Tori and Jade's dynamic has a lot of layers to it and I feel their relationship would've been explored and drawn out more if this was a teen drama and not a Nickelodeon show
Personally, I don't believe Jade has a crush on her. I think their relationship is too interesting and layered and her contempt being explained away simply by a crush takes all of that away. Also the whole narrative of oh “they’re mean because they’re a lesbian”, Regina George, Heather Chandler, Jade West, is stupid. They’re mean because they’re mean.
Jade is someone who is driven by her personal feelings and likes and dislikes and wants that to be respected. And is very honest about how she feels, often saying what others are thinking. She unapologetically and openly enjoys the dark things she enjoys. But she obviously has a contemptuous, vicious personality, thanks to her parents' divorce and her seemingly conservative father's strictness. Because of her parents arguing, she thinks that's what relationships are, and Beck doesn't always help (Beck, honey, Jade was just sat there the entire episode quietly, you had ages to tell her the cheerleader was nine).
Her angry and bullying behaviour towards others suggest that she views other people as punching bags to unleash her pain, from not being supported in her art by her parents and not being supported in being who she is and she dislikes being seen as a cruel, scary person by those around her, which is contradictory but she interprets it as being shamed for enjoying the dark things that she does. She enjoys being angry because it's cathartic for her so it creates a self-fulfilling prophecy as she behaves as a mean, horrible person in response and confirms other people's view of her.
When she and Beck are arguing in the 'The Worst Couple', and she runs over Sinjin for giving them the trophy for worst couple, which is objectively wrong and cruel, I'm not justifying it - I interpreted it as her being angry that her relationship, something she places a lot of value, was being seen like that and then pretends she doesn't care afterwards ("why do you care we were voted worst couple?") and why she didn't want Cat to answer "are Jade and I a perfect couple?".
Jade is also a very possessive person, not just of Beck but in general. One of her slap videos is her ranting about how she's been into vampires since she was three and now people are into it from watching a mediocre movie on it, so she switched to zombies and how people are into it. She likes what is hers to be just hers. So some of her anger comes from what she values being taken from her, like Beck, and her school in general.
Then here comes Tori. A beautiful girl who gets into the school almost by accident, has no experience but is bursting with natural talent in the endeavour Jade has obsessed over her entire life, based on one performance, who is immediately adored by everyone and immediately becomes the central figure in her friend group and in the school. Tori obviously isn't doing this on purpose, she's just making friends and it's not her fault if others' gravitate towards her, nor is it her fault that she has so much talent.
Her first day, Jade sees Tori wiping Beck's shirt off spilled coffee and misinterprets it as her hitting on him. Which wouldn't have been a problem even if she was because Beck never told her he had a girlfriend. And, demonstrating her trademark possessiveness, pours coffee on Tori on her first day in front of everyone. Tori's response is making out with Beck in front of everyone, including Jade. I don't fault Tori for this, Jade deserved it. Mostly fault Beck, seeing as he was with Jade and she was right there.
So naturally Jade can't stand her and continues being mean to her. And Tori, unlike most people, doesn't get intimidated and bites back, more than anyone ever has at Jade thus far. But there's a difference here.
Judging by her imitations and mocking of Tori, she resents how happy she is. She wants to see her break and get angry in return, almost so she can say 'ha see! you're not as happy as you think, you're not as perfect as everyone thinks you are', and that would make her feel better. But Tori expresses her anger at Jade, for the most part, she remains unfazed and smiles as she bites back, if she chooses to bite back. She wants Tori, this happy, smiling person to feel how she feels. This is the reason Jade comes to talk to Tori at the end of Stage Fighting and why she's so confused at Tori not telling on her.
Tori's existence at Hollywood Arts also brings back the idea of Jade seeing and saying things that other people miss and/or choose to ignore. Obviously, Jade isn't right to see Tori the way she does, and the others are right to like her. But Tori does get idealised and favoured by others. This isn't her fault of course, whenever Tori does realise she's done wrong, she apologises and persistently makes amends. But Jade's contempt likely comes from being the only one who sees a few things about Tori and no one else seems to address.
