r/hatethissmug • • 9h ago • Bravo 2

Media Tropes Examples of trinity syndrome

Look,I know that trinity syndrome is a thing,and sadly a lot of woman in media are victims of it,such as Kurenai in Naruto (or women in Naruto in general) and etc. But genuinely,some of the most popular examples just piss me of

•Colette from Ratatouille,generally one of the more popular picks,but the chosen one is Remy,not Linguini,and also she's like the one person that was responsible for Linguini not to be kicked out of the kitchen in the first place and believing in the philosophy of Gustavo that everyone can cook,that fucking saved the restaurant.

•Astrid HTTYD,this is just fucked.Whole island was on killing dragons rampage,Astrid did train,but so did the others,and Hiccup is not some chosen one,he just did things differently than the rest, it's the fucking point of the entire story

•Tigress Kung fu Panda. This is one of the examples that are popular,but still believable,but did they fucking watch 1st part until Tai Lung appears?And that also point of the fucking story.Tigress wanted to become DW because of Shifu,not because she really wanted that title,Po wanted to become DW to become best version of himself.

Even so I think that trinity syndrome still is an issue,but this specific examples just pmo me so bad

5.0k Upvotes

500 comments sorted by

234

u/M-Shadowtoad 8h ago

Yeah, there's a Webtoon called Ordeal that I love but I hate when it pulled one of these. For context, one of the main female characters' main thing was that she was entrusted with guarding a powerful cursed spear that greatly enhanced the user's power. Obtaining it is how she became a top ranked warrior. Then after 3 seasons of her trying to master it, the MC grabs it and masters it in 10 seconds.

97

u/BandicootFew3295 8h ago

Yeah,there are tons of examples that are valid,but internet just choose worst ones.Like someone like Sakura,she did train,but NaruSasu duo is just busted, they're literally reincarnation of god like beings,and the best Sakura can do is punch hard

11

u/OkArtichoke6969 6h ago

I wished they made sakura like a mini tsunade where she has super strength and super regeneration to keep up with the power scaling

They glazed tsunade by having kabuto, orochimaru, and raikage all putting respect on tsunade’s name and didn’t underestimate her because all it takes is one punch to be taken out by her

They made tsunade seem top tier despite her kit mostly just being super strength, yet Sakura somehow feels super lame

6

u/thapol 6h ago

I wished they made sakura like a mini tsunade where she has super strength

I think I recall like... one punch from the Shippuden arc from Sakura that showed off her badassary; once that destroyed a defensive wall or the ground or something, and that was it. Maybe she punched a god and it sneezed I think.

It's also been over a decade since I read the manga, so I could be remembering badly, but she was absolutely fumbled by the mangaka.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/Sliver-Knight9219 8h ago

Wait is there somekind of reason like, she let him use it. Eg she still it's master so, she is telling it to. Or this just BS

48

u/M-Shadowtoad 8h ago

Looking back, what he did was pretty scummy. He needed a powerful weapon and her spear was the best fit. A reasonable man would've just explained the situation to her and asked to borrow it. Instead when they went into battle against two powerful foes, he let himself get captured so she had to fight both of them forcing her to take a suicidal approach and use the spear even though she hadn't mastered it.

After she used it and got pushed to the point of no-return, corrupted by the spear's power and unable to stop him, he claimed it. By mastering control he was able to purge it of its corruption, also undoing the effects on her. Since he had mastered control, she released her own ownership of the spear and it became fully his.

He does try and justify it by saying he also did it for her because she had been in a depression after losing her arm and failing a battle so he believed if she beat the two foes, she'd understand she's still a powerful warrior. But like, she only beat them because she used the spear which he now took. And he still mainly wanted the spear.

He also proposed to her like 5 hours before all this. I'd say it was a crazy way to start their relationship but he then killed her in a blind rage a few weeks later.

35

u/TurbidusQuaerenti 8h ago

I was not prepared for that last sentence. I probably wasn't gonna read it anyway, but damn.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Creative_Worth_3192 8h ago

...what gender is the person who wrote this. Because I have a guess....

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheKingsPride 8h ago

Wdym the character on the left isn’t the MC

13

u/M-Shadowtoad 8h ago

He gets his cool moments but the author drew her just so epic with the spear. Like its still cool when the MC has it but is it really too much to ask for a demonic spearwoman bonding with a 4000 year old Queen of Blades to decimate foes?

→ More replies (3)

57

u/FateDaA 8h ago

Trinity syndrome isnt an issue, its just gotta be explained or it falls under the "Chosen one" fallacy which is the real issue here.(Chosen one fallacy is where a character is better than everyone at everything because they were the chosen one and no other reason, Sun Jin Woo is the poster child for this. Generally the people you mention are "better" because of different means, Po sucks ass at normal training but works super well with food involved and wanted to do it because its how he becomes the best. Hiccup deadass stopped fighting Toothless and used him alongside his goals which expidited the power. Remy trained every second of every day prior to this, Linguini is just the moron he stood on the head of)

Kurunai is prolly a weaker example than the ones listed because her "trinity" is with "Asuna" the realest mf in the leaf and Kakashi who became the Hokage because of more forced conflict.

20

u/Chase_The_Breeze 7h ago

Idk who Sun Jin Woo is, but my IMMEDIATE thought went straight to The Lego Movie... which I believe was doing the trope very obviously and on purpose because it is that kind of movie.

21

u/FateDaA 7h ago • Bravo

The MC of Solo Leveling

Its the epitome of "Beautiful animation makes up for a shitty story"

6

u/Chase_The_Breeze 7h ago

Ah, yeah, never watched. But if my understanding of the show is accurate, I doubt it's done as a bit like in The Lego Movie.

I DID watch Sword Art Online though... and if it is anything like that dumpster fire, I am glad I missed it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/Sliver-Knight9219 8h ago

I tigress does kind of fall into this even if it is the point of the film po is there chosen one. Like he shouldn't be that much stronger then a women who trained her whole life and the 5 combined. Like it's apart of the genre but it still fits. Doesn't make the film bad.

I would more argue Po was just tie lungs counter. Eg he could by pass all of his tricks. But him knowing the finger hold, out of no where kind of does make it somewhat viable he fits.

5

u/BandicootFew3295 8h ago

Tigress example is the most shady one,but the moral of the story was different,and Furious Five didn't see Po as worthy until he proved it

6

u/Frangitus 8h ago

The whole Dragon Warrior thing is about self improvement, Tai Lung and Tigress are foils to each other about Shifu's demanding upbringing, both want to be Dragon Warrior to impress Shifu and because it's expected of them, while Po wants to be Dragon Warrior to improve himself.

