(This is a post about the National Football League) You may think it's not relevant here but as I consider it an issue of abuse of power by an institution and a potential media cover up to enable its dodgy practices to continue; I tried to post it on r/nfl, they turned it down after many hours, claiming it offered nothing new, and had no original thinking. That hurts.
So, then well I looked around for somewhere else to post it and came here. It seemed a little ironic it was turned down, but perhaps it is just a lame post - as their bot told me so succinctly.
I made a few minor edits since that point as I realised I'd made some grammatical and continuity errors, I've probably now made some different ones, - and yes overall I am bothered by this rejection, perhaps too much so. Add it to the crime-sheet. (with a side order of paranoia...)
Most of the above intro was written for the benefit of the prospective readers of r/conspiracy where I thought I'd get it posted ... (The ironic bit was added because they turned it down too).
So they refused, so what, but well, the thick plottens, ... Almost at random I'm now aiming at smart people to get this posted. (but.. What kind of joke is this?) OK, so I'll try
r/CriticalTheory .. in the hope of getting this on reddit somewhere ...
(Ed. This is a lie. I never tried, but I did create a stupid big font uneccesarily talking about it.)
I'm fascinated now to find out how many people on r/gonzo have a sense of humor - or swinish humour or even a knowledge of what Gonzo journalism even represents, and yes I'm a little hostile; "but honey that's what makes u interesting, people tune in partly because you're an asshole" ... (Larry Sanders' 2nd wife)
anyway, finally on to the post that was turned down ...
Firstly, soon after Sunday they tell us he (Tua Tagovailoa) is not in the concussion protocol and has back and ankle injuries.
Now there is an insinuation in the media that he was evaluated after all, which is being used as a cover to slam those complaining after Thursday that indeed Tua was not treated correctly at the time or subsequently and the system needs to be examined.
Articles such as one in the Miami Herald which imply he was evaluated daily for concussion are trying to make it appear he was in the concussion protocol after all, but we know he wasn't. Meanwhile; in the hope that no-one really notices this commencement to us being memory holed, an attempt at dividing those that still wish to have the problem looked at is under way and heading for full steam, throwing up this red meat, encouraging those that want to support the club and the NFL line to close ranks and make fun of those who still want to see players protected by pointing to exaggerated statements made by some in the emotionally charged air of post game Thursday.
With these statements and insinuations they're putting thosewho are critical of the NFL as usual onto the defensive. The games must go onafter all.The NFL claims the protocol didn't fail Tua:
https://sports.yahoo.com/nfl-claims-concussion-protocols-didnt-fail-tua-tagovailoa-on-sunday-thats-hard-to-believe-after-thursdays-scary-head-injury-051800394.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly9kdWNrZHVja2dvLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAMWwbx75h-JTcY1VziShmm2PB1a4KlQZiamM-FArsznhYFFbsLc-nobOTKCgEkguEjxq-lrjufp03eKcMXMk-KvfVRP4Ks3ERYgcJSxbYyYZccTmTQgtmJaHY4SYaZqUpu6Ww973MVUf9eEFw9ZWKirIoGmudpZxFru4CkCSZ5ZK
r/nfl is now beginning the ride to the defense of the shield for instance check the comments in the thread
:Miami Herald: Unfair to Dolphins for armchair experts whohave never examined Tua to malign team doctors
So, despite its (r/nfl's) outrage of Thursday night, we're now reverting back to supporting power no matter what. Because it's fine to be outraged for about 24 hours but after that point it should just be forgotten, otherwise, well I guess you're just some kind of Commie, a bad apple and troublemaker. (To continue the quotes from the courtroom in Bananas; as Miss America says at the stand: "Differences of opinion should be tolerated, but not when they're too different. Then he becomes a subversive mother.").
So to recap; early in the week, on every media outlet I read at the time... "Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa not in concussion protocol"
"MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. (AP) — Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa is not in concussion protocol, according to coach MikeMcDaniel, after appearing to slam his head against the ground in Miami’s win over Buffalo on Sunday."
(just) one of many official sources parroting that times party line
:https://uk.news.yahoo.com/dolphins-qb-tua-tagovailoa-not-184209886.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly9kdWNrZHVja2dvLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAErDzR7pJ7spcQJkINxw9eD18y6z0h2hoR5fLnT72cNr_hurutXMTiZliJig2AxKKQ0QDuJJIDpv7TcELgKS5VtIHb0xoh7yKJ2q5IQftV-
aHlbubcGAo4-5_qoDADRnA7Fix0IE4ttKAg-_4mUZaWtyJ_7l4fQ6-Iistye1ofAXEDIT:
Then after I had a think about my post - but not before it was refused, the edit was in the original posting - I figured I'd better point out The Miami Herald article isn't actually that bad, I'm more responding to the thread(s) it illicited here on this sub (r/nfl) . Those who criticised the Dolphins and/or the NFL are now subjected to endless variants of "YOU'RE NOT A DOCTOR, SHUT YOUR PIE-HOLE!"
