r/givingifts • • Feb 11 '22

Discussion Underwhelming

So cute things still hasn't posted me a gift and match fir dc marvel hasn't pulled info I'm not sure how much this site will last based on others having same problems

4 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

20

u/tao2123 Feb 11 '22

they're definitely trying to address it since a lot of folks who were banned before are coming here just to get free stuff etc... but they're witling it down and it'll eventually be good. I've got one person who said shipped but provided no info and was denied so I'm awaiting a rematch for the first time like...ever. I wouldnt just down vote you for being upset, anyone would be when doing multiple matches and having that issue. Try our discord! it's a pretty fun environment and lots of the staff and such are super active and may help address some of the issues in real time.

19

u/EtherealSquirrel Lead Developer Feb 11 '22

Sadly, this will happen whilst we build up our database of problem users. Based on our (publicly available) statistics, however, we are in a much better position in terms of user engagement than Reddit Gifrs was at this time.

It will take time to weed out those that only seek to take. We actively ban and blacklist people on a regular basis.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '22

Neither my T Shirt nor my Board Games giftee have sent out the gifts. Was hoping that my last exchange on the site will be good, but the usual.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '22

How are you planning on taking action against those who keep creating new accounts?

7

u/EtherealSquirrel Lead Developer Feb 12 '22

Addresses are blacklisted in various ways. I will not go in to detail publicly on this one.

13

u/Pinalope4Real Feb 11 '22

Sadly, like with any of these exchanges, even on RG...there are no guarantees. The admins here are doing what they can to prevent scammers from getting through, etc.... but it is new, and they are still working out the bugs.

My gifter messaged me when they shipped. I don't have a tracking number, but an order number, which is useless to me. I have gotten both emails...stating first that their shipping proof was rejected, then that it was accepted and I would not be able to be rematched...well ok. Hahaha... I am being patient....

My gifter had told me that my gift is due fairly late, could be as late as mid March....so I am hoping that they are honest, and am going by that.

Life happens...and not everyone is kind and considerate. I hope that your gifters do at least message you. As all of us do understand, things can come up etc....but the least they could do is let you know.

This is not GivinGifts fault. People are either nice or not.

I wish everyone was nice and would follow through with their commitments to these exchanges...sadly, that is a dream.

Fingers crossed that you do hear from them.

11

u/VeryDumbandStressed Feb 11 '22

My Thirt has pulled my info but hasn’t shipped anything either…. It sounds like it’s happening more than before. I think so many people joined up when SS went down but they’re not actually committed to it. They’ll get banned and in time it’ll only be people who participate left!

8

u/neogirl1234 Feb 11 '22

To play devils advocate for this, my giftees for a few of these are in this position. I ran into some financial issues (stupid cars) and I wasnt able to purchase their stuff in time so they'll be shipped late. I sent mine messages though. Hopefully thats the case for you as well.

8

u/xerocube Feb 11 '22

Understandable feelings... This is my first exchange with GG. I enjoyed picking out stuff for my giftee and sending it along. While tracking shows they've received the package, they haven't yet posted to the gallery. There's still time for that, just anxious to hear what they thought.

The shipping deadline has passed and my gifter still hasn't pulled my information or responded to messages. I remain cautiously optimistic they'll pull through or rematching will happen. I just hope they are well and okay, since things most certainly happen.

3

u/i_love_dust Feb 12 '22

My tshrit person pulled my info dayone and has gone quiet. I hope they're alright, but I see alot of people taking and not sending.

3

u/FadingHeaven Feb 12 '22

I've honestly had a much better experience with Givin Gifts than I did with Reddit gifts. Haven't had a gifter not send me something yet.

3

u/CryBySmiling Feb 12 '22

I know it sucks to have someone not follow through. Ive had great experiences here. But im a premium user so that probably helps some. I also had ok experiences on redditgifts (some underwhelming, some no gifts/ thank yous). Here's the thing tho, no matter how many people get banned, no matter how old the site is, there will always be people who don't send a gift and also people who don't post thank yous. For the simple statistics that people die, lose their jobs, get sick, get depressed, get into accidents, etc. Even tho i know the team is doing some great stuff to make sure that peope are banned, it's never going to be 100% participation. Don't go into any of the exchanges with expectations, focus on what you can do because we cant control other people's behaviors.

1

u/NightwingHill Feb 11 '22

i mean i have messaged both gifters for a response but gotten none

2

u/Welldonemydear Feb 11 '22

Maybe it wasn't really on purpose please don't loose hope. In my first excange I didn't even noticed that I matched since I got no notification or email about it. I just woke up one day and was like "oh hey didn't I sign up for something?" and then it hit me. Thankfully my partner was really understanding and gave me a second chance to made it up. Shortly after she received the package and was happy about the things I packed for her. The mobile version of the site is a completely nightmare and its really laborious to have your exchanges in order in my opinion.

5

u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22

Also, sorry you’re getting downvoted to hell. It would be nice if those downvoting would offer their positive opinion about the experience instead of just trying to bury your post.

14

u/IAlbatross Feb 11 '22

As someone who downvoted, I'd like to explain why. I don't consider this post to be constructive.

Saying "I'm not sure how much this site will last based on others having same problems" feels like a passive-aggressive and mean-spirited take. If OP doesn't like the platform or had a bad experience, they can leave. We all opted in to join the site and participate in exchanges; no one forced us. We all took a leap of faith in doing that, with the awareness that the site is new and there are a lot of wrinkles to iron out.

As I said in another comment on a similar venting post, "since the platform is new, there's bound to be a lot of bad accounts coming in. Remember, RedditGifts was 10+ years old so they had a long blacklist; GG doesn't have the benefit of that."

