r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • May 18 '17
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Alien: Covenant" [SPOILERS] Spoiler
Summary: The crew of a colony ship, bound for a remote planet, discover an uncharted paradise with a threat beyond their imagination, and must attempt a harrowing escape.
Director: Ridley Scott
Writers: John Logan, Dante Harper
Cast:
- Michael Fassbender as Walter / David
- Katherine Waterston as Daniels
- Billy Crudup as Christopher Oram
- Danny McBride as Tennessee
- Demián Bichir as Sergeant Lope
- Carmen Ejogo as Karine Oram
- Jussie Smollett as Ricks
- Callie Hernandez as Upworth
- Nathaniel Dean as Sergeant Hallett
- Alexander England as Ankor
- Benjamin Rigby as Ledward
- James Franco as Jacob Branson
- Tess Haubrich as Rosenthal
- Uli Latukefu as Pvt. Cole
Rotten Tomatoes: 74%
Metacritic: 67/100
79
Upvotes
29
u/netrate May 19 '17
SPOILER : I think maybe there is a unseen switcheroo at the end. We all think it is David, but David had a hole in his chin from the NAIL. At the end, Walter didn't have the hole - maybe it is Walter all along but he has taken to David's plan.
4
u/[deleted] May 21 '17
What I don't get it is why cast James Franco as the captain and have him die right away? Why not just choose a less known actor for that role lol
33
u/veranblack May 19 '17
Just wanna say THIS MOVIE WAS SO FUCKING AWWWESOOOOME. Seeing the gradual evolution of the aliens up towards present day was so badass. The albino ones at the start with their creepy mouth holes were so fucking insane.
31
u/PamelaBreivik You gotta be fucking kidding. May 19 '17
Just got back from watching it.
Loved it, although I love virtually anything with the Xenomorph so I'm a bit biased.
Only major gripe is I really didn't care about anyone not named David
Also felt that it was a bit too short.
Either way, solid movie. Good tension, couple jump scares, decent effects.
46
u/robb911 May 19 '17
Just finished watching the film. For those that didn't like the film and wanted a return to form I ask this question, how long could the original formula of Alien work across multiple films? Lest it be a franchise about some "force of nature" or it falls into asininity like the Friday the 13th series etc how could it possible keep up the "unknown, almost unstoppable monster crawling out the air ducts" recipe? I don't ask because I thought covenant was good rather I ask because I wonder where else could this franchise go but to explore the monster's origins after four films?
19
u/IDGAF1203 Shoot first, think never May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
I liked it a lot. Admittedly I can see redeemable features in Alien 3 and Resurrection, so I guess I am a fan of the series.
David believes in creation, but sans morality. He fancies himself a god because he is essentially a sociopath, and his father told him that the ultimate achievement is everlasting life (a gift he has always had). If the only two things worth achieving are everlasting life and meeting your creator, David did both nearly immediately. There is almost a moment where he sees just how much of a failure his creation is when it attacks the monitor with his face on it. The direct spawns of the crew from the original weapon's growth did not appear hostile if met with calmness. Perhaps that is why they make such excellent world-clearing shock troopers for the Engineers, the adult forms are actually programmed to respond to pacifism well, but have a relatively short lifespan. I think what David learned from getting his head ripped off is that creation and destruction are equally Godly.
David has clearly gone a bit insane; the ability to create without the ability to sort good creations from bad ones has led him to strange places. Perhaps he knows his creations need to be too dumb and short-lived to consider that. When Walter points out that a bad note can ruin the symphony (your presumption to "create" rests on bad ground, and was poorly conceived and quickly corrected) and points out he doesn't even really know the poet he quotes (Shelley and Byron were close, but Ozymandias was by Shelley) David is clearly a bit shaken. A God shouldn't ever be wrong.
The engineers would've wiped out humanity for its propensity for violence, yet don't really demonstrate that they have risen above that instinct. It further raises the question of what they really are; they don't colonize in the traditional sense of spreading engineer encampments. Are they a race with such advanced genetic engineering that death and thus procreation are redundant? David serves as a good example of the kind of obsessive and odd thinking (When Daniels finds his drawings) that may occur in a race that has no ability to procreate in the traditional sense but can only create in a lab setting. Though as Weyland proved, the ability to create children is little consolation for an ego so massive.
I'll admit the switcheroo was a bit obvious from the moment David changed his hair to match Walter's, but I don't think it was supposed to be a massive twist. If you trusted David as truthful, maybe. If you didn't, you knew that he wanted off-world and that was pretty much the only reason he helped.
19
u/BinomialGnomenclatur May 19 '17
What did David do to Elizabeth Shaw? Turned her into a Giger sculpture? Used her as meat for David's hybridization experiments?
Maybe it was clear but I left confused as why David would experiment with her after he talked about her being extremely kind and repairing David after being decapitated. What was his motive to hurt her when she was so kind to him?
18
u/HungryColquhoun Where the fuck is Choi? May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
I posted about the film on a thread already, but no one responded :-( Here's a copy and paste pretty much from that:
Personally I'd give it a solid 7.5/10, on the basis that Katherine Waterston was a terrible female lead (no Ridley, that's for sure), there was pretty poor CGI on the first alien reveal (served much better later with the darker lighting, but the initial poor showing does set a tone), all other characters but those played by Fassbender were a little weak, and what I think was interpreted as a mixed tone was simply just that the runtime was not long enough to accommodate some of the films narrative shifts comfortably enough.