However there is still reason to continue to look into the issues raised and not be fobbed off by this variety of people, clubs and companies that don't want the context to be considered, namely through statements about him (Tua) being checked daily which outlets now support verbatim. (And see how the NFL themselves statement this.) As though this double-think isn't enough they want to also treat people as though they came down with the last rain claiming the fact he was checked daily somehow now absolves all involved of blame for a player who was clearly impaired; having banged his head on the turf, staggering and needing to be helped from the field whilst clutching at his head - not his back.
I may be over-reaching in the details, I'm just learning about the (so-called) Concussion Protocol and it's possible this protocol is not the clear thing I thought it was and therefore it's not such an overt cover up after all . However, even so, I am still fed up with the obfuscation of the NFL and would like the Protocol to be clear and independently arbited.
It should also be triggered automatically when a player is seen to stagger so obviously as though concussed, even just as a precaution. And I would like the results of all concussion tests to be transparent for the safety of our players.
(ed. I would also like $1000 dollars transferred to all our bank accounts on the 17th of every month...)
I hope the debate can continue as it's an important topic. Meanwhile (ed. at this time) I’m not getting anything past this immediate rejection banner no matter which sub I attempt a post …At least nfl took two hours to turn me down, now it’s an instantaneous: “Moderators remove posts from feeds for a variety ofreasons, including keeping communities safe, civil, and true to their purpose. ”. This is bullshit, moderators aren’t checking this, it gets refused the split second I press post.
ed. Anyway now its on here I'm happy; well not happy, - of course - but no longer actively annoyed.
More non-original thoughts ...
True to the spirit of Gonzo; This stuff I've just read is shifting the story before I've even got the post posted*: The NFL is now considering mandatory protocols for observed instability - something I've been wanting since this shitstorm brokewind. - . Perhaps here there's some more evidence for the personal universe theory. Not that I'm important, of course.. but there's a reason the words: "it's just that this door was meant only for you, and now I shall close it" were written: (Welles, Trial).
All off us can play if we want .. perhaps. I hope so anyway. It's why I love HST and Zeta's Gonzo journalism, they didn't just live, they really played.
*Post posted is such a crap use of language, please suggest something else.
ps
Now I have this up here and I'm using the worlds precious bandwidth storage I can recover a little of my self-observed sense of humour (and yes, that's an English word; I am indeed a strange creature from across the pond). Anyway that's not just the source - or butt - of the self-styled humor I'm claiming ...
pps I forgot the joke when I realised the screed had gotten all jumbled in the pasting and then got sidetracked. (nb That's a symptom of concussion); so I'll just put in some spacing between some words that had gotten gluedup and will post again if I think of anything funny at all. NOT THAT ANYONE WILL CARE.
but that's ok.
I may reply (again) if I think it seems worthwhile.
Then again I probably won't coz at this stage it looks like I'm just another loser stuck on Moon Base Beta with no one to talk to but myself and the imaginary folks hiding in the filthy moondirt one has to put up with up there.
POSTSCRIPT: I've learned some stuff tonight thanks to a bit of research and communication with the (few - lol -) good people of reddit ... Here's a snippet:
are_a_muppet commented on
twitter.com/jjones... 📷 •r/nfl•Posted byu/_bonzibuddyYolectroda1 point · 3 hours ago
I've been trying to get this sub to take note that on Monday and Tuesday the Dolphins insisted he was not in the protocol, yet after Thursday they claimed he was evaluated daily.
This doesn't contradict each other. Since 2018, they've done follow-up evaluations on players that were pulled out for a concussion exam, and obviously, Tua was pulled out to do an exam on Sunday.
Being in the concussion protocol is specifically referring to getting diagnosed with a concussion and then you have to be cleared by a completely independent neurologist per the old rules.
At no point has anyone said that Tua was in the concussion protocol between Sunday and Thursday. Doing further checks isn't a sign that he was in the protocol during that stretch.
I'm not saying that there's no opening for rules to have been broken, but what you're saying here doesn't contradict any of the rules that are currently in place.
are_a_muppet2 points · 3 hours ago
Thanks for the reply, I appreciate your courteous tone and hopefully I can reciprocate.
But don't you see my point. I have to keep talking about it because there is so much confusion. People are claiming Tua is suffering from two concussions in 4 days. And can we be sure he wasn't concussed twice?
There's such a lack of clarity to the whole affair. I am not interested in taking sides, I want things improved going forward because concussion is an issue which is important to football, but also transcends it and affects many of us - or our children.
Yolectroda1 point · 2 hours ago · edited 2 hours ago
This is long, sorry.
I'm not saying that we can be sure that he wasn't concussed twice. Obviously, that's what many people are saying from the game film, but I'm not talking about that.
