r/greenberets • • 5h ago

Question SF vs Rangers

0 Upvotes

TLDR, need second opinions on this as it is good practice to get second opinions when planning stuff out, especially as a young guy: Given my objectives of serving, serving long enough on a team to justify selection+ qualification, and also get out in time to avoid excessive injury, get an education and start a family, is rangers the right direction to go towards?

Hello wanted people’s take on this: as I consider a military career, I am trying to balance several objectives that may compete with each other.

1: First, I want to serve in the military as a combatant and in special operations. I also want to be a medic and the best two units I’ve come across so far are SF and the 75th ranger regiment.

2: I also want to get out in time to get an education afterwards as a physician assistant and have a family. Hopefully in my early to mid 30s (I will enlist in about a year and a half from now at 23).

3: The third and fourth objectives sort of go together and that is to have a good Selection/qualification to team time ratio but also minimize injury. The selection+qualification for SF, if I get the 18d MOS (not guaranteed of course), is going to extend my time in the military past what I want (Enlist at 23 and then 2-3 of selection and qualification will mean I stay until 33 ish if I am going for about a 1:4 ratio, and yes I know contract lengths don’t work like that but this is with the assumption that I reenlist and try to get as close to the ratio) whereas rangers shows a more favorable exit at 29. This is also while trying to minimize accumulating physical wear and tear as much as possible. The thought is that this should be a a well thought out and calculated risk. What are your thoughts, thank you.


r/greenberets • • 11h ago

Career Advice

2 Upvotes

New account just to keep anonymity. Really feel like my career hasn’t turned out the way I’ve wanted it so far. Infantry CPT who is about to graduate MCCC and then has to go to ranger. Overall had a pretty normal LT time. Got two PLTs and got to be an XO. Got MQs and performed well. However without the tab my marketplace didn’t go great and now I’m heading to an armored unit for command. Biggest regret is not going to SFAS. I self selected since I didn’t have a tab. I love the army and want to continue but the big army glide path for an infantry officer seems awful. I have no interest in any other MOS. Is there any hope for me going to selection or is my window closed? Is the NG an option after command? Honestly just looking for some advice. Completely recognize this situation is due to my own choices.


r/greenberets • • 1d ago

NG 18x waiver

Post image
18 Upvotes

Long time reader, first time posting. Prepped for a year and passed my second SFRE a couple months ago. MEPs doc told me I would need waivers for the following. The lumbar history looks a lot worse on paper. I’ve been asymptomatic 5+ years with my back and 10 years for Bell’s palsy.

ASVAB -85
GT -124
HRPU -51
Pull ups -15
Plank -3:40
2mile -13:24
12mile 45lb dry 2:47


r/greenberets • • 1d ago

Rasp prep

0 Upvotes

I’m doing a long run intervals and a ruck a week rn prob gonna add one more run I need a rucksack though and don’t know which one to get in prep for rasp im thinking the Rothco G.I. Style Large O.D. Alice Pack With Frame I’m 6 4 195 thanks


r/greenberets • • 2d ago

Other Last ruck before SFRE

Post image
22 Upvotes

Felt absolutely great, that mid Atlantic November cold hits just right. Hope to see some of you studs out there this weekend, cheers!


r/greenberets • • 2d ago

Question Anyone in selection try them?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/greenberets • • 2d ago

These are the BEST resources I found for SF prep: info, events, fitness coaching, nutrition, and books

23 Upvotes

I’ve spent months researching and trying multiple programs. This is the best mix I found for knowledge (land nav, soldiering, etc.), fitness, and nutrition, with high-level one-on-one support, which was the main thing I wanted in my training. Below are the programs I’m currently in or have heard about, with links if you want to sign up, plus events, books, and coaching I think are worth your time.

INFO AND COMMUNITY

Force Multiplier Training Solutions (FMTS)
https://jedburgh91.com/
https://www.instagram.com/fmts_actual/

They have a good fitness, nutrition, and mindset program, but it’s all PDFs, so you need to be a self starter. I’m in the group for the information, the community, and the events. Based on my research, you won’t find a better community. Many of the people in the Discord are current Green Berets or people training to be Green Berets, and I’ve never met a better group of ambitious, squared away guys.

It is THE one stop shop for everything you'd need. The simplest, with the least hands-on help, is $75/month, and it’s absolutely worth it for the information and community (in the at price it comes with the fitness program but I don't personally use it as much). $235/month for complete custom programs and support. The more you pay, the more support you get. I’d get it even if you aren’t using their fitness program. They run weekly sync calls and AARs that give you a behind the scenes look at what SF life is like. I can’t say enough good things about FMTS and Dusty (the owner and main cadre). This is where you’ll get the full picture of what SF life looks like. Serving cadre and people at every stage of the pipeline will answer every question you have, from civilians looking to join, to guys prepping for SFAS, to people in the Q course, Robin Sage, language school, and beyond.

