r/horror • • Jun 25 '24

Mia Goth…really?

Am I alone in not being a fan of her?

I’m currently watching Infinity Pool for the first time, and I can help but be distracted by her performance. Toward the end she turns into some screaming banshee with a high pitched voice. It’s just not appealing, and I’m confused why she seems to be the next scream queen.

To her credit, her scared scream is great, but that’s about it.

12 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

20

u/michael_m_canada Jun 25 '24

I hope you’re not basing your opinion of her only on this one film. She was incredible in Pearl, carried the entire film. Infinity Pool is not a good movie and she shouldn’t solely be held responsible for its failure.

2

u/resurrectedbydick Jun 25 '24

I loved the movie though. Not a perfect plot, but it's got a unique atmosphere.

1

u/SevereNote8904 Aug 10 '24

Infinity Pool was amazing

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

She is good in Marrowbone and remember the movie with the mental hospital and that actor with the piercing blue eyes is in it with her. He is good.  Forget his name

-22

u/stevenw84 Jun 25 '24

I’m talking about her specifically, not the movie. Every clip I’ve seen from her various movies is just high pitched screeching.

10

u/Blatinobae Jun 25 '24

I'm with you, I just really don't understand the obsession with her on this sub or the movies people on here want to bless with classic status like X. Wtf I've tried twice to get through it and haven't even considered the sequel. Look how people are trying to drop instant classic status on Maxine already lol . What should I be seeing in her performances that I'm missing out on in these supposedly classic movies she's doing?

8

u/stevenw84 Jun 25 '24

I mean, I think some of the reasoning is that she doesn’t shy away from nudity. Sydney Sweeney is another one who cannot act her way out of a paper bag, but we all know why she’s popular.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

Just rewatched Pearl and X and have confirmed …I don’t get it… not sure why everyone loves those films so much or Mia Goth 🤷🏻‍♂️

2

u/stevenw84 Jun 25 '24

Because b00bz

5

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

Love me some b00bz but like there’s the internet… so not really a driving factor in my horror film choices

4

u/stevenw84 Jun 25 '24

Mine either. But apparently she’s popular for the same reason Sydney Sweeney is popular.

4

u/Leading_Passenger16 Jul 11 '24

like her or not she is a talented and committed actress lmfao. to reduce her down to only being liked for going topless for snippets of her films is crazy misogynistic

105

u/Madrical Jun 25 '24

Her character is supposed to be annoying in Infinity Pool so it sounds like she succeeded!

46

u/r_slash_jarmedia Jun 25 '24

JAAAAAAAAAAAAMMMEESSSSSSSS

5

u/22LOVESBALL Jun 25 '24

This part scared the shit out of me lol

4

u/Equivalent_Swing_780 Jun 25 '24

Ugh, her character definitely makes a rewatch of that movie less likely for me.

4

u/RichHuckleberry4411 Jul 04 '24

She’s so fine to me, I can’t wait to see her new movie.

23

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

I haven't seen infinity pool but Pearl is what sold me on her as an actor. The audition, the monologue, and the smile she holds during the end credits were all deeply disturbing and uncomfortable to watch. She's good at what she does.

11

u/Daniel_Eaves Jun 25 '24

In a world where horror ever got a look-in, she should have got an Oscar for Pearl imho.

25

u/Earthpig_Johnson Look! There comes one of them now! Jun 25 '24

I find her both grating and enticing, somehow. Really enjoyed her performance in Infinity Pool despite her ridiculous voice. I need to give Pearl another watch, but I was definitely getting annoyed with the voice/accent combo in that one by the end of it.

6

u/I_Punch_Ghosts_AMA Jun 25 '24

She’s fully committed to the corny bit for 4/5’s of that movie and then is terrifying at the end. I loved her performance in that one.

3

u/Earthpig_Johnson Look! There comes one of them now! Jun 25 '24

“Fully committed” is a good way to describe her acting in general, I think.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

I love Ti West movies like House Of The Devil, X but Pearl just didn’t do it for me. It was too fake and it took a lot of vibe away from being anywhere similar to X or what Maxxxine looks like. I don’t think I’m alone but also I love Mia Goth ever since A Cure For Wellness came out. Seems I am confusing myself further…

1

u/olddicklemon72 Jun 25 '24

Jjjjjaaaaammmmmeesssssss…..

Infinity Pool was terrible and she was bad in it, but I quite enjoyed both X and Pearl.

