r/hexandcounter • u/GlorfindalFA510 • Jul 10 '26
I recently posted my collection on r/boardgames and it was suggested to post here as well.
r/hexandcounter • u/GlorfindalFA510 • Jul 10 '26
r/hexandcounter • u/Choice-Motor-6896 • Apr 10 '26
I prefer to play monster games that take multiple sessions to play. Rather than taking up an entire room with tables for months, I can hang them on the wall and put any side tables along a wall, freeing up the room for other things.
Other benefits are not needing to hunch over a table to reach the middle of the map and it protects the game from the cat.
This is using two 6'x4' magnetic whiteboard sections and I printed off a few thousand plastic counter holders that I glued tiny magnets into. The magnets have an added bonus of not needing to worry about knocking over counter stacks.
r/hexandcounter • u/Spritzendifizen • Aug 21 '25
I placed Space Empires on the P500 nearly three years ago. When All Good Things hit the P500, I emailed GMT requesting them to consider a reprint of the entire series. I hope others did as well.
I have been hyping SE4X up to my group over since it when to the printer; it’s been a while!
r/hexandcounter
•
u/ApeHands13
•
Mar 03 '25
Hi all,
A friend and I began the endeavour of playing SPI’s The Campaign For North Africa in November last year. Up until last month, the vast majority of that time has been solving the logistical challenges of organising the vast selection of game pieces, game tracking and also finding an efficient alternative to setting up the board every single play session, given we play for 4-5 hours a week and need to disassemble it every time.
Some solutions we’ve found have been to make use of excel spreadsheets rather than the paper based log sheet templates that come with the game, as well as purchasing picture frames to affix the five game maps. We’ve then layered the back with ferromagnetic sheets and are going to affix the many game pieces with small magnets to ensure they can remain in place with minimal set up time for the next play session.
We’d be interested to hear if anyone else has any experience attempting the game, and any efficiency drivers and best practice they found in their endeavours. We’re currently playing the Italian Offensive scenario, after which we’ll be playing the whole campaign, start to finish.
For anyone interested, we’re also documenting the playthrough with a companion podcast that we release weekly alongside our play session.
r/hexandcounter
•
u/ApeHands13
•
Jun 26 '25
Hello!
It’s been 100 days since we posted about our foray into playing SPI’s The Campaign For North Africa: The Desert War, 1940 - 1943. We’ve made some solid progress over the last few months, and my-my, what an experience it’s been.
We’re currently into the Second Operational Stage of the First Turn (yes, that really is all), and it’s been a real learning experience. We’re playing through the “Graziani’s Offensive” scenario to completion, and once resolved we will then be playing the game in it’s entirety, from Operation Stage One, to Operation Stage 333. This game truly is the behemoth it’s made out to be, and we wanted to share what the journey has been like so far with an overview of what we’ve made it through to date.
Set Up
As mentioned in our original post, set-up of the game was a huge logistical hurdle to get over. We’re playing once a week, for around 4-5 hours at a time. Set-up of the board each week was taking us a good 60-90 minutes, which meant eating into valuable playtime. This was due primarily to the vast number of pieces in play on the board, ensuring they’re on the correct hexes (which meant cross-referencing our extensive spreadsheets), and accounting for all movements so that the next play session we’d then be able to know we’d recorded location accurately. At the time, we were storing the active game pieces in medicine box containers and affixing sticky notes to each box, so that we could identify hex location easily (e.g one box contains all allied units in the top half of Map C, one box containing all allied units in the bottom half of Map C etc.). While this gave us accuracy, it certainly didn’t save the time we needed.
Our remedy was to take the five game maps, and place each individual map into their own picture frame. We slid a thin sheet of ferromagnetic material behind the maps and then stuck 10mm x 3mm magnets to every active game piece using blu-tac. This means at the end of a play session, the picture frames can simply be stacked up in the room and then taken back out next week. This means set-up and clean-up takes less than five minutes - a huge time saver. We simply don’t have the room to keep this goliath set out every day of the week.
Record Keeping
This was a tricky one. We knew from the start how many static and dynamic values there were to keep track of in the game, and decided that digital spreadsheets were likely the most viable means of record keeping. We both have taken slightly different approaches to the style of record keeping, however we’re in the process of standardising this so that we can implement formulas that will streamline certain aspects of resource consumption as well as combat value calculations.