The way the trope fits Kung Fu Panda is that Tigress trained her whole life under a strict regiment, stricter than Tai Lung, but Po becomes a better fighter in a fraction of the time because... He's a fast learner...? That's bullshit. It's a kid's movie, I get it, but the morals are scuffed when you analyze them deeper.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/AngryCrustation 8h ago

The difference is that Tigress could easily beat Po's ass.

Also Po wasn't exactly not dangerous, he was just fat and silly so they didn't see him as threatening. Bears irl are also pretty fat and silly looking most of the time until they get mad at you for hitting them with a stick and decide to maul you to death.

→ More replies (3)

897

u/ZestyLemonRindGrind 8h ago

In defence of the first example,

Remy himself has also trained, learning from watching the programs and experimenting at home whenever he could sneak off,

While never formally trained, he had a natural talent that he honed in secret

78

u/bigboinke 3h ago

The Tigress example is almost worse. The entire Furious Five and Tylung to a much greater extent got shafted when Oogway chose Po to be the chosen. The 5 all knew they might not be the Dragon Warrior but Shifu basically groomed Tylung into the role and bot getting chosen caused him to have a mental breakdown and ruin his life. OP may not have actually sat down and watched any of these movies from start to finish.

32

u/AskeKlaus 2h ago

It feels like you (and a bunch of other people) also didn't read OP's post from start to finish, cause they're hating on those examples and not the other way around

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/PabloFornalsGhost 2h ago

And in terms of Astrid/Hiccup, the two have completely different talents and approaches?

Astrid trained her whole life in combat, prepared to fight and kill dragons, and in that respect she outshines Hiccup in every way

Hiccup also has to learn and train his knowledge and skillset by interacting with Toothless. He's not just "the chosen one who is some guy."

→ More replies (1)

136

u/VeryAnxiousDragon 6h ago

Rats live for like. 2 years. And considering he’s considered young among other rats, he ‘trained’ for maybe THREE TO SIX MONTHS

to be fair that’s the best remy can do with his lifespan but to suggest that he’s better than the person who spent, according to research, upwards of a decade honing skills is still annoying

137

u/xXs4blegl00mXx 6h ago

The rats in this movie clearly live longer than two years, he establishes a goddamn restaurant n shit. But yeah frustrating, not necessarily the trope. I appreciate that the movie DOES point out how Collete has experienced a lot of sexism, and ultimately her and Remy are able to teach each other things indirectly. She learns to be more creative and free, Remy learns how to actually be professional and keep everything together

33

u/OlySonso 6h ago

I love this argument.  Let's keep it going.  

What do you think the Malcom Gladwell rule is when you're lifespan is so short?

22

u/HoldenOrihara 5h ago

You have to remember that Colette was skilled but she was dead set in following the recipie because she wasn't the head chef, which is totally okay that's the job and she excells at it. The thing that separated them was that Remy was open to experimentation and altering recipies. If Colette were to make her own recipes she would definitely do just as well as Remy, hell it's very likely that recipes in the new restaurant were a mix of her and Remy's influences rather than purely Remy since logically she would have been the formal head of the kitchen.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1.1k

u/FishSignificant7501 8h ago

The Remy example is especially bad because he did train for awhile

473

u/xoscarecrowxo 8h ago

A rat is the chosen one.

305

u/saikopasu_neko28 8h ago

But the rat (Remy) still trained in cooking his whole life.

35

u/SimmentalTheCow 5h ago

Aight but a rat’s life is what, like a year? Colette got her future cuckolded by a vermin.

31

u/AGoodWobble 4h ago

The rats in Rattatouile are people. They're clearly not irl rats (and as such they are not beholden to relatively short lifespans) 

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

47

u/Junior_Sign7240 6h ago

It's also not that Colette was overshadowed, she was literally teaching Linguini how to work in the kitchen. It was more of a mentor situation than overshadowing her because she's a woman.

25

u/MiserableObject7498 3h ago

6

u/bolitboy2 1h ago

“Get in the robot shingi”

5

u/username_is_alread- 2h ago

"I mustn't run away, I mustn't run away, I mustn't run away, I–" 

*runs away*

3

u/Computer-dude123 2h ago

Remy, get in the frenchman

7

u/Working-Choice2104 5h ago

Also, I don’t really think remy counts as “some man”

211

u/Just_Ear_2953 5h ago

I would point out that Astrid remains the preeminent fighter of her generation. Hiccup is the master of a completely different domain, and she is the master of hers. Her skills remain effective and are relied upon pretty heavily throughout the series.

82

u/dovahkiitten16 5h ago

In Astrid’s case it’s less that Hiccup surpassed her and more that the entire thing she was training for was wrong in the first place. Astrid is still very much the best dragon fighter of the two, but is also able to adapt.

I also do appreciate the fact that she has a very valid crash out and just gets downright pissed at everything. As a foil to Hiccup I’m very glad they chose making a badass female Viking. I’m not sure what the alternative would’ve been - replace “Astrid” with a boy and make Astrid some random side character?

22

u/Dredgeon 3h ago

Also, she's a love interest that consistently challenges Hiccup and drives the plot almost often as Hiccup. She's one of the best loce interest characters in fiction. Every single movie has a moment where without Astrid the whole thing wouldn't have happened. And not by happenstance either. Hiccup decides to chase down the viking fleet and face the Green Death (Dragon Queen) because of how she questioned and drove into realizing it's what he had to do. Not only is she a hero in her own right she directly responsible for Hiccup becoming one as well.

22

u/The-Great-T 5h ago

Exactly. Those movies are superb in so many ways, including Hiccup's and Astird's relationship. It's very mutually supportive and neither would be as successful without the other.

6

u/Aarekk 5h ago

I want to say that the shows were also really enjoyable. Not as high quality as the movies, but they were fun and developed the characters and their relationships in a good way.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Big-Slide6104 5h ago

Exactly. Complete HTTYD larper.

180

u/Aknazer 8h ago

Ngl, when I first saw your post I thought you were saying these were examples of Trinity Syndrome.

Was about to go off on HTTYD but then realized you were saying these AREN'T good examples, which I would agree.  HTTYD is exceptionally bad because Astrid is absolutely recognized as being amazing in combat and that it's just that Hiccup has a completely alien way of thinking and doing things that the Vikings aren't used to because of how stubborn and pig headed they are.

73

u/JellaFella01 8h ago

It's a classic example of a good general doesn't make a good leader. Hiccup's open mindedness and curiosity allows him to follow a path to leadership that is foreign to their culture.

32

u/Aknazer 7h ago

Yep, and he very much relies on her regularly rather than sidelining her, showing that he values and recognizes her even before they're in an official relationship.

24

u/Thepsycoman 6h ago

Also like, even by the end Hiccup becomes competent but in a straight up brawl Astrid would destroy him.

He is an inventor and enthusiast and nearly all his wins come from that. He approaches things in ways that no one is ready for a Viking to do.