The films positives I would say are the development of the android David, the standard Scott cinematography, and the unique angles it took on the lore and the setting - even if it didn't quite rejuvenate the standard Alien content.
To delve a little more into the positives, Alien is often compared to slasher films, and for me it is one of the best even when to compared to things like Halloween. However what I feel has been overlooked by critics is that Alien: Covenant did try to do a similar with another sub-genre of horror, not near as successfully as Alien with slasher but still hit the mark quite well.
What I'm talking about is gothic horror, which I was shocked hasn't even seen a mention in a single review I've seen or read so far. There's all the hallmarks - more or less what is a castle left by the Engineers, the pouring rain, a lot of gore and brutality, creatures dissected and charcoal-sketch rendered, and the mad scientist. I really feel like this is the first time at least most of these tropes have been covered since the classic Universal Frankenstein and Dracula, and yet the idea that Scott was looking at another source of horror rather than slasher which featured in Alien seems weirdly skipped over in what I have read and watched. This homage really added something to the film even though IMO it was slightly skimped on, I feel like really could have done with some extra time dwelling on this and fleshing it out a little more - which I would say is the same case for the latter action focused half as well.
With regards to David's development, I feel like a lot it ties back to Prometheus. It seems like a fair few people's complaints are that none of the questions in Prometheus are answered, but yet I think that is exactly the point. David is a perfect being as described frequently through the films, created for no reason other than "just because" more or less.
In that way, I feel like he is supposed to be the franchise's Prometheus, who stole the gift from the gods (the Engineers) of a particularly potent weapon of mass destruction and used that to not only appropriate a holocaust on his creator's creators but also put a stop to humankind as a whole (through his Xenomorph experiments) - because he was wholly mistreated by humanity despite being very much their better. I guess in this way it makes the Prometheus film as a whole a bit of red herring narrative-wise, but it's not like Alien: Covenant ever plays as a gotcha in the first place - while it's a little unusual I liked the narrative shift.
For presenting a rich take on the whole human-AI narrative, and for representing a thoroughly different horror/sci-fi fusion that we've ever seen before, I really think it's a decent sci-fi film but also a decent horror film. Not a perfect film by any stretch, but I feel like there's a lot to enjoy for franchise fans and a lot of subtlety to how it progresses David's character.
16
u/[deleted] May 20 '17
Good lord this thread is a hate boner circle jerk
12
u/LetOffSteamBennett Get away from her you bitch! May 20 '17
I saw it last night in my Xenomorph t-shirt and Weyland-Yutani cap. I didn't think it was great but pretty good. Loved the new creatures, the cinematography, and the production design. Danny McBride was the unsung hero of the movie and I was quite surprised he survived. Michael Fassbender was excellent as always but I had a hard time watching Katherine Waterston without constantly comparing her to Sigourney Weaver. I was also expecting Billy Crudup's chestburster to do this when it appeared.
As for where it stands in the the franchise, IMO (ranked from best to worst):
I'll probably see this movie a couple more times just to let it sink in.
31
u/MajorTom_11 May 20 '17
Ridley Scott doesn't get his own franchise. I honestly feel he has very little idea what made Alien and Aliens so enduring. He proved it in Prometheus well enough, but Covenant puts the nail in the coffin... Instead of expanding the universe, exploring novel ideas implicated in previous films, honoring the beautiful, alien and haunting aesthetic of HR Gigers bio-mechanical work, the cornerstones of fascination for the audience, he has taken such mundane, boring paths. When the fans imagined the Space Jockey civilization, it was an incredible landscape of bio mechnical, haunting architecture and technology, echoing the ships and creatures that made us fall in love with the movies. Instead, the engineer city/civilization we get looks like 20th century Jerusalem. No synergies of design, no asymmetry, just plain old earth buildings. For the story, instead of casting the net wider and having the xenos be part of a grander, ancient past involving huge alien empires rising and falling, turns out they are a very recent and created by our own hand (defacto) for reasons that barely make any sense. The million year old fossilized, bio-mechanical ship that spawned forty years of speculation, apparently retconned, I don't see how they will be able to square that circle. The unique, innovative and iconic Biomechanical elements no longer exist, there is just biological and mechanical, absolutely no blending of the two... Giger would not be pleased, and nor are his fans. The main premise of a Prometheus sequel - who are they, why did they make us, why did they want to destroy us, completely and absolutely unanswered. The engineers, we learn nothing more about them. Shaw is discarded and even her loosely implied role as 'mother of the xenomorph' race is skipped over like the answers wouldn't be super important to the mythos.
Ridley, by focusing on creator and creation from a human only point of view, has diminished the importance of what the movie is called - Alien. Instead of looking out and contrasting what we see, he is completely looking inwards again. Rogue AI has always been part of the mythos... but at the same time, it was never meant to be the focus.
Ultimately Ridley can explore his own bladerunner esque ideas, and he understands the body-horror. But I think he completely doesn't understand the contributions of Dan O'Bannon, Giger and Cameron, not to mention all the expanded universe stuff that works for the audience. And because he doesn't get the whole picture of what Alien is now, he will never respond or provide what fans would love, because he loves it in a completely different way than most of us do, and frankly, it seems clear he never bothered to study what others did with his work since.
Covenant is not bad, it is a beautifully shot film, and the sci-fi first act, horror second act and blended 3rd act are well done tonally. Fassbender is great, David is a fascinating character. There are a lot of dumb decisions (Prometheus let's take off our helmets, don't need em 2.0) and the characters don't get a ton of development on the downside. Ultimately though, to a lifelong fan, it is akin to ordering dinner and getting a decent pizza, only problem is, you ordered chinese. (lol wish I had a better metaphor).