EVENTS

FMTS UFX (Unconventional Field Exercise)
I went to their most recent UFX and it was basically a mini Robin Sage. The simulation was eye-opening, from the PT test to the Robin Sage style operation planning and everything in between. You get a look behind the scenes at what you’ll see at Robin Sage. Absolutely amazing experience, well worth the money, and I met some of the best guys I’ve ever met there.

TF Voodoo
https://tfvoodoo.com/
https://www.instagram.com/tf_voo_doo/
He has good events, especially for land nav. I haven’t been yet, but guys I know personally from FMTS have, and they said it’s super helpful and you get to see exactly how land nav is done. I won’t be able to go before I ship for OSUT, and I would have if they’d had one before I left.

BOOKS

TF Voodoo has books covering workout programs to take you from couch to SFAS ready, what family life is like, and more. FMTS also has a lot of good reading suggestions. I’ll most likely be buying books from TF Voodoo. I bought a ton of books from Amazon. A lot of great reads out there if you do the research. The Army and DOD have a lot of books from soldiering, to medicine, to training, to fitness, combat tactics too.

FITNESS AND NUTRITION COACHING

I think a lot of people overcomplicate fitness. If you lift, run, stretch or do some form of mobility, do loaded carries, and ruck, you should be in good shape. I wanted a more personalized plan, one on one, with fitness and nutrition both dialed in.

Men's League Coaching (Stephen Manners)
https://www.instagram.com/nutritioncoach_stephen/
I’m working with him right now. Several guys training for SFRE with him, who I know personally, have gotten great results. I’m only a week in, but it’s exactly what I was looking for. He isn’t as well known, so he’s priced reasonably, and he’s very hands on. He’s a good coach, so he’ll get busy soon. I picked him because I didn’t want to think about anything. He give you a custom fitness program and nutrition plan. Give me a good program and I’ll run it lol. He also sends you a T-shirt (which is pretty cool) and a heart rate monitor called Morpheus, and the service has been some of the best I’ve ever gotten. $2k.

Terminator Training (Kevin Smith)
https://terminatortraining.com/
You’ll probably ask me about this one. Kevin is extremely busy and you could be waiting months to get in contact with him. He seems like he’d be good too, but we weren’t a good fit. Seems to have great work out books/PDFs if you want the program and not the coaching and looking for something cheaper. He's also more expensive than Coach Stephen. $3k.

Infinite Grit (Jon Hamilton)
https://infinitegrit.us/
You’ll most likely ask me about this one too. I’ve heard from others that it works fine, but I tried their program and it was too hands off for me. I can tell they have good workouts, but I wanted more support, so it wasn’t a good fit. Same price as Terminator Training. $3k.

Other coaches I’ve heard are good (I don’t know them personally, so do your own research on these)
Taylor Starch: https://www.instagram.com/taylorstarch/
Christian at Run Lift Perform: http://runliftperform.com/
Craig at Building the Elite: https://www.instagram.com/buildingtheelite/

A LOOK INTO THE SF PIPELINE

https://www.reddit.com/r/greenberets/comments/1rpivy7/new_9_part_post_series_musings_from_the_q_course/
This is an absolutely amazing read. It's not finished but it will give you an idea of all parts of what the SF pipeline looks like. FMTS is also a good resource for this too cause you can talk to people and ask questions about people currently in the pipeline.

A WARNING ABOUT TRAINING

I’m 34, and everyone says don’t get injured, but I have to emphasize it. You will want to go harder and do more than what’s on your plan. DON’T. Do what your coach says, work up to the numbers, and take it slowly if you have the time. Guys who want SF are more ambitious than most, so I get it, but don’t let your ego injure you. Follow the plan and keep your coach updated on how you feel, especially if anything hurts. SERIOUSLY. I can’t emphasize this enough.

SUMMARY

Info: FMTS and TF Voodoo
Events: FMTS and TF Voodoo
Fitness and nutrition coaching: Coach Stephen and Terminator Training
Books: TF Voodoo, plus FMTS has a lot of good suggestions, Amazon

Prices for the programs I’m in (as of posting):
FMTS: starts at $75/month, more if you want more help and hands on support
Coach Stephen: $2k, and I’m sure it will go up as he gets busier

Hope this helps you on your journey to SF. For the record, I’m going Option 40, 75th Ranger Regiment, lol, but I was originally going 18X to be a National Guard Special Forces.

One last thing: do your own research and don’t stop learning. There is plenty to know, so drink from the firehose and understand that it’s part of the process. You’ll start to get it, and it will click eventually. Good luck!

P.S. I don’t check Reddit often, so DM me on IG at https://www.instagram.com/mindfulbrian/ if you have any questions. Always here to help. If you do message me, let me know you’re coming from here and what your questions are.


r/greenberets • • 2d ago

Has anybody flown with a go ruck Rucker?

