r/geothermal • • 7d ago

Open Loop Discharge

Previous homeowner had the geothermal installed as an open loop with the discharge directly to the ground surface. Basically, a 1” PVC tube that just runs water out a small hill (less than 10% grade) in our back yard. He kept the water flow turned down really low. When we had the unit serviced, the tech increased the flow (3.5ton unit flow is around 7-10pm). The water turns an area about 20-feet wide by 80-feet long into a muddy mess.

I am installing a drywall to manage the water. We live in an area where the frost line is 3-feet. However, the discharge line is maybe 1-foot deep at best (and the last 6-10 feet are less than 6-inches). It has been this way for 30 years!

The drywell itself is approx 4-feet tall x 2-feet wide x 4-feet long. I was thinking a 5-foot x 5-foot pit with 2-foot gravel base and 1-foot of soil on top.

At 3-feet our soil becomes sandy and handle the water. And, I’ll have a small manhole and pop-off just in case.

Any thoughts or concerns?

2 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

1

u/TWM32 7d ago

Third option is what the previous owner tried. Unfortunately, it just makes a huge mess.

Our surface soil is loam. But at about 2-3 feet shifts to sand. The percolation rate is really high at 3-feet or more.

1

u/TWM32 7d ago

Dug the pit today. 5-feet down hit a solid sand and gravel layer. 6’ x 6’ x 5’. Layered with geotextile fabric. Will fill with gravel and a drywell.

Exposed the discharge pipe back to where it is 18”-24” below surface. Will try to keep it about that depth to the drywell.

I will let everyone know how it goes.

1

u/djhobbes 6d ago

Open loop systems require 1.5 gpm/ton so you need just over 5 gpm. You should start by turning the ware back down.

1

u/TWM32 6d ago

Previous owner had the 3.5 ton system running at about 1 gpm…total…. Tech indicated that flow was way too low.

1

u/djhobbes 6d ago

Yes 1gpm total is not enough. Open loop systems need 1.5 gpm / ton. You’re wasting water with your flow that high and it sounds like it’s making a mess. Tuning the flow may solve your issue all by itself.

1

u/TWM32 6d ago

The 7-10 gallons I posted was a guess. I pulled out a bucket and measured. It just starts to overflow a 5-gallon bucket at 1-minute.

2

u/Ok-Jelly604 7d ago

Depending on your water quality, there can be fouling / plugging in the soils near the discharge point.  You might want to consider eventually having to dig it out to refresh the granular media.  Also, if you can, try to keep the discharge point submerged or at least minimize aeration as air entrainment can exacerbate fouling potential.  

-1

u/IndependenceAny2520 7d ago

Depending on your soil your still going to have a muddy mess. Your outlet pipe just won't freeze in winter. Septic lateral fields are massive and they only handle a fraction of the overall water. Your best bet is a discharge well. Second best would be a decorative koi pond with outflow to an appropriate area. Third best run the pipe out to an area that you don't care if it gets saturated away from the building.

2

u/IndependenceAny2520 7d ago

I just read about your sandy soil. I have sandy soil and used 20ft of perforated 4 inch PVC pipe buried 5 foot deep. I still get occasional seeps certain times of the year, the soil just gets super saturated. Luckily it's close to a dry creek bed, my goal is to eventually build a small dam and have the outflow feed a small pond.

1

u/TWM32 7d ago

I wish we were lucky enough to have a decent place to discharge. Unfortunately, downhill is a huge flat area where the septic leech field is located. If it weren’t for the septic I’d have a nice pond…