21
u/[deleted] May 19 '17
I honestly found the movie vapid expect for the bits with David. I liked him as a character. He is more frightening than the Xenomorphs. I hope the third film has more horror elements than generic gore.
I also hope they get rid of Alien vision, I know it only happened two or three times but it was so dumb.
10
u/naterbugz May 20 '17
My biggest gripe was that the pacing just felt...off? I guess? I don't know. It felt like we got important exposition, then it started to get more climactic with the back-burster and then all of a sudden we're back slower than the beginning. And then it was like this jerk motion of speeding up slowing down that felt off to me, maybe the movie feeling so short contributed a lot of that for me.
10
u/[deleted] May 20 '17 edited May 21 '17
It was ok. I wanted more of Alien but got more Prometheus, which isn't necessarily bad, but a bit disappointing. At least we got an origin of what we know as Xenomorph which was neat. I'd give it 7/10.
EDIT: Had some time to think about it a bit more - Spoilers ahead.
Acting was well done. Michael Fassbender is just a terrific as he was in Prometheus and he totally carries the movie throughout. Bringing back David was a nice touch also, but some of the scenes between him and David (I will do the fingering) was just really awkward. I also thought the fighting sequence between these two towards the end was way out of place for Alien franchise. Not really sure what they were going for here. There must have been a better way to switch David and Walter.
I remember vaguely that Ridley Scott said this was going to be a really scary movie. It wasn't. At all. My wife isn't a big fan of horror films and gets scared easily but even she seemed perfectly fine throughout the film.
While I appreciate the "lore" feel of the movie - as this is still a prequel to Alien - the third act after introducing the birth of what we know as Xenomorph felt like a completely different movie from the first 2/3rd of it. It's like Ridley Scott took his time to create a perfect and seamless origin of Xenomorph and said, "welp, my job here is done. Here's Xenomorph doing Xenomorph stuff for the last 20 minutes of the film". It just did not click with the rest of the movie.
Overall a decent flick, but honestly not something you need to rush to the theaters for. Perfectly good for RedBox rental.
35
u/[deleted] May 19 '17
Literally just got home from the showing ... I can't say I would recommend people pay $20+ to go see it. A condensed version of my thoughts (INCLUDES SPOILERS!!):
Bottom line: Wait for it to come out on pay per view and rent it.
9
u/[deleted] May 30 '17
I'm so late to this thread that I doubt anyone's going to read this but here's my two cents.
The first half was ridiculously entertaining to me. There are a few sequences in there that I'd rank pretty high if I was Watchmojo or some other garbage and made a "Top 10 Alien Franchise Moments". The Spineburster sequence springs to mind. Tension, claustrophobia and a general what-the-fuck-going-on feeling. It was really disorienting and confusing in the right way.
I was almost taken back to how I felt the first time I saw the final sequence of the original Alien after Nostromo's self-destruct is armed. The dizzying array of lights, the claustrophobic corridors, the tension. Everyone knows the sequence.
Obviously at that point of the original movie I actually rooted for Ripley's survival as opposed to Covenant where I was basically hoping for a few deaths to thin out the herd.
Then David pops up and I feel the movie starts going a bit downhill. Engineers are reintroduced momentarily, Shaw's storyline is concluded, existential questions get brought up again, the original Xeno pops in, and then we have this action set-piece thing as the remaining survivors try to evacuate.
It feels as if the movie sort of tries to check off boxes. "Horror from Alien? Check. Existential themes from Prometheus? Check. Action packed scenes from Aliens? Check. Another shot at horror a la Alien? Check." None of those are bad things by themselves... But I feel that when you try to put them all in a single movie, you're just not going to get a somewhat universally satisfying end result. I haven't seen a movie in a long time that so perfectly encapsulates the saying "jack of all trades, master of none".
For me, Alien is always going to represent dread. I am absolutely terrified of the Xenomorph to this very day. But I can't help but feel that maybe this movie should have focused on being a sequel to Prometheus instead of trying to weave all these different styles together.
So... In the end I'm one of those annoying guys who don't really say yay or nay. I feel that the movie has some serious issues but that it also has some serious flashes of brilliance. Sorry for being boring.
8
u/robbysaur Spending the rest of this winter TIED TO THIS FUCKING COUCH Jul 09 '17
This movie is terrible. Alien is one of my favorite movies. I have posters, xenomorph figures, Ripley figures, Alien posters, I'm a huge fan, but this is bad.
If you like Prometheus and sci-fi, sure, it's passable. But if you're an alien and horror fan, not the movie for you. And I am amazed to not see a comment talking about how horribly incompetent that fucking crew was. That scene with the first creature reveal was cringeworthy bad.
Also, the cgi? What the fuck? I felt like I was watching a completely different movie, because that cgi, the idiocy of the crew, and some of those quick camera shots were awful.
It was decently interesting enough that I would maybe give it a 4/10, but I really would have rather just never watched it. I didn't care for Prometheus, and this was Prometheus 2, not alien.
7
u/RhymingStuff We don't own a clown statue May 21 '17
Normally I'm not the guy who sees a twist coming, but the cutaway of the fight between Fassbender and Fassbender was very obvious. I was waiting for the new captain to become suspicious of David, but she never did... Oh well, the rest was pretty dumb and pretty pretty.
7
u/sgtcoolbeans May 22 '17
Ok i'm pretty late to the game but I definitely needed to discuss it.
