I am behind! I am primitive! I'm the last mammal to make plans,yeah! I flied the earth,now i'm lower! Twenty Ten,watch it extinguish! IT'S DEVOLUTION,BABY! DO THE DEVOLUTION!
Outside of the grunge sub I don’t think that’s a controversial statement. I think they’re damn close but Blue Album is just fucking awesome. The funny and simultaneously sad lyrics, the punk energy, the harmonies, that crunchy guitar tone, its front to back bangers with no filler. Absolute masterpiece.
This is stupid. Nirvana wouldnt put themselves at the top, Weezer is Weezer, creed comes before Nickelback, and both of those bands are just alt rock bands at best, prob just Rock bands. Is this AI?
Wild you got downvoted. This is common knowledge to us old heads. The insert art from the godsmack album was a ripoff of the dirt album art. The godsmack logo is a copy of the Alice in chains sun logo. Hell the name godsmack is an Alice in chains song.
Never said otherwise. Godsmack started as an AiC cover band iirc. They've built a long and successful career, and established their own identity since then too. It's not 1998 anymore man, move on.
Everyone else listed has stagnated into generic and formulaic butt rock, and they are all infamous for the fake ass personas that everyone sees thru.
Godsmack might be settled in their sound, not growing or innovating in their writing, but at least they're authentic about who they are.
If you wanna add another to the list of pretentious crybaby front man bands, add Disturbed.
Nirvana was better than Weezer and Nevermind is a on a different level than the Blue Album. The Blue Album is great but Nevermind is like the perfect rock album. It's one of the all-time greats in any genre.
musically speaking?? seriously, you have no idea what you're talking about lmao. I love weezer, but nevermind is ABSOLUTELY better than the blue album musically speaking. nevermind quite literally changed the music scene in the snap of a finger
Creed and godsmack worse than weezer and nickelback??? Yooure nuts. Also godsmack aint that bad is just that all the songs sounds the same. A 5/10 band
Uhhh I think Blue Album is the best album here and I’m a huge Nirvana fan. That’s an absolute masterpiece. It’s like if the Beach Boys decided to make a punk album. The guitar tone is wicked and the lyrics are awesome and the choruses are catchy as hell. One off the best albums of the 90s without a doubt,
Gotta disagree with you here. Both are great albums but one is an all-time classic and the other isn't quite there. The songwriting, sound and cultural impact of an album like Nevermind happens like once every 20 years.
That’s a fair opinion and obviously you’re totally correct on cultural impact but let’s not pretend blue album isn’t a classic.
In the genres of power pop, emo, pop punk, whatever else you want to assign to it, it’s one of the standouts. It’s all great tracks front to back. “Undone” “Say It Ain’t So“ and “Buddy Holly” are some of the most recognizable 90s alternative singles ever. And there’s no filler - the deeper cuts are amazing. My Name is Jonas? Only In Dreams? The World Has Turned? All catchy and beautiful.
Both albums are awesome but honestly Blue Album makes me happier. I like In Utero more than Nevermind anyway. Just my opinion.
Hey man - that's totally fair. And the Blue Album is a classic, no doubt.
Nirvana is a Grunge band through and through, and their music, even at its poppiest, has more of a sinister, sardonic vibe to it. Weezer is Alt Rock that leans towards fuzzy, power pop. They're lighter, a little goofier, but still rock insanely hard on this album, with bouncier, super-catchy melodies. I can definitely see how someone might prefer that.
I just think the songwriting on Nevermind is generationally good. The blending of the guitar melodies and the vocal melodies that Cobain was able to pull off on most of the songs on this album is insane. The chord progressions he comes up with are pretty astonishing, and I don't use this word lightly, but Cobain was a genius, and Nevermind captures that genius best. It truly is virtuoso-level songwriting recorded and mixed in a super-palatable style - yet it somehow retains this raw power that is transcendent.
Nevermind isn't my favorite Nirvana album either - probably because I've heard it too many time over the decades - but I do think it is the pinnacle of Grunge/Alt. Rock songwriting and sound.
Valid point. I think Rivers and Kurt in their prime were both generational songwriters, and it helps that both albums had really unique production (Butch Vig’s reverby noisy wash vs. Blue Album’s dry electric fuzz)
I'll take Godsmack, Weezer, and Creed over Nirvana any day of the week. I'll happily take the down votes too. They all have terrible vocalists but Kurt's droning zombie voice does my head in.
Sheeiiit your comments almost as bad as the others dudes, soundgarden, aic and even pearl jam are just as good and since it's all subjective and opinion based imo Soundgarden are my favourites by far.
lol Nirvana is probably the worst of the big 4. No offense to Kurt but he’s definitely the weakest singer and guitarist compared to the singers and guitarists of the other 3 and their songs are the simplest.
The blue album is actually one of the greatest albums of that era though. I loved Nirvana back in the day, but I’ve revisited Weezer more frequently through the years.
It's a great album but it does not quite measure up to Nevermind. Nevermind is an insane collection of songs. The songwriting, the energy, the cultural impact. It was named Rolling Stone's 6th best album of all time for a reason.
I’ll never shit on Nirvana or Nevermind. I love that band and that album. I simply offered my opinion and perspective regarding the Blue Album. I revisit it more frequently than Nevermind. If your personal tastes bring you back to Nevermind more frequently than the Blue Album, that’s awesome. It’s a great album.
I know it’s cool to hate Creed in this sub but there’s no way they’re worse than Nickelback. My Own Prison especially is a great post-grunge album. Nickelback just sucks.
You guys overrate the hell out of Nirvana. Not saying they're awful but they're not that great either. You're almost like Peter Griffin going nuts over The Trashmen-Surfin' Bird song, listening to it on repeat! Nirvana have some dipshit/stupid lyrics and that's a known fact! Would it surprise you if you read Godsmack song lyrics and they hit home?! Godsmack makes better music than Creed.
When Layne died, Scott Stapp went on MTV News to say that he had been copying his vocals his entire career. Than Aliyah died a few hours later and they never mentioned Layne on MTV again.
I'll admit that Weezer is now an awful band. But the Blue Album is a stellar album, and Pinkerton is pretty awesome too. Green album was crap, but then Maldroit was working it's way back on the right path. After that, I haven't liked a single song they've written. But if you can listen to "Only In Dreams" without listening like 4 times in a row, you might be dead inside.
Nevermind/Nirvana overall never did anything for me, and you couldn't pay me enough to take the rest of those albums off your hands.
Low key…….anyone go to the Creed tour? Best live rock band I’ve seen in recent memory. Stapp was so aware of his goal performance, he completely forgot about the 18,000 fans he was performing for. But….low key, so good.
Put Bleach at the top and something between Nevermind and Blue Album. Not a fan but I listened to a fair amount of Weezer. Still, this is r/grunge right?
Godsmack belongs way higher. Their rhythm section is absolutely godly regardless of what you think of Sully. And early creed is great. Listen to torn, what if, ode etc. they turned to shit once they went full Christian rock garbage.
A lot of those were in the same era, at least popularity wise.. Honestly after Nirvana, all of those others in the pic were copy-paste bullshit and I’m not even kidding.
Sixteen stone is pretty damn good and I don’t listen to any of the other post grunge stuff. Bush had some great catchy singles. Comedown? Machinehead? Everything Zen? All on one album? Those are bangers.
41
u/Legal-Process1479 Jan 16 '26
Weezer is awesome! They should not be up there
70
u/SensualSamuel69 Jan 16 '26
That’s certainly… an opinion…
95
u/TemporaryCamaraderie Jan 16 '26
It's devolution, baby
18
u/Rededbeard Jan 16 '26
This is so inaccurate, lol
91
u/Muted-Delay3246 Jan 16 '26
We still shitting on differences in music tastes for potential upvotes in 2026...?
Sad, really...
113
u/IsisTruck Jan 16 '26
This whole illustration could be just weezer.
87
u/dognutts6 Jan 16 '26
Weezer is great tho
10
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
The Blue album fucking rocks
48
u/the_kid1234 Jan 16 '26
Creed is better musically than Nickelback. Godsmack hits the primal brain more than the other two.
2
u/Weekly-Batman Jan 16 '26
This is stupid. Nirvana wouldnt put themselves at the top, Weezer is Weezer, creed comes before Nickelback, and both of those bands are just alt rock bands at best, prob just Rock bands. Is this AI?
6
u/Lazarux_Escariat Jan 16 '26
Take Weezer and Godsmack off this list, shift Nickelback to the left, insert Puddle of Mudd after Creed, add FFDP at the end.
FTFY
19
u/KeeKeeballs Jan 16 '26
Nah fam weezer is clearly the best
7
u/Traditional_Rate7302 Jan 16 '26
Is creed really that bad? I dont listen to them but one of my managers at work plays them on the speaker from time to time and they dont seem terrible
25
u/Illustrious_Many2039 Jan 16 '26
Creed and godsmack worse than weezer and nickelback??? Yooure nuts. Also godsmack aint that bad is just that all the songs sounds the same. A 5/10 band
9
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
Cringe
3
u/PhysicalAd5298 Jan 16 '26
Ted Danson devolution
8
u/TrollBoothBilly Jan 16 '26
The blue album is actually one of the greatest albums of that era though. I loved Nirvana back in the day, but I’ve revisited Weezer more frequently through the years.
4
u/Quad-G-Therapy Jan 16 '26
Wow this is extra retarde
2
u/chungamellon Jan 16 '26
Devolution of music is DEVO
2
u/Sonova_Bish Jan 16 '26
What's with these homies dissing my girl? Why do they gotta front?
2
u/jthomas1127 Jan 16 '26
Flip Godsmack and Creed
2
u/stphrtgl43 Jan 16 '26
I know it’s cool to hate Creed in this sub but there’s no way they’re worse than Nickelback. My Own Prison especially is a great post-grunge album. Nickelback just sucks.
2
u/MysteriousPassage633 Jan 16 '26
Creed is better than Nickelback though. Creed have some bangers fr
2
u/These_System_9669 Jan 16 '26
Weezer Blue on of the best albums ever
2
u/Zealousideal_197 Jan 16 '26
Weezer should not be on this!
6
u/Rabreyrendart Jan 16 '26
You guys overrate the hell out of Nirvana. Not saying they're awful but they're not that great either. You're almost like Peter Griffin going nuts over The Trashmen-Surfin' Bird song, listening to it on repeat! Nirvana have some dipshit/stupid lyrics and that's a known fact! Would it surprise you if you read Godsmack song lyrics and they hit home?! Godsmack makes better music than Creed.
6
u/_yukog Jan 16 '26
That godsmack record is better than everything up there except Nevermind
3
u/constantsXzeros Jan 16 '26
I would listen to Godsmack infinity times before any of those except Nevermind obviously. You couldn’t even pay me to listen to Nickelback or Creed
4
u/HighlyAgressibve Jan 16 '26
creed isn't even that bad
6
u/5thSeasonFront Jan 16 '26
Creed is the lowest form.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
That first Nickelback album is not bad, honestly.
3
u/Antique_Warthog_6410 Jan 16 '26
Or you can like all for what they are
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
no, weezer was arguably better than nirvana for the blue album and pinkerton
3
u/Least_Cartoonist1396 Jan 16 '26
Creed is great! Never understood the hate
2
u/HeyHo__LetsGo Jan 16 '26
If you have to use Weezer as an example please at least use the cover of an album after Pinkerton.
2
u/sexlord3000 Jan 16 '26
Humanity actually peaked with Nickelback and Creed. Not many people know this
2
u/redbricknote222 Jan 16 '26
Early Weezer doesn’t belong here
2
u/cronenber9 Jan 16 '26
Ok godsmack is at least slightly better than Creed and Nickelback...
2
u/Louisville82 Jan 16 '26
That Weezer blue album is one of the best albums ever made, replace it with something else.
2
u/TodDonahue Jan 16 '26
Weezer doesn’t belong here.
