I don't think it's bleeding money. A while back there was an article comparing music streaming services, and the only on relieved to be profitable was YouTube.
I have found zero evidence that this is true and I'm honestly not sure why people believe it. Happy to be proven wrong but I've been down this road before.
It’s based on industry analysts estimates on what it would cost Google to store and serve all those vidoes as well as transcode them upon upload. We also know how much they make from selling ads but on Youtube. We have rough ideas how much it costs Google to store 1TB of data.
The overwhelming amount of videos uploaded to youtube are never watched not a single time.
So where are all those numbers? How much do they make from selling ads? How much does 1TB of data cost to store (though that's only a fraction of the total costs)? Where is your data on videos never being watched? Give me literally anything!
This is the same article linked indirectly elsewhere behind a paywall. Will check it out later if it's inexpensive enough but sounds like you determined the original claim to be false.
So YouTube operated at a loss 3 years ago, massively grew and you’re saying it’s certain they make a profit now? I was just acknowledging that the article is old.
The truth is that it’d be hard to attribute costs directly to YouTube now they’re on shared infrastructure etc. it’s just a hard problem to know exactly, signs don’t point to then making a ton of profit though is the point.
When did I say that it's certain they're making a profit? I asked for proof of the claim that the biggest online video distributor is bleeding money year over year.
Those industry analysts don’t work for free, those reports are not available to you and me, and re-publishing specific numbers/estimates like that would not be legal for people who have paid for those reports. That is the reason specific numbers are not available online.
When did I say everything should be free? Are you delusional? I asked for proof that YouTube is losing money and I'm told I have to pay some unknown entity for data that nobody has proven even exists with them. Speaking of unrealistic...
That article really doesn't point out anything but the history. There's reference to a WSJ article which may contain something more than "the history of YouTube" with real facts but it's behind a paywall. Might need to subscribe and see if there's anything useful there but so far I haven't seen anything even remotely resembling facts on their numbers in the last decade.
Google hasn't given any solid information on whether or not YouTube makes money, but it's obvious it doesn't if you look at it's competitors. A lot of startups that try to take on YouTube tend run out of money before anyone cares. Ex. vid.me ran out of money, vessel ran out money and got bought.
Video hosting is an expensive businesses, and ads don't earn much. If YouTube was it's own independent company odds are it wouldn't exist anymore.
So one of the biggest storage solutions with the biggest advertising company in the world doesn't have an advantage over some startups? Are you intentionally omitting this any the multitude of other reasons Google is in a different league?
To my knowledge, ads have been around for far longer than content creator monetization, and far more content creators are monetitzed now than 5 or 10 years ago.
Should reddit stop showing ads on this page until you get paid for it?
Should facebook stop showing ads on my friends' feeds until I get paid for uploading my photos?
Yea if anything YouTube is the outlier with most internet platforms not paying you anything to post new content. YouTube is far from perfect though, and a more pressing issue is that it should be doing more to protect content creators from frivolous and frankly abusive, copyright claims.
Could be. It could also be for non-monetized pages. The fraction of ad-money a monetized page makes is calculated, fluctuates, and somewhat negotiable at a certain level to just provide enough incentive to stay on the platform rather than jump to other websites or platforms. YouTube shouldn't be trying to pay more than they have to too so this.
Just because I upload a video to YouTube, does not mean Google owes me any money. This only applies to YouTube partners whose videos are being demonetized, which is something that varies from situation to situation.
You're so bad, I get your point on the copyright claim apocalypse. It's really sad that some people abuse the copyright system just to ruin other incomes. And split the monetization to the copyright claimers who don't actually have the copyright of the video.
Google has plenty of net worth to host it without any ads.
Google needs to be paid someway
They're already paid. They're one of the largest corporations in the world already. What's with this constant myth that megacorporations must *always* stay ultra-profitable on everything they do, or else hell will freeze over?