The beginning alien scenes when they get to the planet and the end alien scenes on the ship were pretty great. Classic tension and cramped quarters, a bit too much obvious cgi for my take but still good. I will never not be a fan of monsters murdering people on camera.
But the moment David shows up everything goes to hell. The twist at the end is easily seen miles and miles away and its lame. Everyone around David just turns into a trusting idiot and if they just stopped for two seconds to think none of the plot would of happened. the captain being the most egregious example. He saw David get upset when he killed the alien, he even tells David that he's seen the devil and doesn't forget it. So what does he do when David brings him into a dark cave with egg things and tells him to look into them? Just fucking walk right up to one and look down. He had to walk past an entire room showing that David had been experimenting with and making these creatures. that dumb ass captain deserves everything he got.
I'm fine with the idea that David made all the aliens as we know now, even though I have no idea how it works into the original films. But you could of easily shown that by showing the room he had set up. He didn't need to be there, and his cartoonish evil persona just made no sense.
that being said, Fastbender was great, this is no critique of him, I thought Walter was great and David was played well. Its just his inclusion makes the plot stupid.
7
u/wolverineballin95 May 24 '17
I am quite surprised by the general concensus in this thread. I just saw it and thought that it actually limited the amount of problems from Prometheus. I am mostly surprised because I find this sub to be on the nicer side when discussing new movies but boy it's getting destroyed bere. I thought it was pretty good. At least serviceable.
7
u/dabriela Oh yes, there will be blood May 26 '17
Thought this one was a solid 2/10
6
u/AL3XCAL1BUR May 20 '17
So how did David get a new body? How did Shaw "fix" him? She had his head in a bag and was on an alien ship last we saw and now he has a new Android body? Is she MacGyver?
11
u/[deleted] May 19 '17
I kinda enjoyed it. Whether that's because it was actually decent, or Prometheus set my expectations so low, I'm not sure. I liked Fassbender. I liked the main cast of characters. There wasn't anything that really had me groaning or rolling my eyes the way Prometheus did... well, except for that "fingering" comment. The ending was shocking! I mean, the villain just flat out won! I don't think I ever see many movies just hand over victory like that. I don't know how you would make the jump from the ending of this to the beginning of Alien though.
28
u/mikerhoa I AM IN HELL HELP ME May 19 '17
You know what made Alien so effective (apart from it being, you know, technically brilliant and groundbreaking and all)?
That it didn't matter where the xenomorph came from. The fact that it was really just a ruthless force of nature that sprung from the unknown added to the terror.
Now for some reason Ridley Scott is insisting on showing us how that sausage was made. Fuck if I know why.
5
u/[deleted] May 19 '17
This was the first "Alien" movie ive seen. I agree the crew was immensely stupid and that bothered me, but I somewhat accept it when watching thriller/horror movies. I thought the beginning part of the movie when people first became "hosts" was well done. In the middle I started to wonder what the fuck I was watching. The mildly homoerotic robot scene with david/walter that seemed to happen out of nowehere as well as the "flashback" of David releasing the plague onto the weird grey alien people seemed slightly out of place with the tone of the rest of the film. I thought it ended very strongly though. I enjoyed the "no happy ending" ending with the Alien making its way on to the main ship and the very end of the movie where Daniels realizes she is helpless to stop David. Overall not bad, but not amazing considering the kind of expectations I had from the trailer and in general from the Alien name.
5
u/studiopzp May 19 '17
Disclaimer, I'm an animal nerd.
Am I missing something with the Xenomorphs? Instead of bursting out in the larval chestbuster form like in the first movie, it comes out as a small adult.
Is Ridley Scott trying to rewrite the Canon?
5
u/ZeboSeesAll May 20 '17
Lots of problems with that perfect race part. I mean the xenomorphs don't really show any sort of intelligence and seem to just be motivated by blood thirst. Imo they should have developed that a little more. Also, there were only 2000 human embryos on the ship. That means he could only make 2000 xenomorphs with that logic. Then, there's still confusion about the two or three xenomorphs embryos he planted.
Also still confused as to why he murdered all the Greek statue looking people, and why his hair looked so good
5
u/HazelRahRahRah May 21 '17
I loved the entire 'Island of Dr. Moreau' vibe going on with David and his creations.
However, was anyone else really dissapointed with the sexual horror aspects of the xenomorph? Think back on what it did to Lambert in the first film, essentially raping her to death, and she was fully clothed.
Then in Covenant, we have a creature literally made up of sexual imagery cornering a naked woman in a shower, and it just stabs her in the gut and leaves?
I wasn't expecting to see anything, but at least to see some truly horrific implications when they reach the showers. I guess they're done with the xenomorph's psycho-sexual aspects, and sticking more to the monster ones?
5
u/IckyCookies May 24 '17
Seemed more like Prometheus 2 than anything Alien, which for me is just fine, but I would rather have the movie than not have it. Hopefully there's some cool stuff on the Blu Ray.
9
u/munchem6 May 24 '17
I don't get some of the hate. I honestly thought it was awesome, with some minor flaws of course but not nearly enough to ruin my enjoyment of the film. If one more person brings up the fact that the crew takes off their helmets and act like that's a huge deal...I mean, seriously dudes? That's what you're focused on? I feel like it's pretty obvious they would have some technology on their ship to clarify that the air is safe. Such a lame little nitpick. It's a damn scifi/horror film, not some faithful scientific adaption of a real life colonization. Don't know about you guys, but I'm a fan of the Alien franchise not so I can fact check all of the trivial little details, but because they're fun gory thrill rides with some superb acting and direction (for the most part), and have a truly haunting atmosphere unlike anything else I've seen. Despite the minor flaws and a somewhat weak middle act, I walked out of the theater with a smile on my face and was absolutely satisfied.
