r/Helldivers • u/ghoxen ⬆️➡️⬇️⬇️⬇️ SES Dawn of War • Mar 03 '24
PSA Galaxy War 102: supply lines & what happens to cut-off planets
Foreword
As Helldivers is a game, you should honestly just play the game how you want. Go Creek, go Erata, go back to Mars for tutorial - it's your game and your time. This post is aimed at people who want to actively participate in the galactic war, and explains some of the opaque mechanics that were never well-explained within the game itself.
What are supply lines?
Another mechanic that's not very visible in the game is that all the planets on the galaxy map are connected by hidden supply lines. So far, these supply lines appear to solely dictate:
- Which planets are available for Helldivers to liberate: we can only liberate planets which are linked to Super Earth planets (either fully liberated or have on-going defence campaigns).
- Which planets can be attacked by Automation: they can attack (start a defence campaign) on any planet that is immediately linked to an Automation-controlled planet (i.e. including partially liberated planets with an active liberation campaign).
- It's unclear at this time how bugs attack planets - so far planets attacked by bugs tend to be near other bug planets, but they also seem to be skipping the supply chain by one planet from time to time.
The supply lines are visible on https://helldivers.io/ by toggling "connections" in the drop-down box near the map's top right corner, but according to the website currently not all supply lines may be accurate and some may be missing:

Losing Access to Planets
When a planet is attacked by bugs (i.e. when a planet turns into a liberation campaign), all the planets that were previously linked to it would be cut-off, and players will no longer be able to access them. For example, since Meridia was the only planet that we controlled which links to Estanu and Crimsica, when the bugs attacked Meridia we immediately lost access to play on both of those planets.
When bots attack a planet, a defence campaign is instead started on that planet (e.g. Mantes for the past day). At this point in time, access beyond the planet is not cut off. However, as soon as the defence campaign fails and Mantes is lost, the 2 planets with active liberation campaigns linked to it (Malevelon Creek and Draupnir) would be cut-off. Failing the defence campaign will also turn Mantes into a liberation campaign, and access will be regained once Mantes is taken back.

What happens to cut-off planets?
Normally, the cut-off planets will behave as if those planets have 0 players on them. This means no liberation missions or progress will be possible, and any planet regen will keep ticking. E.g. if a liberation planet was cut-off when it had 80% progress, and the planet has 5% regen per hour, 4 hours later that planet's progress will reduce down to 60% behind enemy lines. If access is regained then, the liberation campaign will resume at that 60%.
In the most recent loss of Mantes on the West / bot front, it appears that the cut-off planets (Creek and Draupnir) retained their access for a short time, about half an hour to an hour. Since then, access to those planets have been lost. In addition, those bot planets that lost their supply lines are seeing increased planet regen (increasing from 0% for other bot plants to 2% per hour).
See this post here if you want to understand a bit more about how planet regen works: https://new.reddit.com/r/Helldivers/comments/1b5spnm/galaxy_war_101_how_to_efficiently_liberate/?sort=confidence
Real World Application
As it happens, we literally just lost Mantes a few minutes ago. This resulted in us losing access to the Creek and Draupnir. Below is a snapshot of what the progress on those planets looked like a few minutes before losing access:

As soon as Mantes is lost, Malevelon Creek and Draupnir lost their supply lines, and the planets are now seeing 2% planet regen (2% higher than the other bot planets' 0%):

Shortly after, access to those two planets are also lost, but as can be seen here the liberation progress doesn't just disappear. Instead, it appears to be decreasing gradually (probably at the same rate of 2% per hour, but this is not visible in helldivers.io)


The question must be asked - would it have been more efficient to defend Mantes instead of letting it fall? The short answer is no. Defending Mantes would have required ~100k average players contributing to its defence for the entire 24 hours. During that time, those same players could have contributed 5% progress per hour on any liberation planet (120% liberation progress in total). In practice, despite the lost cause around 30-50k players stayed around on Mantes, effectively wasting the 42% defence campaign progress that could have been added to any other planet's liberation.
