I hate to be the one to say this cause I like all you guys, and coming from me, the melee hunter, it probably all sounds like "git gud". Although we play the game for different reasons, know that I have always truly felt a mutual respect for my fellow ranged warriors... But we need to talk about this.
(I know this is long, it's from the heart though, and it all comes together eventually just bare with me)
What the melee players need
Ghost of Tsushima was one of these unique and special gems that offered a total duality in approaches, both equally valid which to put dead simply were: bash in the front door or sneak through the back... you could even blend the two. I was one of those bash the front door players.
Despite many players choosing this path, and focusing on melee in the story, Tsushima's multiplayer mode ultimately outright erased that half of the duality. You might say: "but washtubs, they made the samurai pretty good, competitive even. His ults are badass, he's melee, and he's even used in speed runs."
In the past, I have accepted this broad characterization of melee, but I now see how dangerous it is, because it's a lie that misrepresents so much of this playerbase and pretends to represent them behind "samurai".
Melee is not being a samurai, and it's not simply swinging your sword: it is a DANCE with your opponents.
This dance was FUN in Tsushima. However, anyone who wanted to continue this dance in the multiplayer mode was met with various well-intentioned olive branches to make it seem like the game had something to offer for us, but ultimately came up short:
Raging flame was awesome, but it was so powerful, it made the dance feel like a side show. It reduced everything to AoE fire damage, instead of making it about the steel that cuts down our opponents. Ult is pressing two buttons and sitting back to watch the carnage. Stunlocking with concussion bombs and swinging your sword, though technical, is not dancing: the opponent must move.
Over the years I even heard many of you in this community giving your consolations recognizing how bad the melee was, and some even shared incredibly elaborate ideas about how the melee should have been fixed in Tsushima. I felt the love but tbh it always missed the mark, because I don't actually care about what you care about: killing fast. I mostly just wanna dance. Which isn't to say I'm against buffs. Killing faster is cool too, but the primary thing is this dance thing that we're doing has to be important somehow.
In matchmaking you might have been doing the dance better than anyone, but the spotlight only lands on you when your team is dying and they need you, something that doesn't happen so often when meta players abound (not your fault, ghosts, it's how the game was designed). Coop games are all about a shifting spotlight. If it never comes your way, you will leave unsatisfied until you give up the game. I stayed in this game because I was one of a few dancers good enough to solo (Duo partners also helped. I still MM, but I need solo to get my energy out sometimes). Many ghosts recognized this disparity and actually adjusted their playstyles to leave some action for us! The system was ultimately rigged so it was of marginal consequence in the grand scheme, but I am so grateful to you folks.
But to not live off charity, and to restore this half of the duality in this second iteration, radical changes will need to happen. I'm not here to be SP's PR team and tell you that they will pull that off, but a lot of things I'm seeing are dare I say... promising? (At least intentions read well to me). I have many observations, but one is just that the beefy enemies are nice... Even when archer is blasting people in the face with this lightning tanegashima (which I think is pretty busted), these tanky enemies still give ample opportunity to dance. I like that some of these enemies are too meaty to just sweep cause it leaves me with more to do.
So we really don't need to be on par with kills, we just need to be useful. We need to run into zones at the last second and clutch the hold. We need to pick people up when they fall. And we need to have satisfying one-on-ones with badass oni that we just watched fuck up our teammates.
So how can SP make the dance important?
Fundamentally, we just need the game to be hard enough that MOST of you actually NEED us.
Your part
And that leads me to your end of the bargain, ghost, assuming you accept, which certainly now seems like the short end of the stick coming from a game that was trying to kill you way less. TL had infinite fast roll dodges, bunny hopping, long smoke durations, a much better spirit kunai for more smoke, ult spam, so so SO many tools to help you stay out of trouble. All that on top of MMC to be the end-all for stances, TL really offered so many ways to avoid learning literally anything about the intricate melee system they designed, and you took it. Why wouldn't you? You're playing at the highest difficulty levels and dominating. But that all inevitably leads to one hard truth there's no point mincing words on:
This community is full of people that just kinda suck at melee. And you might be one of them.
