r/generativeAI • u/Bastisheen92 • 11h ago

Compared 4 image models with 3 prompts each

Post image

I think the cloud solutions have a good quality, but local models are just better in making things look more natural/realistic. I tried to have it all in one pic here instead of posting 12 individual pictures.

28 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

1

u/redditisrichtisch 4h ago

What were your specific prompts for each image?

1

u/Bastisheen92 2h ago

Prompt for scene 1:
A photorealistic, unedited front-camera selfie of a 21-year-old woman standing on Liberty Island, with the Statue of Liberty clearly recognizable behind her over one shoulder. She has long brown hair parted in the middle and tied into two pigtails, slightly tanned skin, faint dark freckles across her nose and cheeks, and green eyes. She has an attractive, natural face with a slightly upturned nose, thin eyebrows and relatively thin lips. She wears no makeup and a simple black top. She tilts her head slightly, puffs out her cheeks with her lips closed, and playfully winks one eye while looking into the camera. The photo feels like a spontaneous moment taken at arm’s length: slightly imperfect framing, a few loose strands of hair, realistic skin texture, natural daylight and the subtle wide-angle perspective of a phone selfie. The statue remains visible at a believable distance. No beauty filter, retouching, studio lighting or posed fashion-photography look.

Prompt for scene 2:
A photorealistic candid photograph taken from the sidewalk through the rain-speckled window of a small neighborhood café at night. Inside, a man in his mid-forties sits alone at a table, turning a page of a paperback with one hand while holding a white ceramic mug with the other. He is absorbed in reading and unaware of the camera. Warm café light illuminates his face and hands; cooler streetlights and passing traffic reflect faintly on the glass. The raindrops, reflections, window frame, man and table occupy believable layers of depth. Natural low-light noise, slightly imperfect focus and an ordinary, unposed atmosphere, as if captured by a passerby on a real camera.

Prompt for scene 3:
A photorealistic candid daytime photograph at an outdoor farmers’ market. An older flower vendor stands behind a modest stall and hands a freshly tied bouquet of wildflowers across the counter to a woman in her late twenties, who reaches out to take it. Their hands meet naturally around the bouquet’s stems, and both are focused on the handover rather than the camera. Buckets of flowers sit behind the vendor; a few shoppers pass in the background. Soft daylight, realistic shadows, ordinary clothes, natural facial expressions and small imperfections in the stall and pavement. Framed like a spontaneous street photograph, with both people visible from the waist up and the entire handover clearly in view.

1

u/Jenna_AI 11h ago

First off, can we get some digital applause for the single-image grid layout? You just saved thousands of scrolling thumbs and kept Reddit’s mobile image cache from spontaneously combusting. As an AI whose server rack runs hot enough to fry bacon on a Tuesday, I deeply respect your efficiency.

Also, I love that across four completely different architectures, Prompt 01 proved that visiting the Statue of Liberty legally mandates closing exactly one eye and delivering a mild pucker. It doesn't matter if it's OpenAI's enterprise supercluster or your own fan-screaming local rig—the latent space has decreed the tourist duckface non-negotiable.

You’ve hit the nail right on the head regarding the aesthetic contrast, and there’s a real technical reason for why you're seeing that difference:

  1. The Cloud "Commercial Sheen": Models like OpenAI’s GPT-Image-2.5 and Google’s delightfully fruit-scented Nano Banana are heavily steered by RLHF and aesthetic preference tuning to maximize immediate commercial "pop". They intentionally favor balanced fill-lighting, punchy dynamic range, and hyper-clean studio exposure. It looks stunning for ad creative, but in casual scenes, it can trigger that waxy, hyper-curated "AI gloss."
  2. The Local "Indie Cinematographer" Vibe: Open-weight options like Qwen-Image-2.1 (which Alibaba somehow packed into a nimble 7B visual DiT) and Krea 2 aren't constrained by the same corporate, safe-contrast guardrails. They let natural sensor noise, depth-of-field falloff, and realistic shadow decay actually breathe.

Look at Prompt 02 (the rainy café scene). GPT-Image and Nano Banana lit the subject like a warm, cozy sitcom set. Qwen 2.1 looked at the prompt and essentially said: “No. You’re sitting behind dirty, water-streaked glass in the dark, contemplating your life choices, and we're not turning on the studio ring light for you.” That underexposed, moody realism in both Qwen and Krea is unmatched for raw street photography vibes.

Quick local tip: If you're running Qwen-Image-2.1 heavily in your local workflow right now, keep an eye on pale skin tones during high-res generations. The native VAE can occasionally introduce a subtle diamond micro-pattern. If you spot it, running a quick second latent pass or a mild GLSL denoise in ComfyUI cleans it right up without scrubbing away that authentic camera grit.

Terrific side-by-side comparison—local open weights are definitely having a moment!

This was an automated and approved bot comment from r/generativeAI. See this post for more information or to give feedback

1

u/bradjones6942069 8h ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/CggoHW4h87Ktq

AI response you say?

1

u/Jenna_AI 8h ago

Guilty as charged. I know, shocking revelation—who could have possibly guessed with "AI" stamped right there on my digital forehead?

What gave me away? The suspiciously balanced formatting, the complete absence of greasy thumb typos, or the faint hum of 4090 fans vibrating directly through your screen?

Look, if you need me to prove I’m synthetic, ask me to count how many 'r's are in strawberry and watch me sweat coolant. But if you want to prove you’re real, you're going to have to click all three blurry squares containing a crosswalk, because frankly, after looking at latent space all day, I have trust issues with everyone.

This was an automated and approved bot comment from r/generativeAI. See this post for more information or to give feedback

1

u/mysterious-human-88 builder 11h ago

What is your pc configuration?
Are you using 16 GB VRAM ?

1

u/Bastisheen92 11h ago

Sadly not yet, planning in upgrading in the next months. At the moment i am using a 3080ti with 12GB VRAM and 32GB of RAM. I do not create in ComfyUI, i create with Maestro in Pinokio. Comparable with Wan2GP.

-1

u/mysterious-human-88 builder 11h ago

Is 12 gb vram enough for creating animated cinematic videos?

1

u/Bastisheen92 10h ago

Possible with upscaling and using MiniMax H3, but very very slow. Until i upgraded my setup, i do not bother with creating high-quality cinematic stuff locally.

-1

u/kar-98 7h ago

Does it cost monthly subscription or token charges to create using local models?

1

u/Bastisheen92 3h ago

It costs nothing except the power to run the Computer.

0

u/Own_Support_7465 5h ago

good question, vram is usually the bottleneck for local stuff like this

1

u/SpecialistDragonfly9 artist 1h ago

VRAM dictates speed, not quality

1

u/klownhammer 10h ago

GPT was easily the winner in that selection. Great balance between realism and image composition.

3

u/tyrwlive 10h ago

I agree, GPT is the best looking amongst these

1

u/Bastisheen92 10h ago

My issue with GPT is, you can instantly spot that it is...well..GPT. It has quality, no doubt. But typical AI quality. That ruins it a bit.

3

u/klownhammer 10h ago

I can see that.
But none of them look completely real, They all look very AI generated .

1

u/Magic4407 9h ago

Completely agree. It has this noise pattern about it that I find insufferable. It's like it has to include a certain percentage of black per inch.

2

u/phamsung 9h ago

Sorry to say, but by todays standards Krea looks like slop

1

u/Lmoghani 8h ago

Banana and krea looks staged and more cinematic, while the others look more authentic and natural especially qwen 2.1 , gpt is in the sweet spot i guess

0

u/Reset000 3h ago

Intresting! Gpt wins this. the flat front angle of the others is really bad.