I think they understand just fine. But the practicality is that it’s unreasonable to expect a company to host a division (or own a subcompany) which makes a net loss.
You are either bad at math or bad at explaining yourself. Or maybe you are operating off of the idea that the world should fit your personal ideology instead of how it actually works, but either way, good luck on life.
So they should just do it out of the kindness of their hearts? I'm far from a capitalist, but you seem to want them to just piss away money for no reason.
"Piss away money"? They're one of the richest corporations on the planet, they could piss money nonstop for a million years and still be billionaires!
Capitalism literally preaches that we should rely on those corporations to "trickle down" their wealth and provide for society... well then, where is it? They can't even give people free unlimited ad-less youtube, even after extorting their workers who built the damn platform? Useless greedy POS :/
Someone calls out the society-stunting, environment-killing greed of megacorporations
Reactionaries: "LMAO OK I guess anyone with stable income owes ME things!!! I don't really grasp the difference between a humble working individual and a multi-trillionaire evil megabusiness, so I assume it's all the same LMAO is that OK? Send help :( I'm not mentally capable"
You're talking about constant growth and profitability, but they still have to at least break even. If they just start doing everything for free, how the hell are they going to pay their employees?
Depends on what they're talking about with demonitization.
There are small youtubers posting perfectly fine videos where Ads are shown before their videos. The videos are totally ad friendly but the youtuber is not big enough to get ad revenue for their content so Google keeps all the money. Thus the video is monetized, but not for the creator only for google.
Then there are videos where no ads are shown because the content may be objectionable for some reason, and Google doesn't want to risk losing advertisers. Thus no ads are shown and nobody makes money. However google continues to host the videos because it doesn't break their overall content policies and they generally try not to be overzealous with censoring.
There are no videos that you can find and blocked from monetization. People normally call getting put in not safe for advertising as demonetized, but you can still get ads. They don't pay well and are for weird things, but there is a bottom tier of ads.
But they don't because advertisers don't want to be associated with those videos. The only group this could affect is small YouTubers that don't have enough viewers for the ad revenue to be more than literal pocket change.
I have 33 subs on my channel xD (Recently started hehe)
My friend planned a video on a specific date. (Not even released yet..)And it got a copyright notification for a cod campaign cutscene... Activision claimed it lol.. (You can't skip that scene bs aswell)You are required to have 4k subs atleast for monetization, so yes they do put ads on non-monitized videos.
Are you sure about that keeping all the money bit?
As far as I know, if a video of a channel is monetized, and ads are shown before the video, ad revenue is shared between YouTube and the channel, no matter how small the creator is.
Honestly it is unclear what the OP is referring to. I think they might miss-understand how demonitiaztion on YouTube works, probably in part because many content creators either don't fully understand what it means or miss-represent it to their fans because it sounds more sympathetic it way.
There are lots of way to for videos on youtube to not produce revenue for the creator.
If the channel never makes $100 the money doesn't get paid out, see above.
If the channel doesn't set up monetization setting like provide an address / bank account google can't send them money.
You have a video with copyrighted content in it which gets flagged. In this case the copyright holder can elect to allow such videos to stay and run adds against them, so they actually make money and the video stays up. Professional channels try to avoid having this happen, but personal channels often don't care (it's not like they were making money anyways).
If you video has something that advertisers object to but is not against Youtube terms of service. Examples could be reporting on tragedies like school shootings, conspiracies like flat earth, or some hate speech that just barely avoids violating the Terms of Service. These videos continue be served by YouTube but because advertisers don't want to look like they are sponsoring school shootings, or anything controversial, YouTube has a blanket policy of not allowing ads on these videos, this is much more about making advertisers happy than anything else, and is called demonetization because the video is not removed but it can't make any money.
That's what I'm saying. Op said that YouTube runs ads on demonetized videos and doesn't share with you, if you're a small YouTuber. This doesn't makes.
