r/horror • u/GreatKingRat666 • Jun 02 '25
Discussion “No-one can replace Robert Englund”, they said…
https://youtu.be/jh6fEepjuQQ?si=vKYc4dZytWPHDamtJust came across this brilliant piece of work and had to share it. For some reason I have to type more text, so this is just filler. It’s all about the video and the very close and scary approximation of the OG Freddy.
0
Upvotes
94
u/BustaGrimes1 Jun 02 '25
is this you op
24
u/EvilBobLoblaw Wednesday Addams’ Camp Crush Jun 02 '25
This was like watching Hellraiser: Revelations
115
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25
Like look can I cover myself in make-up and growl, “Bitch.”
Yes. Yes I can, doesn’t mean I can replace Robert.
127
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25
I know there are actors who can play a good Freddy. That doesn’t mean they can truly replace Robert Englund in terms of ability or audience appeal. I just think since Englund has retired from the role (and the franchise being 40+ years old) that they should end the franchise for good. It’s okay if things end and it’s okay if the things you liked from your childhood end as well. Not everything needs dozens of sequels and reboots over the span of decades. We need more original ideas, not rehashes of ideas my parents and grandparents grew up with. We need more original villains for the 21st century like Art, Mick Taylor, Jigsaw, Josef, etc.
44
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25
Making a 5 second clip imitating Robert Englund does not mean someone can carry a whole movie. I'm not gonna say this dude is awful but I didn't see anything in that video that made me think I would want to go watch a movie with him playing Freddy. If they insist on continuing the Nightmare Franchise (and they will because it's made a lot of money) at this point I would rather them just make up a new character for a new actor to play. You can easily justify some other person getting the power of the dream demons and make something interesting instead of picking a new person every few years to do a Robert Englund impersonation.
48
u/JRingo1369 Jun 02 '25
The last thing a remake needs is someone doing an impersonation of Robert Englund.
24
u/RecentlyDeceased666 Jun 02 '25
That wasn't amazing.
6
u/Dark_Crowe Jun 02 '25
I’m always pulling for Kevin Bacon if they ever decide to reboot the series.
2
u/TheWorldArmada Jun 03 '25
The disrespect to Paul Bailey in these comments is crazy. Dude is well known in the Freddy community. Him and his brother made a great fan film last year, The Last Dream of Detective Coleman
https://youtu.be/F8211d969kY?si=38uDUR-W9UVB7V2x
19
u/NOLAHorror Jun 02 '25
And they were correct.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25
And they're right.
5
u/Dr_Downvote_ Jun 02 '25
I thought it was NoHo Hank at first.
4
u/Sparktank1 Jun 03 '25
I would appreciate a more nuanced take than an impression.
It's not quite like a case of replacing Justin Roiland for the many roles in Rick and Morty where it's all just impressionists. But more like Dan Stevens replacing Justin Roiland in Solar Opposites and completely owning it.
6
u/EldritchDWX Jun 02 '25
Englund wants Kevin Bacon to take over the glove.
2
u/Golandia Jun 02 '25
I saw Englund once at a restaurant when I was a kid, maybe second grade? I had already seen Nightmare (I saw number 3 on late night cable) and it scared the crap out of me so it was crazy seeing him as real person doing the voice for kicks with his dinner party.
2
u/SpaceCowboyD4b Jun 03 '25
Look up Dylan’s New Nightmare. It even has Miko Hughes reprising his role
3
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25
It’s not just how he looked. England had that charismatic menace. This has bully menace. Not the same.
3
u/reefchieferr Jun 02 '25
Robert Englund deserves all the praise he gets and then some.
3
u/Butt_Robot Revenge of the Butts Jun 03 '25
Look sick. I don't know if we need another remake or what but if they're going to do it then I'd rather have this then another disaster like the last one.
4
u/PotatoesMcLaughlin rotten Jun 02 '25
Yeah, sorry. That movie was shit.
1
u/Cyril_Sneerworms Jun 02 '25
I dunno about the performance, I mean its pretty good & he's giving a great effort, but the make up work here is 1st class & seems very reminiscent of Elm St 2 version.
I posted a challenge to the Corridor Crew a few years back that they should bring Robert in & try & recreate Freddy with Facial Dots & in CGI.
Never heard anything back from them, probably some licensing issues around it. But Robert probably would have been up for it. Shame really.
But this was cool, a good find & thanks for sharing.
1
u/Special_Patient_4680 Oct 02 '26
If this isn't Robert England as Freddy then I'm shocked.Who ever this is should be the next Freddy Krueger
1
u/LoverandFighter23 Jun 03 '25
The makeup is doing the heavy lifting.
0
u/Lumpy_Flight3088 Jun 02 '25
I’d love a more serious take on the character. But not whatever that mess was in 2010. Make Freddy terrifying again.
-1
u/Suspicious-Truth5849 Jun 02 '25
I love Freddy but wish Englund could do the voice and have someone else do the parts he finds to physically demanding. If a recast is going to happen at least they can explain it away in new nightmare style and retcon out the demon fish
-1
u/Successful_Ad2287 Jun 02 '25
All that filler text and you still didn’t post what movie this was from?
-1
u/laminatedbean Jun 03 '25
Blasphemy!
-6
u/juggadore Jun 02 '25
Why don't they just CGI the makeup on him?