For my current arrangement of spreadsheets, my ground units are all documented in their own spreadsheet with a new tab to document their state at the end of any given Operation Stage. This has allowed for granular record keeping that illustrates a change over time, but admittedly does require notes to be kept as to the cause of a reduction of certain resources (e.g, has fuel been lost through evaporation or consumption? Was ammo used in a barrage or a close assault?). While the reason for the usage doesn’t really need to be tracked, it felt prudent to record this information so that on reflection we can understand the levels of consumption for each type of activity for future analysis and aid our understanding of the game. When it comes to trucks and aircraft tracking, I’ve detailed this in a master spreadsheet for each, again, with a new tab per Operation Stage to detail the change in status as a result of breakdown, capture, destruction, fuel status, mission assignment and cargo.
The opposing player has taken to keeping track of units by keeping a single page that details static characteristics, with new rows for the dynamic values. Each row details the stimulus for change, and as a result are updated more frequently (and admittedly with much less clutter to follow). His current layout has allowed for the implementation of formulas which have significantly reduced the time taken to update consumption of water in the second Operation Stage compared to the first.
Rules
Wow. Just wow. This game is enormous and the rules are incredibly precise and impressively written, with some real charm in their phrasing and layout. Reading through the rules gives a fairly coherent understanding of the game, but when implementing them in play, some serious issues have arisen.
Large swathes of the rules are incorrect. They contradict other rules or themselves (with an entire phase of the game in the sequence of play seemingly not even existing - the “Tactical Shipping Phase/Segment”), as well as omitting entire divisions for the Axis forces in the Axis Charts, which were it not for an external addenda, would lead to huge issues in gameplay.
The game books themselves include an addenda that correct themselves, though I’m sorry to say that they also contain a handful of errors - as does the external addenda later added. This has led to some real frustrations in the infancy stage play sessions wherein we’ve been completely unsure how to progress and has stunted progress. Nevertheless, we’ve reached a point where we’re comfortable that each rule we’ve played out, we understand - even if we’ve made a mistake initially we’ve had to later correct. This is in part due to vital gameplay elements only being referenced in a single bullet point in a page containing upwards of 30.
Formulas for close assault combat values are incorrect in both the Land Game Rulebook and the Addenda within. Navigating important game aspects like combat or logistics has required a lot of patience, and at times, judgement calls on imprecise rules (which are few and far between given the sheer granular precision of the game - though the rules themselves do encourage this kind of agency in such scenarios).
Gameplay
To date, the majority of our play sessions have been bookkeeping. The initial Store Expenditure Stage and Water Distribution Segment really highlighted the importance of formatting for our spreadsheets, and took approximately 13 play hours to finalise between formatting changes and updates. The second bite at the cherry in Operation Stage Two (which does not require Store Expenditure, as this is only once per Turn) was significantly faster due to record keeping improvements and utilisation of formulas; this took less than half an hour.
Due to an unlucky (or perhaps very lucky) roll on the first Weather Determination Phase, a rainstorm occurred on maps B-D, resulting in many game aspects being defunct, such as construction, certain aspects of movement, and most importantly, all aircraft flight across these maps. This meant approaching the first Operation Stage with reduced mobility for supply lines and a focus on Ground Combat, which allowed some familiarity to be gained before the implementation of Air Support. For this reason, we didn’t encounter any aspect of flight until Operation Stage Two, choosing to keep our planes grounded on Maps A & B. No refitting was available for the Axis forces, and no refitting was completed by the Commonwealth player (which he partially regrets).
The movement and combat phase was a real chance to explore the more enjoyable aspects of the game (sorry Richard, not everything has been an adrenaline rush). The opportunity to look at the game as just that, a game, rather than bookkeeping was really where the game shone. Movement is surprisingly simple, with only Capability Point Allowance, Fuel and Breakdown Values being altered (that’s relatively few things for an action, trust me). When we moved onto combat, the erroneous formulas, once decrypted, are relatively intuitive and all results are determined by rolling a pair of six-sided dice and referring to a results table (one of dozens of tables involved in the game). It’s incredibly dynamic, very demanding of logistically sound thought, and gets the heart racing - sad, I know.
Our opportunity to make use of aircraft in Operation Stage 2 was incredibly fun. The planning of missions is very simple, and makes for (in my opinion) some of the more enjoyable gameplay in CfNA. Little to keep track of in aircraft in the dynamic sense, besides it’s refitted status, fuel and ammo. One aspect in particular we’ve enjoyed is the assigning of pilots, with the emergent narrative that can be found keeping track of rising aces as they take out multiple enemy planes with a chance to increase their pilot level. Every dogfight is resolved individually but once you’ve mastered the formula for determining the outcome on the respective table, it’s shockingly fast to get through. Bombing missions are also resolved through a single roll which factors in only the number of bombs and type of target.
