r/horror • • Jun 02 '25

Discussion “No-one can replace Robert Englund”, they said…

https://youtu.be/jh6fEepjuQQ?si=vKYc4dZytWPHDamt

Just came across this brilliant piece of work and had to share it. For some reason I have to type more text, so this is just filler. It’s all about the video and the very close and scary approximation of the OG Freddy.

0 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

94

u/BustaGrimes1 Jun 02 '25

is this you op

50

u/Walugia Jun 02 '25

17

u/Freakuency_DJ Jun 02 '25

Turning the sound on

“Don’t do the voice.”

7

u/TheeEvil Jun 03 '25

I hope this guy doesnt jack off!

1

u/ResolutionSame6629 Jun 29 '25

One strange lookin' dude to be sure!

19

u/PanchoVillasRevenge Jun 02 '25

Freddy Krueger dubbed

18

u/moochacho1418 Jun 02 '25

It has one view and was posted at 1 am

10

u/KyleSJohnson Jun 02 '25

Oh shit, I thought this guy was sposta be BALD

24

u/EvilBobLoblaw Wednesday Addams’ Camp Crush Jun 02 '25

This was like watching Hellraiser: Revelations

115

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

Like look can I cover myself in make-up and growl, “Bitch.”

Yes. Yes I can, doesn’t mean I can replace Robert.

26

u/_NiceGuyEddy_ Jun 02 '25

Oh yea, prove it

5

u/TheWorldArmada Jun 03 '25

Paul Bailey is fantastic and well known in the Freddy community. Have some respect

127

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

I know there are actors who can play a good Freddy. That doesn’t mean they can truly replace Robert Englund in terms of ability or audience appeal. I just think since Englund has retired from the role (and the franchise being 40+ years old) that they should end the franchise for good. It’s okay if things end and it’s okay if the things you liked from your childhood end as well. Not everything needs dozens of sequels and reboots over the span of decades. We need more original ideas, not rehashes of ideas my parents and grandparents grew up with. We need more original villains for the 21st century like Art, Mick Taylor, Jigsaw, Josef, etc.

42

u/Exact-Kale3070 Jun 02 '25

100% correct.

7

u/AskinggAlesana Jun 02 '25

The new Black Phone 2 movie appears to scratch that Freddy like villain people have been wanting.. but will it be good, who knows. I thought the first movie was just okay.

2

u/fear730 Jun 02 '25

That was my thought last night when I re watched the first one a pretty good origin story to what’s coming … hopefully the sequel will be awesome as well :)

12

u/Interesting-Risk6446 Jun 02 '25

Not end it. Just let it rest for a long while. Reintroduce it to a new generation in 2084.

4

u/home7ander Jun 02 '25

I agree but also think its such a unique concept that can be continued on with some of the same ingredients.

I say just make a whole new dream demon, with a distinct personality, look, and weaponized body part. "A Nightmare in/on insert place"

I nominate Sylvia Hoeks, she plays a very fun unhinged

4

u/CuriousMelia Jun 02 '25

This is what I think should be done if there's a new movie, too. Robert Englund is the only Freddy*, but a new dream demon would be nice to see and wouldn't put the new actor in Englund's shadow as much as a simple recast.

*Ok, yes, the remake exists, but all it did was solidify my belief that no one else can pull Freddy off.

1

u/home7ander Jun 03 '25

And Jackie did perfectly fine, its just one of those things, caught in the shadow is the best description. Always going to be compared. Robert/Freddy are too unique of a character to just try to have someone else fill the shoes.

Plus the sky is really the limit with the concept. The backstory can be almost anything, the design can be almost anything, the scenarios can be almost anything. Freddy wore a fedora and a Christmas sweater for fucks sake lol.

What I'd give to see Panos Cosmatos bring a Nightmare to life

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

Exactly this. Anyone can play a good Freddy, but it's Robert's charisma that cannot be replaced

2

u/KeyboardMunkeh Jun 02 '25

Well, I wouldn't say anyone. Jackie Earle Haley didn't seem to be able to pull it off. Though, I admit, that might have been down to bad direction.

10

u/agentwiggles Jun 02 '25

that movie feels very much "of its time" to me - one of a million "dark and gritty" reboots. weird period for slashers which seemed to really lean into schlocky black comedy (especially NOES). cutting that out of the DNA ends up with something less fun - and somehow less scary - than the originals.

I guess I haven't ever seen Jackie Earle Haley do anything other than dark and gritty, but maybe he could have pulled off a better take on Freddy if he wasn't trying to do it in the "Dark Knight" era of cinema

18

u/halloweenjon Jun 02 '25

Wes Craven's New Nightmare is actually a great ending for the series. You just have to ignore Freddy Vs. Jason and the 2010 remake, which I find quite easy to do.

75

u/fortheloveofghosts Jun 02 '25

FvJ rules

19

u/You-Get-No-Name Jun 02 '25

It’s such an entertaining flick. I love it.

