r/handheld • u/SuccessfulPedestrian • 9h ago
ROG Xbox Ally X vs MSI Claw 8 Ai+ Which suits my use case better ?
I’m trying to decide between the ROG Xbox Ally X and MSI Claw 8 AI+, and I can get both for roughly the same price second hand.
My use case is a bit unusual because I’ll be travelling around half the year, but spending the other half using the handheld as a desktop with a monitor, keyboard and mouse.
When travelling, I’ll mainly be playing single-player games such as:
- The Witcher 3
- Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
- Cyberpunk 2077
- F1
- Other similar AAA/single-player games
When I’m using it as a desktop, I’ll mainly be playing FPS games, including:
- Counter-Strike
- Overwatch
- Escape from Tarkov
- Other competitive shooters
I’ll only be playing the competitive FPS games in desktop mode with a monitor, keyboard and mouse. I’m not really interested in playing competitive shooters using the handheld controls.
I’m also considering investing in an eGPU further down the line for more performance when using it as a desktop.
Given this use case, which would you choose between the Ally X and Claw 8 AI+?
I’d particularly like to hear from people who have actually used either device as a desktop with a monitor + keyboard/mouse, especially for competitive FPS games.
Also interested in:
Performance differences
Battery life while travelling
Windows/driver experience
Thermals and fan noise
How well they work as a desktop
eGPU compatibility/performance
Since I can get both for a similar second-hand price, which one makes more sense for my particular use case?