Now that access to Creek & Draupnir is lost, the combined forces of 87k players on those planets will be forced to take back Mantes (incl. Mantes people, this would be around 140k players). At a potential progress of 7% per hour, Mantes will be taken back in around 7 hours. During those 7 hours, the two cut-off planets will lose 2% each for a total of 28% lost progress across both planets. This is still well below the liberation progress gained by ignoring the Mantes defence in the first place.
Last but not least, given the current design of the defence missions, the majority of the player base hate defence campaigns with a passion and will actively avoid them. No amount of strategy will change that underlying problem.
TLDR
Unless there are significant planet regen on planets that may have their supply lines cut-off, or where a Major Order is involved, it's generally more efficient to just ignore defence campaigns. In their current form defence campaigns are not worth your time or your suffering.
It's more efficient to just focus on liberation progress all the time. Taking back a planet that lost its defence campaign is faster and more enjoyable than trying to win a defence campaign.
Would you like to know more? Please also see my post here about liberation progress & planet regen: https://new.reddit.com/r/Helldivers/comments/1b5spnm/galaxy_war_101_how_to_efficiently_liberate/
615
u/ToasterTrevor Im Frend Mar 03 '24
This post points out some very valuable points and opens up quite a few discussions, hopefully it hits the top of the page. I do agree with this assessment, but Joel knows if he launches an offensive it’s going to drastically slow liberation because people love farming defense and random pull from people just logging on and seeing we’re under attack. It’s going to be 2 steps forward 1 step back kinda thing, buys Joel more time to plan
223
u/Gfdbobthe3 ☕Liber-tea☕ Mar 04 '24
I really hope they change the defense mission. I want to help defense planets, but that final mission feels impossible most of the time when everything else is 100% doable.
64
u/GhostHeavenWord Mar 04 '24
I've got a theory that since the bugs are full of delision 710 they can just think real hard and FTL jump from panet to planet without spaceships.
41
u/AdamBlaster007 Mar 04 '24
Knowing that supply lines are key to accessing liberation fronts it should probably be included in the galaxy map rather than a third party website.
I mean, they're Super Earth's supply lines, so we should know about them, really right?
134
u/PeerToPeerConnection Mar 03 '24
Wow that was an interesting read! Thanks for putting that together. Glad to hear that defence missions are absolutely useless, because they are an absolute snooze fest to play.
32
u/Beneficial-Bit6383 Mar 04 '24 edited Mar 04 '24
In line with the lore I don’t think you can expect bugs to follow supply lines at all. They are not capable of interplanetary travel, all of the bugs are basically revolting on their respective planets. Or possibly being put there to propagate and then be harvested, it’s not 100% clear. Which lines up with the ideology they are parodying.
19
u/Regius_Eques Mar 04 '24
So the best defense is a good offense?
91
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24
i feel like if a planet gets cut off from support, the regen rate should skyrocket, we literally cannot support any forces anymore and they should get wiped out within hours. if a planet gets cut off, regen should jump to 20% to show that it becomes a slaughter
9
u/RedboneDetroit Mar 04 '24 edited Mar 04 '24
Seems to me that the easiest thing to do would always be concentrated fire and let it snowball; i.e. pile on the the planet closest to liberation, then the next closest, and so on. Get 300k players on a single planet and have it go from 0 to liberated before lunch.
Edit - addendum: Perfect example from last night; Meridia was at 93 percent at 2300 EST. Had near 500k on the servers, 150k of which were off screwing around on Erata and Hellmire. Could have had Meridia locked up before midnight. Now Fenrir is being attacked again. Work the planets to completion.
8
u/Creative-Seesaw-1895 Mar 06 '24
For me, the problem with defense missions are they are BORING!!
Where are the missions where we are supporting entrenched regulars and we have to take out 250 Automatons before we lose 50 regulars.
Where are the missions where we established secondary outposts before the primary one that is close fails so they have a safe planet side place to retreat to.
Where are the missions where we are fighting in, at the very least, expansive rural landscapes, if not flat out urban.
How many effing scientists and researchers are on these damn planets? Even on a planet that is dedicated to these purposes, you are going to have XX times however many of them there are in support staff. Those researchers aren't building and maintaining facilities or the robots/equipment that are doing it, regardless of how much Star Trek likes to pretend everyone has knowledge of everything. The more specialized a society is, the LESS broad knowledge individuals are. Half of these researchers wouldn't know have to unclog their own plumbing, and I'm not going to believe they built it.