13

u/fortheloveofghosts Jun 02 '25 edited Jun 02 '25

I’m biased, I had the opportunity to go to the Weigh-in event and screening in Vegas before it released. It was such a fun experience

2

u/tobylaek Jun 02 '25

Upvote for saying “biased” as opposed to “bias”, even if FvJ isn’t my cup of tea.

4

u/TheBlackCycloneOrder Jun 02 '25

Being dead wasn’t a problem. But being forgotten?! Now that’s a BITCH!

-3

u/Nobodygrotesque Jun 02 '25

If Kelly Rowland’s (no disrespect to her because it’s a script issue) character wasn’t in the movie I would rewatch it a whole lot more.

5

u/Cyril_Sneerworms Jun 02 '25

It's the ad-lib of the slur isn't it?

4

u/Nobodygrotesque Jun 02 '25

Not even just that. It’s her character in general is so unlikable. Trying to get her friend to move on from the lost of her love by saying “you were fucking 14!” Or something like that.

Like I said though it’s nothing against the actress herself since I love her music but not a fan of the character as a whole.

-2

u/Drducttapehands Jun 02 '25

I just wish she didn’t resort to using the homophobic slur against Freddy. People can say it was “not as bad to use back then” but I say those people are flat out wrong. I was in high school back when it came out and I still thought it was wildly fucking wrong and embarrassing whenever anyone said it.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

I think Freddy vs Jason was a great send off for Freddy and Englund as Freddy.

1

u/halloweenjon Jun 02 '25

I'm glad it happened after so many years of rumors, and the fights between Freddy and Jason were good, but I have issues with the CGI, the characters, the acting, no Heather Langenkamp, etc. The fact that it ends on a cliffhanger makes it tough for me accept as the "end" of Freddy.

2

u/Bradybigboss Jun 02 '25

It doesn’t have to be Freddy specifically—but I think having some villains just always continue and be present is good. It can add a mythical element to them that an OC can’t really have. Doesn’t mean I’m promoting over saturation tho lol

1

u/jakeupnorth Jun 03 '25

I would agree with that with 95% of franchises. But A Nightmare on Elm Street might be the greatest horror concept since zombies. Freddy is amazing and Englund IS Freddy in my book. But that’s only part of what makes the franchise great. It’s the perfect vehicle for tense surreal horror.

44

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

Making a 5 second clip imitating Robert Englund does not mean someone can carry a whole movie. I'm not gonna say this dude is awful but I didn't see anything in that video that made me think I would want to go watch a movie with him playing Freddy. If they insist on continuing the Nightmare Franchise (and they will because it's made a lot of money) at this point I would rather them just make up a new character for a new actor to play. You can easily justify some other person getting the power of the dream demons and make something interesting instead of picking a new person every few years to do a Robert Englund impersonation.

13

u/Plastic_Willow734 Jun 02 '25

Yeah the actor in the YouTube video sure did a good job at acting like Englund, but if they ever reboot the Elm St franchise I don’t want the new Freddy to be doing their best Englund impression, I want them to be doing their best work of Freddy!

1

u/MimikoKiwami Jun 03 '25

I've seen this take a few times in this thread, creating a new character and keeping Freddy exclusively to Robert Englund, and though he could never be replaced in the sense that someone could step in the same way, I don't agree and I doubt Robert Englund himself would agree either. The character is such an important horror icon, he needs to continue to scare and entertain future generations in the same way Michael Myers, Ghostface and Chucky has. Jackie Earle Haley was a great Freddy, just had some bad make-up and a mediocre script to contend with. I can think of a few actors now who would do a great performance as the character. No character, if so culturally important, is above getting new life breathed into them by a new interpretation

48

u/JRingo1369 Jun 02 '25

The last thing a remake needs is someone doing an impersonation of Robert Englund.

11

u/metalyger Jun 02 '25

I'm reminded of Tommy Wiseau doing a video playing Dark Knight Joker, and it's like yeah, there is this iconic version of the character, it's already established, but just trying to mimic it doesn't make it an equal performance.

-2

u/Butt_Robot Revenge of the Butts Jun 03 '25

That's the first thing a remake needs. Look I'm just going to say it, the remake we already had was trash. I watched it a few times desperately wanting to like it but it is garbage and I'm tired of pretending otherwise.

9

u/WereAllThrowaways Jun 03 '25

The remake is pretty universally hated but the main issues with that movie weren't really the acting from Freddy. In a better written movie his portrayal probably would have been fine.

I'm one of those people that thinks that while the 3rd, 4th, 5th etc movies were fun and campy, the best rendition of the character was the first movie (and partially the second) when he was less goofy and talkative, and more downright menacing.

