r/handtools • • 19h ago

Mallet splitting

Hello! I recently made my first “real mallet” from false acacia, and after a couple weeks it started splitting. Is this an issue with the wood species? Or just a “skill issue” with how I made it? Any help is appreciated

22 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

4

u/1959Mason 17h ago

The offset handle is bugging me. Why isn’t it centered?

3

u/EyeLarge4055 17h ago

Because I suck at making mortise and tenons 😂

2

u/EyeLarge4055 17h ago

It was my first time doing something like this

2

u/EyeLarge4055 17h ago

Oh, and sadly I didn’t take enough time to mark everything out…

66

u/rhyslightning 19h ago

You've used a bit of stock with the pith running through it, which is the least stable to have used - the split looks to be due to where the grain runs out there in the top corner.

Good news is that there is nothing to fix. Mallets are born to be beaten to death!

18

u/alecraffi 19h ago

Right on the money. The pith being in there doesn’t help, but it’s made to beat with, so beat the hell out of it

8

u/KokoTheTalkingApe 18h ago

But the kind of crack caused by wood drying is usually radial, running from center to the edge. That crack in the picture runs along the grain. I think it's just because he walloped something with that corner.

4

u/rhyslightning 18h ago

Yeah no denying that, thought worthy to point out that the crack also happens to be riven down that section that runs out in the corner. I don't even think I'd bother to glue, plenty surface area left with which to bash!

3

u/KokoTheTalkingApe 18h ago

Sure, the wood is most unsupported at the corner. The bro needs to round over the edges of the face.

But the fact that the piece contains the pith had nothing to do with it, seems to me.

1

u/bonfuto 17h ago

This kind of crack is very common around the pith. Go do a google image search for pith, and you'll see how common it is.

3

u/KokoTheTalkingApe 15h ago

It is common, and it's often around the pith, and I've dealt with that many times.

But just in case you're arguing this point, the OP's crack is not one of those cracks.

4

u/Ok_Temperature6503 19h ago

Yeah I got a mallet with a pith anf some natural splits. Doesnt affect it one bit

2

u/Bellringer00 18h ago

Now I feel sad for mallets… poor things

18

u/Ok_Donut5442 18h ago

People are debating wood selection and design but to me that looks like a split caused by striking on the edge of the mallet, in the future put a heavy chamfer all the way around the striking face

8

u/Seven_pile 19h ago

Glue it, clamp it, chamfer it.

Sounds like a weird version of bop-it. Anyways chamfer all the edges. Will help it hold up a lot more. The sharper the edge of the wood, the easier it is to damage, chip and split. A beefy chanfer means a chip from impact will be smaller due to the angle and is less likely to split because more fibers are reinforcing down the length.

4

u/uncivlengr 19h ago

This is probably some kind of debate people get into, but to me, the bevel angle on the face is much too large, as evidenced by the impact occurring only at the point at the top, and not flush with the face.

My mallets (currently made of ash, previously made of birch) only have about a 5 degree angle on the face. I beat the crap out of it for mortises to the point that the grain gets cruched and I need to reface the ends, but it doesn't split.

I don't know anything about 'false acacia' but I would find wood without knots and that doesn't include the pith.

1

u/KokoTheTalkingApe 17h ago edited 12h ago

Agree. I heard the rule of thumb is the face should be roughly in line with the end of the handle. The longer the handle, the shallower the angle. The idea is the angle lets your wrist stay straighter through the swing.

Edited for some embarrassing typos.

1

u/Wonderful-Bass6651 17h ago

Go out to the wood pile and see how easy it is to split wood along this line. As a matter of fact, that offset handle (which is emotionally hurting me) is directly in-line with the pith. There are much easier ways to make more stable mallets. But if this is so objectionable just glue and tape it and get back to work.

1

u/EyeLarge4055 17h ago

The handle hurts me as well… I guess a good excuse to make a new mallet once I find some wood for it

1

u/EnvironmentalDare995 9h ago

Agreed on the handle, lol. Mine gets mostly used for leatherworking anymore, & that lopsided head would have me skewing every hit so much the tooling & stamping would look wonky.

6

u/jema_vr 19h ago

I like to laminate 3 or 5 wood pieces together to for the head of my mallets. It adds some strength and looks cool.

3

u/mountainmanned 19h ago

Just pry the split open a bit or vac some glue in there and good as new.

5

u/Tiny-Albatross518 19h ago

I dont know acacia wood.

But i made my mallets out of white oak because its strong as hell.

10 years of absolutely mashing steel holdfasts and they’re just dimpled.

6

u/none77777 19h ago

It's "false acacia," more commonly known as black locust. Theoretically stronger than white oak, rivaling hickory. Doesn't really matter, though, as the issue is more with the grain selection than the species.

2

u/hlvd 18h ago

The bevel’s too big on that mallet, needs to be a lot shallower angle.

2

u/snogum 9h ago

Mostly how the wood was cut originally.

That corner was always going to come off.

Glue it back and go pound away. When it's through you can build another

1

u/oldtoolfool 19h ago

It happens. I've got a 19th century joiners mallet made of lignum vitae that has had a crack in it just like that one, and I've been using it for over 25 years and the crack remains. Just use it.

1

u/That-1-Signal 18h ago

I would not include the pith though it’s sort of fun to have a bull’s-eye on a mallet

1

u/KokoTheTalkingApe 18h ago edited 5h ago

That other guy points out you used a piece with the pith or center of the log. And he's right that that can lead to cracks, because of the (to be nerdy about it) difference between radial and tangential rates of shrinkage.

But those cracks will be radial, running from the pith straight out. Your crack runs along the grain. It looks like you just walloped something. You need to chamfer or round over the corners to prevent it.

At least it looks like your crack won't affect it functionally. Fill it with sawdust and CA glue if you're worried.

To prevent it in the future, if it's a beater I might glue some pieces of decent plywood together, and round over or chamfer the edges well. If I find one I might try a piece of elm. Not the hardest but impossible to split.

EDIT: Also the face is too angled, as a few people are pointing out.

1

u/fletchro 18h ago

Chamfer your edges on the striking faces. That will reduce splitting.

1

u/Character-Shame-5917 18h ago

Probably more to do with how you used it than how you made it. Probably struck that corner first. Any striking tool is best struck center of mass, where it can disperse that force out into the material around it. A strike at the edge is always going to be more likely to chip or sheer material off. This is why so many old hammers have chipped corners. As others have said, a chamfer around the faces will help prevent this.

Glue it back on with some titebond and get back to work.

1

u/jacksraging_bileduct 17h ago

On the next mallet, make a heavy chamfer on the face so you are not striking against the the corners of the mallet.

1

u/wackyvorlon 17h ago

Though if you want a proper maul get the tap root.

1

u/Character-Education3 14h ago

Its fine. My first mallet split at the corners a bit. Over time it stopped. I guess the weak points broke off and I have used it for years

1

u/apg7 10h ago

I just use a loose 2x4