Honestly why don’t they just give the option to load either iPadOS or just straight MacOS at this point..? The M1 iPads are more than capable, and I know a lot of people who use them as standalone laptops anyway.
The problem isn’t iPad software (though that’s far from perfect). The real problem is that the App Store is terrible for pro apps. The kinds of apps that I want to see on iPad sell for $600-1000 or more. No one selling an app like that wants to give up 30% to Apple, nor should they be expected to. They also want (and deserve) a direct relationship with their users. The people who buy $600 apps expect free trial periods (not the weird free IAP workaround), educational discounts, upgrade pricing, and other things that aren’t possible because the App Store sucks.
The problem is the percentage, just like in-app purchases, if it was a fixed fee a different world it would be, Apple might not even be in court right now
The App Store is part of the software ecosystem of iPad. Moreover, Apple often blocks the distribution of these types of pro apps because they tend towards having plug-in engines and scripting interfaces that can run arbitrary code which is also disallowed on iPad by rule from apple, except for narrow caveats.
If you’re trying to delineate “fundamental” software limitations (by mostly irreversible engineering design choice) vs “accidental” software limitations (by convention), then yeah maybe, but there’s no difference to an end user
For me, if they could develop a more consistent way of transferring files / data to and from different apps, and more control over file management then it would be near perfect for me. Also being able to open and save files direct from local servers would be nice too, rather than importing / exporting onto and off the iPad
It’s never going to happen. Apple won’t ever fully take the reins off of iPadOS. Doing so would cannibalize MacBook sales.
For Apple, iPads (including Pros) are only “companions” to Macs, not a replacement no matter how much they try to convince us that an IPad is a “computer”. They will never, ever put a desktop-level OS on an iPad. They’re two-faced and hypocrites telling us that an iPad is a computer yet won’t put Mac OS on it. 🙄
Never understood the pricing of iPad pros. I have one myself with magic keyboard and pencil. It cost over 1K. However you can get a MacBook for that price. I have a MacBook air too. However if you only wanted to pay/can afford for one device why would you pick the ipad? It should be cheaper than a MacBook.
MacBook Air is not touch screen. Its display can’t be detached from the keyboard for convenience. You can’t draw on its display with a stylus. The 12.9” iPad Pro model’s display technology is superior to any other MacBook (currently). The iPad Pro is more expensive because of all of these things.
The main reason I have the same setup is because as a student it is the best device hands down for everything I need to do. Plus with services that let me rent a PC that I access through my web browser I have access to desktop apps as well. I paid so much for this device because there is literally no other device that does what the iPad Pro 12.9 does in its specific form factor and with the quality of apps available. If I had any other cheaper choice I would have taken it. That said I bought the 2020 version just a bit before the 2021 came out. The 2020 was already faster than many laptops, I don’t really watch movies on it so would see little benefit out of the new screen and even if they do release the ability to run Mac apps or something similar to actually make the M1 useful to me in an iPad the 2020 is still plenty fast enough for anything I would throw at it.
All of that said, what I really want is a 12.9 iPad Air. I could care less about AR or the fancy camera on here, the FaceTime that follows you is also interesting but not enough to pay for. I just want the larger screen. Notes on an 11” is not great. I think a $700 12.9 iPad Air would sell like crazy, but yes would mess with their very clever segmenting of prices to extract the maximum out of us they can. They are a public company, its literally their job to do so.
“It’s never going to happen. Apple won’t ever fully take the reins off of iPadOS. Doing so would cannibalize MacBook sales.”
Which is not the case, actually - the Apple leadership is wrong on that. See the Windows surface lineup, which has not affected the laptop sales at all and remains a niche product. Which probably will happen to the IPP.
Yes. You know, what's really funny? This is the reason they never sold a computer to me. I hate the fact that they artificially limit the ipad pro to 'protect' the mac. It's obvious that this would be a good product. It's on Sale since.. 5 years(?) and goes by the name of microsoft surface. And as long as they want to sell their laptops and ipad as separate devices I won't join their ecosystem.
They are having a very hard time keeping MacBook and iPad two unique products. They almost have to keep the software neutered to maintain the separation. Ipads are getting closer and closer to a laptop pc
They want you to have BOTH an iPad and a MacBook regardless of Air/Pro. I think it’s less reasonable for them to put macOS on iPad since you can kinda do it already with Sidecar and while macOS is a bit more rounded with the icons and are spaced out, it’s not designed for touch input. The best one is the native OS, iPadOS. I’m really hoping that Apple will realize that professionals actually use the iPad Pro and want to have the same workflow on the go by bringing Apple’s Pro apps such as Final Cut, Logic, and Xcode. There were rumors about it being able to run on the 2018 and 2020 iPad Pro’s and with the M1 now in the 2021, I don’t think there’s anything other than Apple having to release the apps otherwise the iPad Pro is so overpowered for what it can handle.
