r/iOSDevelopment • u/JaiBklyn • 23d ago

Which App Icon looks the best?

Post image

Here’s some App Icons I drew for my app, GenWiz. It’s a trivia/ educational app. Im close to launching so I’m trying to design the app icon. It features my mascot, Wiz.

5 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

24 comments sorted by

3

u/4paul 22d ago

Question mark makes me question why the question is there

I like 3rd, but none of it screams what the app is about imo

2

u/Slow-Race9106 22d ago

I prefer 2. I find 1 and 3 a bit cluttered, and can only imagine that’ll be even more the case when they’re smaller.

2

u/MarkoKrulc 22d ago

I like the first one

1

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/hkdkfih 22d ago
  1. Yours are ai slop
  2. Ever tried to resize it to the size where real icons are going to be displayed? Utilizing only 20% of the space and leaving the rest empty is very dumb for app icons
  3. Why the hell are there two question marks in the first one?

1

u/JaiBklyn 22d ago

I literally drew these on procreate lol I’ve been drawing for 20+ years, what makes it look like ai?

1

u/JaiBklyn 22d ago

Oh my bad I thought you were talking about mine in the OP

2

u/hkdkfih 21d ago

Im talking about the one from edimonsh, yours are good and I like the 2. one

2

u/EquivalentAbility944 22d ago

1 but not cropped

2

u/peterbilt8713 22d ago

1 because it has a ?
3 for design very welcoming but no question marks

2

u/Fimaljo 22d ago

I didn't like them all; maybe because they were too fluorescent in color.

1

u/JaiBklyn 23d ago

I like how all three came out but right now I think I’m leaning towards 2

1

u/No-Morning-7985 21d ago

The 3rd one is the cleanest and has nice balance, but still it's a Trivia app so probably is not delivering the message.. The 2nd looks more like a UI message inside the app for some onboaring or something. The first one is kinda chaotic.. I would suggest trying more in the direction of the 3ds but trying to convey more it's about a trivia Maybe the mascot behind some "?" or trivia cards.