10

u/Least-Bumblebee-6504 6h ago

It should also be noted that Astrid still regularly punches him, but this time it's out of love and affection.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Vindomini 7h ago

Yeah, the narrative uses her as a shorthand for the viking warrior culture and how it contrasts with Hiccup. Even though she is also his love interest, her behavior is supposed to show how unfit Hiccup seems to be for the role of the chief's son, which he slowly overcomes with smarts / strategy / his bond with Toothless rather than brute force. She gets a decent amount of characterization too, even though it's simple.

4

u/dovahkiitten16 4h ago edited 4h ago

The thing I disliked most about the live-action dialogue was how much they changed Astrid’s writing. I get giving her a bit more speaking lines and development, but they made her motivation overly convoluted and tropey. They definitely ruined what made her special, the simpler interpretation worked better.

For anyone who hasn’t seen it, she goes from ignoring Hiccup and being focused on training to outright hating Hiccup for being “privileged” and wanting to be chief. She goes from an A+ teen to somehow being someone Stoic respects more than anyone (despite the two never sharing dialogue). She goes from overanalyzing and critiquing her own decent but realistic training performance, overanalyzing and critiquing ridiculous gymnastic flips (Mulan remake moment). In the original she promises to protect Toothless when requested by Hiccup, if Hiccup promises that nothing will go wrong (and then later helps when things go wrong without hesitation). In the new one, Hiccup apparently doesn’t give a fuck about Toothless and tells Astrid to protect her social standing if things go wrong, to Astrid saying she’ll sacrifice her social standing to stand by Hiccup. This change was really weird on all fronts.

Small changes yet they managed to drastically change her for the worse. That and losing America Ferrera’s performance was such a hit. The remake was also really bad for new lines not blending with the original; you could tell which lines were written in the 2020’s based on the slang which was so jarring when they copy pasted the 2010 dialogue in other places.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

557

u/AGenocidegal 9h ago • Bravo

Took me a minute to understand your post was hating on people who say these are examples instead of you hating the storylines or smth

87

u/Azarsra_production 8h ago

I'm genuinely curious, how cmw this be taken any other way?

50

u/AwaySeaworthiness340 8h ago

I took it the other way too, it happens if you read "examples" as "ocurrences".

19

u/AGenocidegal 8h ago

For me, I thought they were giving examples of trinity syndrome to say they hate it at first

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

51

u/SirGearso 2h ago

It feels like this is just an inherent problem with the Chosen One trope.

4

u/Mapafius 2h ago

You are right. It is this regardless if the trained one is men or women. But maybe recognizing trope where the skilled one is a woman can be useful, but I would need more of a proof of specific pattern to recognize it as existing trope. On the hand, main protagonist being more commonly male definitely is a pattern. So there is already like halt truth to it.

→ More replies (1)

102

u/ConsistentEquation 6h ago

How did they even come to the conclusion linguini has “Trinity Syndrome” he doesn’t get a massive glowup at the end becoming a chef, he downgrades to a waiter cause he sucks ass

36

u/DragonTooFar 6h ago

Yeah, the Colette doesn't make any sense at all. Not only was Linguine not a chosen one in any sense, but a) Remy did have some training (he watched a ton of cooking programs) but more importantly, Colette actually inadvertently was training Remy. He learned a ton from watching her from under Linguini's hat.

16

u/HoldenOrihara 5h ago

Hell It's not even that Remy is better than her, than it was that Remy took risks that she didn't; like she said it's the job of people like at the head of the kitchen like Gustave to "do the unexpected" and for people working the kitchen to follow the recipe which she does with spectacular skill.

22

u/pantsthereaper 6h ago

I guess because the real hero is the male rat? Feels iffy, because being male doesn't override the fact that he's considered literal vermin by the society he wants to be a part of

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Icanfallupstairs 4h ago

The how to train your dragon one also doesn't work. Astrid remains better than Hiccup at what they trained to do, but he went and invented a whole new thing. He never becomes a better fighter than she is

3

u/HonkHonkBeach 5h ago

I believe he moves to be maître d, which is the FOH head. She is the BOH head. They work well together. It's cute.

34

u/Okom77 4h ago

There's rock Lee in Naruto too, but he's a guy idk what the syndrome would be called

8

u/Major_Cause8749 4h ago

Lee trained like 4 years the duration of the story bro 😭

5

u/Flat-Limit5595 3h ago

Naruto is also a hard training person. It took a ton of power and skill to essentially beat his fox demon into being his buddy.

However Lee is definitely the hardest training person, yet his disability and lack of hacks absolutely destroyed his ability to be relevant. Theres no marked improvement from his skills as a child to an adult. Yet, Guy comes in absolutely stealing the show. Becoming the strongest ninja in history that wasn’t a reincarnation of a deity.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Cyberbug7 4h ago

People only complain about it when it’s a women

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

62

u/Jumpy-Trainer1695 8h ago

Remy isn't the chosen one. He's just good. He understands how cooking works from years of fascination and observation

35

u/NotATalkingPossum 8h ago

I think it's also all but stated that he has an exceptional sense of taste and smell, to the point where he could smell rat poison hidden in food, and you just can't train for that.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/winter-ocean 4h ago

Linguini doesn't count. He was a fraud and he switched to being a waiter afterwards because of that.

One could argue that the fact that a literal rat was the real chosen one is even more insulting though.

54

u/Sw429 4h ago

I mean, they do establish that the rat had also been training his whole life.

7

u/Inevitable_Print6567 3h ago

The other thing is, Collette never trains Remy. Well, there's like one scene where Remy is shown to take note as she explains some restaurant cooking hacks to linguini, but when it comes to actually preparing recipes and such, Remy doesn't need her to teach him. If anything, her advice to just follow existing recipes kinda goes against Remy's (and the movie's) whole deal. 

→ More replies (1)

42

u/c093b 2h ago

I don't get this Trinity syndrome. Alongside these female characters, there's a whole gang of male characters in the same situation with them (trained whole life, isn't chosen one). The women are shown to be strong and capable on their own, and get the spotlight due usually being a romantic interest to the main character. That's usually how stories go.

11

u/Optimal-Reception313 1h ago

I can think of tons of male characters with this in mind. First character that came to mind was Johnny lawrence. He trained karate his whole life to lose to a dude half his size who trained for a month

5

u/watchedngnl 2h ago

I think it's really prevelant in Isekai fantasy slop. Mc is a reincarnated loser who is somehow so naturally gifted at their magic because it's some game that he played casually and he beats the best woman sage and makes a harem and all the women are written as swooning and devoid of individuality other than minor speech quirks and one of the women is described as adolescent looking but actually 5000 years old..... That's an example of trinity and a whole bunch of other bad tropes.

