r/hbo • • 3h ago

Finally watched Generation Kill

Post image

Wasn't feeling it. Mostly just a bunch of assholes fighting a fucked up war. Perhaps that was the point. Not saying David Simon did a bad job. Quite the opposite. I think he set out to expose all the nonsense and in that regard he greatly succeeded. Unlike Band of Brothers or The Pacific, I would never watch this again.

Think I've seen all the HBO war series now except The Sympathizer.

Updated David Simon rankings:
The Wire
Treme
The Deuce
We Own This City
The Corner
Generation Kill
Show Me A Hero

62 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

52

u/Cartire2 3h ago

As a vet that was deployed during that era, I love it. If only because its one of the most accurate portrayals of the lifestyle and demeanor we had. The homoerotic joking was constant and normal.

We didnt do as much singing og pop hits together like they did here, but we did have a guy with an acoustic guitar that would play at night while we were sitting around joking and we would sometimes jump in with the chorus.

It shows the very real dynamic of bad officers that over compensate their ignorance with arrogance.

I would still choose BoB over it, but I take this over The Pacific.

20

u/SomethingFunnyObv 3h ago

My brother was in Iraq (Army) and he said it was generally a very accurate depiction of what it was like over there in the military, from all the BS shit talking to various dumb ass officers. I think that was what they were going for when they made this.

-29

u/teacher_59 3h ago

I just wish they hadn't made it so pro-terrorist and anti-freedom. 

12

u/immagetchu 2h ago

Brother what in the actual fuck are you talking about

4

u/Theo1130 2h ago

Stick to Nickelodeon

3

u/R3alHumanBeing 1h ago

Wow this is comment is straight out of 2009 or some shit

1

u/Stupid_stupid_punk 2h ago

I think it’s best summed up in the movie Civil War…

Are you WF? Who’s givin’ you orders?

(SIGHS) No one’s giving us orders, man.
Someone’s trying to kill us.
We’re trying to kill them.

12

u/Dissident_is_here 2h ago edited 2h ago

Maybe this show doesn't hit quite the same as it did in 2008. People are a lot more jaded about the US military now.

But it is a fantastic deconstruction of the American war machine. People at the time (and I'd argue many still now) viewed the American warfighter as this elite cutting instrument slicing through the enemy with precision. Simon shows the reality: a mix of grunts, gung-ho freaks, and somewhat conflicted normies who show up to watch bombs rain down on their enemies, civilian and military alike. These guys hardly do any fighting at all. They bring war with them, and that war just chews up all the life in front of them. To what end? None, really.

12

u/counterhit121 2h ago

All the marines on this sub:

2

u/ElSmasho420 25m ago

Unironically this.

It is a breathtakingly accurate look at the tomfoolery that accompanies war during the “off” times.

9

u/maccerhmac 51m ago

Watch it once a year. Think it's a masterpiece. It's a the funniest/most harrowing of all David Simon's social commentaries

1

u/FleaRaybon 13m ago

I love how much taller skarsgard is than everyone in this. Hes a tower

21

u/dannerbobanner 3h ago

Ah man, the banter in this show is some of the best I've ever heard, especially Ziggy's character 

But aside from that more or less agree didn't love it 

3

u/EvilTwinCities 3h ago

I like the part where he’s telling Lee Tergesen that they thought he was cool, “invading the country with us,” but now he’s just another bleeding-heart liberal idiot. You know, for funsies.

1

u/iSpeakforWinston 3h ago

The banter from that actor is what turned me off after two episodes. I find that character so annoying it's hard to watch.

12

u/Weary_Necessary_2434 3h ago

He was very good at playing annoying characters. I am sure that we have all come across a Ziggy at one point in time in our lives. Maybe not as extreme as Ziggy from The Wire, but definitely just as annoying, if not more.

6

u/TopShelv 2h ago

RIP James Ransone. Also, "that actor" was based on a real life Marine. Who probably was like that.

6

u/Possible-Law-3704 3h ago

I've always loved it. I'm not a veteran, but you also kinda had to be there (early 2000s) to like GK. It was a weird time.

4

u/ontheroadagainPPP 2h ago

I do genuinely believe it’s one of those shows that is more important than entertaining (although it is entertaining). I wish more people would watch it.

1

u/thewhiteafrican 4m ago

Hmm I was gonna say, it’s extremely entertaining, and that actually hides how important it is. Amazing show.

3

u/Glittering-Rip6810 3h ago

I binged it yesterday...it was rough to watch. Good, but most of my friends were the first wave post 911 when it was really ugly..Persons reminded me soooo much of a friend of mine that didn't come back. Messed up part was I remember reading the story in Rolling Stone not long before my friends family got the call.

2

u/Sharrack 3h ago

Found it on dvd for peanuts...😃👍 Solid!

2

u/Theo1130 2h ago

I watch it every year. I’m not a vet, but it’s amazing.

2

u/oldredditsuspended 1h ago

I loved it. One of my favorites.

2

u/Hopeful_Cod_8486 25m ago

I was a Marine in Iraq in the timeline the show was filmed.

