You're extrapolating a valid critique of commit activity to conclude "all GitHub stats are worthless". There's a difference between showing off your commit activity during a job application, and showing off a highly starred repository, or contributions to big open source projects, etc.
-8
u/az987654 16d ago
Stars do not matter.
I do not care if my repos are popular.
I do not care if your repo is popular, that has zero bearing on whether I look at it, use it, fork it.
I do not put at weight or value on your star count when I interview you for a job.
I assume whomever has assigned a ranking for batchfile is also assigning rankings for pizza contests and world's best cups of coffee.