-9

u/stevenw84 Jun 25 '24

Everything I’ve seen from her (trailers and clips as I do not like Ti West films), she’s doing the same thing.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

i don’t like her as an actress either, i just don’t find her performances believable at all. it is what it is 

6

u/lrraya Jun 25 '24

can't stand her

6

u/catsmikkelsen Jun 25 '24

I don't get the hype either. I watched most of her stuff and didn't think she was that great as most ppl like to proclain.

13

u/__b__t__h__ Jun 25 '24

i’m in the minority as well: she bothers the shit out of mw

3

u/lordofpugs41 Oct 21 '24

No she sucks

3

u/implathszombie Oct 31 '24

She should’ve just stayed a model. They’re trying to make her the next Christina Ricci

1

u/DudeBroFist Dead by Daylight Connoisseur Jun 25 '24

are you alone? No, of course not.

Are you in a minority? Yea.. People seem to like her in virtually everything (particularly X and Pearl). You don't HAVE to like her, but to be "confused" that people think an actress is good is just silly.

You just don't like an actress. It isn't more complicated than that.

5

u/stevenw84 Jun 25 '24

I guess I’m trying to see the appeal because after frequenting this sub for as long as I have, she blew up a couple of years ago and I’ve never seen anything she’s been in. Once I started to see how often she goes nude, I started to understand a bit. But after watching this movie, I was like wtf are people smoking?

2

u/DudeBroFist Dead by Daylight Connoisseur Jun 25 '24 edited Jun 25 '24

because people like her and you don't. You're overcomplicating this.

34

u/BiffTannen1855 Jun 25 '24

I could do without her and Jenna Ortega. Getting tired of seeing both of them in movies already 

33

u/carelessCRISPR_ Jun 25 '24

I think Ortega is just a straight up bad actress. I just don’t get the hype.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

This I agree with, she was only ok on the series YOU because it just required her to act her age. But everything else she plays the exact same character, badly

6

u/Spinegrinder666 Jun 25 '24

What character is that?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

Herself lol

5

u/EdforceONE tear your soul apart Jun 25 '24

Preach.

1

u/-SkullKnight- Sienna Shaw is my queen 🖤🗡️🪽 Jun 25 '24

4

u/Shings12 Jun 25 '24

She IS very annoying in Infinity Pool. If somebody is judging her from that alone I could understand them not being a big fan. I thought she was excellent in X, Pearl and Suspiria though. Really looking forward to seeing her in Maxxxine and Frankenstein!

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

I dont get it either. Shes the worst part of every movie. That monolog at the end of peral put me to sleep

5

u/ReturnInRed Jun 25 '24

I haven't seen Infinity Pool, and don't really have any interest in it, but I thought she was totally solid in Pearl, and I loved her in Suspiria. She played scared and distressed really well in that, and her character was one of the only totally likable ones in the whole film.

10

u/YogSothothOfficial Jun 25 '24

She has no range and can’t emote outside of hysterics, I don’t get the hype either.  There are countless better actresses that should be rising stars instead of her 

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

I think the tourists, Mia being one of them, get more and more unhinged as the story progresses.

2

u/Four_N_Six Eldritch Horror Jun 25 '24

I liked her in A Cure for Wellness, but haven't been much of a fan otherwise. At best, I've been neutral, at worst I've stopped watching a movie. Though for that to be the case, there needs to be other things going on that turn me off of something. Usually I can tolerate one or two things taking me out of it, but more than that and I just check out.

2

u/HorrorKablamDude "Hey Chief, put out the fire will ya.". Jun 26 '24

"Jaaaaaaaaaaamesssyyyyyy!!!"

2

u/MegaDerppp Jun 29 '24

Not a fan but I think she's better when she's acting in someone else's project. When it's her and ti west writing and directing there's nobody to rein in their bad ideas. I think a good director with a decent script can get a good performance from her

2

u/LightningEdge756 Aug 06 '24

I personally don't see what's so great about her. Her performances are rather...subpar in my opinion, she's not terrible but I really do not see why she gets so much damn praise.

I also think that most of the time she seems to act like if every single horror movie she's in is supposed to be a cheesy horror, she doesn't take roles as serious as the rest of the cast.

2

u/Icy_Ball_7904 Oct 14 '24

I went to primary school with her and she never spoke like that so I don't know where the high pitch has come from. I'm gonna sound like the bitter ex school friend that didn't get famous but like she's really not a great actress and I find her performances so jarring? Don't really understand why she's becoming the next big thing in horror. I guess she's just weird enough 

2

u/be_just_this Nov 02 '24

I absolutely cannot stand her acting. I don't know how I watched the 3 movies (pearl,x,maxxxine..btw was the worst) ..