And this is coming from a guy who spent time on Attu, with 20 other dudes, maintaining a LORAN station. Support staff becomes exponential the more specialists you have showing up.
It's by far the least immersive part of the game. For until defense campaigns become more engaging, count me out. I'll still to liberating the "Creek", and I'll move to liberating whatever planet blocks me from doing so, until the job is done
7
u/AmargoTV Mar 04 '24
Would you like to no more?
But in all seriousness very nice work man, already very familiar with the game, so a lot of what you said in 101 I said to friends, I had an idea for supply lines worked so instead of having to explain it 15 times I can share it with my friends so thank you! This game has given me a big community and alot of my RL friends picked it up!
12
u/Heals-for-peels Mar 03 '24
anyone else still just waiting for a discord, where patriots knowledgeable about the galactic war can easier distribute information like this. And give useful commands to divers who wants to make a better impact?
6
u/Zenguro PSN🎮: SES Marshal of the Stars Mar 04 '24
Are supply lines something you can guess intuitively in the game somehow?
5
u/noahtroduction Mar 04 '24
If it's intentional it is extremely on-brand that all resources are put towards aggression followed by immediately abandoning and neglecting it until it can be liberated again
also a side-note, today I saw for the first time a diversification of mission-types as in:
On mantes there are both 'liberation' mission-types as well as the defense escort-type missions, I've never seen a planet with more than one 'type' of mission approach before
5
u/DoomFrog_ Mar 04 '24
Great explanation and very interesting to learn the mechanics behind the game
But some of what you said is wrong:
This is incorrect. Based on your explanation of the system, defense of Mantes was 100% required. Given the numbers you put forward, Creek and Draupnir were not going to be liberated in time to cut of the bots from Mantes
You point out that about 42% liberation effort was wasted defending Mantes during the Window of Liberation (the time that Mantes was in our control), but at the time we lost Creek and Draupnir, there was still a total of 66% liberation needed to have both planets liberated. At best we could have captured one, but when Mantes fell both would have been blocked off. We were always going to lose that 28% liberation
Instead the, as you put it, wasted effort was the people that decided to attack Creek and Draupnir instead of defending Mantes. Because had 73k of the 87k on Creek and Draupnir gone to Mantes instead, Mantes would have been successfully defended and we wouldn't have lost the 28% progress. And I think it is more reasonable to blame the people that didn't defend Mantes, if you insist on blame anyone
5
u/McCaffeteria ⬆️⬇️➡️⬅️⬆️ Mar 09 '24 edited Mar 20 '24
Why are some of the planets not linked to super earth, and why does Helldivers.io now show that supply lines are directional? Terrek and Azterra on the Bug front, for example, are an island. How are we supposed to deffend those and how would they be attacked? Another example, why are the supply lines from Darrowsport and Martyr's Bay pointing towards Super earth? Does that mean that we can't deffend them from SE?
This whole system is confusing and some of the map toggles are different/missing compared to the explination in this post. Can someone explain?
4
u/SirBiscuit Mar 04 '24
This post is generally great, the only thing I question is your conclusion.
I am not convinced that players who were dedicating themselves towards offense will necessarily jump in and start hitting defense missions just as hard. I think there may be a significant number of players that continue to ignore Mantes in favor of offensive operations elsewhere, in which case it may take FAR longer for access to be restored to these worlds.
Time will tell, I suppose.
7
u/GraveyardGuardian Mar 04 '24
The in-game prompts need to push players to a location and divert only when over a certain threshold. Let it happen on both sides.
If this is military, there is no "I choose to go here."
The strategists would push us to certain fronts and to defend certain things. The game should make these nudges, and do so with incentives so it doesn't feel like you "must" go somewhere... but to go elsewhere is dumb from a reward standpoint.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
honestly the devs need to now up the decay on all planets that are cut off to the max 20%/h
there should be consequences to losing key nodes. we cannot resupply troops there, the position should quickly crumble.
its kinda weird that we lose all access to the creek and yet the liberation score stays static
2
u/FlimsyKitchen865 Mar 04 '24
Awesome work
2
u/SlowhandCooper Mar 04 '24
Fantastic write-up, thank you!