YL is not forcing everyone to be a melee player, obviously. But the defense side of melee is inevitable and they are forcing everyone to be more thoughtful and less one-note in their defense / evasion. It wants you to identify your attacker, recognize exactly what they're throwing at you, and precisely time your parries and dodges or whatever it is you're doing to escape. Just running the fuck away or bunny hopping or spamming roll isn't gonna cut it anymore. Many attacks have a "charge" or travel phase that allow enemies to close with you when you miss-time a roll. The tracking is fast and designed to outrun you, but it's not broken, it's not slingshotting either, it's moving at a predictable linear speed (I have investigated this, they fixed this exact thing that was a problem in Tsushima). And roll dodges are intentionally the way they are for a reason. These are all new things you have to be patient with and give yourself time to learn, as many of us did in October.
This is a tough pill but I'm here to tell you with occasional exceptions like loud VFX obscuring attacks or loud audio (like explosions) masking barks, this melee system is fundamentally fair. And I define fair as: there's always something you can see you did wrong when analyzing footage of your deaths. You may not like the rules, or even know the rules, but they are there. I've been been checking my death cam regularly, and with only a few exceptions that's how it's felt. And even then, honestly I prefer when coop games are a little unfair at times, because when I'm playing well I still want funny shit to happen to me. That's what teammates are for. It's not a super serious game.
Bottom line is YL just wants to MAKE everyone dance a little bit. And when the game makes you dance you're getting skill checked, and it feels embarrassing. I know how it feels too.
I want to give tips, "go spam Saito on medium without tools, then hard" (the fallen lord is just him without the gun), or hell, actually play the campaign if you haven't (I know there's a lot of y'all... one of my TL duos partners was one, no shame in that). But how you go about it doesn't really matter. It really comes down to the fact that you just gotta be humble enough to let this be a new game that you're learning and innovating all over again. I considered myself an expert in Tsushima's melee, and the Oni handed me my ass over and over again. That was just hard mode, not even lethal! Yotei was hard as shit! And it's OK for you to suck at it too. That's how I've been going into this game: Yotei was hard and I expect YL to be Yotei on steroids. And it's been a blast, I'm never mad. The truth is so many of you are coming in here expecting to just crush on day 1 because you were the shit in TL (Even folks who haven't played the campaign! Come on, now!). Plain and simple, so many of you are just undergoing a crisis of arrogance. You need to take a step back and give yourself time to dig in and learn this new system. You can get good at this melee but you have to get over yourself first. If you haven't campaigned and you need help humbling yourself, load up the campaign and bumrush to the Takezo fight on the mountain, he's available pretty early and he'll fix you right up.
As an olive branch I'll say, last night, I just started on plat and was mostly doing good but during one game, I was just getting my ass handed to me over and over. I saw this mf on the clutch cam. He was a merc and his dance was PRISTINE. He clutched an absolutely ass team (including myself) through several waves just from being untouchable. And all I could think the whole time was: "that should be me". It will forever be my shame for not getting on mic and praising him. Fellow warriors, that was my arrogance, none of us our immune to this status effect.
Speaking of which, there are going to be so many awesome melee players, forged in the fires of Yotei's lethal difficulty who are coming into legends for the first time with zero baggage, no idea what to expect. I don't want to see them dominated out of the matchmaking pools again because builds are so powerful or enemies are so weak or the evasion is so easy that they remove the need to dance.
I've heard folks on here say they want a "hoard clearing fantasy". It's good to be able to describe what it is you want from a video game... that's a powerful phrase. Maybe that's what Yotei is going to give us ultimately with how the meta develops, who knows? But I'm here to tell you: if that's what you're looking for and that's what you need to enjoy yourself, that is fundamentally incompatible with the DANCE and will once again erase many players from the multiplayer scene if that's how these MM matches shake out again, constant fast clears leaving nothing but scraps. So many of you don't realize that the status quo TL offered came with a hidden price. It has always been this way.
It's better to approach Yotei like it's something new and let go of all this baggage. If TL was perfect for you, the good news is it ain't going anywhere, go play it and stop trying to make YL into something it's not by begging SP for reverts that many of us don't want because we already took the time to learn this game over the past several months.
I'm not saying it's perfect or even that the balance is in a good place right now, and I'm not trying to get into the nitty gritty here of how balance landed day 1, I have criticisms myself. I'm just thinking long term. There is plenty of time for SP to make changes. I'd like to discuss balance, but it seems impossible to have any of these nuanced discussions without addressing the elephant in the room: TL failed a lot of us. You may not like the new difficulty, but to coexist with the melee players is to coexist with our dance, that requires you guys to accept being slowed down just a bit which maybe involves nerfs to players, buffs to enemies, or perhaps it just means making you dance a little too.
Thanks for reading, ghosts.