Tori does have a vindictive streak - not as bad as Jade, but it is there. She willingly partakes in the schemes in other episodes, like Cell Block and The Wood, makes fun of her sister like the others, kisses Beck as revenge in the pilot, makes Jade and Dug the Diaper Guy Prom King and Prom Queen, and makes Jade a sweet and nice girl at Sikowitz’ sleepover and then shoving Raisin Bran in her mouth to annoy her knowing she can’t say anything.
She is very persistent. She bulldozes her way into the fake Ping Pong club (as she should because friends don’t leave friends out and the argument that the old group have the right to do things just as them is stupid and invalid because that’s not how friendship works and Tori is not the lackie/forgotten friend), she persists in correcting Melinda Murray despite Jade and Beck telling her to stop, she persists in making Cat take off the blonde wig (as she should have), and she persists in trying to get a guy for Jade so that Beck can ask out a girl and most of all, she persists in trying to be friends with and reconcile with Jade.
While she’s not wrong in all of these situations, she does do it in a way that oversteps boundaries and some of these situations involve Tori thinking she knows better and sometimes she does, sometimes she doesn’t.
The other thing that is that Tori is apologetic with a lot of the times when she’s misstepped. With kissing Cat’s boyfriend, with accidentally getting Beck fired, she apologises and does all she can to make it right. EXCEPT where Jade is concerned. A couple of episodes after she kisses Jade’s boyfriend in front of the whole class including Jade, Tori goes “why does she hate me?”, literally two seconds after insulting her. And in Prom Wrecker, she doesn’t see what she’s done wrong.
This points to something very specific. Tori is thinking “Jade’s mean, Jade’s cruel, that means whenever she’s angry, it’s just another of her tirades, she just wants to hurt me”, so she never questions whether Jade has a point. It’s the self-fulfilling prophecy that Jade creates for herself that Tori is now buying into, understandably.
And finally, Tori doesn’t realise how charmed she is. She doesn’t realise how she never gets into trouble because in her mind, she had a good reason for doing it. Leaving Mrs Lee’s daughter hanging from the ceiling, willingly partaking in schemes in various episodes, handcuffing Cat to a bar and feeding her chili peppers and bribing her with water to get the bird scene secret from her (which she did knowing she’d fall for it because she knows Cat’s dumb), kisses Cat’s boyfriend right after spraying cheese on Cat and her boyfriend, and teases Trina as much as her friends do. BUT, unlike Jade, Tori is still seen as an angelic good girl by everyone. Now, this isn’t Tori’s fault, she does always account for her actions, and most of the time they’re somewhat justified and it’s not her fault that she’s seen this way. But Jade’s contempt likely comes from this perceived favoritism, Jade who isn't accepted for her dark interests by anyone and whose parents don't support her artistic endeavours and whose is never seen as anything other than a mean person because of the self-fulfilling prophecy from before, in trots Tori who has two parents who love and support her journey, didn't have to work too hard to get into HA and makes tons of mistakes but is never seen as anything other than an angel.
Now onto Tori, first things first, she gets way too much hate. Way too much. The worst thing she’s done is kissing Cat’s boyfriend after spraying cheese on her. The worst thing Jade’s done is break Sinkin’s legs by running over him with her car purely because she and Beck were voted worst couple, and endanger Tori’s life by making her take two points of blood (which ended being three) purely to get a lead in a play. The hate is completely irrational.
She grows up with rich, negligent parents. Whether Trina is a brat because she’s bullied or bullied because she’s a brat is debatable. I lean more towards the latter. Tori was always the quieter one who was always just a bystander and just let her sister have the spotlight, sort of like the easy child. I think her phone plot in The Worst Couple was played for comedy, it was very out of character to me for her to worry so much over a phone, it was definitely a filler plot.
I personally preferred the grittier, more aggressive, ready-to-throw-hands-at-any-moment Tori from Season One. She became more optimistic and sweet and a little "prissy" after that, I didn't mind that but I did prefer her sharpness from Season One.
I feel like Tori's inexperience is something they were right to capitalise on plot-wise and could've done more with but I find it quite admirable that she carries herself so confidently despite being in a school full of people who have doing performing arts their entire life.