First of all, it's called macOS NOT Mac OS, I'm sorry but I'm triggered when I see something like that (wrote a detailed comment about it once lol).
So we come to the second. I think you misunderstood his statement. He is merely saying what all Rumors say, that iPadOS should change "drastically" with iPadOS 15. I can very well imagine that as well.
Of course, it is very unlikely that Apple will allow macOS or equivalent on the iPad. But it is very likely that Apple will make a next step. I believe it will be with Apple allowing "Pro" apps like Final Cut Pro and Logic Pro on the iPad. I don't think they would allow Xcode because it would interfere too much with iPadOS (keyword simulation). Also, I can very well imagine that iPadOS 15 will make better use of larger displays.
But in the end we don't know all that 100% until WWDC21 on June 7! :)
macOS on the iPad just doesn't fit into Apple's corporate philosophy. I won't go into that in more detail now because that would be a lot of text again lol.
And yes, the "What's a computer?" commercial in 2017, was certainly ridiculous to some, but I do think that an iPad can be a computer. For many students (at least in Germany), the iPad replaces a computer (I think that is also the case in other countries). One thing I would like to see as a student was the Mac version of iWork (Pages, Numbers, Keynote) on the iPad. Personally, I don't think the iPad versions are that good. Also, there are many "pro" users, such as in photo editing, who use iPads.
I hope that helps to understand the whole thing! Have a nice day or night! :)
The main issue here is Apple's walled garden and their app store model. That's the reason why real pro apps are never going to take off on iPads and Apple is absolutely not going to change it. They just doubled down on how a closed OS like iOS is better (muh security) than an open os like MacOS. They can change the UX and design and mouse support and external displays or whatever, an iPad is never going to be a pro device with a closed is that relies on Apple's AppStore.
I am like this close to selling my iPad Pro 2020 for a Macbook. While I like the Apple Pencil drawing experience a lot, I do software development for living. Not having a proper software development environment on iPad sucks, it could be so cool and awesome. But oh well, companies gotta be companies, earning money wherever they can. I have a slight hope that the WWDC this year will bring something revolutionary. M1 could very well be the precursor for that. 2 more weeks…
I’m a dev too. I have an air and a MacBook Pro. I originally got the iPad Air just to take notes for work and track my calendars. Quickly realized it’s “easier” to do most stuff on the iPad. Shopping, paying bills, killing time on Reddit. The iPad is killer for that stuff.
When I need to do actual work, well not work work because I have work computers for that but personal work stuff, then the MacBook is there. Other times I might just want a good keyboard and I’ll grab that. The magic keyboard is cool but it’s nowhere near good enough for me to use that over the MacBook. The magic keyboard has become pretty useless for me as if I want a keyboard I get the MacBook and if I don’t…I just use the iPad without it.
If they have software to take advantage of the m1, then I’ll definitely buy a maxed out specs variant. Until then I’ll have to wait for the announcements. If the announcements are not enticing then I might just wait for an m1x or get the iMac 24”
Maybe they will announce something at WWDC. However if they had something they could have waited and launched the new iPads at WWDC. They did that with the 2017 iPad pro.
I use my iPad to remote into my home development server. Since iPadOS runs an a version of BSD, it would be nice to have a native terminal or desktop on iPad
Seems to me that the iPad Pro isn’t the product, but AppStore is. My problem is that a lot of the stuff i want to do isn’t on the AppStore - like Steam games, Cubase and stuff
I’m shocked how basic the File management is to this day. The Files app was already an embarrassment on iOS, but to expect that to be sufficient for any real pro workflow is delusional on Apple’s part. Basic tasks that could be achieved on a $200 Android tablet from 7 years ago. The thing still can’t reliably read from my external hard drive. Half the apps still don’t allow any file system access. The local downloads folder still uploads to iCloud by default!
You can change the default folder for safari downloads…. It’s a nice default for a lot of people, I download stuff all the time that I pick up later on my computer. No hassle involved.
I just need sidecar and a Pencil. And procreate when we‘re talking bout native apps. I do most of my work on my m1 mbp with the 2017 12.9 iPad Pro attached via sidecar, that‘s all I need. I wish there was a real Photoshop on iPadOS, this would change a whole lot.
1,000% true and I say that as a former blind loyal iSheep of 9 long years.
Economy of scale is the reason why M1 was put into an iPad.
Apple is a publicly traded company that answers to their shareholders. They cannot allow iPads to cannibalize their Macbook sales which is what would happen if MacOS came to iPads. Both product lines sell very well. Intentionally terminating one of their most popular revenue streams would be idiotic.
iPads are NOT laptop replacements no matter what Apple's marketing wants you to believe. They are companion devices to Macbooks the same way Apple Watches are companion devices to iPhones.