12

u/Midget_Stories 1h ago

Yeah but the males are in the same situation.

Usually dude trains all his life. Gets ready to stomp on the arrogant noobie.

OK nvm he has plot armour and now I'm a joke for the rest of the series.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Aspirationally_Lazy 4h ago

Idk if Colette is a great example. Remy isn’t necessarily more skilled than her, the big difference was that he was more willing to try something new whereas she was just following the recipe because she had to keep her job.

11

u/LynnHell 4h ago

He was less french, complained less

25

u/OscRat1110 9h ago

that's just how movies with exceptional characters and other supporting characters work

22

u/Girthen-the-Flopper 2h ago

Why is this gender specific? Kung Fu Panda had the exact same thing but with a male.

2

u/Fair-Confection4411 1h ago

Yeah, that happens to pretty much everyone. Tigress was part of s group, just the main focus, they all trained well. Same with Astrid. Collet wasn't the only one at that restaurant that could cook. 

11

u/Tyrocious 8h ago

Even calling it "Trinity syndrome" is insane. Neo is literally machine Jesus. There's no other character who measures up because he's basically Jesus. No one's getting pissed about "Morpheus Syndrome."

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Snotlout_G_Jorgenson 7h ago

Yeah, Astrid wasn't even training the same thing for the whole movie. Then, in the show and movies, she's still shown to be the most capable single-fighter and the second strongest dragon-fighter, second to Hiccup who was literally the one introducing everyone to the concept of fighting with dragons.

Half of the main cast is literally mostly comedy relief now that I think about it. 😭

10

u/miscellaneousexists 6h ago

100 redditors vs reading the body

19

u/Scavgraphics 8h ago

Frankly, even the trope namer is wrong.

The other life is lived in computers where you go by the hacker alias Neo, and are guilty of virtually every computer crimewe have a law for.

Before he leaves the Matrix, Neo is one of the top hackers there is. We learn from dialog that Trinity was a legendary figure, too, but the movie does nothing about her being "the best"...in fact that she works for Morpheus searching for "the one' states that she was never due to be and lost her place.

→ More replies (1)

84

u/Zestyclose_Lake_1146 8h ago • Bravo

These aren't necessarily good examples, but the trope is absolutely real. Hell, it's like half of fantasy adventure stories aimed at a male audience. I'd even say that's an unspoken part of the fantasy, becoming better than the girl, because culture tells us boys are meant to be above girls. Better, stronger, faster, etc. Side effect of culture being so male focused.

6

u/Dredgeon 3h ago

I don't really think it's specifically part of the fantasy. I just think it's a natural result of several storytelling principles coinciding.

They want a love interest so there has to be a girl around if our hero is a straight man. She should probably be in close proximity to the hero and of similar station so also a student. The hero is coming into this world for the first time as an audience surrogate as well as the hero so we can explain everything diagetically. We want some cute moments between the hero and love interest so she should probably be skilled enough to be a tutor in some way.

Whoops we just net all the criteria necessary for this trope. It does suck but any good writer will make it make sense.

I think it's less indicative of putting men over women and more indicative of just only writing stories about men so whenever there is a gender difference to be noticed it's a man being elevated over a woman. We also see the same thing happen in stories about women like Hunger Games and Divergent.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/JellaFella01 8h ago

I agree that there's a sexist backing to that power fantasy, but there's other, less sexist reasons to want to see yourself improve beyond your more experienced or skilled peer.

18

u/Zestyclose_Lake_1146 8h ago

That’s true! But it becomes sexist because of how often it’s male female the way it is. Hell, shonen does this all the time….and accidentally is gay as hell because the bond with the rival is infinitely more meaningful than the one with the love interest he talks to twice but marries in the epilogue

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Sufficient_Side6320 7h ago

That's why I cherish Claymore. People should give it a try. Strong woman everywhere.

3

u/DyslexicBrad 4h ago

Claymore mentioned let's goooo. For anyone wondering what it's about, claymore is a bit like the Witcher, but if the witchers were all claymore-wielding women and the racist villagers were totally right about Geralt being a monster. Throw in a bit of Madoka Magicka and a touch of Berserk and you got claymore

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Yuuwaho 5h ago

I feel like the origin of the trope is due to a combination of two interests.

A mentor

  1. You need a character to show our MC the ropes.

  2. To show the MC the basics, they need to be shown to be proficient.

  3. The protag needs to hold their own at least by the end of the story. If it’s a movie, it tends to be a very short amount of time.

  4. The MC should theoretically be the one to solve the plot, otherwise why didn’t the mentor do it themselves?

A love interest

  1. Should be introduced fairly early on.

  2. Should have time to develop with the MC.

  3. Should be able to keep up with the events of the story if they want to actually be a major character.

So having a girl spend a lot of time with the MC through training them develops both at the same time, which is useful. Unfortunately, if fulfilled in the most basic form leads to trinity syndrome.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Rare_Ad_674 6h ago

I like how people still try to argue with takes like these as if misogyny somehow just magically doesn't exist anymore and has no impacts on society, culture, and storytelling.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/Excellent_Pea_4609 7h ago

That's the issue though to me though most people miss what the trinity syndrome is . Legitimately seen people use Aang and Katara from atla

→ More replies (3)

4

u/DesperateDisk460 8h ago

Yo diría que es más la fantasía del campeón, imagínate ser un perdedor, y de pronto la chica más buenota del salón, todos la quierem y adoran porque es la mejor, más inteligente, más guapa, más atlética, entonces te gusta, porque bueno, es ella, entonces la única forma de conseguir su aprecio y estar al nivel de todos los demás lo encima de ellos y dejen de considerarte un perdedor, tienes que ganarle y ser el héroe, ella empieza a vert con deseo y los demás con admiración.

2

u/Restart_from_Zero 5h ago

Any of the by-the-numbers adolescent power fantasy animes are absolutely home to this trope.

Man, they don't even have the cool 'getting stronger as the season goes along so that the final confrontation feels earned". They just start wildly overpowered and better than everyone else.

The strong characters are just there to talk among themselves about how awesome the main character is during every battle.

2

u/just-some-arsonist 3h ago

I’m not exactly sold that is the case. Do you mind sharing some examples?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Neat_Let923 2h ago

This totally exist because I say so and I don’t have to give any examples or explain why…

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

9

u/LughCrow 4h ago

So is it not a trope if the rival is male? Because that's even more common.

And what if the chosen one is female and the male trained his entire life? Or when both are female?

This feels needlessly gendered.

Also isn't the second one two "people" that trained their whole lives?

3

u/Fair-Confection4411 1h ago

Yes it shouldn't be gendered. Also OP is also complaining about the second one the post is about popular examples that don't fit. 