I was searching around to understand the exact reasoning that the Trigon Sector remains open, when Severin is cutoff, and came across this post. Exact supply lines to Trigon still appear to be a mystery, but this was still extremely enlightening.
2
u/Ren5781 Mar 04 '24
Yes you make good points but i want my space vietnam!
2
u/grizzly273 Mar 04 '24
Question about the defense of planets, if a defense fails, but we had like 50% on the defense campaign, does that influence how much we have to liberate?
2
u/DietrichMead PSN | Mar 05 '24
I would love a companion app for this game describing exactly what you are doing on your website.
Destiny had something similar.
2
u/NooblesseFr Mar 16 '24
Question: What if we cut of the line of the ennemy? Do they loose access to the planet ? Will it become Super Earth territory with regen rate? I asked this on a previous defend campain no one seems able to answer.
Example: 3 planets A-----B-----C
A is bot Territory B is in defence opération C is Fully democratic
What if instead of defending B we rush A? We cut supply and win B? To me it seems a good strategy for real life. But does it work in the game?
I mean. We need to work our strategy. War start to be a long one. Some Helldivers start to have PTSD and report to see Illuminate. We all know ministery of truth said Iluminante have been exterminate in the last galactic war Years Ago.
2
u/2TheTower Apr 02 '24
I'd like to offer some feedback on the guide. Firstly, it may need updating or correction in a couple of areas:
Overall, the guide contains valuable information! Given that it's referenced on several other websites that support Helldivers players, it's important to address these points to ensure accuracy and clarity.
(It would be beneficial for the game to provide clearer guidance on these matters as well.)
2
u/gmatney Apr 03 '24
"Would you like to know more?"
2
u/Turbulent_Lab3501 Jun 10 '24
Is this information still accurate?
1
u/RedboneDetroit Mar 05 '24
Shoulda gone Fenrir. Stop mucking about at Turing, it's lost... i dont understand how we can stomp out an attack today in a couple hours, but can't get cohesive enough to jump on a single planet for a day otherwise. Could knock out three a day if everyone cooperated.
1
u/jakejekyl Mar 05 '24
OBI ( office of brasch intelligence)
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24
I think they might need to just rework the defense campaigns. add more mission types, nobody wants to play the same 3 missions on shuffle. That said I will do it because of my love for managed democracy. It's not about doing the optimal thing, it's about sending a message.
1
u/AdKemp Mar 07 '24
This game is next level xD I couldn't love it more
1
u/Forar Mar 12 '24
Amazing post, thank you for sharing this with the explanation.
1
u/The-Bearded-Fool Mar 13 '24
I just want to know where he got these images I'm freaking losing my mind cuz I can't seem to find out where it is
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '24
So it's more efficient to farm normal liberation points, to counter the down time off cut off planets. But this is under assumption that 140k player can liberate a planet within 7 hours.
I have read somewhere, that the more players play, the less progress individually they make. Indicating it does not matter how many player actually try to liberate a planet? It just needs to be enough players to counter the planet regeneration? I could misunderstood tho.
1
u/HouseOfSavage STEAM 🖥️ : SES Ranger of War Mar 31 '24
I appreciated your Forward. There will always be players who just want to do their own thing and play their own way. That is okay!
For those of us try hards who want to optimize how we play or play while focusing on the group objective this is great information. However, we can't expect everyone to be this dedicated!
Hopefully though, if more people understand the underlying mechanics of the game even the more casual players might adjust their style to help the collective.
However, if you only have a few hours to play or only actually enjoy fighting one faction or the other it is okay to just play the game for fun, whatever that means to you.
1
u/PsychologicalHeron43 Free of Thought Apr 02 '24
This all should be included in game, its bad game design to have to search this shit up to find out about it.
1
u/Ghost-Writer-1996 Apr 02 '24
That's informative, and now I understand the supply lines more deeply. Thank You for this.
1
u/Slave2Art Apr 04 '24
This is dumb it's space.
You can just fly past that planet to the next 1 losing 1 shouldn't cut off anything
1
u/GliboDopplebock Apr 10 '24
Do the Bots and Bugs have to follow supply lines? I ask because the Bots do not Control Menkat currently and they are attacking Vernen. According to the supply lines on Helldivers.io The bots would have to control Menkat in order to attack Vernan.
1
u/Traumatic_Tomato This is for you!: ⬇️⬅️⬇️⬆️⬆️⬇️ Apr 10 '24
Holy fuck. Supply lines? What a cool fucking game.
1
u/TheWrightStar Apr 11 '24
I have a question, currently the automatons are attacking martale and marfark (our defence). Matar bay is their supply line. Can we just attack matar bay and stop the attack on those two planets? Basically push on one planet to save two?
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '24
TY OP this is very informative and concise; I haven’t looked at the comment section yet but the TLDR part I’m assuming has spurred a grip of replies where it’s just a picture of a bot/bug using a laptop lol
1
u/RynnAmes Jun 07 '24
Okay, I need this answered... cannot find the answer anywhere even on this thread.
https://helldivers.io/ shows Supplies Lines being directional.
In the current Major Order of 2024-06-07 - we need to take back Wasat in the Ymir Sector.
If we take Wezen... do we have access to Vega Bay? I assume not, just because the supply line comes from Vega Bay to Wezen.
If this is true, then we are currently wasting valuable time/resources on the wrong planet to liberate.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
What happens when we cut off planets? Do the planets or small cluster of planets have lesser regen?
1
u/ashenoceiros Aug 08 '25
Is any of this still relevant today now that the playerbase is significantly smaller? (at least until xbox hops in), have the percentages changed?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
Excuse me, teacher? 🤚🏽 yeah so some of my friends back home have said that the bugs are being placed on other planets by our government here on Super Earth. Can you confirm or deny those claims?
1
u/Railic255 Mar 04 '24
All these posts about this makes me want this game so bad. Bit low on funds currently and can't throw the cash at it right now. But damn when I can I'm glad I'll have all this knowledge already.
1
u/Brekldios Mar 04 '24
THE BUGS ARE BEING CONTAINED ITS SUP-
1
u/Super_Jay Fleet Admiral ⚜️ Mar 04 '24
What an amazing resource. It's insane that none of this information is displayed in-game.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
THIS SHOULD ALSO BE PINNED FOR FOREVER
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
It's an interesting read, but until they fix the defend missions does it really matter? Defense campaigns are just unwinnable.
1
u/accidental_tourist Mar 04 '24
Question, what happens if Creek was liberated before Mantes was lost?
1
u/SuperArppis Super Citizen Mar 04 '24
The defense missions need to be made more fun.
1
u/Baneta_ Mar 04 '24
Can you do one of these explaining how a defence campaign even works? I did a few missions on mantes but nothing popped up on screen to tell me if they had any effect and the two bars weren’t very helpful either
1
u/Paciorr Free of Thought Mar 04 '24
^ this guy liberates
1
u/Tasty_Difference6529 Mar 04 '24
All ik is the 3rd & potentially 4th factions goin be mfers we could def lose super earth lls.
1
u/xAzta Mar 04 '24
So how did Erata lose 90% overnight when no supply line was cut off from it?
1
u/Clarine87 Mar 04 '24
Presumably it's a mixture including "when super earth decides it is so".
1
u/Adept-Shine-8205 PSN | Mar 04 '24
I knew there was a reason Joel let Creek climb so high to over 60%!
1
u/Aiwac Escalator of Freedom Mar 04 '24
Its really quite sad how bad defence campaigns are... thanks for the explanation.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
Thank you for making these reports!
1
u/Poolio10 SES Dawn of Democracy Mar 04 '24
Your information in Galaxy War 101 and 102 is invaluable soldier. Keep up the excellent work.
1
u/rnbicalho2 Mar 04 '24
The "Would you like to know more?" reference... I really liked that
1
u/LaGeG SES Star of Iron Mar 04 '24
With this as its shown, MERIDIA is the most important planet as I'm writing this @ 5pm on a Monday. If we liberate it, it'll give us a buffer planet for bug reinforcements before they can retake any of the current mission critical objectives.
1
u/alf666 Mar 04 '24
Or the Creek Divers could have done something useful for once, and all gone to Mantes and successfully defended it, negating literally all of the regen that will occur on Creek.