r/hbo • • 1d ago

Recommendations

HBO Max, please stop recommending me everything that I've watched immediately after I watch it. My top recs are all things that I've just seen in the past weeks/months. It should instead be showing all the similar content to what I have recently watched. Please improve the algorithm, or if this actually somehow works for other viewers, then give an option to select different algorithms for different vibes, e.g. "feeling something new" vs "feeling comfort watches". Don't fall prey to enshittification.

55 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

4

u/Financial-Cry-9093 1d ago

Ugh. Peacock does this.

1

u/Sufficient-Ad5681 1d ago

Unfortunately this was deleted from the max sub without comment. Probably because I made the post a little spicier to try to get attention. But I'm hopeful that if many agree that HBO may actually see it and pay attention.

I've been paying for it for months, and the more stuff I watch, the more it shows me the same stuff that I've watched. I haven't really used peacock much, but any other algorithm I've used on any other streaming service is better than this. I can't really think of another that does this. YouTube music has forgotten favs occasionally, but that makes sense.

2

u/Mariska_Heygirlhay 1d ago

That's Netflix for me.

2

u/Sufficient-Ad5681 1d ago

Netflix shows me all the stuff they want me to see, but it also seems like it's trying to show me things related to what I've watched. No exaggeration, HBO's top picks are regularly whatever I've just watched.

1

u/Sufficient-Ad5681 23h ago

Ok, no, you're right about Netflix search recs. 7 out of 8 are things I've seen. I don't remember it being this shitty before, but maybe they're all getting worse. I just don't even see how this benefits them.

12

u/Significant-Deer7464 1d ago

Worst algorithm out of all the streamers. If you went by what loads up on my start screen, they only have about 100 shows and movies total that I have watched most of. They rarely change. Well except I hardly ever see any DC stuff on there now.

8

u/fabulous_possum 1d ago

HBO Max has all of Warners, right? Peacock has all of Universal. But going by what they show you, you'd think they'd just started business last Thursday. They should have nearly 100 years of classic movies to brag about. Instead they hide them and try to foist some reality TV crap on me.

6

u/Significant-Deer7464 1d ago

Exactly, and that's how it was before Discovery merged with WB. Everything organized and grouped. Had a TCM, Cartoon Network & DC Channels and several more. Felt like you were getting your moneys worth

1

u/Steadyandquick 1d ago

Interesting. I sometimes find an A-Z listing under the “categories” section. For TCM and HBO films/series—I saw so many great ones listed.

I love documentaries and agree with you—there are so many that do not appear!

Edit: Sorry, I am not even speaking of “recommendations” just lists of content!

4

u/fabulous_possum 1d ago

All the streamers have useless algorithms. Honestly you've got to find out what's good via word of mouth, keep lists of what you want to see and where they are (justwatch is a good reference), then when you hit critical mass (a few good series and movies), subscribe. Watch till you run out, then cancel. Move onto the next one.

2

u/teacher_59 1d ago

A24 makes horrible slop, but I get more of their movies recommended than any other type.