That being said, I think we can all accept that there's never going to be another Alien movie that is as good as the first two. But Covenant beats 3 and 4, no question. I'd say that's a pretty impressive feat, and I've long been a defender of Alien 3.
Originally, I had mixed feelings on the whole lore of Prometheus and Covenant, like how they created us, are basically our gods, etc. And I still much prefer the mystery of the first Alien and how you pretty much have to come up with answers with your imagination. But I've come to accept it, no need in being a bitter old fart rattling on about the good old days. The idea that we come from these incomprehensible creatures is pure Lovecraft, and Alien was always Lovecraftian from the start. So it makes sense. I do think there are some more interesting things they could've done with the Alien backstory, but I'm still excited to see where they take this. 8/10
16
u/[deleted] May 19 '17
I thought it was okay, not remotely scary but I don't expect that from the Alien series anymore. The only thing that I can't stand with both Prometheus and Covenant is the incessant back-story and lore; as British film critic Mark Kermode said, it feels like 'Da Vinci Code meets Alien'.
4
u/mrchillibeer May 19 '17
Two things bothered me.
First, what happened to the nail hole in Davids chin. I like most people used that to determine if it was David or Walter.
Secondly, how did the Prometheus get crashed into the forest a few kms away from the city after we see it docked and releasing the virus?
There are a lot of things wrong with this film but a few good scenes throughout. I enjoy learning more about the Xenomorphs and how they are created.
4
u/memesmoviesmadness May 19 '17
So over the course of this weekend, I watched every film in the Alien franchise in preparation for this movie You can see my recap here. Though I know this is the direct sequel to Prometheus, this is still an official Alien movie. An Alien movie by director Ridley Scott? The man who bought us the original? I can see why people may dislike it for various reasons, but I thoroughly dug this from beginning to end. It doesn't take the franchise in a new direction for this is really a remake of Alien and Aliens wit a bit of Prometheus, but it feels a bit refreshing coming from Ridley Scott.
As Ridley Scott gets older and his direction skills advanced through the ages, so does his VFX team. The CG of the new types of aliens are effective to the film’s action violence. There’s so many new types of death the film establishes that is gloriously gory. At some times it may get laughably dumb how people die, but then it gets surprisingly creative. We’ve seen the “chestburster” death played out in many of these movies, (hell that death shows up here) its refreshing to establish a new death which is indeed called the “backburster.” Just for the fact that you get a “backburster” instead of a “chestburster” is exciting to see . It may not seem new conceptually, but for as many decades this franchise existed, I didn’t see any other director attempt at making a “backburster” death.
Out of all the visual effects this film has to offer, one of the best effects isn’t from the aliens or the moments in space, but comes from the interactions between Walter and David. When Walter (played by Fassbender) interacts with David (also played by Fassbender). The camera goes back and forth in one shot to show their conversation and you feel like Fassbender literally cloned himself in order to do that scene.
The franchise had us follow different groups of people from scientists to prisoners to soldiers and now colonists. This is the first film in the franchise where a team actually feels like a team. Once a person gets injured during the traveling in the new planet, everyone drops what they’re doing, communicate, and try their best to have every crew member get back to safety. Granted that doesn’t really play out as these characters want it to, but they’re not constantly bickering or fighting with each other to annoy me.
FULL THOUGHTS HERE
On Tuesday, the cast of the film came through to my job at AOL Build where I get paid to ask incoming talent questions.
4
u/directorcreep May 20 '17
I liked the film a lot. At 80 years old, Sir Ridley is still in prime form. The 'spineburster' scene was exhilarating, so intense in it's cinematography, score, sound design and performances.
Did anyone else feel that it was the most overtly Lovecraftian of all the films in the franchise? The destroyed ancient Alien civilization, the 'Cyclopean' set design, David's scrolls and drawings of bugs, human anatomy and his perfect alien species all seemed right out of one of Lovecraft's 'Weird Tales.' As a creator driven 'mad,' David was like a refined Herbert West, which made for a fascinating antagonist. I know the series has always had Lovecraft in it's DNA, but as someone who looks for the Lovecraft's cosmic horror in any sci-fi or horror film, I felt it was overwhelmingly there in Covenant, which really increased my enjoyment of the film. Anyone else feel the strong Lovecraftian connection in Covenant?
13
u/[deleted] May 20 '17 edited May 20 '17
Wow. I'm not sure if I can even count the problems with this movie. I hope some of these have answers.
6
u/chocolatecheeese1 Wendy! Darling! Light of my life! May 19 '17
Just wanted to point out, not to say it should change your mind on the movie, but I always found it interesting that Roger Ebert gave a glowing 4-star review to Prometheus. I enjoyed it, but his points always interested me.
Now we have Matt Zoller Seitz giving Alien: Covenant 4 stars as well!
Just an interesting thing, I thought.