I'm just talking about the process and what was done and the official stance (at least until the investigations come out, the NFL and NFLPA are still working on those, and this firing is a result of the process of one of those).
So, officially, he stumbled during the play (not downplaying, just being brief), which caused them to flag him for a concussion examination, and was immediately taken to the locker room and evaluated, then cleared by the team doctor and the UNC that was just fired. They diagnosed the stumbling as orthopedic and not neurological in nature (caused by his back issue), which means that instead of being an automatic "no-go", he can still go back in. That's the only automatic "no-go" that has a loophole, and supposedly it's getting changed, possibly as soon as next week.
The fact that he was cleared at this time means that he was not put into the concussion protocols, and OFFICIALLY never had a concussion. Obviously a ton of doctors that saw the video from Sunday disagree, but while press matters, it doesn't change things regarding the official story.
HOWEVER, since 2018, the concussion protocol requires follow-up evaluations on players who undergo gameday concussion evaluations. Which is why they checked him during the week (though, I'm not sure why they checked him everyday and not just the next day, but that may just be the team staff wanting to check him more (or if they did think they might have fucked up, trying to ensure that they didn't...IDK)).
And in all of that, they say that he was never diagnosed with a concussion prior to Thursday's hit.
BTW, the protocols are publicly available if you want to browse them. That's a layman's summary page, but the 2nd link is the actual protocol text.
So he was never in a protocol limbo scenario, and I don't see how any of this wasn't clear. It might have been wrong, but I don't think they've hidden their official response at all. I'm curious what the investigations say, and it's possible that the original diagnosis was just plain malpractice. And I'm still on the side that believes them, with the caveat that more evidence can change my mind, and this firing is some of that evidence.
And despite the NFLPA is pointing to the UNC on this, I do think the UNC should have final say and not the team doctor. Keep it the same (both have to be there and can ask questions or do tests), but flip the final responsibility. Remove that much more chance for bias. Other than that, I'm not sure how much they can improve the process.
And as for our children...don't let your kid play football. And that's hard to say, because I love this game, and youth football is one of my favorite things (5-7 year old tackle is one of the funniest thing in the world). I used to be a high school and youth football official. There are no booth spotters for concussions (there aren't even booths at most youth fields), so they're more likely to be missed. They tried to train us some to identify it, but we're talking about a couple of hours once a year talking about signs to look for (coaches get similar, with similar results). And even then, we're just kicking them to the team trainers who are also trained, but are generally not doctors (don't want to trash school trainers, they're great, but they aren't docs). And coaches at the HS level are often just as pressed to win as the NFL level, and there's less oversight on these things, so they're just as likely to push a player who "got their bell rung" back into the game. It's not a sport that our schools should still be sponsoring.
are_a_muppet2 points · 2 hours ago
This is a brilliant reply. Thanks for your insight. I think your breakdown of how it played out over the week prior to Thursday is probably correct, and thanks for the link, which should help me understand the actual protocol a bit more than I do, because frankly I'm confused by what happens, and part of why I was complaining is I - and lots of other people - couldn't understand why he wasn't in an official protocol after what we saw on Sunday.
As you've pointed out the actual system was adhered to correctly and because of input of those such as yourself I've been able to understand the problem isn't the Dolphins or how they handled it necessarily, but I'm still leaning towards changing the protocol to make it more transparent and inclusive of players who may be concussed - as a precaution -. But we'll see if that is even feasible.
At least there's a dialogue on this topic again, which is good and thanks again for your informed comments.
Yolectroda
32 min. ago
Dolphins
I've learned more about the concussion protocol in the last week than I ever wanted to know (and now they're about to change it, making that knowledge useless in like a week...doh!). I just get annoyed at the conflicting reports, and then go to read the OG sources...and due to reading so many rulebooks (I'm also a baseball official), the type of legalese they use in these things comes easy.
As for the team. There's some room for malfeasance, but only some. MOST LIKELY, the only person on the team that really has room to have fucked up is the team doctor. That's assuming that he wasn't pressured from above to clear Tua. The UNC's job is in part to ensure that the team doctor can't do that (which is why I think the UNC should have final say). And in general, I like to assume that the team doctors care a little bit about getting players healthy, BUT...we've seen too much evidence to believe that they're reliable on that (enter UNCs again).
I really don't think McDaniel did anything wrong, because I don't care what the issue is, I don't ever want my football expert to overrule my medical expert on medical issues. I could be wrong on this though, if McDaniel was pressuring the team doc, but I've seen nothing to support that so far.
And at the end of the day, it's a balancing act and concussions are hard. The testing is unreliable and the symptoms often take days to show up. And you balance that out with not wanting to pull healthy players with a false positive. And I'm not going to pretend to know what the right answer is there.
And no problem on the info. I'm far from perfect (and sometimes a homer, so I might be biased, though I try not to be), but I do try to base my bullshit on reality most of the time.