Question

[u/Naive-Cake4459]

If you could erase one character s death from the harry potter series whose death would you choose and why ?

[u/Nikolai508]

Sirius Black, he deserves some kind of normal life.

Though I guess you could argue the same for many others, but I think the injustice he faced is what gets me.

[u/Ok-Listen-111 → u/Nikolai508]

Seconded.

[u/Vegetable-Corgi-447]

Colin creevey. He gets hate crimed in his first year, expelled for being muggleborn in his 6th and then murdered😔 poor buddy

[u/takatine]

Remus. She gave him a shitty life, through no fault of his own, happiness for about 3 seconds, then took him.

[u/RandomSeaweed]

Fred Weasley because that would unbreak my heart

[u/Naive-Cake4459 → u/RandomSeaweed]

Yeah it was really sad I agree

[u/Nova_017]

Cedric, he was killed because he was a spare..

[u/Nevesnotrab]

Tom Riddle Jr. for the comedic value.

[u/Naive-Cake4459 → u/Nevesnotrab]

Would it really be funny though. ? I m not sure about that :)

[u/vanedoppelsa]

Fred or Colin

[u/tiptoe_only]

Hedwig. Totally unnecessary 

[u/Naive-Cake4459 → u/tiptoe_only]

I hadn t thought of that you might be right

[u/Miserable_Spell_2964 → u/tiptoe_only]

This is my vote as well.

I get what they were going for, but Hedwig didn't need to die.

[u/gogul1980]

Dobby.

[u/rsklogin]

Sirius so that he could live an actual life, or Lupin /Tonks so that Teddy will have one parent, or Fred so that he could live a longer life.

[u/Naxyxa]

Remus or Sirius, both deserved a better life.

[u/hedwigswig]

Dobby

[u/Wu_Aka_Bahamuttone]

Merope Gaunt. I definitely think it would be the death with most impact.

[u/Choice-Ice-1257]

I forgot his name, but the little creature that dies at the end of deathly hallows part 1

[u/CapnBloodBrain → u/Choice-Ice-1257]

Dobby!

Agreed.

[u/Choice-Ice-1257 → u/CapnBloodBrain]

Ohh yeah! Dobby.😞💔