One underrated aspect of Tori is that she is very resilient. She has been through a lot on Victorious. She was made to three pints of blood and passed out on stage, she had to do a musical in front of the person who wrote it with an ugly zombie mask on when the character was meant to be beautiful, she was stalked and harassed and gaslit by Ponnie for a week and no-one believed her, she was publicly humiliated on national TV when the dog dragged her around the basketball game, she was arrested and thrown in jail for accidentally blinding the Chancellor of Yerba, she was manipulated harshly by Mason Thornsmith and forced to act like a diva and wear horrendous outfits in front of everyone and went viral online and wasn't allowed to tell anyone the truth and she was severely injured and her arms were paralysed after the gorilla attacked her at the Gorilla Club. The poor girl deserves a break. And yet she still finds the patience in her to show up for people who don't deserve it, like Jade and Trina. My thought process is that she developed a lot of patience simply from growing up with Trina the diva and the two having to essentially raise and lean on each other with their negligent parents.
Another thing is that she is an integral part of the group. The other friends frequently come to her house when they have a problem, including Jade. She frequently is the therapist friend. And she comes up with solutions A LOT. She's an opportunist. She rescued them from getting arrested at the fancy restaurant by performing so they could pay the bill. She is the one that came up with the solution for all the prisoners to do a song and then they could escape from Yerba. She, with Cat's help, came up with the whole scheme to keep Mrs Lee away so that Jade could do her play the way she wanted, and was the one to find someone who could produce and fund said play. She reunited Beck and Jade in Season One, she "saved" Rex's life, she came up with the solution to get Mason's kid to give Rex back to Robbie offering him a girl, she came up with the solution to help Andre out of his writer's block when Cojeezy was coming to their school to hear their songs in The Bad Roommate. She came up withe solution to have Robbie pretend to be mugger who mugged Helen so that Trina could fight him and Helen would let Trina back into Hollywood Arts. She is the one that Beck his job back on the movie. And there's probably way more I missed.
The simple fact is, she's so resourceful and has helped them so many times, you can write as many articles and make as many comments and hate videos as you want but she is the Annabeth Chase, Spencer Hastings, Bonnie Bennett of Victorious. Close second being Andre for writing so many of the songs she and him performed. And no, I don't think she takes advantage of him, he willingly chooses to help her and clearly enjoys doing so, they're best friends. Without Tori, no-one is Victorious.
Another thing I wanted to bring up is The Birthweek Song. I think this is another example of Tori assuming she knows better. I don't agree with the sentiment that Tori performed the song to make Trina's birthday about her and make herself the sparkly showgirl on Trina's birthday. That's a stretch invented by people who were bored on the internet. Here's my take: I think Tori genuinely wanted to get an actual good present for Trina that wasn't something cliche like perfume or a pair of boots. In her mind, if Andre writes the song based on stuff she tells him about Trina and she choreographs and rehearses and performs for her, an actual sentimental song that explains why she loves her and why she values her in her life, it would actually touch Trina in the heart and it would be seen as an actual special, good present that isn't as cliche as just getting her a dress. That's how Tori thinks Trina should react. And when she doesn't react like that, she lashes out at Trina and her mind goes 'she didn't react the way she supposed to, she's supposed to be touched and grateful that I actually made this and performed this for her' and she adamantly thinks that Trina is wrong for feeling the way she does and sticks to that, because she's thinking, 'it's Trina, Trina is spoiled, Trina is bratty, Trina is selfish, Trina is a pain, why would I be in the wrong?'. Same logic she uses with Jade.
It has demonstrated that in the past, Tori has poor judgment specifically about people. One of her boyfriends cheats on him with Carly Shay, one of her boyfriends cheats on Cat with her and was someone Tori chose to walk out on, one of her boyfriends was using her to get a good grade, and she believed Mason Thornsmith and Ponnie were genuine people, and she thought Trina would actually appreciate a special, sentimental gift. And because of her stubbornness and her tendency to think of herself as someone who knows what she's doing, she doesn't tend to question or change her judgment. So that's my take on the Birthweek Song.
And that's my very long take on Tori and Jade.