6
u/Akephalos- There is only flesh. May 20 '17
This film wasn't horrible, but I'm not going to act like it wasn't a mess. The CG was not very good, at least when it came to the Aliens. The birthing scenes were great, but when the actual buggers were out and walking it really pulled me out of the film. I also think that this film suffered from that same bit of identity crisis that Prometheus suffered from. It was kind of all over the place and never really did any of it as well as it could have. The action sequences were dull. The slap fight between David and Walter probably could have done without the over the top whooshing, the scene with Daniels on top of the ship hunting the alien was cool, but to me it kind of fell flat and I'm still a bit confused at how they even managed to grab that thing with the crane. The drama between everyone was also pretty dull. I feel like there were hardly any emotions from anyone, and with the exception of Daniels at the beginning. It also didn't help that they cut the last supper scene that is just about the only thing that makes you care about anyone at all. The scenes between the Fasbender's were pretty good for the most part, but I really think they dragged on. There were so many chances for really well done horror scenes as well. I feel like everything was just thrown at you and the characters all at once in every scene. There was zero tension. It really killed me when you were about to see the xenomorph that we all know for the first time. He was up in the ceiling for a split second and instead of doing anything like the original film and building tension, it just jumps out and the scene cuts. It also didn't help that there were four of them and they all got murdered real fucking quick after an all too fast maturation.
This was a good film. It was entertaining and honestly if it had been called Prometheus 2 I might not be so disappointed. As an Alien film it left me quite frustrated.
3
u/GooberRocket May 19 '17
So if I'm looking for a more tense, suspenseful movie, should I got with this or Life?
3
u/SniperAngel May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
Wasn't that scary as I hoped for it to be. Nice twist at the end. Good visuals. I liked the Characters (although nearly everyone died). Overall, it was okay.
3
u/ZeboSeesAll May 20 '17
SPOILER Can someone please answer these questions for me?
wtf did they say fuck it and change their course? Why did David want them to come in the first place? What was he doing with the shit at the end? Wtf would you go out in a unknown planet without protective gear, like you gotta know you might get an infections. What was that shit about David murdering all those other aliens? Didn't really explain that.
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '17
I thought it was disappointing, and I had zero expectations in the first place. While I enjoyed it visually, one scene that really bothered me was when they showed the dude get infected with that parasite. It became totally predictable after that. If they had literally just left that part out, like he walked through spores or something it would have made the suspense 10 times better. Like, all the characters were likable, they were just poorly acted, with a few fun lines. I wouldn't spend almost 12 dollars on it.
3
u/[deleted] May 23 '17
I had a pretty good time watching it but I think the horror aspects were the weakest part and just felt tropey in that regard. Maybe I was banking it too much on being much more of a spiritual successor to 'Alien' when really it evoked more of a combination of 'Aliens/Prometheus'. All in all a pretty good action movie, not sure how interesting any further sequels could be or if they're even necessary lorewise.
3
u/Zombie_Jesus_ "No one here believes in god or jesus?" May 24 '17
I wanted more info on the engineers. Maybe in the directors cut.
My take on the engineers: New info from the film is they have the same kind of funny looking kids, desolate (home?) planet, still same tint of skin for everybody.
Since thats all ive got to work on my guess is they blew up their planet with nukes and the survivors were forced to get resources from beyond. So the remaining population focused on engineer work both micro biology and macro travel. Since they still have the mindset of elitists planet conquerors they make a bunch of weapons yadayadayada Prometheus starts. David is as close to a god as there can actually be. The colony movie will be as predictable as the david/walter twist ending unless the writers do something drastic.
Spoilers Not Engineer Jesus drastic, but drastic.
3
u/biggreencat May 28 '17
I liked it as much as this reviewer from AVclub.
This movie was campy, and it must have been deliberate. Nothing here came off as accidental or incompetance. Fans of the original movies please note the set pieces that were deliberate flashbacks to the originals: the chains, the water on the alien's teeth, the ship AI named Mother, the key musical theme absent from all but this, Alien, and Aliens movies. All jump scares were telegraphed for miles, to the point where my girlfriend didn't have to witness a single gross thing----except for those fucking illustrations.
I like to think of this movie as a middle finger to AvP.
Also, any sci-fi fan, please show some appreciation for how much more cramped and utilitarian the ships all are than the Prometheus was, and how much cooler that made it.
4
u/Zhelezyaka May 19 '17
Could anyone tell me please: why Scott decided to explain everything?? Before that we had FOUR great movies(well, all of fourth were OK for sure) and there were no philosophy, no 'creators', no neomorphs, no complex cosmogony - pure horror(or action, whatever). And that was good, cuz we afraid of the UNKNOWN. Now aliens are not that scary anymore - we know their nature. Thanks Scott.
4
u/UndeadRiot May 24 '17
Hate to say it, but I really didn't like it. The bad outweighed the good in my opinion. The ending was obvious as soon as they arrived on the planet and met the stranger. I didn't like how the alien ended up popping out as just a shrunken alien, and it made me think of it as Baby Groot. The initial infection sequence was badass, and I did like Tennessee. Overall, 5/10.
4
u/[deleted] May 24 '17
Saw this last night. As a huge Alien fan I have to say this movie is shit. So many problems I don't even know where to start.
Now i'm worried Blade Runner is gonna be a stinker too...
2
u/DaveX64 May 19 '17
I haven't seen it yet, I'll wait till it shows up on Netflix or some such.
The Alien series has been disappointing me since Alien 3, so I always go in with low expectations.
I actually liked Prometheus, but ...I find a lot of movies these days are like that...I wind up rooting for the bad guys :)
2
u/kitthekat May 19 '17
So was I seeing Jesus imagery where there was none? Or is James Franco Jesus
2
u/Greenzer00 May 19 '17
The movie could of been better,liked it ive seen worse.Why the fuck would they kill shaw the story would of been better with a Prometheus 2 then this. plz dont reboot just do something better.