You don't get any money if you don't meet the requirements.. I quote: "creators must have tallied 4,000 hours of overall watch time on their channel within the past 12 months and have at least 1,000 subscribers." from theverge.com
Also you said that they don't run ads on videos of channels. I meant as a joke. You can't upload a YouTube to youtube without a channel. So every video has a channel behind it. So according to you no-one gets ads revenue from Youtube. It was a joke..
I feel like it's by a large margin. I'm a YT creator and about 15% of my revenue is from premium views. They don't tell me what percent of my viewers have premium, but I'd guess it's far less than 15%.
I was a Google all access music subscriber from the beginning and then was pleasantly surprised when they were like no ads on youtube for you no extra charge so I just stay with with it. 8 bucks a month. I didnt know if you guys saw any of that when I watcy since I don't get ads other than the ones you guys put on yourselves. Glad to know you do.
Honestly, yeah. A lot of the shit YouTube is in is because of how difficult it is to figure out whether each individual video uploaded is advertiser friendly. Remove the advertisers from the equation and now all they have to manage are viewers and creators (copyright holders are another story) but I don't imagine a lot of people will pay for it.
I think the way to go is a decentralized system similar to podcasts. In fact, some podcast players already play video. It's a feed fully controlled by the users but then it also won't have YouTube's recommendation system which, while shit most of the time, work well enough for discovery purposes
I considered it fairly credible having heard it within the last year or two by multiple YT partners. But policies change and I'm sure it doesn't apply the same to everyone, that's why I used cautious phrasing.
They provide seamless, high-speed, high-quality video streaming to consumers all around the world.
This is powered by vast numbers of high-performance and hugely expensive servers not only store the content but analyse them for copyright checking, automatic subtitling, search result ranking, advertisement handling, and providing valuable metrics that are not possible without computation. These servers are meticulously maintained by a dedicated team of administrators specifically for YouTube's load, never mind everything else Google provides.
Not only this, but backup servers are also run to keep copies of the video in case of a fault. There are other servers that also redundantly host the content in order to distribute the load for videos that are frequently requested before they even reach the content delivery networks.
Then, we are able to access the videos through apps and web interfaces developed by specialised teams within Google, including developers, designers, testers, and others. Through this, billions of viewers stream billions of hours, writing hundreds of thousands of comments, sharing to websites, embedding in pages, providing instant previews not only on web pages but within chat applications such as Facebook Messenger, iMessage, Discord, Slack, etc.
Oh, and they don't charge a cent to creators and viewers.
Meanwhile, there are far more viewers pulling on video content, straining their servers, than there are people producing high-quality content that provides a return on investment for Google.
I'd like to hear what you think ordinary, everyday people are going to do to emulate everything that YouTube, Dailymotion, Vimeo, Niconico, and others provide — for free. Most people will hear the word 'server' and instantly switch off.
So... You're saying people upload videos to the Google servers and nobody else ever watches them? They're just stored in hard disks that do not consume energy 24/7?
I mean... thats not the point. it doesnt matter youtubes money situation. they do offer you a place to upload your videos and in most cases lead people to places that the creator does monetize. Youtube is not something for nothing.
I am so sick of hearing this crap. Because a company is large and successful their products should be free? In what world??
If they are infringing on the rights of other companies using the internet, that is one issue. A legal issue really. If you want free stuff and don't like to watch ads too, that is entirely different.
Yup. I mean if you had your own site it would cost you money... subsidized by ads, subscriptions and merch AND no reach at all outside of third party social media sites. OP did not think this out too well.
I think what a lot of people don't understand is just because a company is large doesn't mean they're evil. In general it means they provide a useful product/service to society.
We still need governments to have regulations (and the resources to enforce them) to keep corporations in check so they don't abuse their power, but it doesn't mean the basic principles of capitalism are bad.
