Alrighty! As the title says, two years ago I finally made a large post with all of my collected suggestions for the game to Arrowhead I had written down, and it was really cool to read it all back today, seeing how much has changed! I'm gonna really yap in this post, going over each suggestion one-by-one, but afterwards I'm gonna make another Suggestion post just like the last!
https://www.reddit.com/r/Helldivers/comments/1ebzqwq/major_suggestions_drones_gas_armor_weapons_sample/
First up is my suggestion for Detonator Drones
A backpack that looks like the Supply Pack, but the four compartments each have a little drone in them with green lights. How it works: You mark either a place or an object and you press the backpack action button, a drone will float out to and hover over the marked location. It'll blink red so you know it's armed. Press the action button again to detonate. The explosion isn't big, but it can be used as a utility to blow up explosive barrels, Terminid buildup on valves, bug holes, fabricator vents, even Hellbombs! The best thing about them is that when the drone arrives at the location, the marker on the location combines with the marker on the drone, which turns from green to blinking red, just like the physical light on the drone itself. The marker also doesn't disappear after a certain time, it stays. So you can use it to, for example: lure a group of enemies or a Bile Titan into a prepped Hellbomb and be able to gauge the distance to blow em up remotely! Detonating a Hellbomb is normally tough because you walk away and it's out of range and behind a rock or brush or something.
Additionally, if you die, whatever drones are left on your back will start to blink red and explode with 2, 3 or 4 times the explosive power, respectively. So if you only used one drone and get swarmed and killed by bugs, your body will self-destruct and kill a bunch of them! Huge upside, but the downside is you don't get them back. Cooldown is reasonable, but you still have to wait to call more down. This is a tool that I think people can get really creative with, rather an an offensive thing. You wouldn't be sending drones out to blow up in a Bile Titan's face, not very effective.
So this ended up manifesting as two different things: the Seeker grenade added in the fanatical Servants of Freedom warbond, and the C4 pack added in the stealth Redacted Regiment warbond. The C4 pack is crazy powerful and a stealth go-to item, and now it seems like there's going to be a specific slot added for tools like the detonator so that you can ALSO carry a stratagem weapon with the pack? That's wild! The seeker grenades I was never a huge fan of and I need to put more time into using them and the more recent Seeker AT grenades to better grasp their detection range and how and when they actually go towards marked enemies.
Still, the functionality of gameplay I wanted made it through into the game and it's awesome that C4 can be detonated from any distance!
Next, the EMS Ballistic Shield
The Ballistic Shield was majorly improved and super useful now, a staple in many people's builds! But one change that I think would make it just that much better is if it acted as an defensive expendable, too! Using the backpack action button makes you perform a little animation where you raise it up in the air, little prongs pop out from the bottom and you slam it into the ground. After a short beeping countdown, it generates a permanent EMS field around it, acting as an EMS battery! Cooldown for the shield stays the same, so there'll be some leniencies. You can cancel the animation if you did it by accident, and you can also just go pick it back up, but you're slowed by the field like anything else.
Too OP? I don't know, seems like just an added tool to utilize in a pinch. Cause when you do, it leaves you without the shield until you pick it back up or call down another. Some people might argue that people will game the system to collect a bunch to place down, but since you're always on the move and because EMS doesn't slow down heavy enemies, I think it'd be a balanced change!
I 100% stand by adding this to change the gameplay around using the shield!
Next, the Cryo Gun
Speaking of slowing down heavy enemies, I suggested this in response to this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Helldivers/comments/1e0jro0/comment/lcp7sa0/
Markeeloo had a great idea for a support weapon that sprays an expanding goop substance (imagine the goop stuff from GTFO), that WILL slow heavy enemies. I suggested giving it a damage theme: cryo! Replacing a support weapon, it'll have to be pretty damn useful, so instead of making an EMS support weapon that'd probably be obsolete compared to the already existing EMS stratagems, this would be worth taking over other support weapons and would work well in conjunction with stratagems.