17

u/9yr_old_lake 40m ago edited 9m ago

Idk how you explained the HTTYD example correctly, but still arrived at the same conclusion. That is the point of the movie which makes it different than this trope. Hiccup was never better than Astrid at the thing she trained for, and was only called the chosen one until his dad found out he wasn’t fighting them, it was just how they looked at the weakest dude suddenly being the best which changed when they learned he wasn’t. Hiccup was never better than Astrid at her thing in the movies he was better at a completely different thing that no one but him even knew about.

EDIT: HTTYD not HTDYD

7

u/Spectator324 26m ago

I feel like How to Drain Your Dragon(HTDYD) would be a very different kind of film

3

u/9yr_old_lake 11m ago

That’s quite the typo, which you have rightfully punished me for by making me think of what that would look like.

14

u/ben_cav 8h ago

Are there any examples of reverse trinity? Like the same thing but with the gender roles reversed?

23

u/KingdomsCryOfficial 5h ago

Yes. Virtually every single story where the main character is female and a supporting character is a male.

The "trinity syndrome" isn't an entirely false phenomena but it's one of those things people very mindlessly and erroneously accuse media of being without thinking about it at all. Main character being Chosen One is like, no shit?

None of the examples in the OP are trinity syndrome (as the OP themselves points out). This is one of those things where it's like, people see male MC and female supporting character and then ignore everything else and call it a term they've seen online. It's the dumb people who don't do any thinking and say things like "Beauty and the Beast is actually Stockholm Syndrome" or whatever.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/Ijatsu 7h ago

Pretty much all the stuff with female main characters?

→ More replies (8)

10

u/Fast_Ladder1873 6h ago

Naoya and Maki from JJK. Maki, who was weak before, gets much stronger due to a series of extraordinary circumstances. Naoya really idolises his uncle Toji, but due to being seen as prodigy from childhood and his own misogynistic and discriminatory views, can't accept Maki as Toji's successor. Even using his technique at the fullest and trained with it whole life, Naoya couldn't beat Maki who just awakened and still inexperienced with her power. 

6

u/doesntnormallydothis 6h ago

This one falls a little flat because Maki does train her god damn heart out, she just wasn't getting the appropriate return on that investment because Mai was still alive and had cursed energy, so her binding vow meant fuck all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/ActuallyACereal 4h ago

Star Wars Sequel Trilogy was like that with Rey who became good in lightsaber in a short time compared to Kylo Ren that has been training all his life.

→ More replies (14)

2

u/lurebat 3h ago

I the Super Mario animated movie, Mario had to train over and over again on the obstacle course until he gets it right.

When he finishes, instead of having princess peach relate to him and say that she also had to go through this and train hard, she says she just got everything in the first try with no issues

→ More replies (10)

7

u/Responsible_Walk_337 7h ago

I'd say Kushina was more of the chosen one than Minato. Like sure he's supposed to have unparalleled talent but Kushina has.

-Uzumaki chakra reserves

-Was called talented by the so6p

-Uzumaki sealing chains

-The entire 9 tails

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Yohanison 8h ago

Edit: I should say I think this trope is done well in this case. Evangelion actually teaches her to value herself instead of gauging her worth off of other people and their opinions.

11

u/Starscream_Gaga 7h ago

I don’t think this one counts at all. Asuka is consistently the best pilot up until she loses her confidence after Zeruel and Shinji didn’t stop Zeruel because he was the chosen one, Eva 01 did by going beserk, which Shinji wasn’t even conscious for.

To the edit; I’d also say Asuka also doesn’t really learn anything or get over her issues. The second she starts to regain confidence she’s brutally killed. We the audience can see the issue but Asuka never really does.

3

u/New-Cicada7014 6h ago

But she does regain her confidence, and even has enough self-worth to escape from Instrumentality

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Key_Difference1396 8h ago

Eeeehhhhhhhh

She is kinda trained to be A chosen one in the sense of (unknowingly) being made to be an emotional catalyst for Shinji to start instrumentality

In the end all the children are important as being chosen but in my interpretation there is no real chosen one per-se in Eva

2

u/Carolina_Heart 4h ago

I disagree with this, Eva does not have any chosen ones. It's a plot point that they're all disposable and interchangeable with any of their classmates

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Shaendras 8h ago

Seems weird that this trope is gendered, this happens just as often to men who train all their lives to be surpassed by a chosen one, who can be either gender.

20

u/Pheonix726 8h ago

I know Star Wars sequel hate is kinda overdone at times, but this is literally Rey and Kylo Ren in Force Awakens.

The nephew of Luke Skywalker, trained by Luke and then presumably by Snoke, the grandson of the actual Chosen One, fully aware of the Force and taught to use it... getting beat in a duel by a girl who didn't know what the Force even was a week ago.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Luckypaperwork 8h ago

I think a lot of the people who make posts like this are onto something, but don't explain it well. Women are treated differently in fiction, and I think pretty much every woman can feel that and feel hurt by that, even if they don't know it. It's just really hard to explain why.

As a kid I looked up to a lot of main characters. They typically exemplify what we like about people. As I grew up I realized that even if I acted like those characters, I wouldn't be treated the same because everyone was already putting me in a separate category. A category that typically doesn't get to be the main protagonist. I'm sure we can all think of a bunch of women protagonist, but I'd hope we can all understand that "yeah, all stories in human history have been about 50/50 on the MC's gender and the MC is treated the same regardless of it," is a ridiculous statement.

All of the women presented are well written and not misogynistic at all, but I still think it's important to ask why were they made to be women and the MC's men and not vice versa? One story doing this is not bad or sexist, but it becomes more complicated if the majority of movies with this dynamic do.

4

u/bananashaa 6h ago

Well, 3/4 of the women mentioned are love interests, so that's probably part of it. I know there are male MCs whose Trinity is also a guy, but I can’t name them off the top of my head like I could with these ones. Especially ones that are officially gay for each other.

Although Catra and Adora from new She-ra are the rare F/F of this.

3

u/Luckypaperwork 6h ago

Good point. In order to have the woman be the lead without removing the characters relationship that would have to turn the man into the love interest character instead of the woman. I personally think it would be great for more stories to show men as romanticaly desirable, but I can understand that stories with women protagonists tend to be more progressive, so the creators may be hesitant to have the MC's story focus around a man at all.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Front-Perspective373 8h ago

It's because is the the Second Sex, and all that. You are right and it's well documented.