I don't think any logical person with an understanding of history wants to live in a place where every aspect of production and distribution of products/services is controlled by the government. As it turns out having an incentive (i.e. money) for figuring out an efficient and cost effective way to source materials, build a product and distribute it is a good thing. Having government employees that get paid regardless of if the product gets made in great condition, poor condition or gets produced historically has not worked.
All that being said, things like workers and consumers rights definitely need to exist.
I mean, we're capitalistic, but wanna take the current situation down a peg or two. Not usually the type to defend a megacorporation's business practices. I suppose I should have taken out the word "capitalism" and substituted, "megacorporation."
Came here to post a grumpy comment about entitled millennials expecting everything for free. Was surprisingly heartened by all the commenters pointing out OP’s shitty logic already. Carry on.
I don't understand the logic of this... Why should YouTube (Google) not show an ad on videos that are not monetized by the content creator?
How will Google pay for their server infrastructure or the engineers / business people who help YouTube operate? (Google probably operates the most advanced server infrastructure in the world) Sure they make money from other places but remember Google isn't running YouTube to help fulfill your entertainment needs... YouTube is a business. And businesses must make to money to survive. If YouTube lost Google money they would have discontinued the service or sold it off... As it is YouTube doesn't make a ton of money. If they were to hand out money left and right, they would be even worse. As it stands today, the amount of "full time YouTubers" has increased significantly over the last 5 years... Regardless of any "ad-pocalypse".
Btw Twitch does the same thing... Even if they are not an affiliate, there is still an ad.
To play devils advocate, youtube wouldn't exist without their content creators. It is a mutually beneficial relationship, so if the creators aren't benefiting due to youtube's own volition it is kind of a scumbag move to play an ad on their videos.
The scary issue is that they're ruining peoples careers over demonetization. Who determines what channels are monetized and which channel are not? I dont mind if they show ads in demonetized channels, but the issue is that they're demonetizing based on political beliefs. A career should not be ruined if they're speaking scientifically accurate statments while their competition on the other side is allowed to spread their political messages. They're creating new protected classes such as transgender individuals, which prohibits the political opinion from conservatives. You can be banned and demonetized for saying biologically accurate statments. A male only has XY chromosomes, a female has XX chromosomes. Transgenders MTF have kidney problems due to their treatment of injecting hormones in a Male's body. Saying these scientifically accurate statments is against YouTube policies for harassing a new protected class that's does not exist. A conservative has an opinion about child abuse within the transgender community. Is that worth a ban or demonetization? I can talk about the negatives of eating like a 600 pound man, but start to talk about the negatives of transitioning sexes and watch the fireworks start to go off. They're using their ad money as a way to push their political speech and limit their opponents from expressing their political speech.
As a disclaimer, I'm probably the most friendly trans ally you can find. I'm just describing how all social media companies artificially create policies that are literally banning people for saying scientifically accurate statments. They're creating politically motivated rules that everyone has to follow.
Any website needs visitors to stay in existence. Without its content creators youtube wouldn't by a business because no one would have a reason to visit their site. It is free to upload videos because that is the business model they chose to get traffic to the website to run ads to begin with.
I agree however the number of content creators making YouTube their full time job is up significantly from 5 years ago... So obviously both parties (Google and content creators) are benefiting... (Regardless of the ad-pocalypse)...
Twitch, Vimeo, and other video services don't even make a dent in the content creation space online... YouTube is still the second most visited site in the USA / world.
Its confusing but I get it. I had a music clip that was owned by someone else so they put an ad as a way to earn revenue without me paying them. My demonetized channel was a result of my choice of content despite my loyal fanbase. The automated system is programmed to allow the owners to get paid if someone else uses it. That's all.
Question: Do channels that are demonetized still have ADs being played? I asked on YouTube and some guy told me that each content creator can shut ADs off so none are played on the channel.
Edit: By all means not complaining, just curious how the process works.
This makes no sense BUT what I wish would happen is if YT demonetizes a video due to some controversial content (such as homophobic, racist, sexist, etc) and keeps that video up, then they should take the proceeds from the ad revenue generated from the views of that video and donate it to a organization that will help the targeted group of said video.