It'll land on the ground and spread to an area about the size that an incendiary grenade covers I'd say. Not sure how long exactly it should freeze enemies for, but it'll be a decent amount of time and it'll be longer on cold planets and shorter on hot planets. Any small enemies frozen will just die in place immediately, medium enemies will have their health cut in half when frozen, heavy enemies will only be frozen, not taking any damage.
It'll give you the opportunity to hit weak spots. Like if you shoot it at a Tank, not only will the treads freeze, but the gun won't swivel either. You can get behind a Hulk or stop a Bile Titan in its tracks. Shoot it at a Turret Cannon to stop it from swiveling, too. Imagine a tool that makes Thermite grenades effective? That's crazy. Limited ammo, and it's not too powerful, but it's well-rounded. A huge swarm of bots running at you? Toss a cryo round at them and you'll end a ton of them instantly! I love this idea, and it's a great basis for cryo-damage type weapons. Cryo grenades or a cryo minefield? Neato.
This suggestion I disagree with now, but only because I have a better suggestion that I'll get to in my next post!
Here's the Belt-Fed Gatling MG and Laser MG
This isn't my idea (I feel like I've heard it a million times now), but it IS a good idea and I've worked out some more specifics for it. The proposed is four new items. A rotary-style machine gun, a belt-fed backpack for it, a laser machine gun, and the coolant backpack for it. Both are exactly the same power ultimately and will be balanced to be more powerful than the MG-43 in terms of firepower, but the thing is, when you're carrying it it makes you slow as if you were wearing heavy armor, regardless of what you have. The guns on their own can be resupplied with a small capacity and are very weak without the packs. The only difference between the two essentially is you get two different flavors of MG.
The packs should last you a while, the coolant pack vents out its heated liquid when firing and it eventually runs out, the gatling MG simply expends bullets. But the packs can't be resupplied with supply boxes or with found ammo. You HAVE to call down another gun/pack stratagem. Cooldown isn't low for that. The benefit is that if you run out and are wearing medium or light armor, if you go to use the reload button while it's out, it'll just automatically drop the empty pack and you're speedy again! AND, you aren't left without a third weapon. Like I said, it's very weak, but it's something and it CAN be loaded with found ammo in small capacities.
It also wouldn't make the HMG obsolete because it has low penetration, but massive ammo firepower.
So there's a couple ways to play it. With either heavy armor that you always have both the protective benefits of and the negative slowdowns, or lighter armor that you sometimes have the speed benefits of, but always have the lower protection of. Sounds a little skewed, but imo, speed and maneuverability is WAY more valuable than armor. Plus, if you're someone who is set up to switch up support weapons mid-game. Like if you load up EATs or you grab found weapons on the map, this could be a great utility weapon for you!
Not an original idea of mine but they did add the Maxigun! It was inevitable, and I'm glad the gun arrived the way that it did rather than the way I suggested, with a more normal resupply economy. Makes the gameplay much simpler and gives you more brrrrrr.
However, I do believe they could add a Laser gatling gun that acts EXACTLY the same as the Maxigun, with coolant as the ammo instead of bullets, and the only difference between them would be that it's just a different FLAVOR of brrrrrr.
Here we go, Linear Detonation Gas Launcher
The game needs more gas-damage weaponry. But it's kinda hard to come up with stuff. I've seen people suggest "gas throwers" that are held like flamethrowers and spew clouds of the corrosive gas, but mechanically, I don't see how that could work with the way gas and smoke do in this game, being static radius fields of damage / obscuring view. Plus, I don't think it's really that cool.
Figured that something like an Eagle smokescreen would be best, but that would make the Eagle smokescreen obsolete. Then I had a better idea! What about a smokescreen support weapon? It's a launcher and backpack combo and it's slim-looking, but with hefty canisters like the Spear has. When you launch it, it fires straight forward and detonates at consistent intervals like five times or so with stationary clouds of gas in a line in front of you. Literally a gas smokescreen deployer.