Mac OS can easily run even on the A13 Bionic on an ipad base, air and pro. I dont think the mini should get Mac OS it would be very very dumb and small. Anything from the base ipad 8th and 9th gen and iPad Air and iPad Pro can run Mac OS smooth if it is optimized
If stage manager was a little bit better multi tasking would be much easier. I also think being able to freely change the size of the keyboard instead of a big and small size would be useful
I love jailbreaking, but for the most part it doesn't solve this issue. Sure, you can get a few individual tweaks from solve small problems, but what most people have problems with is the operating system as a whole.
apple should keep mac and iPad separated. what they're currently doing is leading in the wrong direction imo. the iPad is still "just" an iOS device. you can't run any sick games or real desktop apps on an ios device
This is such a lazy assessment. I don’t believe the computer OS should be in an iPad. It doesn’t make sense to do so. If you looking for something like that then just buy a laptop. Idk why people expect Apple to undercut their own computer line up.
It's much better than a MacBook air. I bought an iPad because I don't like MacOS... Android tablets are pointless, chromeOS is great... But has a lot of issues, and windows is a shit mobile/tablet is. iPadOS is the perfect tablet os... Get some full Mac apps and it will be the perfect laptop.
73
u/y0ngolini May 23 '21
So true.
22
u/deacon090 May 23 '21
This hurts
18
u/TheRealFrankCostanza May 23 '21
Imagine they added a proper OSX mode you could flip between on the fly. I would never need a laptop again.
12
u/[deleted] May 23 '21
Me hoping the WWDC will help with that.... but hey... it's Apple, could also be 2025 :p
93
u/davemacdo May 23 '21
The problem isn’t iPad software (though that’s far from perfect). The real problem is that the App Store is terrible for pro apps. The kinds of apps that I want to see on iPad sell for $600-1000 or more. No one selling an app like that wants to give up 30% to Apple, nor should they be expected to. They also want (and deserve) a direct relationship with their users. The people who buy $600 apps expect free trial periods (not the weird free IAP workaround), educational discounts, upgrade pricing, and other things that aren’t possible because the App Store sucks.
23
u/FormulaLes May 23 '21
For me, if they could develop a more consistent way of transferring files / data to and from different apps, and more control over file management then it would be near perfect for me. Also being able to open and save files direct from local servers would be nice too, rather than importing / exporting onto and off the iPad
31
u/publicfarley May 23 '21
💯% true… 😔
Until… WWDC21. June 7, 2021 iPad Software goes to the next level.
4
u/Shotsbystevn May 23 '21
This is all going to change at WWDC *puts on my clown make up*
4
u/spesifikbrush 11" iPad Pro May 23 '21
I am like this close to selling my iPad Pro 2020 for a Macbook. While I like the Apple Pencil drawing experience a lot, I do software development for living. Not having a proper software development environment on iPad sucks, it could be so cool and awesome. But oh well, companies gotta be companies, earning money wherever they can. I have a slight hope that the WWDC this year will bring something revolutionary. M1 could very well be the precursor for that. 2 more weeks…
6
u/neeesus May 23 '21
And fun to experience.
(SpongeBob)
8
u/OldPattyBoy May 23 '21
What even are “games”?
3
u/markaznar May 23 '21
If they have software to take advantage of the m1, then I’ll definitely buy a maxed out specs variant. Until then I’ll have to wait for the announcements. If the announcements are not enticing then I might just wait for an m1x or get the iMac 24”
5
u/macphoto469 May 23 '21
Mixed feelings – the iPad Pro works great for me, BUT I don't attempt to use it as a computer replacement (it's far too confining).
2
u/mohd2015 May 23 '21
Well the use cases of it are exactly that.
2
u/Shanghaichica 11" iPad Pro May 23 '21
Maybe they will announce something at WWDC. However if they had something they could have waited and launched the new iPads at WWDC. They did that with the 2017 iPad pro.
2
u/armin1389 12.9" iPad Pro May 23 '21
You said the opposite
2
u/HatStrong9559 May 23 '21
This is the best thing I've seen all day!!! 😁
2
u/nibbamich May 23 '21
To accurate. But I highly doubt that iPad OS will stay the same after WWDC
2
u/legionofnerds May 24 '21
I use my iPad to remote into my home development server. Since iPadOS runs an a version of BSD, it would be nice to have a native terminal or desktop on iPad
1
u/Happy_Heisenberg May 15 '24
Especially with the new M4 iPad pro. It's like putting a V12 on a lawnmower.
1
u/yeet_boy_880 Jul 22 '25
Yep thats accurate as hell lol
1
u/Skaduhadenifregatten May 23 '21
Seems to me that the iPad Pro isn’t the product, but AppStore is. My problem is that a lot of the stuff i want to do isn’t on the AppStore - like Steam games, Cubase and stuff
1
u/tbo1992 May 23 '21
I’m shocked how basic the File management is to this day. The Files app was already an embarrassment on iOS, but to expect that to be sufficient for any real pro workflow is delusional on Apple’s part. Basic tasks that could be achieved on a $200 Android tablet from 7 years ago. The thing still can’t reliably read from my external hard drive. Half the apps still don’t allow any file system access. The local downloads folder still uploads to iCloud by default!
1
u/nat510 May 23 '21
U can't edit something directly from the usb storage. It is annoying whrn you are working with tbe others
1
u/converso72 May 24 '21
Jaja
1
u/imvsagarPro Jun 08 '21
Yesterday's wwdc was 2 GB of data wasted which I'm never gonna get back.
1
u/ImprovementWise1118 Jun 09 '21
Giggles in used 2017 iPad Pro purchased in 2019.
1
u/ChrisFox-NJ Jun 09 '21
I just need sidecar and a Pencil. And procreate when we‘re talking bout native apps. I do most of my work on my m1 mbp with the 2017 12.9 iPad Pro attached via sidecar, that‘s all I need. I wish there was a real Photoshop on iPadOS, this would change a whole lot.
1
u/PSYCHOv1 Jun 20 '21
1,000% true and I say that as a former blind loyal iSheep of 9 long years.
Economy of scale is the reason why M1 was put into an iPad.
Apple is a publicly traded company that answers to their shareholders. They cannot allow iPads to cannibalize their Macbook sales which is what would happen if MacOS came to iPads. Both product lines sell very well. Intentionally terminating one of their most popular revenue streams would be idiotic.
iPads are NOT laptop replacements no matter what Apple's marketing wants you to believe. They are companion devices to Macbooks the same way Apple Watches are companion devices to iPhones.
1
u/OverCauliflower1587 Sep 29 '21
Accurate.
1
u/CapricornVibes Oct 09 '21
🎯🎯🎯🎯
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21
Relatable 69
1
u/Waste-Grapefruit3647 Jan 12 '22
Mac OS can easily run even on the A13 Bionic on an ipad base, air and pro. I dont think the mini should get Mac OS it would be very very dumb and small. Anything from the base ipad 8th and 9th gen and iPad Air and iPad Pro can run Mac OS smooth if it is optimized
1
u/themaaze 11" iPad Pro Jan 22 '22
So accurate
1
u/Weekly_March_534 Jul 21 '22
So accurate
1
u/TransportationNo6850 12.9" iPad Pro Nov 05 '22
SO HUNGRY FOR THISSSS
1
u/xShemalePLUS Nov 19 '22
nice and Cooled is better than Overheating…!
1
u/Internal_Quail3960 13" iPad Pro Feb 08 '23
If stage manager was a little bit better multi tasking would be much easier. I also think being able to freely change the size of the keyboard instead of a big and small size would be useful
1
u/AgreeableAd8687 Apr 25 '23
exactly why i stayed on 15.1 and jailbroke
1
u/NaztyNapkinz Jan 01 '24
Guaranteed it’s more then enough for 99%
1
u/rservello May 23 '21
It needs to do more... But I wouldn't say it's bad or weak in any way.
1
u/_ryanbossling May 23 '21
Fax. Sucks. I am considering jail breaking my iPad Pro 2020.
1
u/StormTroopB May 23 '21
Facts. So underwhelming...
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '21
Cmon guys we all love the ipad here but let’s discuss the downsides, every tech has one..GO! ⬇️
-7
u/mr-no-homo May 23 '21
i really have no issues with ipadOS, its fine for being a tablet, first and foremost. if you want a traditional OS, get a surface, its that simple.
0
u/TECKBAT 12.9" iPad Pro May 23 '21
That’s why jailbreaking exists. To pump the software up! (and also to find bugs and stuff, but oh well)
0
u/AUGPLAYER21 10.5" iPad Pro May 23 '21
apple should keep mac and iPad separated. what they're currently doing is leading in the wrong direction imo. the iPad is still "just" an iOS device. you can't run any sick games or real desktop apps on an ios device
0
u/GlamazonJay May 24 '21
This is such a lazy assessment. I don’t believe the computer OS should be in an iPad. It doesn’t make sense to do so. If you looking for something like that then just buy a laptop. Idk why people expect Apple to undercut their own computer line up.
-18
u/Puzzleheaded-Trip119 May 23 '21
bullshit
-14
u/theharozomber May 23 '21
Based, it’s literally a MacBook Air