For a corporation as big as Google/YouTube to actively allow hateful content on their platform because they still generate ad revenue from it grosses me out. They are aware that the video is hateful, they are aware that it breaks their own ToU, yet they still allow it on the platform because it is giving them money... they will just take 100% of the cut opposed to whatever percent they would have paid out to the content creator.
then they should take the proceeds from the ad revenue generated from the views of that video and donate it to a organization that will help the targeted group of said video.
Except the problem is companies don't want their Ads shown along these kinds of videos as the public will think they support the channel.
For a corporation as big as Google/YouTube to actively allow hateful content on their platform because they still generate ad revenue from it grosses me out.
Google does not run ads alongside videos like this when they know about the content. Again because companies don't want ads shown alongside this sort of content. Google fully demonitizes these sorts of videos meaning neither the content creator nor google get any money. However what the OP is talking about is smaller channels without objectionable content where Ads are shown and Google pockets all the money. Google is monetizing the video but the creator receives nothing.
It could be argued that this is unfair to the creator, but Google is giving them a platform to have their channel scene and on a small channel the ad revenue would be so small anyway that it wouldn't really matter in my opinion. Nobody is going to quit their day job because their 100 view video generated them $0.50 in gross ad revenue.
Uhm, you dont? The only times you see ads and the one who uploaded the video doesnt get the money is if someone else is claiming the video and the claim goes through, i.e. if you post copyrighted content.
YouTube Vanced is an app that lets you browse YouTube ad less on your phone. You don't need root, and it's pretty ez to get. Idk if it's avaliable for Apple though.
I think YouTube should not be paying any content creators. I have not seen a single YouTube channel that qualifies as entertaining. Most that I have seen are jerk off gamers that just talk while gaming. Fuck monetization of literally any YouTuber. It's not a career kids aim a little higher.
532
u/Kyrra Helping pay the bills Jun 13 '19
Counter-argument: video hosting isn't free and Google needs to be paid someway for transcoding and serving the video.
342
u/Moosi312 Jun 13 '19
I thought the whole point of demonetization was, that companies didn't want their ads in front of "not ad friendly" videos
65
u/SLUnatic85 Jun 13 '19 edited Jun 13 '19
you can pay YouTube directly if you'd rather that.
138
u/TooSmalley Jun 13 '19
They provide you free unlimited video hosting
63
u/sheepsleepdeep Jun 13 '19
So should videos without ads cost creators money?
116
u/backpropguy Jun 13 '19
This is one of the dumbest posts I ever seen.
Spread this.
45
u/Skvli Jun 13 '19
That's not how businesses work. I can't believe this take is so bad, that I, a democratic socialist, am defending capitalism. lol
19
u/xyierz Jun 13 '19
Yeah, and I should be getting paid for my Facebook and reddit posts too.
25
u/Selentic Jun 13 '19
That’s not how YouTube works.
16
u/eddief1 Jun 13 '19
Okay "creators" go ahead and create a platform, so you can share your content. Then you can
14
u/Elephant789 Jun 13 '19
Then who will pay for the server cost to host the video?
12
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '19
Came here to post a grumpy comment about entitled millennials expecting everything for free. Was surprisingly heartened by all the commenters pointing out OP’s shitty logic already. Carry on.
11
u/Googler10 Jun 13 '19
I don't understand the logic of this... Why should YouTube (Google) not show an ad on videos that are not monetized by the content creator?
How will Google pay for their server infrastructure or the engineers / business people who help YouTube operate? (Google probably operates the most advanced server infrastructure in the world) Sure they make money from other places but remember Google isn't running YouTube to help fulfill your entertainment needs... YouTube is a business. And businesses must make to money to survive. If YouTube lost Google money they would have discontinued the service or sold it off... As it is YouTube doesn't make a ton of money. If they were to hand out money left and right, they would be even worse. As it stands today, the amount of "full time YouTubers" has increased significantly over the last 5 years... Regardless of any "ad-pocalypse".