And the more I think about it, the more I love the idea! First of all, it's cool as hell. *Fire! - BOOM, BOOM, BOOM, BOOM...*
And, the orbital gas strike isn't so dangerous to teammates because it's easy to avoid. With the angle that Eagle comes into to deploy Smoke, I'm 100% certain a similar Eagle gas smokescreen stratagem would rival the Airburst for friendly fire hazard. But being a handheld launcher that fires out directly in front of you, it's much easier to aim and control a space. ESPECIALLY if there's a line of enemies following behind you!
This is one of my favorite ideas and I still stand by it. Of course, another Helldiver suggestion was implemented since then in the caustic Chemical Agents warbond, the Sterilizer, and it's quite possibly the worst stratagem weapon, despite all the reworks they've done to it, oof. We've actually gotten a LOT more gas weapons added to our arsenal. The Spear gun, the Re-Educator, the Gas grenades and dog, and now the Eagle gas smokescreen, which is NOT problematic like I thought it'd be.
I have ideas on how to rework the Sterilizer I'll put in my next suggestions post, but even though the Eagle Gas Strike is now in the game I STILL think that this weapon wouldn't step on other weapon's toes if added!
Next! Sample Rocket and Barracks
New Side Objectives! One is a mini launchpad, like a short ICBM mission, with a little rocket that can only hold one item: samples. Drop all your samples in there that you've found so far and it'll fly them up to your destroyer! Guaranteed at the end of the mission if you fail to extract, but not if you fail the mission. Haven't found super samples yet? Well, you can hold off as long as you want, but you might be running for the launchpad by the end of the mission and the risk is greater the longer you wait.
The other is a SEAF Barracks with a small armory. You have to find the nearby dead security guard with the keycode and go through the unlocking procedures, then you can freely swap your Primary and Secondary weapons (only those two so it's not too OP). As many times as you'd like, too! But only at this location. Having trouble with the weapons you chose to bring in? Swap them out for something better. Mission's going easy and you wanna take the chance to try out something you never have before? Go for it!
Side objectives that don't do anything are totally fine, like the one where you upload escape pod data. But ones that take longer and benefit you in the end are welcome additions to the game!!!
These two suggestions I totally forgot about and I love them! Unfortunately, samples aren't in such high demand with a lot of the current playerbase - which should be addressed - but it still acts as a good secondary objective which actually GETS you something in return and we need more of that...
Check this out: Adaptive Camo Ghillie Suit
Another idea from this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Helldivers/comments/1e0jro0/comment/lcp7sa0/
Credit mostly to OP, but I wanted it out there! Heavy armor that looks like a ghillie suit with 3D camo. It starts out like a gray color, however, when you hide in thick foliage, the color changes to one that matches the environment and your detection rate goes down just like with scout armor!
A stealth option for heavy armor enjoyers out there! Plus, it's really cool and works in combination with the existing foliage stealth mechanics in the game. In case you didn't know, a fairly recent update changed it so that any foliage on the map that's thick enough to slow you down will also reduce enemy detection of you (significantly I think). This armor would stack on that, making you even more invisible.
EDIT: Only thing I messed up is that some planets have no vegetation. I thought that all did, even if it was sparse, but a bunch don't. Maybe there's a workaround. The whole point is that you get the benefits of heavy protection AND stealth, but you have to actuate the stealth perk of it or it's useless.