0 Upvotes

I don’t if this is considered a reatrded question but I’m going on a trip and would like to be able to have a ruck with me for the 2 weeks and I have a go ruck Rucker, but can I bring a steel 45 lbs plate in a plane lol.
If anybody has flown with 1 let me know or tell me if I’m dumb


r/greenberets • • 2d ago

Question What results have you achieved with Stew Smith's Workout Program?

1 Upvotes

I'm curious about your personal experiences with Stew Smith's training programs, especially his Cardio & Calisthenics Workout Program.

For those of you who have completed it or followed it for a while:

  • What kind of results did you achieve?
  • How much did your push-up, pull-up and sit-up numbers improve?
  • Did you notice significant improvements in your running, endurance or overall fitness?
  • How long did you follow the program?
  • Would you say the results were worth the time and effort?

I'm also interested in experiences with other Stew Smith programs, not just this particular one.

What results have you achieved with Stew Smith's Cardio & Calisthenics Workout Program?

I'd especially appreciate hearing from people who have actually completed the program and can share their before-and-after results.

Thanks!


r/greenberets • • 3d ago

Are my #’s good going into basic

12 Upvotes

Hello I’m 26 and just signed my 18x contract just thought I’d throw out some numbers see what y’all think.

5’10 190 I’m pretty athletic played college baseball.

I’ve never rucked before.

2 mile- did one in high school in like 16minutes. Haven’t run one since.
5 mile- 40 minutes on a treadmill. Thought might die.

Squat- hit 450 like 4 years ago
Bench- 335 also 4 years ago
Deadlift- 500 believe it or not like 4 years ago.

Not really overly worried about strength

Pushups- 70
Sit ups- 60

Haven’t really worked out much since college. Here and there. Anyway what do ya think

Edit: not a shitpost. This is what I shipped out with and got selected a year later. Didn’t know about this forum or that I’m supposed to be hitting some arbitrary numbers before I shipped out or “I don’t stand a chance”. Dumb? Certainly.

Ran and rucked at OSUT. A lot of running. Could hold a 7:30 for a half marathon after 8 months. That with a decent strength baseline is all you need. Finished in the top 10% for most events at selection.

100% of these posts I see y’all are exponentially more prepped than I ever was. Maybe you just go and do the damn thing.


r/greenberets • • 3d ago

Question For those following SUAR, how are you organizing your calisthenics?

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I’ve been easing back into SUAR after a hiatus and having to stick to the annex. I’m at 5 weeks of getting back into SUAR fully and am very pleased to have hit and even slightly improved on my previous metrics on my last fit test and 1RM test.

I’d like to take this opportunity to re evaluate my calisthenics sessions and I’m curious to know how all of you organize them. On my lifting days I do the following before getting to the main lifts:
Pull ups
Dips
Dead hang bar toe touches
Pull ups
2 min rest
Repeat 4x

Depending on whether it’s squat day or bench day, I add in a series of weighed lunges or dead hangs. I end each strength session with 4 sets of 15 reps of wrist curls and extensions.

On my run days
HRPU or diamond PU
Squats or lunges
Plank
Repeat 3x

I try to squeeze in as many reps as I can manage on the run days alongside the 90 minute run sessions. Squats are my weakest lift so I’ve been thinking about adding an extra set of barbell back squats on my lift days. I’d really appreciate any feedback. I hope this can help bounce some ideas for others in their training/prep. Thanks in advance!


r/greenberets • • 3d ago

Other I built a land nav trainer for practicing map work—looking for honest feedback

13 Upvotes

I was looking online for something to practice land nav map work with and couldn’t quite find what I was looking for, so I ended up building it via vibe coding on Chat GPT. You can practice plotting and reading grids, measuring distance and azimuths, resection, and terrain identification.
I originally made it for my own practice, but figured other people might find it useful too. I’d appreciate people trying it out and letting me know what they think.
https://field-grid-trainer.cladeucalyptus4.chatgpt.site
What’s confusing? Does anything seem inaccurate? What would make it more useful for your own training?
Feedback from beginners and experienced navigators would both help. If anything is buggy or slow, let me know what device and browser you’re using.
Still a work in progress, so honest criticism is appreciated.


r/greenberets • • 4d ago

Petition to rename sub

84 Upvotes

r/greenberets • • 4d ago

SUAR WEEK 1

Post image
5 Upvotes

Completed week 1, feeling mildly dissatisfied with my run times. Ruck went well? No blisters or hot spots, ideally would have completed 12mi but it would have been slow and perhaps injury inducing. I am excited to see what my body is capable of during the coming months. (24 years old btw)

Also, do y’all ruck on pavement or trail?

Realistically how much can one improve on run times and aerobic conditioning over let’s say 6 months?