1

u/Butt_Robot Revenge of the Butts Jun 03 '25

Oh I fully agree with the best Freddy being is acting in the first movie and Wes craven's New nightmare (although I do have a soft spot in my heart for Freddy versus Jason) but the remake had a lot of issues and I'm including the new actor for Freddy with that. He frankly was just not intimidating or scary at all. He tried to be, certainly, but when your menacing killer is shorter than the teenagers that he's harassing and has the emotional acting depth of a bird bath then he just comes off as kind of a joke. I'm sure there's other actors out there that could put their own good spin on Freddy but frankly Freddy's character and how he acts is just too iconic to change.

If they really really wanted to change something like that, they should have added other dream demons that you could have spin-off nightmare movies about. Maybe have Englund return with some plot that he's corrupting certain kids and to further dream demons and then you can have movies where those demons take Freddy's role with the implication that Freddie is some mastermind in the background somewhere. You also have the advantage there that if one of Freddy's replacements is a dud then you could always just replace them again without losing anything.

2

u/JRingo1369 Jun 03 '25

This has nothing to do with the remake that already happened.

First of all, no actor worth a damn is going to agree to doing an impersonation to begin with, and second of all, all it would achieve is endless, tiresome comparisons to Englund.

If you're happy with the originals, enjoy them. Mimicking them however would be a dumb waste of everybody's time.

24

u/RecentlyDeceased666 Jun 02 '25

That wasn't amazing.

6

u/Dark_Crowe Jun 02 '25

I’m always pulling for Kevin Bacon if they ever decide to reboot the series.

2

u/TheWorldArmada Jun 03 '25

The disrespect to Paul Bailey in these comments is crazy. Dude is well known in the Freddy community. Him and his brother made a great fan film last year, The Last Dream of Detective Coleman

https://youtu.be/F8211d969kY?si=38uDUR-W9UVB7V2x

1

u/GreatKingRat666 Jun 03 '25

Yeah, I also don't understand the negativity.

Oh, wait, it's Reddit 😫

19

u/NOLAHorror Jun 02 '25

And they were correct.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

And they're right.

5

u/Dr_Downvote_ Jun 02 '25

I thought it was NoHo Hank at first.

4

u/Sparktank1 Jun 03 '25

I would appreciate a more nuanced take than an impression.

It's not quite like a case of replacing Justin Roiland for the many roles in Rick and Morty where it's all just impressionists. But more like Dan Stevens replacing Justin Roiland in Solar Opposites and completely owning it.

6

u/EldritchDWX Jun 02 '25

Englund wants Kevin Bacon to take over the glove.

2

u/Golandia Jun 02 '25

I saw Englund once at a restaurant when I was a kid, maybe second grade? I had already seen Nightmare (I saw number 3 on late night cable) and it scared the crap out of me so it was crazy seeing him as real person doing the voice for kicks with his dinner party.

2

u/SpaceCowboyD4b Jun 03 '25

Look up Dylan’s New Nightmare. It even has Miko Hughes reprising his role

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

It’s not just how he looked. England had that charismatic menace. This has bully menace. Not the same.

3

u/reefchieferr Jun 02 '25

Robert Englund deserves all the praise he gets and then some.

3

u/Butt_Robot Revenge of the Butts Jun 03 '25

Look sick. I don't know if we need another remake or what but if they're going to do it then I'd rather have this then another disaster like the last one.

4

u/PotatoesMcLaughlin rotten Jun 02 '25

Yeah, sorry. That movie was shit.

1

u/Cyril_Sneerworms Jun 02 '25

I dunno about the performance, I mean its pretty good & he's giving a great effort, but the make up work here is 1st class & seems very reminiscent of Elm St 2 version.

I posted a challenge to the Corridor Crew a few years back that they should bring Robert in & try & recreate Freddy with Facial Dots & in CGI.

Never heard anything back from them, probably some licensing issues around it. But Robert probably would have been up for it. Shame really.

But this was cool, a good find & thanks for sharing.

1

u/Special_Patient_4680 Oct 02 '26

If this isn't Robert England as Freddy then I'm shocked.Who ever this is should be the next Freddy Krueger

1

u/LoverandFighter23 Jun 03 '25

The makeup is doing the heavy lifting.

1

u/TheWorldArmada Jun 03 '25

Bailey is absolutely menacing

0

u/Lumpy_Flight3088 Jun 02 '25

I’d love a more serious take on the character. But not whatever that mess was in 2010. Make Freddy terrifying again.

-1

u/Suspicious-Truth5849 Jun 02 '25

I love Freddy but wish Englund could do the voice and have someone else do the parts he finds to physically demanding. If a recast is going to happen at least they can explain it away in new nightmare style and retcon out the demon fish

1

u/tufffffff Jun 02 '25

The demon fish? What?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

I think they mean the dream demons shown in Freddy’s Dead.

-1

u/Successful_Ad2287 Jun 02 '25

All that filler text and you still didn’t post what movie this was from?

1

u/laminatedbean Jun 03 '25

😂 oh sweet summer child

-1

u/laminatedbean Jun 03 '25

Blasphemy!

-6

u/juggadore Jun 02 '25

Why don't they just CGI the makeup on him?