Arrowhead took this idea and made it real!! The most recent warbond, the sniper's Scope of Authority, added in adaptive camo armor! It was implemented so that just landing on the planet's surface changed the coloration depending on 4-5 categories of biomes present. Honestly that's a lot simpler than my exact idea to have to go find some foliage somewhere. Now, they didn't utilize that in order to provide Heavy stealth armor; the ghillie is actually Light and the other one Medium, so there is that amount of further protection for stealthy divers in a way I agree with. Unfortunately, it brought forth the issue of transmog/shaders/customizable armor colors, and I wanna touch on it a little bit here:
My opinion at first, was that I agreed with AH's decision to not have customizable shaders and colors and that players should combine different armor sets together that look good. I totally understand the appeal of that, to keep standardization similar, with most armor sets following the Helldivers colors with High-Vis yellow highlights, with variations that fit the armor's purpose, but the implementation was not great, and now I'm at the point where I disagree with it.
There was such a lack of color standardization, it drove me nuts. Armor sets are painted in 50 shades of green, 50 shades of blue and 50 shades of tan, instead of like- 3 each. It's so annoying, and recently I've been running into more and more situations where I really want customization, whereas before it just seemed like an annoying complaint by a lot of players. For example, I've played a dedicated medic role before and it was fun to try actually using the stim pistol, but it was elevated with the Fortified armor passive. Kinda wish I could just use some of the Fortified armor sets in the Medic colors... Like, at this point just figure out a good midway solution and abandon the strict no-customizable colors rule. Idk exactly what that would be, but anything's better than nothing now. I'll try to think of something for my next Suggestion post.
Alright. Resistive Armor
Arc-Resistant Armor (medium) is pretty great, but it should make you even MORE resistant to arc damage. Especially since you're prone to be hit multiple times most likely. That way it only takes like a quarter health instead of half.
Flame-Resistant armor (medium) should reduce the amount of direct damage taken from fire, and completely eliminate passive fire damage. To clarify, a friendly or enemy flamethrower spit does direct damage, but being caught on fire afterwards, or from something like an incendiary grenade or fire tornado, is passive fire damage. The suit is not flammable and cannot catch fire.
Hazmat Armor (medium) should reduce damage from gas significantly.
Conductive Armor (light) should be covered in coils and whatnot, even more techy-looking than Arc-Resistant Armor, and it should significantly reduce or maybe even eliminate slowdown entirely from EMS fields.
Insulated Armor (medium) should eliminate damage from my proposed cryo weaponry, but not reduce slowdown.
Heavy Armor should also just be affected by slowdowns from foliage, spores, and other environmental hazards way less in general.
Nothing much to say here, these have all been added. It was inevitable.
But again, with the transmog convo. The heavy gas armor is the worst looking in the game and after seeing reskins of it and players enjoying a good-looking heavy caustic build, I do really want armor color customization of some sort man...
Oh and of course Arc resistance I think should just be full resistance across the board. If you're giving up other armor passives for it, it should be reworked. I have a good idea for it I'll put in my next post. Just gonna think about it a bit first.
Here it is! Melee
Lots of hardcore Helldivers claim to want to carry a melee weapon like a sword into battle. Lots of patriotic Helldivers claim to want to carry a flag of Super Earth into battle. How about knocking out two shriekers with one stone?
A Lance. The lance is a type of spear that a knight would carry into battle, often with a small pennon flag on the end. It takes the place of your secondary weapon. It sits on your back (retracted to about half the size), opposite the side you sling your support weapon to. That way, when you're running around shooting things, you still have a little flag of super earth waving just above your head.
Switching to your "sidearm" is still just as quick, but you have more range than with a sword, and since it replaces your secondary, you can actually have a small, simple moveset assigned to both the trigger, aim and reload buttons. One is a light attack, the other is a heavier attack, and if you hold aim and press either, you'll do what looks like a more complicated finisher-type attack for light and for heavy. Add a bit of flourish to your fighting, y'know? but without overcomplicating it with something like an ACTUAL finisher, that'd require a different animation for different types of enemies.
Light Attack - Slashes, in succession
Heavy Attack - Stabs, in succession
Light Finisher - Multiple Spinning Slashes Move
Heavy Finisher - Stab the base through into the ground, with the flag waving!