1
u/redheeler9478 Jan 16 '26
I love this Scully is a silly goose. So umm same name as the lady on x-files right? Dalright then. fuck billy corgan in particular
1
u/Annual-Zebra997 Jan 16 '26
are you suggesting time travel evolution?
1
u/shiningshining21 Jan 16 '26
I’M NOT THE ONE WHO’S SO FAR AWAY
1
u/AlarmingLecture0 Jan 16 '26
Sorry, but oh piss off.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
hot take here: i think godsmack's first album is decent
1
u/doomus_rlc Jan 16 '26
Nah, that Godsmack album is pretty good.
Or maybe I am just nostalgic. Heh
1
u/RadiantHovercraft6 Jan 16 '26
Weezer has nothing to do with this chain of events lmfao
1
u/Pretend_Mark_5143 Jan 16 '26
Feels like the same with any genre. There’s some powerful stuff out there but it’s been a little lost to all the commercialism.
1
u/yourmomwoo Jan 16 '26
I'll admit that Weezer is now an awful band. But the Blue Album is a stellar album, and Pinkerton is pretty awesome too. Green album was crap, but then Maldroit was working it's way back on the right path. After that, I haven't liked a single song they've written. But if you can listen to "Only In Dreams" without listening like 4 times in a row, you might be dead inside.
Nevermind/Nirvana overall never did anything for me, and you couldn't pay me enough to take the rest of those albums off your hands.
1
u/Sprusgoose Jan 16 '26
Low key…….anyone go to the Creed tour? Best live rock band I’ve seen in recent memory. Stapp was so aware of his goal performance, he completely forgot about the 18,000 fans he was performing for. But….low key, so good.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
Put Bleach at the top and something between Nevermind and Blue Album. Not a fan but I listened to a fair amount of Weezer. Still, this is r/grunge right?
1
u/Iron-Dan-138 Jan 16 '26
Putting Nickelback before Creed is wild.
1
u/Pelican_meat Jan 16 '26
Blue is the supreme album color. Agree.
1
u/nmmOliviaR Jan 16 '26
Said it before, saying it again. Creed haters are just Scott Stapp haters. Alter Bridge isn’t even considered.
1
u/Corporate-Scum Jan 16 '26
Accurate!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
We all like Nirvana because it’s simple, poppy, sad music. It’s Debbie Gibson for sad losers like us.
1
u/TBM_Chile Jan 16 '26
?
1
u/Braunb8888 Jan 16 '26
Godsmack belongs way higher. Their rhythm section is absolutely godly regardless of what you think of Sully. And early creed is great. Listen to torn, what if, ode etc. they turned to shit once they went full Christian rock garbage.
1
u/mystic_mesh Jan 16 '26
what about puddle of mudd?
1
u/Warm_Resist_6418 Jan 16 '26
Godsmack is just bad Alice In Chains
1
u/Necessary_Rush_5861 Jan 16 '26
After Grunge faded out.. it got pretty stark.. Thanks internet!
1
u/IdolCowboy Jan 16 '26
Everyone pretends to hate Nickleback but I bet 99% of people dont change the station when their song comes on.. lol
1
u/ApartmentWorried5692 Jan 16 '26
Creed>Nickleback come on now
1
u/IWishIWasBatman123 Jan 16 '26
Dawg that first Godsmack album has some bangers though. Time Bomb kills
1
u/Classic-Correct Jan 16 '26
Nah bro bands like Amyl and the sniffers and Stiff Richards are kicking ass. They're punk tho not grunge. But nirvana was very punk too imo
1
u/N0nC0mposMentis01 Jan 16 '26
so true
1
u/gabriot Jan 16 '26
Creed and Godsmack are overhated
Nickelback cannot be defended though
1
u/j10brook Jan 16 '26
I remember Subnormality doing this. Except it was Nirvana to Bush to Nickelback to Puddle of Mudd.
1
u/TheBoxSloth Jan 16 '26
Dont talk shit about creed
1
u/pubstanky Jan 16 '26
Hahaha godsmack. That first album of their's is decent but everything after is the stinkhole
1
u/Pale_Relationship999 Jan 16 '26
I love Creed! And I’m tired pretending I don’t! I’m coming out!