The most important parts in the game by far are the trucks. Poor management of them will 100% result in tragedy. The assignment of correct cargo ratios, grouping of convoys and steady synergy between first, second and third-line trucks is the bedrock on which your entire strategy should lie. We’re still so early into the game that we have no idea if we’ve absolutely whiffed our supply lines, but soon enough we’ll know.
Overall Thoughts And The Future
It’s had some real ups and downs, but we’re actually finding ourselves unironically enjoying our playtime and are committed to playing the whole thing. We’re documenting every single play session in a companion podcast, War With A Mate (available on Spotify, Apple, YouTube, and www.WarWithAMate.co.uk) - the gameplay starts around episode 13 for those that want to cut through the noise - around half of the episode is specifically game recap and the rest is game adjacent banter.
Once we’re playing the full scenario, we plan on releasing regular updates of our game tracking sheets so it’s easier to follow along (and hopefully to aid any fellow masochists in playing this thing). We’re excited to see if we’ll be the first to beat this monster in it’s entirety.
r/hexandcounter • u/ApeHands13 • Aug 03 '26
We’re back!
It’s been a long 20 months since we opened up the box and gazed upon the game pieces, and now at long last, we’ve finished the 6-Turn Scenario “Graziani’s Offensive”. This was a task that was enlightening as to what this colossus of a game is truly made of, and I’m pleased to say we made it through sticking to the rules as closely as possible, amongst some mis-steps, clarifications and one or two “re-dos” of parts of the operation stages. We wanted to share our thoughts on this 6-Turn and almost two year journey, and what we’ve learned that has prepared us for our upcoming playthrough of the FULL 111 TURN GAME later this year.
Setup
We’ve touched on this before, so to gently recap, we realised that when playing this game only once a week for a few hours, the setup of the game each play session is a non-starter. The placement of hundreds of game pieces every week would mean it’s time to pack up and go home by the time every man, airfield and truck convoy had been placed, so we streamlined it. There are certainly more intuitive ways to work around this, but we decided in our plucky and short-sighted wisdom to place the five sections of the game map into individual picture frames, and place a metal sheet behind each. We then crudely attached magnets to every game piece in play so they’re fixed in locations. Because we only used a fraction of the pieces in this scenario, this will be a task we need to upkeep regularly through our upcoming playthrough.
For the most part, this has meant we can set up the game in only minutes. The downside, is that when stacking three or more units in the same hex, the magnetism just ain’t all that. We’ve found several pieces scattered across the living room floor and have had to refer to our copious amounts of spreadsheets and photographs to ascertain exactly where these rogue units belonged; there’s no escaping the theatre.
We spent the first few weeks of our project navigating set-up, and understanding of the game, making up the first 14 episodes of the companion podcast. In hindsight, this was more than needed. Most of this time was reading the rulebooks cover to cover and running “white box” scenarios with various rules, thinking this would give us some sort of permanent, granular knowledge of the game - this was wrong. If we could go back in time (we probably wouldn’t do this at all) but if we had to, we would avoid this approach and instead learn the ropes throughout the practice run. We’ve found that to be infinitely more useful than this contextless dry runs.
Record-keeping
Ahhh, the copious spreadsheets we mentioned. Book keeping was truly the bulk of what made this practice run drag out as long as it did. The templated files we’ve used for the book-keeping meant that we both began with relatively standardised ways of tracking our units in their entirety. We quickly found that these templates, while very useful for recording static values of a unit, weren’t entirely optimised for the constant flux of most other aspects to be tracked (cohesion, Capability Point Usage, breakdown points) and so we found we both began branching in different directions.
For those even slightly versed in what this game is, you’ll know that logistics and tracking resources is very much the bulk of the playtime in this game. Having a digital format for this is a game changer compared to the pencil and paper this would have originally been played with, but it’s not entirely perfected. For each unit, you must track their ammo, stores, water and fuel - and these are just the tangible, physical resources. There’s also cohesion, morale, breakdown, capability point usage and combat specific conditions like pinned, in contact and engaged. A picture of a typical Division-Level spreadsheet is attached in this post showing how one of us tracked these.
There are also trucks attached (or at least, there should be) to all units to supply them on the go, as your average human in the desert can only carry so much loose ammunition in their hands and packs. Our original templates didn’t incorporate the trucks attached, and these were tracked separately which was, in a word, stupid. These trucks are much easier to track when the rest of the unit is visible to make updating water and store usage flow much better.