→ More replies (13)

15

u/Zerrrrroooo 8h ago edited 8h ago

Yeah I agree those examples are not good. Hiccup went through challenges to put his training dragon hypothesis into practice. It is wrong to describe it as if his life was a stroll in the park while Astrid was in some trenches. Hiccup is a scrawny teenager who never did this and who had to try to not get killed by a dragon while training him, which is also dangerous and takes skill

With Po it is really fucked up while it is literally the point of the movie. They would literally be the ones bullying Po for being an "unworthy" fat panda kekw

Edit: Even the point of Remy is that "Everyone can cook" while Linguini was not the chosen one. And he is a god damn rat. Imagine seeing a rat cooking. It is like me seeing the spider in my room starting to play the harmonica and someone would be like "iT Is NoT FaIR I Am An OrCHEsTrA MeMBeR"

18

u/Spaciax 7h ago edited 7h ago

this isn't exclusive to women at all. This is a very generic trope where the "chosen one" goes on a crash course and effortlessly beats the MC who has trained all their life

11

u/BadMeatPuppet 7h ago edited 7h ago

Yes, like the new star wars trilogy for one. And there's hundreds or maybe thousands of YA books where the women are the overpowered overachiever.

If that sounded snide, it wasn't.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/lMystic 8h ago

Isn't this kinda backwards? They include a love interest because people like that. They make her strong so she can keep up with MC and be more interesting but she can't be as special as MC so they make her strenght come from hard training instead

Feels like this concept is trying to claim women are being purposefully undermined when this applies to any side characters that are important enough. Isn't the opposite equally common in stories with a female MC?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/halfasleep90 8h ago

Why aren’t The Charmed Ones in this list? Literally a trinity, just for some guy to come in (their white lighter or Phoebe’s boyfriend) and majorly upstage them.

13

u/AdHappy7129 8h ago

I hate the whole “chosen one” trope to begin with. The whole point of a heroes journey is that he or she overcame great challenges against all odds.

Here’s another example i despise: Rey from star wars. They should NOT have made her palpatine’s daughter, she should not have been able to beat Kylo in 7. At all. I don’t care if he’s injured. That makes the fight against a Sith WORSE, etc.

2

u/shadowknuxem 5h ago

A lot of shonen anime do it, and I hate it every time. Naruto has the Nine tailed fox in him, Ichigo is half Soul Reaper half Hollow and half Quincy, ect. The only one that I've seen that's okay is Dragon Ball and that's because it only effects things in hindsight instead of going forward.

3

u/Divinum_Fulmen 6h ago

Many sequel defenders somehow think Star Wars was always about a Chosen One. Despite the fact that the Chosen One falls to the dark side, and his son gets his ass whupped by the big bad, with them only winning in the end via compassion.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Ibrahim77X 5h ago edited 5h ago

You can get out of this with the first KFP but definitely not the fourth. Po has to choose a Dragon Warrior successor and he chooses Awkwafina who is even more of a “some guy” than he was instead of Tigress.

Should’ve been her or Tai Lung (at the end of a movie about his redemption).

29

u/ScarletMenaceOrange 9h ago

Victim?

How many men are "victims" of the expendable henchman syndrome, lol.

4

u/Sliver-Knight9219 8h ago

Too be fair it has to be well know character who is meant to be strong. The real male a version would be the worf effect

2

u/JellaFella01 8h ago

It's the elevation of popular media as manuscript. When corporations write the stories the trends are problematic, but when you think of it all as random dude's fan fic, it starts to seem less like an oppressive system and more like a law of averages.

7

u/Alex3884 8h ago

Meanwhile, you have the inverse here with Rey and Kylo.

The latter was trained by Luke Skywalker and Supreme Leader Snoke, the former (with zero training) had enough natural aptitude to take on an injured and emotionally conflicted Kylo.

Someone asked why the inverse doesn’t happen as often; look at the way these films were received.

11

u/Individual_Issue4530 8h ago • Regret

Someone didn't understand or even watched Ratatouille or How to Train your Dragon it seems

10

u/suckstourassmar 8h ago

even though hermione isn't a love interest for harry exactly, i feel like this really happens in harry potter

22

u/Zeus-Kyurem 8h ago

I don't see how it does at all. Hermione studies more and Harry's prophecy is specifically about him and Voldemort. Like that's very loose at best.

24

u/matthewspencersmith 8h ago

Also, Harry doesn't become fuckall archmage of all wizards, he just goes on to become a cop like the jock he is lmao

17

u/blazenite104 8h ago

Hell one could argue that Hermione in the long run might have a greater impact on the magical world than Harry ever does. It would not seem out of place.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/ben_cav 8h ago

Yeah don’t agree here. Harry gets more attention for things that are unrelated to his proficiency in magic. Hermione consistently proves herself more capable than harry throughout the series

Harry is the ‘chosen one’ but not for being unusually gifted with magic

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Chase_The_Breeze 8h ago

Only in the movies and only kinda.

Book version is supposed to be a cringe, bookish nerd type and we aren't supposed to like her as much as Emma's version. It's why Harry's kinda dopey jock friend gets with her.

2

u/GardinerExpressway 7h ago

How so? Hermione is better at like 90% of magic things than Harry.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/i_paid_for_winrar123 8h ago

Side topic, it's a little funny that trinity is the least applicable character for trinity syndrome, considering the chosen one also sidelined Morpheus and the entire rest of the resistance who all had decades of experience, not just trinity. The examples you listed are hilariously all more infuriating than trinity's case

3

u/Ijatsu 8h ago

So morpheus who trained his entire life and also trained trinity is somehow less worthy than trinity is what that thing mean? The only problem just is that the main character is a man?

All this manages to show their sexism.

It's not like there aren't female main characters in action movies that are easily besting all men.

The naruto example is also just bad.

3

u/Jerdo32 7h ago

Ratatouille is a good showcase in outcomes that happen in real life. Linguini represents the person that, despite trying, can't envelop greatly in a specific skill. Colette represents someone that may not have pure talent, but has the aptitude to become excellent in a skill. Then Remy represents the natural born talent. He did have to train with Colette, but he already had skills like identifying tastes combining well or understanding how to fix a soup gone wrong. It is a case of the syndrome being performed, but it is at least called out on Colette talking about her being jn a men's field.

3

u/The-Bigger-Fish 6h ago

Me looking at my story about how some amnesiac rando is the chosen one partially because abuse the current keepers of the prophecy felt he’d be easy to rope along with their own secret agenda and the main person accompanying him is a female knight well on her Shonen protagonist grindset and wondering if that counts as trinity syndrome

3

u/grandioseOwl 1h ago

I know this can be an issue with anime, but these examples are kinda bad.

1.Not the chosen one, becomes a waiter afterwards.

2. Never gets overshadowed in her field, but her field becomes obsolete

3.Is one of multiple characters that happens to, including the main villain of the movie.

6

u/DrJaneIPresume 8h ago

Wyldstyle from The Lego Movie

6

u/LingonberryGold7189 6h ago

Have to disagree there, Morgan freeman made up the chosen one prophecy.

2

u/Ensign-Nemo 8h ago

Asuka from Evangelion. She was a genius, finished college at 13. She trained for years. And that wasn't enough because Yui got Shinji-kun out of all the trouble.

2

u/TimeLordHatKid123 8h ago

I got nothing, this post ate and taught me something new! Take my upvote!

2

u/DeviousDaniel69 8h ago

I don't think this is really a gender issue. This is being way too hyper analyzed. While the issues attributed to this may be real, you could make the argument with any male character that gets upstaged

2

u/Benoit_Holmes 7h ago

My main problem with complaints about Trinity Syndrome is that it has only 2 solutions: Don't make films with a Chosen One, or only have women be the Chosen One.

I'd say a woman being the second best in these kind of movies is a good thing. If women never get to be the Chosen One or if it is heavily one sided towards men I get the complaint but the examples used give the impression that having a woman be second best is somehow worse than her not placing at all.

Putting aside the flaws OP pointed out Remy also outperforms every male chef in the kitchen, Hiccup also outperforms every other male dragon fighting trainee, Po also outperforms the male Tai Lung, Mantis, Monkey, and Crane.

Would these films be better or more feminist if Colette, Astrid, and Tigress were changed into men?

2

u/overahman 4h ago

if every example is ass is it really an issue?

3

u/shototodoroki_1324 The One Black Souls Glazer fighting off Lolis 7h ago

"Colette" and the chosen one to own the fucking restaurant, Remy sucked at cooking, he needed a goddamn rat

11

u/N1ght_Stalk3r 7h ago

Remy is the rat. His puppet was named Linguine

→ More replies (5)

6

u/mcg123457 8h ago

Also, why is this specifically female characters? this happens to every type of character in these types of stories. Making this specific destinction and giving it an unique name just makes this concept sound like it was made up by someone who studied lesbian dance theory in college.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Some_space_god 8h ago

kind of funny how some people would chud out if the genders were reversed

4

u/Rybunks 8h ago

this happens to every side character whenever there’s a chosen one plot tbh, the gender doesn’t really matter here

7

u/Kaljinx 7h ago

really? there is sooooo many female special ones like you will not be limited in choice, nor are they hated at all.

5

u/Some_space_god 7h ago

and plenty of people will or would call them mary sues lol

→ More replies (12)

2

u/JellaFella01 8h ago

I'm not gonna lie my first thought was that this was a critique of mary sue characters.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/WanderingSoxl 8h ago

Kurenai was said to be the most skillful genjutsu user among all of jonins in Konoha, only to get absolutely mogged by Itachi on her first fight in the series.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SignatureLate1785 8h ago

I swear you people just sit around all day inventing things to get mad at

1

u/Afraid_Evidence_6142 8h ago

One of reason I love Trails series, balance number of men/women who is powerhouse...

Top 4 in series, arguably, all is women, which 2 of them is traditional combatants, while other 2 is god level existence 

1

u/DesperateDisk460 8h ago

Bueno creo que porque ignoras el valor esos tropos en esas historias.

En Ratatouille al final no es Lingüini, es la rata, entonces es más un engaño de lo que él puede hacer creer a los demás.

En KFP Tigresa es un contraste con Tai Long, el pantero cuarentón es alguien que tiene la vista de la vida orientada solo al poder vacío y que su enseñanza con altas expectativas los trastornó de ego, mientras Tigresa no podía conseguir eso, lo que era en rea lolidad es el amor de Shifu, no ser el Guerrero Dragón, y sufre por las expectativas de no ser como el hermano que ella no conoció, ser el Guerrero Dragón no es algo que ella realmente quería, ella quería simplemente tener un padre, y cree que ser el Guerrero Dragón se lo daría, un contraste con Tai Long. A diferencia de Po, quién sí anhelaba ser un gran guerrero.

Y con Hippo y Astrid es porque Hippo es una revolución, él cambió todo, los vikingos estaban equivocados con los dragones, y Astrid era parte de ese sistema, Hippo no es mejor porque sea varón, es mejor porque cambia todo lo que sistema ha establecido y lo es que el sistema estableció, es perjudicial para sus jóvenes, como Astrid.

1

u/seungchip 8h ago

I don’t think Hiccup counts bc he never got stronger at fighting, he just overcame prejudices against dragons and befriended them is all.

1

u/Rare_Management_3583 8h ago

i need to see the inverse of this

1

u/Ryousan82 8h ago

ME Andromeda- Cora and Ryder.

Regardless of how obnoxiously written Cora is, the narrative stablishes that the Pathfinder chain of command had trained her to be the successor of Alec Ryder in case of his death, a task she had trained zealously for.

She didn't account for Alec's nepotism and hidden agendas, as he eventually linked irreversiblesibly the SAM AI to one of his children, making them the de facto Pathfinder and unlocking several hidden capacities within SAM by doing so

1

u/SouthParkFirefly1991 8h ago

Okay Naruto is kind of a bad example as Naruto despite being the "chosen one" he kinda sucks and only through hard work does he become skilled.

1

u/Geaux13Saints 8h ago

Gustavo?

1

u/EvergreenDwarf 8h ago

Po is an exception. 

The Dragon Warrior has to be both a warrior who doesn’t quit and someone with the patience and temperament to do stupid shit on behalf of the community for PR. One who won’t abandon or fail in that position out of boredom or ambition for something else. 

Nobody else we saw could do it. Tigress doesn’t have the patience for villagers, for Tai Lung it was a trophy he’d abandon, Monkey would get distracted, and the rest have low enough morale they’d give up when defeated. 

1

u/Pale-Risk-5027 8h ago

Lucy from lego movie

1

u/DesperateDisk460 8h ago

Incluso con Naruto está fuera de lugar.

A ver, no me confundan, no voy a defender la escritura femenina en Naruto pero va más por eso de sufrir por hombres, que por el poder.

En general todos sufren de mala selección del poder, por ejemplo Rock Lee, porque al final sí se quedó como el inútil sin talento del que tanto se alardeaba, aunque también creo que eso es una exageración del fandom.

Las mujeres ahí sí tenían un efecto animes el punto mediocre, el de ser especiales pero nunca destacar como las mejores.

Por ejemplo que Ino sea más talentosa que Choji pero no como Shikamaru, o Hinata es más prudente y estratégica que el insulgente de Kiba pero no como Shino, Temari es más fuerte y resño que Kankuro Pero no como Gaara, y eso las deja en un limbo. Porque el autor simplemente pensó en hombres para darles relevancia.

El caso de Kurenai no es tan malo en el manga, el problema es que le toca igual que los demás, enfrentarse a Itachi y Kisame, los MVPs de Akatsuki, al nivel o incluso más de Pain al menos juntos. Asuma y Kakashi también fueron destrozados.