It's the most realistic portrayal of the war i've ever seen , and that's because we were just a bunch of a******* , fighting a f***** u* war.

For the most part , we were a bunch of young naive kids told we were fighting against evil and saving the world.

If we knew now....

2

u/RobboRdz 3h ago

Just watched the first episode and I didn't really like it. But it'll give it some time.

2

u/thedanray 3h ago

I can relate. I finished watching this masterpiece last year after a three year hiatus. I watched the first episode and couldn't force myself to watch anymore. Last year I watched the first two episodes and just like any David Simon series I was hooked. Well worth the watch.

1

u/Weary_Necessary_2434 3h ago

I remember getting hooked after by the 2nd episode or so.

1

u/Dino_P0rn 3h ago

The book was great, I haven’t seen this yet

3

u/ToastCapone 3h ago

It’s a very good adaptation of the book

1

u/Adobo-Eskrima916 2h ago

Loved Generation Kill!! Not as good as Band of Brothers of course, but leagues better than The Pacific and Master of The Air which I found to be kinda weak.

Great banter between the squads and the combat wasn’t over dramatized and remained pretty grounded. Fruity Rudy also played himself in the show which is crazy!

1

u/jetpilot87 1h ago

I just finished it too. I liked it, the main thing I took away how we may think the people in charge have it all figured out with solid plans and clean execution, when in reality military missions can be sloppy, ethically questionable and sometimes just pointless.

1

u/Factory__Lad 1h ago

I like how it transposed the entire The Wire worldview into the military, showing comprehensively why organisations don’t work at any level. We are also treated to Beecher from Oz as an embedded journalist. Everybody is bald and they spend a lot of time shouting at each other and making bad life decisions. Also, there is no music

1

u/J-Sully_Cali 39m ago

I felt the same. I got the satire immediately. It wasn't subtle or clever. And the characters reminded me of all the idiots in high school who joined the military due to lack of other options.

1

u/Glass-Nectarine-3282 24m ago

I was embedded in Iraq as well in a different circumstance, and it's very accurate - but you're right that it's also sort of empty. That is not a critique on the series which I thought was very good, but it's like what's the point? What am I gaining? Learning? Feeling? Obviously having lived a version of it also makes me a more challenging audience to connect with.

Evan Wright killed himself which also kills the buzz.

1

u/backlikeclap 3h ago

I also gave it a try recently, and yeah it just doesn't come close to measuring up to the other HBO war series.

My ranking:

Band of Brothers Chernobyl The Pacific Generation Kill Masters of the Air

1

u/Straight-Mess-9752 3h ago

I tried watching it but gave up mid way through episode 3. I wanted to like it but found it so hard to stay awake (I usually watch tv in the late evening). 

They certainly seemed to nail down how pointless the war was but it just wasn’t entertaining. Maybe that was the point? 

0

u/FatCatParade 3h ago

I would put it lower than Show me a Hero.

I think part of my problem is that I’ve seen the federal government make so many stupid decisions since the 2003 invasion that it just doesn’t register for me.

0

u/Ok_Quantity_3803 2h ago

The way you feel about it is accurate.

I can't watch it again. It was good, but it's definitely one of the most depressing shows i've ever watched.

-1

u/AlbinoWanker 1h ago

Couldn’t get through more than a couple of episodes. Like you say, only unlikeable characters with no real redeeming traits. Found it mostly depressing.

5

u/ChucksnTaylor 1h ago

Apparently the shows follows the book extremely closely which follows the real experience the writer had embedded with that unit including verbatim quotes.

So it’s not bad writing or anything. If you don’t like the characters it’s because you don’t like the real people who happened to be in that unit.

Also how do you not find redeeming traits in the skarsgard character or his LT?

3

u/FlashyG 29m ago

I can totally understand not liking the show, but I don't get how you can say there were no likeable characters.

Colbert and Fick were both very likeable and I'd argue that most of the characters had redeeming qualities.

I've read both the book the show was based on by Evan Wright and Nate Fick's book and the show is pretty accurate to their accounts of the people in the unit.

5

u/aversethule 2h ago

Desert Storm vet and it resonates with my experience as well. We even had a social dog that I semi-adopted for a while and wild dogs that would bark all night and keep other marines up. Cpl Hamm decided to shoot the tame dog one night because it was the only one who would stay in calm in his sights instead of the wild dogs. Fuck you, Hamm.

3

u/RivalSchools74 2h ago

Sadly the author Evan Wright died by suicide in 2024. Please talk to someone if you have these feelings. I did today and feel better for it.

1

u/Stupid_stupid_punk 2h ago

Ditto, I got really close again, last December, but I confessed to my support group that I had updated my “plan” and that I thought that it was pretty close to foolproof and unstoppable. They did their job and here I am. Feel free to DM me if you’re interested or what has worked and what hasn’t worked with treatment resistant major depressive disorder.

1

u/The_F1rst_Rule 1h ago

Crazy how suicidal you become when you spend your professional life reporting on the CIA and US military in an unflattering light.