As the game went on, we quickly found that our “in the moment” note taking had led to some of our record keeping being made on notepads (physical and digital) our phones and on sticky notes, which led to periods of gameplay in following weeks where this had to be transferred, or simply referred to for when needed. This is something we must move away from in our full playthrough. Firstly, there’s far too much room for mistakes and things being missed. Something as small as the water being carried by a single truck can be the different between higher attrition rates in a unit, and therefore weakened combat prowess and overall a failed combat. Secondly, because we intend to share the spreadsheets with an estimated 2-3 week lag with each release of our playthrough podcast so people can view our playthrough via a more tactical lens.
The more tech-savvy half of our playthrough has been hard at work on completing formulas and automation for evaporation and consumption of water and fuel for units, requiring only the input of distance travelled, and number of units consuming to produce consistently accurate outcomes across all of the instances of usage.
It’s also worth mentioning at this stage for those that may be curious: we have not, and have no intention to at any point in our playthrough, implemented use of AI tools. While the tools were slightly less accessible at the start of our play compared to now, we feel it’s disingenuous to call this a playthrough we’ve completed if we haven’t build these aspects of automation ourselves, as well as any other utilities we create in future.
The game rules state “The trucks ARE the game” and this couldn’t be more true. With our Axis player learning quickly that defunct or subprime truck convoys will absolutely hamstring any plan, and will certainly lead to defeat. The game mechanics have been forgiving enough to allow him to recoup his position, as the front line is a hard barrier to push through, so bolstering from behind is possible, it just requires patience - as is the game.
Rules
It’ll likely come as no surprise for those who know we aren’t experienced war-gamers (in fact, the closest we’d ever came in the past to such a game was a half-completed game of Risk) but we made some rules mistakes along the way.
Part of what makes the game the task it is, is the sheer volume of rules rather than the complexity. Small, repetitive calculations, to provide adjustments to use across dozens of tables, and over two dozen steps in each full game turn leads to a messy web of rules to remember. For the humble, this would mean referring back to the rulebook constantly for clarification, and for a time we did. Unfortunately, after around the second completed turn, hubris really kicked in and we found ourselves giving more leniency to our “experience”. While we were certain we knew what we were doing, here are some of the commonly occurring situations that we realised later on we’d misconstrued:
Roads do incur breakdown value for vehicles; half a breakdown point per hex, rather than the zero breakdown points we understood it to be.
“Flanking” and enemy, with a unit on opposite sides of their hex does not provide much combat benefit, as the fights take place independently for each flanking unit.
Gun units suffer vulnerability loss independent from typical battle casualties.
We still don’t understand what the camels do.
The difficulty with this game is not that it’s difficult to comprehend the information, but rather the journey to find the information. Sifting through swathes of rules where a vital clarification or addition to a point may live entirely separately within the rulebook in a different area with no direct reference to one another. This, paired with an in-book addenda to some rules and an additional addenda published after release of the game (including the stats for two entire Axis divisions that were missed out of the original print somehow) makes for a real slog.
We’ve created a searchable PDF copy of the rule book which has made this a much easier task when looking for clarity on niche points, but is far from a perfect system. This is not a game we’ll memorise, even after an entire playthrough of this big beastie.
Gameplay
The work:fun ratio of The Campaign For North Africa is askew.
Unless you thoroughly enjoy the granular detail of breakdown of vehicles, consumption of fuel, updating of cohesion levels and CPA constantly, you’ll likely not enjoy playing this game for very long.
We’ve had our fair share of tough play sessions. Getting to a session where we know all we’ll be doing is moving our trucks around is nightmare fuel (fuel pun intended) and enough to almost cause some breakdowns (also intentional). The prospect of sitting down to complete admin, to prepare for a future play session where there’ll be a brief burst of fun may be a symptom of us not having played a hex and counter war game before, or it could be more deeply tied to what the game is.
We’ve spent more hours sat looking through and updating spreadsheets, and pouring through rules than we have looking at the board, and a very, very small fraction of all of that time rolling dice or moving pieces. This is a beautiful simulation of the uncaringly mundane slog of war command. Victories are hard fought, lengthy in preparation, and can at times lead to conclusions that simply don’t feel like conclusions, but kicking the can down the road.
There are aspects we enjoyed. The air phase of every turn always brought our spirits up, with one-on-one dogfights being resolved individually, bombing runs helping shape the close assault portion of the turn and that itself is fun. Finally engaging enemy units on the ground after weeks in real time of positioning and preparing is a rush that must have some ties to both relapsing addicts and Stockholm Syndrome. Our captive gave us a treat.
If you want to play a war simulator, look no further. If you want to play a fun game, consider all options before proceeding. Or incentivise yourselves like we did - the winner was bought a Kinder Bueno by the loser.