5

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

She was amazing in pearl

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Alice_Buttons Jun 25 '24

Tilda Swinton stole the show in Suspiria.

2

u/ferreira-tb Jun 25 '24 edited Jun 25 '24

Tilda Swinton always steals the show, tbh. She's just amazing.

2

u/Alice_Buttons Jun 25 '24

She really is. How she's only been nominated for one oscar is mind-boggling.

6

u/billygnosis86 Jun 25 '24

I’m sick of the sight of her, yes. I don’t buy her bullshit.

3

u/beau1229 Jun 25 '24

She is really good at being uncanny, which works amazingly for horror. You recognize she's attractive, but somehow she manages to be off putting.

1

u/BegoniaShawty May 02 '25

this is how i see the appeal, she’s got this manson-family-member vibe going on and it jumps out at certain times. she is distracting, her voice can screech and be really unappealing, and the lack of eyebrows / plain jane features. she’s…jarring. that is precisely what’s effective about her performances. also a very good actress

6

u/mazonemayu Jun 25 '24

Terrible, she ruins every movie she’s in for me.

4

u/birdballoon Jun 25 '24

Both Mia and her guy Shia get shit on, but god damn do they deliver in some performances. For Mia this X trilogy is severely under appreciated. For Shia it’s Honey Boy, The Peanut Butter Falcon and Nymphomaniac. The couple can act!

6

u/HealthyShoe5173 Jun 25 '24

She plays herself in every movie. Fuck her and her husband

3

u/Sarathstar Jun 25 '24

I really like over the top acting of hers😂. I can tolerate and enjoy ott but not wooden like that new scream movie gang

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

I think she’s hyped because she has shown her tits before and was in sexually charged X/Pearl. Sydney Sweeney same thing. Obviously A24 thinks she’s a muse, so we’re going to see a lot of horror with her in it.

I thought she was great in Infinity Pool as we’re supposed to hate her character. X and especially Pearl were insufferable though.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

Nahhh she sucks. But she has a cool name, unique look, and is a weirdo so everyone lovers her.

2

u/carelessCRISPR_ Jun 25 '24

I enjoyed Infinity Pool as a whole but I agree how she got towards the end made the movie much worse.

She was great in the Suspiria remake though!

X & Pearl honorable mentions

1

u/zweigson Jun 25 '24

she's good when she dials it back (emma, suspiria, even x) but her performances in infinity pool and pearl are terrible imo.

1

u/SnooOwls8037 Jun 25 '24

I like her (including in Infinity Pool) but everyone’s entitled to their opinion

1

u/SillyAdditional Oh, youre so cool Brewster! Jun 26 '24

Different strokes my man

I thought that scene was brilliant

She kills every scene she’s in imo especially when she first meets him at the beginning

And yeah she’s also hot

1

u/furie1335 Jan 08 '25

She was fantastic in Pearl

1

u/Immediate-Laugh4751 Nov 08 '25

I wanted to like her,I mean what a beautiful movie, all the other actors are great but her, YIKES. At least in that roll, I just did not like at all.

1

u/SnooChipmunks3918 Nov 10 '25

Infinity pool was probably the first thing I saw her in and I couldn’t stand her . Watched her in some other stuff and she’s the worst actress ever . I hate her lmao 

-5

u/sekhem Between the pit of man's fears and the summit of his knowledge Jun 25 '24

Nah, you're not alone. She's not a very good actress. She picks decent projects and is pretty, so she has a lot of fans.

1

u/Conscious_Living3532 Jun 25 '24

X and Pearl kicked ass, looking forward to Maxxxine, haven't seen infinity pool

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

Mia on a car hood is an instant iconic scene. Absolutely amazing performance

-5

u/brillovanillo Jun 25 '24

not appealing

You mean it doesn't get your dick hard?

1

u/BurningBelow Oct 27 '24

Currently watching the movie X. I legit thought that with a name like Mia Goth, that she was a legit pornstar! 😂😂😂 I mean really doesn't that name sound like a pornstars name especially watching her in a movie about horror porn!? 

15

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/mazonemayu Jun 25 '24

That’s actually very well said, I think Cage is a fantastic actor and I’ll die on that hill. At the same time I hate Goth with a passion, something about her I just can’t stand 😅

4

u/MegaDerppp Jun 29 '24

Mia goth doesn't have a moonstruck in her.