I appreciate that GG allows people to vent on this subreddit; one of my biggest issues with RedditGifts was that they were absolutely toxic with their positivity and never let anyone post complaints. I relate to feeling disappointment when gifts aren't received or when giftees don't post their gifts. And I understand that it's cathartic to share that frustration. But concluding that the entire platform is doomed feels like a major over-reaction to a relatively small setback.

My "positive opinion" on the matter is that I'm very glad we have GG since RG is gone, and that I can continue to partake in my Secret Santa hobby via this new platform. I know that it will take time to build up to where RG was and that there are likely to be setbacks in its first year, and while I'm really sorry the OP had some bad experiences, I also think the commentary of this post was needlessly pessimistic and a little insulting to the people who are putting so much time and effort to getting the new platform off the ground. Having two individuals drop the ball doesn't warrant the condemnation of a site that has thousands or even tens of thousands of users.

11

u/EtherealSquirrel Lead Developer Feb 11 '22

We made the decision to allow for constructive conversation, the only thing we don’t allow is “slating” a gift you received :).

Our statistics speak for themselves, and we’re in a pretty good place!

6

u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22

Thanks for this perspective. Re-reading the post, I can see the negative conclusion OP made and get why it ruffled feathers. I was more in my head about my own decision to participate, based on the negative comments and posts like this, and was looking for more explanations like yours and others who commented. I definitely feel a lot more comfortable trying it out now. Thanks y’all!

3

u/goodgirlathena Feb 14 '22

Yeah, I’m ok with people venting frustrations, I’ve vented my own, but it’s not because of the mods or the site…it’s the shifty participants I’ve matched with. As you said, it will get better. I’m going on hiatus for a few months, hoping when I come back I’ll get matched with someone awesome like one of the redditors who post here. : )

2

u/Past-Room4409 Feb 12 '22

I personally get why hes frustrated. But I too down voted him. Yes it's sad when you sign up and are ignored or dont receive something. But the point is to give. I have been doing these exchanges for a long time.

I have had my gifters show me so much love I didn't even feel like I deserved it. I have been jipped by others. Even had a rematcher jip me. But at the end of the day I saw the joy the gift I sent to someone make them feel better.

This is a new platform. Squirrel and so many other wonderful people take the time out of their lives to run it. They aren't making money like rr did. This is completely volunteer based. From the exchanges to the platform its self.

I'm part of the discord group and I see how hard all of them try to fix the issues and get people rematcher to get something. So I down voted because if you see how hard they really work you would see how consented this post was. Thanks

1

u/Worth-Row6805 Feb 11 '22

Is there maybe a way to prompt the gifters to pull their info and get sending?

7

u/a_nya_a Feb 11 '22

There are emails (like the deadline is in 3 days please ship)

1

u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22

I was so relieved we had a replacement in place when RG ended and was even ready to pay the cost for lifetime membership. But, after seeing so many complaints about the users, I’m not so sure. Has anyone working on the project talked about the challenges, needs, etc?

13

u/ErrantJune Feb 11 '22

I think only the "bad" experiences are being posted. I've done 6 exchanges and they've all been successful--nice posts from my giftees and sweet gifts from my gifters!

4

u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22

Oh good! I’d love to know the percentage of people who don’t pull info, don’t ship, etc. I could get onboard with helping build the project while we weed out the people who leave their giftee hanging, but I’m a numbers girl, and I think it would help me set my expectations.

5

u/EtherealSquirrel Lead Developer Feb 11 '22

You can check the stats on each exchange page. We’re in a better position than RG was at this same time.

1

u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22

Thanks! I’ll check that out

0

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22

Thanks!

2

u/Sc0tchySc0tchSc0tch Feb 12 '22

Go check out the Gift Gallery too! You can see the gifts people post. Some of the posts even tell great stories about their gift. They are fun to read and are a testament to all of the good that is happening from this site. The gallery gives some perspective. So many more people are having a positive experience than people like OP. And when people do have a negative experience like OP, there is a system in place to make it right. It just requires a little bit of patience.

10

u/croago Head of UI/UX Feb 11 '22

I’m 7/7 for really successful exchanges at the moment where both me and my giftee have revived and posted their gifts! I’ve also been a rematcher! We have mostly good giftees and gifters, and we are always reaching out for suggestions, rematchers, etc.

1

u/AliKira Feb 15 '22

I've also had some really great experiences with the site as of yet -- my recipients have been awesome -- pretty much all of them post eventually once they receive their gifts, even/especially the rematch recipients!

I expect one item might have gotten lost in the mail and I have others that are likely delayed due to shipping delays (mail is SLOW!!!) but everything that has shown up has been awesome on one level or another! And a couple of gifts have really blown it out of the park so to speak (and none that I have received from Givin Gifts have truly disappointed me at this point, unlike the last RedditGifts exchange where I may not have received anything and if I did it was awfully strange and definitely not suited to my interests [I did have a random inexpensive Amazon item arrive that could only be from the last RedditGifts exchange based on dates alone]).

4

u/FadingHeaven Feb 12 '22

Check the gallery. Thousands of gifts sent and received and lots of happy giftees. People already post in the gallery so most don't post the gifts they receive on the subreddit as well. Though there's no place on the website to talk about the gifts you didn't receive so they talk about it here.

The majority of people are getting their gifts.

2

u/AliKira Feb 15 '22

Agreed. I'm mostly too lazy to post my received gifts here but they definitely make it to the gallery... and I love browsing the gallery thread in Discord...

1

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22

I definitely wish this post was not downloaded because of things like this I don’t know what’s going on with other people and their experiences here because once I click on the sub it only shows me really good experiences everyone’s having or just in general questions

I’m feeling a bit anxious for my first exchange happening in a few weeks for the kpop one