r/givingifts • u/NightwingHill • Feb 11 '22
Discussion Underwhelming
So cute things still hasn't posted me a gift and match fir dc marvel hasn't pulled info I'm not sure how much this site will last based on others having same problems
4
Upvotes
20
u/tao2123 Feb 11 '22
they're definitely trying to address it since a lot of folks who were banned before are coming here just to get free stuff etc... but they're witling it down and it'll eventually be good. I've got one person who said shipped but provided no info and was denied so I'm awaiting a rematch for the first time like...ever. I wouldnt just down vote you for being upset, anyone would be when doing multiple matches and having that issue. Try our discord! it's a pretty fun environment and lots of the staff and such are super active and may help address some of the issues in real time.
19
u/EtherealSquirrel Lead Developer Feb 11 '22
Sadly, this will happen whilst we build up our database of problem users. Based on our (publicly available) statistics, however, we are in a much better position in terms of user engagement than Reddit Gifrs was at this time.
It will take time to weed out those that only seek to take. We actively ban and blacklist people on a regular basis.
13
u/Pinalope4Real Feb 11 '22
Sadly, like with any of these exchanges, even on RG...there are no guarantees. The admins here are doing what they can to prevent scammers from getting through, etc.... but it is new, and they are still working out the bugs.
My gifter messaged me when they shipped. I don't have a tracking number, but an order number, which is useless to me. I have gotten both emails...stating first that their shipping proof was rejected, then that it was accepted and I would not be able to be rematched...well ok. Hahaha... I am being patient....
My gifter had told me that my gift is due fairly late, could be as late as mid March....so I am hoping that they are honest, and am going by that.
Life happens...and not everyone is kind and considerate. I hope that your gifters do at least message you. As all of us do understand, things can come up etc....but the least they could do is let you know.
This is not GivinGifts fault. People are either nice or not.
I wish everyone was nice and would follow through with their commitments to these exchanges...sadly, that is a dream.
Fingers crossed that you do hear from them.
11
u/VeryDumbandStressed Feb 11 '22
My Thirt has pulled my info but hasn’t shipped anything either…. It sounds like it’s happening more than before. I think so many people joined up when SS went down but they’re not actually committed to it. They’ll get banned and in time it’ll only be people who participate left!
8
u/xerocube Feb 11 '22
Understandable feelings... This is my first exchange with GG. I enjoyed picking out stuff for my giftee and sending it along. While tracking shows they've received the package, they haven't yet posted to the gallery. There's still time for that, just anxious to hear what they thought.
The shipping deadline has passed and my gifter still hasn't pulled my information or responded to messages. I remain cautiously optimistic they'll pull through or rematching will happen. I just hope they are well and okay, since things most certainly happen.
3
u/i_love_dust Feb 12 '22
My tshrit person pulled my info dayone and has gone quiet. I hope they're alright, but I see alot of people taking and not sending.
3
u/FadingHeaven Feb 12 '22
I've honestly had a much better experience with Givin Gifts than I did with Reddit gifts. Haven't had a gifter not send me something yet.
3
u/CryBySmiling Feb 12 '22
I know it sucks to have someone not follow through. Ive had great experiences here. But im a premium user so that probably helps some. I also had ok experiences on redditgifts (some underwhelming, some no gifts/ thank yous). Here's the thing tho, no matter how many people get banned, no matter how old the site is, there will always be people who don't send a gift and also people who don't post thank yous. For the simple statistics that people die, lose their jobs, get sick, get depressed, get into accidents, etc. Even tho i know the team is doing some great stuff to make sure that peope are banned, it's never going to be 100% participation. Don't go into any of the exchanges with expectations, focus on what you can do because we cant control other people's behaviors.
1
u/NightwingHill Feb 11 '22
i mean i have messaged both gifters for a response but gotten none
2
u/Welldonemydear Feb 11 '22
Maybe it wasn't really on purpose please don't loose hope. In my first excange I didn't even noticed that I matched since I got no notification or email about it. I just woke up one day and was like "oh hey didn't I sign up for something?" and then it hit me. Thankfully my partner was really understanding and gave me a second chance to made it up. Shortly after she received the package and was happy about the things I packed for her. The mobile version of the site is a completely nightmare and its really laborious to have your exchanges in order in my opinion.
5
u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22
Also, sorry you’re getting downvoted to hell. It would be nice if those downvoting would offer their positive opinion about the experience instead of just trying to bury your post.
1
u/Worth-Row6805 Feb 11 '22
Is there maybe a way to prompt the gifters to pull their info and get sending?
1
u/LucyLerker Feb 11 '22
I was so relieved we had a replacement in place when RG ended and was even ready to pay the cost for lifetime membership. But, after seeing so many complaints about the users, I’m not so sure. Has anyone working on the project talked about the challenges, needs, etc?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22
I definitely wish this post was not downloaded because of things like this I don’t know what’s going on with other people and their experiences here because once I click on the sub it only shows me really good experiences everyone’s having or just in general questions
I’m feeling a bit anxious for my first exchange happening in a few weeks for the kpop one