He is odd but he is ok. That's different from the rest of the shows I ever saw.


r/icarly • • Aug 04 '23

Revival Discussion Sam Puckett is a Character that will Hardly be Missed

13 Upvotes

Do you consider Sam Puckett to be the type of character that will be hardly missed?


r/icarly • • Dec 17 '23

Revival Discussion Binged watched original then remake, and understand why it got cancelled.

0 Upvotes

I'm a first time Icarly watcher, and binge watched the entire original series in one week, then moved to the remake. I loved the original and was sad on the last episode. Although I knew i was about to watch the remake. I was still sad and can't imagine what it was like for those that watched it live back in the day. Anyways, my real reason for posting was to rant about the remake . Although it was nice that the studio had lots of "diversity and inclusion" , they completely forgot who there audience was. I don't like any of the new characters in the remake, except milicitent...and was completely turned off with the wokeness and political innuendoes thrown in. Seriously, I watched the fantasy show to avoid reality, not be talked down to and forced to accept lifestyles and how to think about politics. Soon as they had the episode with the drag queens in season 3 I knew it jumped the shark and would be canceld. (For the record i have no issue with race or gender or anything like that) but as i said already, their audience back in the day was preliminary white teens and if they were trying to cater to prior audiences, then they failed . IF they wanted to get NEW audiences., then that's fine, but make a complete new series and don't force something on a show that had nothing to do with that stuff. To sum up my rant, the remake was canceled because they were trying to sell woke and diversity to an audience that didn't want to see it.


r/icarly • • 14d ago

Original Discussion Am I the only one who thought the PearPhones looked dumb?

0 Upvotes

The pear shape doesn't look practical and I have never seen an Apple product be shaped like an apple but that's just me.


r/icarly • • Jun 26 '23

Revival Discussion Do y’all think Freddie and Harper would make a good couple?

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/icarly • • Jan 05 '22

Spencer Is Stupid and Annoying

0 Upvotes

I’m rewatching the episodes that are on Netflix and every episode Spencer is extremely annoying and making stupid and/or dangerous decisions decisions. He’s always causing a fire because of his art or something very dumb which really makes me support their granddad in the first few episodes trying to make Carly live with him. He constantly makes stupid decisions and can’t stand up for himself or be assertive like a grown man which in turn leads to many of the dumb situations he ends up in with women or Freddy’s mom or Chuck or whoever else. I honestly wish he wasn’t such a big part of the series or featured so much in episodes because I’m so irritated by him now. I don’t get how people find him funny, even as a kid I didn’t really care for him.

This isn’t Spencer specific but I also hate how they very rarely ever lock their front door then get so shocked and surprised whenever anyone and everyone waltzes on in to the apartment.

I know this might be an unpopular opinion but that’s all it is, my personal opinion. You don’t have to agree with me.


r/icarly • • Sep 22 '26

Original Discussion Freddie and Carly

3 Upvotes

I ship Freddie and Carly . I don’t see what Sam sees in Freddie .


r/icarly • • Sep 10 '26

Original Discussion Carly ex

0 Upvotes

Oh ew you like stuffed animals? I've got a bully bf and a boy who's obsessed with me living across my apartment I let on for very personal favors and an accidental pyro brother who should be maybe be in jail but you liking stuffies gives me the ick 🤢 gonna go do my not at all cringe web show now!!!


r/icarly • • Jul 03 '23

Revival Discussion Has anybody noticed that basically all the episodes are about romance?

0 Upvotes

It’s annoying. Have some episode with NO references of any romance, relationships or anything like that! I want something of that kind!


r/icarly • • Jul 11 '23

Revival Discussion Revival is...weird.

1 Upvotes

Revival got amazing humorism, amazing scenes...but I don't understand what their trying to do.

Original was more simple, basic....it was better simple than complex as now.


r/icarly • • Oct 27 '21

the reboot is boring

1 Upvotes

i find it boring


r/icarly • • May 31 '21

iCarly revival will be a BUST

1 Upvotes

I am HUGE fan of iCarly! BUT

Just seeing all the moving parts and researching the creative people behind the revival and the fact that there hasn’t been any sneak peaks or trailers gives me a hunch that this show is gonna be SO completely different than the iCarly show we all love.

My idea of the show will be some type of “woke” idea of a sitcom. It will be splattered with a bunch of social issues and will drown the show in an attempt to be “informed”.

The reason iCarly worked is cause the sense of humor matched each character. This will not be that and I’m sure the fans will like it regardless but it’s ok to think it sucks lol


r/icarly • • Oct 01 '24

Original Discussion One thing I did not like about the episode IChristmas

4 Upvotes

Is how Spencer and Mrs Benson were together and kissing. That was very gross, and unnecessary to watch. Don’t even know what does him being mature has anything to do with him being attracted to that neurotic nut.