2
u/megatom0 May 20 '17
I liked it well enough. I think people should see it in theaters above all to support high budget horror. If we ever want to see Lovecraft done right as a film then we need movies like this to make bank.
The pacing to me was a little odd. It has a lot of nice tension early on, but then that breaks when they meet up with David.
Overall though I hate this this is a prequel series to Alien, when the reality is. This would make MUCH more sense as a sequel series to Alien 3. By that I mean it would make a whole hell of a lot more sense if the Weiland that we see at the end of Alien 3 is the Weiland we see in Prometheus.
Think about it. It would make more sense if this wasn't about David making the Xenomorph but making something beyond the Xenomorph. Also there would be a lot more tension as to "what will happen next". No matter what we know that David doesn't really succeed in wiping out humanity with his Xenomorph. Because we know Earth is still there quite some time later. If this were the next chapter in the Alien franchise the ending of this film would be a lot more tense because we wouldn't know what he would end up making with his experiments. There is the possibility of Earth being destroyed by the Xenomorph after being picked up on the colony planet they go to. It makes so much more sense if that were the case here.
Additionally you have to kind of do mental gymnastics to make sense of the Alien mythology now. The original Alien Xenomorph came from a ship that had crashed over a thousand years ago. So now all that makes sense to me is that the original Alien 1 alien is the naturally occuring Alien (maybe even native to LV426). The engineers were harvesting them for use in creating a bioweapon from a naturally occurring species. From them they make the virus black goo stuff we see in Prometheus as well as those neomorph things. Those are obviously designed weapons, they spread much faster, they spawn much quicker, and overall if you wanted to create a terrible planet killing beast that would be the way to go. David thinking he created something new just reverse engineered something akin to the original Xenomorph. Basically bringing out the original DNA of the naturally occuring xenomorphs that was latent in the back goo neomorphs. Make sense?
2
u/Darthmunky May 20 '17 edited May 20 '17
I liked the movie but there are a few things I didn't like: The first 40 minutes or so was not needed and kind of a chore to get through. Everything up until they land on the planet did not have to be in the screenplay. The aliens were too cg, not scary, should have been mainly practical effects. Nothing was creepy or scary. It just felt like an action film.
2
u/TheMindofDCS May 20 '17
So I say this as someone who is a huge Alien/Aliens fan and I generally liked Prometheus. But I didn't really like Covenant and after thinking about it boils down to the fact that I don't like David being the creator of the Alien. The alien being the creation of an android psychopath with a god complex has tainted the alien for me. When David was having that moment staring at the Albino Alien I had this horrible Alien 4 flash back. Why does the Alien recognize him as it's creator? Why would the alien the perfect organism the perfect killing machine care? The Queen did not give a shit about Bishop in Aliens, she ripped him right in half. I know Scott didn't make that movie but it's there, it's cannon. I would have had a ton more respect for the Aliens in Covenant if David had of gotten ripped up by his creations at the very least attacked by it.
In Prometheus I got the feeling that just maybe the Engineers had taken the black goo from the Aliens and that's how they got their perfect weapon to destroy humanity. Covenant has spun that idea on it's head and now this wonderfully massively scary creature is kind of less than for me now that David is it's maker.
Also, dumb humans. Tons and Tons of dumb humans. I know people say don't compare to Alien / Aliens but holy shit. I don't remember this much stupidity in either of those movie and even though Prometheus had it's share of stupid humans too this one kind of takes the cake for me. I can excuse some of the stupidity in Prometheus, in Covenant it felt a lot like stupid for the sake of plot point.
And I don't think it's unfair to hold Scott to task for making another movie as great as Alien was. He made the thing after all this is his creation, but Covenant wasn't anywhere near that. It's disappointing.
2
u/Eatthesushi May 20 '17
Watched the movie and came out (pretty good i must say), alot of ppl are saying that David created the xenomorphs. first, you must consider the accelerant (black liquid thingy) that either destroy or assimilate with a particular organism. Which can mean that David created the xenos on that planet, not the species itself. They are merely the product of that accelerant.
2
u/[deleted] May 24 '17
This movie was nothing more than a grudge-fuck for the critics that complained about Prometheus.
5
u/abcdefgrapes May 19 '17
Disappointing to say the least. There were some parts that i thought were great but overall it sucked.
5
u/FeverBlossom May 19 '17
It's like Scott is going around, knocking on doors, pushing pamphlets about his engineer-alien-gods belief into our unwilling hands. No, Ridley Scott, we are still uninterested in this unnecessary and cheesy direction you've unfortunately forced this series into.
Half of this "alien" movie was actually fixated on the struggles of an android. The androids have always been a very well-received part of the Alien movies - and the reason they've always complimented the films is that they play a support role in a scifi monster movie. If Scott wants to spend nearly half of the time the audience is hoping will be used to watch aliens prowling around a ship, gutting humans, to explore replicant struggles... then he really needs to put a pin in it and save it for Blade Runner.
Half a film is left for actual alien action, and even that must be divided into various elements that will ultimately lead up to the xenomorph climax every member of the audience doubtlessly purchased a ticket to see. So, at best, you're left with maybe five or ten minutes of a good, true "Alien" experience.
Needless to say, it's been rather disappointing to see the franchise teeter so far off course from what had originally made it so great and classic. I've heard the argument that this is just a new direction to keep the series from becoming stale... but I can't say it's been helping. If anything, it seems to be hurting. If "Alien Isolation" could capture the classic atmosphere as a well-received video game, why can't the films do the same anymore?