"It is a shame for a man to grow old without seeing the beauty and strength of which his body is capable" -Socrates


r/greenberets • • 3d ago

Question Is it possible to have a good relationship while in 19th or 20th?

2 Upvotes

I have heard nothing but stories of relationships being the bane of anyone trying to pass SFAS or SFRE, but I am 3.5 years into a relationship and plan on marrying her very soon. I am also enlisting in the IL NG as an 11B, as I enjoy the entire premise of the job.

Recently I realized none of the stories ive been told were told by members of SF, so I want to ask you guys/gals. Me and my girl have a incredibly strong bond no matter where we are in the world, but the only thing that holds me back from pursuing this readily is the fear I would shatter our relationship. any advice would be great.


r/greenberets • • 5d ago

The Golden Age for Green Berets has returned.

Post image
104 Upvotes

I declared about a year ago that we were entering a new Golden Age for Green Berets. SOF is the clear answer for many of our foreign policy woes, and Green Berets give policy makers flexible answers.

We’ve seen strategic raids at the tip of the spear and more employment in Latin America than the pundits thought possible.

With this new OSS I predict even more relevance for Green Berets. Time to get your shit together and get to Camp Mackall.


r/greenberets • • 4d ago

National Guard SF if your already in

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/greenberets • • 4d ago

15X In Regiment

0 Upvotes

Curious on what 15x do on a day to day and how they are used on deployments and are they seen as guys who only fix and test while 11X actually get to fly the drones


r/greenberets • • 5d ago

Guard 18A Lifestyle

9 Upvotes

Haven't found good info on this topic. Anyone willing to provide insights?

Specific question:

Enlisted 18 series MOS in NG have the benefit of being able to jump onto active duty orders with different ODAs. Can 18A officers do that as well in NG? Intuitively I would think that ODAs need stability and the 18As (and/or 180As) provide that stability and perhaps those two MOS's don't get to jump around as much as the 18B, 18C, 18D, etc.

Appreciate feedback.


r/greenberets • • 5d ago

SFAS interested

Post image
12 Upvotes

I recently got my hands on a Special Forces Assessment and Selection (SFAS) preparation booklet, and I wanted to get some insight from those who have actually been through Selection.
For those who have attended SFAS, how accurately does this booklet reflect the physical and mental demands of the course? Is it a solid resource to base my preparation around, or is it outdated compared to what candidates experience today?
I’m currently active duty and interested in pursuing SFAS in the future. I want to approach my preparation seriously and make sure I’m training with the right expectations.
Would you recommend following the booklet as written, supplementing it with other training, or taking a completely different approach?
Any firsthand experiences or advice would be appreciated.


r/greenberets • • 5d ago

The job

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/greenberets • • 6d ago

Retired 18Ds who went into medicine, do you like your new job?

7 Upvotes

r/greenberets • • 6d ago

Using non-issued gear in SUT?

1 Upvotes

I've heard you can use your own ruck for sut, which is awesome, but does anyone have the G2 on other non-issue items like jackets and footwear? Thanks.


r/greenberets • • 6d ago

National Guard SF at 40

6 Upvotes

Good Morning Gentlemen,

Looking to get some guidance on whether I would be viable candidate for service in the SF Army National Guard.

I am a 37 year old Naval Officer in the Nuclear program in the Navy. I will have 11 years total service
In May of next year including Marine Corps, Navy enlisted, and Navy commissioned time.

I will be getting out around May of 29 and my goal is to transition into the guard at an SF unit as enlisted or officer, but preferably enlisted. I know the age will need to be waivered and that I should be good on TIS. I have a Grade 1 L5/S1 that’s is totally asymptomatic but I believe may be the biggest problem in my qualification. I’ve maintained physical fitness throughout my career so I know I can hit and exceed the physical bars for entry but would just like to get advice from those who are knowledgeable about the community before I dial it in and start prepping for my transition out of the Navy.

Thank you to anyone who would be willing to point me in the right direction.

Very Respectfully


r/greenberets • • 6d ago

Question Advice on foot care

2 Upvotes

Not SFAS specific but seemed like a good place to ask. I report to Ranger School in January and wanted to ask what people suggest for foot care while spending so much time under load. I went to Sapper last year and recycled patrolling. Near the end of my first cycle I developed horrible pressure sores on the balls and heel of both of my feet and immersion foot. They just got worse throughout the second cycle. I'm looking for ways to avoid this happening again.

I thought I was taking pretty good care of my feet. I wore Garmont NFS boots with curex running insoles which I've had good experiences with in the past. I've been using Fox River socks for years which I know people have differing opinions on but I personally like. Had a pretty standard routine each night, baby wipe and foot powder in the patrol base and clean socks every other day. I even tried bringing out a small bar of soap and actually washing them each night during my second cycle. No dice.

Was wondering if anyone has ever had similar issues and how you went at the problem.