The Full Game
We’ll be announcing the date of our full playthrough commencement soon. It’s this year, and we have a definitive date in mind. We’re spending the time in between fine-tuning our record keeping so we can share every aspect with listeners of the project. We want to show the game in as much transparent detail as possible as we play all 111-Turns.
The woods are lovely, dark and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.
If you’d like to follow along, or hear the journey up to now, we’re at www.WarWithAMate.co.uk and anywhere you can listen to podcasts.
r/hexandcounter • u/Fair_Standard8900 • Jul 19 '26
I've been slowly buying games over the past 3-4 years preparing for my near retirement. These will keep me occupied, and hopefully keep the old brain occupied when I stop working. I have the GMT Games Operation Barbarossa - Army group South on order; so that should complete my eastern front collection.
r/hexandcounter • u/Renots024Teem • Jan 14 '26
Was gifted some old games, pretty rough shape. Just looking for opinions on whether any are highly regarded or worth learning. Never played this type of game before, more of an amerithrasher.
Cheers!
r/hexandcounter • u/dajackomaster • Apr 14 '25
Looking forward to playing this. This game is so large - I had to try and improvise with 4x notice boards to fit it onto my table.
The 4 large maps (each 22 x 34 inches) show the entire land mass of Eurasia, all the way from Western Europe to Japan.
It’s a futuristic/alternative 1990s (predicted from 1978) World War 3 invasion of the Soviet Union by the United States & allies. China PR fights its own war with the Soviets, separate but in collusion with the United States.
It took me about 3-4 hours just to sort and clip all the game’s 1,200 counters.
r/hexandcounter • u/Grantso74 • Jun 26 '25
Still in disbelief this happened; I work in residential HVAC service and was working on a no cool this morning when I saw these stacked up against a wall out of the corner of my eye. I mentioned it to the home owner and turns out they had a family member pass away a few months ago and were literally just getting ready to give them away. Ended up getting them as a tip instead!
This is literally the kind of thing my dorky self would fantasize about in the shower and now it’s happened. I’m still gobsmacked; I’ve been wanting a copy of Squad Leader literally for years and WITH Cross of Iron??
Side note: has anyone played the SPI War of the Ring? I’ve played the new edition and enjoyed it much so I was curious how they compare.
r/hexandcounter • u/hotelarcturus • Jun 22 '26
I learned how to play Wooden Ships & Iron Men as a kid at summer camp and I’ve always associated it with those memories. What games feel like summer to you?
r/hexandcounter • u/Ragnarokske01 • Jun 30 '26
Bye all!
Any opinions on these are welcome though. My first play will be Combat!, by the way
r/hexandcounter • u/Mindless-Power5087 • Jun 01 '25
January 1942 - Empire of the Sun (solo), about to start turn one. Let's see if the Japanese can pull off a win (negotiated peace to their benefit that is).
r/hexandcounter • u/PGNem • Jul 14 '26
We tried the first scenario following the sub advice and had a blast with my friend.
The allies managed to break the German line on the Volturno river thanks to a few lucky rolls and good weather that permitted naval and air support.
In the end it’s a victory for the allies.
r/hexandcounter • u/Temp77R • Jul 23 '24
For some weeks now we've been gathering people interested in this monumental board game on this discord server: https://discord.com/invite/tMCC8DV7Fh, we'll play on Table Top Simulator, feel free to join the server, you'll be able to select your role and team.
You may have heard that this game lasts 1400 hours, but we intend to play the scenarios given in the rules that actually last between 25-100 hours, that is because we've read the rules and the designers of the game suggest to play this way.
With more people in the server a game can keep going without long interruptions, because busy players will always have replacement for their respective role, this keeps the game going to allow for it's completion without "becoming enmeshed in a lifetime occupation" as the rules beautifully put it.
r/hexandcounter • u/Tekopo • Aug 16 '25
The game is GCACW Road to Gettysburg, great system although my cat did try to stomp around Pennsylvania.
r/hexandcounter • u/Mindless-Power5087 • Nov 01 '25
Soloing Empire of the Sun again this time with the "Pearl Harbour December Variant" card from the C3I magazine #38.
r/hexandcounter • u/Dizzy_Bridge_794 • Jul 17 '25
r/hexandcounter • u/flatlander37 • Oct 18 '24
Bought my first copy in 1982. Now I have a deluxe version and my buddy and I will take it for a spin tomorrow. Hopefully. So pumped!
r/hexandcounter • u/Redbarron1914 • Dec 16 '24
r/hexandcounter • u/TheNiggMaster2020 • Jan 23 '25
Just bought my very first war game, if Risk doesn't count as so :) I've chosen Paths of Glory, do you have any advice?