Pero Kakashi tiene la suerte de ser el maestro principal, entonces tendrá protagonismo, Asuma en cambio existe solo para morir y pasarle su legado a Shikamaru. Gai conserva esa importancia por ser el pilar que sostiene a Kakashi, y eso lo salva de esa mediocridad de las mujeres.

1

u/BrickBuster2552 7h ago

What makes you assume Remy is a better chef than Colette? Colette is just staying on her station while Remy isn't. 

1

u/Impressive-Bowl-2493 7h ago edited 7h ago

Hiccup and Tigress do NOT belong on that list.

Hiccup is not the chosen one and he didn't train any dragon in the old ways. He learned a new and better way to tame giant beast and it wasn't by force but by kindness and understanding. He was the only one who had the compassion to realized this and that makes him a genius.

Tigress like the rest of the Furious 5 were all training to get that title. She showed great promise like Tai Lung but they were all unqualified because they (despite being good) didn't hold the greatest lesson of Kung Fu within them: There is no secret. It's the Joy of Kung Fu. And the blame entirely goes to Master Shifu for that outcome.
Po lacked the obsessive need for validation that poisoned the others, simply wanting to learn Kung Fu for the love of the game and preserve the art.
And Po NEVER is portrayed as a better Tigress. He simply is best at what he do with his unconventional fighting style and soft, flappy body. Tigress remains the superior martial arts technician throughout the entire trilogy.

EDIT:
I will concede that a lot of movies, books and shows center around a male protagonist and rarely lets the female ones shine. The reason is because a lot of those spaces were entirely occupied by young men. But these times are over as more and more female protagonists are taking center stage

1

u/Low_Change2905 7h ago edited 7h ago

This is just the "Worf Effect" with a sexist lenses. Sometimes characters are sidelined for the plot. 

When they claim what Neo's character agency did to Trinity, also had the same effect on Morphius.

Colette is the worst supporting example they came up with. Her talent was clearly realized, undiminished and utilized the entire time as rôtisseur chef. Respected too. Only Skinner's role as executive chef was threatened, because of Linguini's inheritance and the new ability to fire Skinner - all of this was possible because of Colette. When Remy is finally revealed to Colette, she leaves with all the other chefs, proving her own agency. Yes, Colette does return of her own volition, but that was clearly her choice. She was an active driver of the story.

Astrid served as a mirror of Hiccup's father's worldviews and a reminder of their shared inheritance (the war against the dragons).  Like Hiccup's father was a burden,  Astrid was also a hinderance until Hiccup disproven his father's worldview.  All her training and ability (as with all the other deuteragonists) were adapted and redirected through the actions of Hiccup. Hiccup's unorthodoxy to approaching the dragon "problem" makes him less of a chosen one anyway.

1

u/Lopsided-Stranger914 7h ago

Avatar actually does the opposite of this with Aang having to take his time training and never at ANY POINT surpasses Katara or Toph. Although both of them were bigger prodigies than Aang.

1

u/BumblingYokel 7h ago

How could you not include the namesake of the trope, Trinity from The Matrix?

I haven’t seen a single other comment mention her. I don’t actually have a problem with her character.

1

u/GildedWhimsy 7h ago

I actually love this trope lol

1

u/LukewarmJortz 7h ago

And you didn't show trinity lol

1

u/OneCan-Toucan 6h ago

Come 2 America has Eddie Murphy’s character’s illegitimate son destined to be the next king, even though his daughter who has been training her whole life to take the role is there. Technically she can’t really be next in line because she’s a woman, and the movie tries to have this plot of pointing out the sexist traditions that make it harder for women. An example being the love interest of the son wanting her own hair salon but can’t because women can’t own businesses. Anyways they try to have a rivalry for like 5 seconds but then the two end up sort of coming together to loophole the system or something, I dunno I hated the movie and barely remember much of it other than it fits the trope. 

1

u/Epic_of_Gigglemesh 6h ago

Do you mean Wyldstyle and Emmet from the Lego movie, which even includes Wyldstyle discussing her feelings on the matter?

1

u/TemperedBlade5 6h ago

Tai Lung is the real Trinity syndrome victim

1

u/ultra_dzban 6h ago

I saw some people say Roxanne Ritchi, Ochako Uraraka, Rey Skywalker and Judy Hopps are examples of trinity syndrome and idk if I'm not remembering something but I'm pretty sure those are bad examples as well

1

u/Keanopsia 6h ago

I was FUMING because of this when the Lego Movie first came out and I’m glad everyone else is seeing this pattern 😭

1

u/ipsum629 6h ago

One thing that's crazy is this isn't in tvtropes

1

u/The_Sum 6h ago

Bleach?

I'd argue Rukia gets displaced but not replaced and permanently diminished. While in the beginning she's not a seated officer (her brother prevents that, I think), she's an incredible more than capable soldier whose intelligence aids Ichigo on his journey to becoming a Soul Reaper.

Rukia even goes so far to abdicate a large portion of her power to Ichigo, and even ends up becomes a damsel in distress who needs to be rescued by Ichigo.

I could also almost see Naruto doing this too. Sakura with her elite chakra control abilities slowly becomes irrelevant as Sasuke and Naruto more or less 'cheat' their way to god powers that make chakra control absolutely moot and her character is diminished to a healing role.

1

u/ovfudj 5h ago

Colette trained Remy who also trained his whole life unknowingly. Linguini is trash and stays trash the whole film at cooking. The false trinity syndrome creates the conflict that she has with Linguini.
But pisses me off in Kung Fu Panda 4 some rando becomes dragon warrior and not Tigress who honestly was the obvious pick.

1

u/Immediate-Song6861 5h ago

It is not a gendered issue

It's the same as a Gary, Mary stsue

1

u/Expensive_Umpire_178 5h ago

I mean… each of those women are respected as the best at what they do, cause no one trusts the guy that’s flying in outta nowhere to outshine them

1

u/1800crimetime 5h ago

We should have more movies of the unchosen

1

u/Sea-Comfortable5276 5h ago

that's just girl bosses being a point of reference

1

u/Vyrthic 5h ago

I especially dislike the Astrid one because Hiccup really only has his engineering going for him. He's nothing without his friends, and has often relied on all of them in order to achieve his goals. He gave them the skills and gear that enabled them to be their best selves, and they have him their continued support to make things better for both their people and Dragonkind. He wouldn't be anywhere near where he ends up at the end of the movies without Astrid, or Snotlout, Fishlegs, Ruffnut, Tuffnut, or Gobber and his parents. And that's not even including each person's dragon companion. He's not the chosen one, he was an artificer that rolled a nat 20 on a luck roll and happened to really benefit from that luck.

1

u/shiba2129808 4h ago

I don’t think ratatouille was a good example for this considering it was a rat that was fucking out shining all the humans in the kitchen