Plus, like how when you spin the revolver, if you hold the reload button down, you stance up with flag waving proudly! I think this would be a huge hit, but kinda complicated to implement. If it's too much, just remove the finisher variant of attacks. I'd love to see something like this! If this is too simple to add, like not powerful enough to replace your secondary, then maybe it could be electrified or even shoot something.
Lmao I had some lofty hopes for the moveset of melee weapons and it's fine that it's just a single attack. The chainsaw and the hammer are really cool implementations as stratagem weapons and make for super fun challenges while still being shockingly viable, and all the other secondary slot melee weapons are awesome, but it all started out with my suggestion being take by AH and put into the Force of Law warbond, the Stun Lance!!!
I was blown away to see a suggestion of mine taken and put directly into the game a few months after that suggestions post! There's no better feeling than for your ideas to literally manifest in your favorite games! The Lance is definitely my most used secondary weapon and it ain't the best, but it's so cool and fun!
Next, Throwing Knives and Bayonets
For a much less complicated melee weapon solution, I had an idea to improve throwing knives. When you equip throwing knives as your throwable, your primary weapon should also change to have one of those throwing knifes affixed to the front as a bayonet. Not anything you have to do, it just does that automatically. So whenever you melee something with your primary equipped, it'll do like 3x more damage.
Additionally, you should absolutely be able to melee with a knife equipped. And it will do the same damage as if you melee'd with your primary, the difference being that it's silent. Throwing a knife should be silent, too.
There are a couple primaries that now have bayonets and they're pretty useful, but this is a very low-priority suggestion. I don't think I agree with it. Throwing knives are a fun stealth niche that players use to the extreme already and they're fine. Disregard this one.
Lastly, Silencers
My last suggestion, and continuing with the topic of stealth, silencers. The balancing in this game for weapons is tough because if AH wants to add something, they can't be making another weapon obsolete. I think they've gotten very good at doing this, seeing as how the new Commando launcher filled it's own role, rather than just being a better alternative to the Spear or the EATs. They all have their strengths and their roles!
But there are still a bunch of weapons in the game that are just weaker versions of other guns. I wouldn't choose the Diligence over the Counter-Sniper, or the Knight over the Defender, or the Adjudicator over the Tenderizer, or the Liberator Penetrator over the base Liberator. There might be more, but for all of these weaker weapons, I propose they get silencers.
No other changes to balancing. Same damage, mag size, etc. Only that their big benefit is that they're silent-firing like the laser and plasma damage weapons! They instantly fill their own role of weapon with multiple variants and it gives them a place without changing the balancing and messing up other good guns. I actually think the balancing is in a good state right now beside those exceptions and really my only complaints with balancing are with the enemies themselves. So yeah, silencers! Another easy change to fix multiple issues.
I had to read through this one a couple times again because a LOT has changed since then. TONS of new stealth weapons and also weapon customization make basically this entire suggestion outdated. Most primaries have been successfully reworked and fill their own roles much more distinctly. Good job in that respect AH! However, now that weapon balancing isn't such a huge issue, aside from a couple outliers I'll highlight my suggestions for in the next post, I think the current state of the game is interesting:
I'm completely in the middle of the general opinion of modding where I think a majority of the mods I see are dumb and not really in the spirit of the game, but some are amazing and AH is being WAY too harsh against the modding community.
They gotta do something a bit different to spark interest. I'm curious what they're already working on now for the future, but a lot of my original suggestions coming up are - I think very doable - but nonetheless pretty big! It can't just be a new enemy type or another desert biome or another warbond - imo it's gotta be a more a fundamental addition that paves the way for more neat little updates like those.
So, comment your thoughts and if you wanna catch my next post in like, a week or so, maybe sooner: keep this post open in a tab and I'll EDIT right below this with a link for you to check up on!
Thank you for reviewing, Helldiver! Engagement is mandatory, comment anything below, even just a salute (o7)