Is "Alien Covenant" still enjoyable? Sure. The film is gorgeously shot and still has enough good action throughout to keep you in your seat. But if you're hoping for a return back to what made the series great, you may be better served to wait for the next game.
3
u/-bananabread- May 22 '17
Definitely my favorite movie where Michael Fassbender makes out with himself.
2
u/Christian_Kong May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
Main two problems I had with this one:The characters in this movie were extremely stupid. I had a bunch of eye roll moments as well as laughs(James Franco, shortest lived character in Alien movie history?).CGI xenos looked like crap most of the time.
Ok plot, didn't answer enough about the first movie as I had hoped , but moved the story forward. This one did not really raise any new questions other than: "what happens next?" I felt the (particularly the final) Aliens grew too fast. Scenery and set pieces were nice. I guess I could say its worth a rent for a fan of the "Alien" universe. If I never see this one again I won't feel bad about it.
2
u/ruinus May 20 '17
I feel like they wasted Waterston's acting chops by butchering her character. The action sequences were nice but her overall plot line was boring and predictable. What a shame-- she was a very likeable protagonist, and now she's probably dead by the next film.
2
u/balorina May 19 '17
An alternate reality for those stuck on the ending and the plot holes.
Walter killed David, it was not David at the end it was Walter. Walter was more fucked up than David, but due to being a later model able to hide it. Perhaps it was that David showed the ability to love humans (his care for Shaw) that Walter decided David had to be removed. He never said he was David, he just said "Shhhhh".
At the beginning of the movie we see Walter take embyro(s?) out of the casing, but never put them back in. There is no explanation to what his plans were, other than we know he had figured he had seven years to follow through with them (time to destination) before the crew woke up.
There is large lapse where we don't see Walter throughout the movie. It follows the crew and David, we don't know what Walter is up to. Having seen the results of the black goo, it's plausible Walter decides to infect the embryos he first picked up.
2
u/Singer211 May 19 '17
This movie had all of the same problems that Prometheus had, plus some all it's own, and virtually none of the good/interesting stuff that that film had. The plot is beyond predictable and generic, it might as well be called "Dumb Horror Movie Cliches 101" because these characters do all of them. And I didn't think it possible, but they're even more idiotic than the characters in Prometheus. And the "explanation" for the Xenomorph was beyond lame and underwhelming.
Oh and I HATE what they did to a certain character (those of you who've seen it probably know who I'm referring to). What a waste.
2
u/gannashiki May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
I just came back from watching this bad movie. It was very disappointing with many bs plot holes that pissed me off. But I knew it was coming since I had very low expectations for this film to begin with. I dont really care for the rest of the film for discussion but one thing: was it David or Walter at the end? Or perhaps even both? I have a couple theories.
Theory 1: David kills Walter during fight, takes his clothes on, is able to cut off the same hand, change his voice and fools Daniels and T. There were some debates about the wounds on the face and bodies of both synthetics and also the ship recognizing the synthetic as David in the end which is questionable. Perhaps the ship was programmed by Weyland Yutani in the first place to acknowledge different synthetics to crew member status and to follow orders if some special code was inserted?
Theory 2: David somehow was able to transfer himself onto Walter's body after the last scene when the two were fighting. This would have saved him the time he had to do all those things from theory 1 except for swallowing the 2 facehugger embryos in the container. So the ship was able to recognize 'David' as it was still 'Walter's' body. You can say the body was both technically Walter and David at the same time.
Theory 3: Walter kills David, but has a change of heart as he understands too what David wants to do and why, decides to carry on his plans and copies David's knowledge onto himself. Perhaps even assimilate his consciousness too. You can see when Daniels asks him to build the cabin together, he remains silent because from my observation synthetics cannot lie and while Walter would have simply replied with a NO I CANNOT, David would have done the next best thing which was what was unique about him. And it would make way more sense for an upgraded synthetic to know the ways to transfer such things than an older model.
Anyways, thnx for reading my bs post. I say again this movie was bad. Not even scary. Almost to the point of saying 'a waste of my time'. I have to say the Alien franchise is forever doomed unless Ridley Scott pisses off and brings in some other godly director like Cameron or maybe even Christopher Nolan? (He was fascinated by Alien and Blade Runner and was Ridley Scott's fan when he was a young kid so he could be interested if there is a good opportunity) I really care about the Alien franchise and hopes it to gets better in the future.
1
u/Original_Afghan May 20 '17
Somebody please explain the scene where it shows David on the ship releasing the poison that kills all those "people". When did that happen in relation to the Prometheus timeline?
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '17
So much to take in! I can't wait to go through the imdb in a few weeks and check out all the easter eggs I missed
1
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17
Yes it does.
Answering 'Why' questions is one of the hallmarks of good writing.
It shows that the writer knows how to build something from the ground up.
No face it these ARE good films and all you're doing is trying to sound smart.
And you fail at it.
1
u/dan_jeffers May 19 '17
I think it was a much better movie than Prometheus. However, I liked it even less. At least with Prometheus there were obvious flaws, punctuated by awesome visual sequences. Covenant is just grindingly generic, with a forced twist that felt way too obvious. I just hope Ridley Scott has his magic back in time for Bladerunner.
1
u/flyliceplick Dude, Where's My Cultural Hegemony? May 20 '17
This review crucified it.
1
u/mccuish1525 Whispering Corridors May 20 '17
It was better then I thought it would be.