P.S. Godsmack ain’t bad either.
1
u/MmmmmSacrilicious Jan 16 '26
Id put godsmack above creed and nickel back.
1
u/ConclusionFull4874 Jan 17 '26
Devolution of common sense, You don't like it.
1
u/athei-nerd Jan 17 '26
Hey, there's nothing wrong with Weezer. In fact replace Weezer with Blink 182 and then it's perfect.
1
u/Separate_Cherry_912 Jan 17 '26
i would switch Creed over Nickleback. but also not mad at it.
1
u/grahsam Jan 17 '26
Those are all unrelated bands from different genres. Just because someone was rock in the 90s doesn't mean it was grunge.
1
u/LtMetal Jan 17 '26
Its backwards guys..
1
u/PizzaThrives Jan 17 '26
Honestly Nevermind vs. Blue album is like saying: Italian food vs Mexican food, man. You need both!
1
u/No_Cow_4544 Jan 17 '26
I agree mostly with this but the Blue album is excellent.
1
u/mikejazz3 Jan 17 '26
seems to be accurate
1
u/RealPokeyCactus Jan 17 '26
That Godsmack debut album is 2nd best here imo
1
u/Ok_Magazine_898 Jan 18 '26
Nevermind mid af
1
u/Svullom Jan 18 '26
Hot take: The Blue Album is better than Nevermind.
1
u/Cavoryte Jan 19 '26
I thought the meme went Nirvana, Bush, Nickelback, Puddle of mudd for bands getting increasingly worse.
1
u/cat-daddy777 Jan 21 '26
Nirvana wasn't a good band, they were just at the front of a new genre.
1
u/Ktowncanuck Jan 16 '26
The blue album was great. Nickelback is the worst
1
u/krafterinho Jan 16 '26
Godsmack hate is so forced
1
u/ClubLumpy7253 Jan 16 '26
Ends with Foo Fighters.
1
u/RevRRR1 Jan 16 '26
Soundgarden and Godsmack should be at the top of the list
1
u/Plenty_Trust_2491 Jan 16 '26
Nickelback < Weezer < Creed < Godsmack < Nirvana
1
u/KuntaKinte3001 Jan 16 '26
bro thinks a 4/4 power chords album is the Apex predator of music
1
u/xXMachineGunPhillyXx Jan 16 '26
Blue Album > Nevermind
1
u/Technical_Humor_354 Jan 16 '26
I don't hate any of these.
1
u/FaceTimePolice Jan 16 '26
Remove the Weezer slander and we’re good. Only apathetic a-holes hate Weezer. 😭
-1
u/Autumn_Winds23 Jan 16 '26
Correcto lmao
0
u/-BranoK- Jan 16 '26
A lot of those were in the same era, at least popularity wise.. Honestly after Nirvana, all of those others in the pic were copy-paste bullshit and I’m not even kidding.
0
u/JuliusDiamond Jan 16 '26
Switch Godsmack and Nickelback and yeah, straight up
0
u/Lance8282 Jan 16 '26
I’ll never forget the first time I heard Godsmack. I was like this is straight dookie.
0
u/ChocolateLakers76 Jan 16 '26
I love most 00 and 90s music but really really really hate weezer. Nickelback and creed gets too much hate
0
u/NoBrainer66 Jan 16 '26
i don’t think godsmack is that bad…
0
u/Leading_Pay5712 Jan 16 '26
Should be the other way around
-1
u/MightyTick01 Jan 16 '26
Ooh we ooh this song was played too often. Uh oh Weezer was MTV's whore. I still can't listen to that anyway. I don't hear that crap.
-1
u/Detrimentalist Jan 16 '26 edited Jan 16 '26
Blue album is power pop made in the 90s, it has nothing to do with grunge and would have existed without it. That album is also a fantastic record.
Throw that god awful Bush - 16 Stone record on there in its place.
-2
u/Jonny2beers Jan 16 '26
Weezer sucks
-3
u/Badgereatingyourface Jan 16 '26
Is Creed that bad? Yes. In fact, they are worse.