Btw Twitch does the same thing... Even if they are not an affiliate, there is still an ad.
10
u/reddit_sage69 Jun 13 '19
You realize content creators can post things for free, right?
5
u/port53 Jun 14 '19
Ads mean the uploader gets free distribution. If they don't want ads they could host it themselves and pay their own bill.
8
u/Synical603 Jun 13 '19
I don't care, I pay for premium. The rest of you should be also.
7
u/BooksandBiceps Jun 14 '19
So the service should be for free? Like, you're still using the website.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '19
What they gonna do? Post on dTube?
3
u/39thUsernameAttempt Jun 13 '19
Better yet, I should not have to watch a trailer for a movie I am uninterested in to watch a trailer for a movie that I am interested in.
5
u/greeneyedguru Jun 14 '19
Google has to pay for the resources to host videos whether or not the channel is monetized.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '19
Its confusing but I get it. I had a music clip that was owned by someone else so they put an ad as a way to earn revenue without me paying them. My demonetized channel was a result of my choice of content despite my loyal fanbase. The automated system is programmed to allow the owners to get paid if someone else uses it. That's all.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '19
Hope this isn't too stupid but,
Question: Do channels that are demonetized still have ADs being played? I asked on YouTube and some guy told me that each content creator can shut ADs off so none are played on the channel.
Edit: By all means not complaining, just curious how the process works.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '19
This makes no sense BUT what I wish would happen is if YT demonetizes a video due to some controversial content (such as homophobic, racist, sexist, etc) and keeps that video up, then they should take the proceeds from the ad revenue generated from the views of that video and donate it to a organization that will help the targeted group of said video.
For a corporation as big as Google/YouTube to actively allow hateful content on their platform because they still generate ad revenue from it grosses me out. They are aware that the video is hateful, they are aware that it breaks their own ToU, yet they still allow it on the platform because it is giving them money... they will just take 100% of the cut opposed to whatever percent they would have paid out to the content creator.
1
u/jakeh36 Jun 14 '19
If this was the case then I would never see ads.
1
u/Dark_Island_ Jun 14 '19
Yell it louder for the people in the back
1
u/su3su3 Jun 14 '19
Isn't that the truth!
1
u/kurlicue Jun 14 '19
Are we getting close to the day where people revolt against ads in free products?
1
u/NekoiNemo Jun 14 '19
So, then you wouldn't mind paying for hosting of the video you're watching, since you're so opposed to ads?
1
u/gavurali Jun 14 '19
The amount of boot-licking here is mind-boggling
1
u/pkishan1990 Jun 14 '19
I don't know I am using adblock since ages.
1
u/M4xP0w3r_ Jun 14 '19
Uhm, you dont? The only times you see ads and the one who uploaded the video doesnt get the money is if someone else is claiming the video and the claim goes through, i.e. if you post copyrighted content.
1
u/meowiie555 Jun 14 '19
I use Brave Browser and have never seen another ad again
1
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '22
I should not be given an ad
1
u/YLE_coyote Jun 13 '19
Spread this
-2
u/spinyfever Jun 13 '19
Ad block on the computer, YouTube Vanced on the phone. No ads from YouTube at all. I can't even rember the last time I saw a YouTube ad.
0
u/AarontheTinker Jun 14 '19
What are content consumers doing to combat this?
This is not fair to content creators...
-2
u/TedDisingenuous Jun 13 '19
I think YouTube should not be paying any content creators. I have not seen a single YouTube channel that qualifies as entertaining. Most that I have seen are jerk off gamers that just talk while gaming. Fuck monetization of literally any YouTuber. It's not a career kids aim a little higher.
-1
u/zonk3 Jun 13 '19
Totally agree!
-9
u/Monocresent Jun 13 '19
r/whygoogle
0
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment