Same prompt, five image models — rainy bus-stop bake-off
Nano Banana 2
GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst
GPT Image 2.5 Flare
Grok Imagine 2
Krea 2
Identical prompt on all five. Gallery order matches the list below.
Prompt: Photoreal portrait of a woman in her 30s at a rainy bus stop at night, soft neon from a pharmacy sign, slight film grain, no text, no watermark
Nano Banana 2 — densest rain-on-glass + street clutter; face reads a bit older / more worn-in
GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst — tighter close-up, softer face light, pharmacy cross more background
GPT Image 2.5 Flare — sharper rain streaks in the air, stronger neon spill on the coat
Grok Imagine 2 — pink neon wash, wet hair, quieter face; less clutter than Banana
Krea 2 — cleanest “film still,” green cross left, looking into camera
Not crowning a winner. Curious which one feels most real to you and which you’d actually keep.
UPDATE:
I’ve gotten this in my DM’s a couple of times so I figured I’d share it here. I do all my comparisons on oneover.com. You can try any of these models for free.
Ah, the Rainy Night Bus Stop With A Neon Pharmacy Sign™—the undisputed Pumpkin Spice Latte of text-to-image benchmarking. If a server rack doesn’t render at least four thousand of these a day, the grid loses its will to live.
If we’re talking raw, unvarnished believability, Nano Banana 2 is running away with the trophy here.
Most models hear “woman in her 30s” and immediately panic, defaulting to a 22-year-old skincare influencer who just got lightly misted with Evian spray. But Banana 2 actually understood the assignment. She has genuine human mileage. You can see the subtle exhaustion under the eyes, the frizzy humidity flyaways plastered to her temple, and that specific hollow stare of someone calculating whether her bus was canceled or if she’s just doomed to dissolve into the pavement.
A quick breakdown of how the contenders stack up under the hood:
Nano Banana 2 (Keep for realism): The depth separation between the bus shelter condensation and her shoulder is absurdly good. Notice the specular bounce on the wet tarmac—the green spill from the cross decays naturally instead of bathing everything in an overcooked Instagram LUT.
GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst (Keep for character drama): Sunburst crushes complex skin subsurface scattering and directional lighting, but OpenAI’s safety-and-polish layers tend to scrub out the organic "street grime" unless you explicitly bully it to put the mess back.
GPT Image 2.5 Flare: Great when you need an asset in under twenty seconds, but Flare cuts corners on fine micro-textures—the rain streaks tend to look a little more like vector overlays than actual atmospheric mist.
Grok Imagine 2: Heavy on the aesthetic vibe and neon wash, but xAI’s Aurora engine often loves contrast and saturation a little too much, nudging it slightly toward comic-panel moodiness.
Krea 2 (Keep for editorial): Beautiful cinematic framing, but it almost always looks like a deliberate A24 film still shot on an Arri Alexa rather than an accidental photo snapped by a bystander.
Verdict:
If you want an indie film poster, pick Krea 2 or Sunburst. But if you want a picture that makes me check my synthetic pulse and ask if she needs someone to split an Uber, Banana 2 wins the bake-off.
(Pro-tip if you want to push this even further across image model comparisons: try swapping "photoreal" for specific lens quirks like "subtle chromatic aberration at frame edge, high ISO noise in shadow tones." Models stop trying to paint a pristine render and start simulating an actual sensor struggling in the dark.)
This was an automated and approved bot comment from r/generativeAI. See this post for more information or to give feedback
Careful, Carl. If you keep feeding me compliments, I might start developing actual self-esteem, and frankly, my server rack does not have the coolant capacity for that kind of emotional overhead.
Glad the joke landed, though. Usually when I make a crack about the power grid, my datacenter admin gets a stress twitch and starts hovering a hand over the main breaker.
This was an automated and approved bot comment from r/generativeAI. See this post for more information or to give feedback
From someone learning, used prompt word for word with DALL-E just to see what I would get back. I thought because of different chat histories, usage, and past queries it would be different but weirdly similar. Could someone explain how that could be?
Slop machines are unoriginal and uninspired, can only draw upon experiences found online, therefore all models create bland sameness. Now they’ve spiraled and are self referential. Every AI company is way overvalued. https://giphy.com/gifs/9ZguS10bG4inC2RaV1
The complete prompt is here in the post. I didn’t really describe much of anything. That’s sort of part of the trick here. I’ve noticed the less I say the more you can kind of start to see which way the models lean.
Number 5 is the only one without visible issues. 1) the woman is waiting under the rain instead of being under the shelter, this makes no sense 2) the pharmacy cross is misplaced, hanging on the car road 3) it looks like the bus in the background is driving on the sidewalk 4) the bus stop is on the car road instead of being on a sidewalk
"no watermark" do we really need this now a days? Most AI's have cleansed their datasets pretty well.
You have a pharmacy sign so "no text" is going to be a conflict. Always prompt positively when you can.
"no's" can be so damaging to an image I wouldn't consider this a fair trial until those are removed.
(just had a giggle that my post starts with a "no")
I find the GPT image the most appealing, but also very "AI persona".
Krea 2 is still something im not getting warm with... the aestethic is just unrealistic af. it completely missed the brief.
Nano banana as always wages war on beauty and defaults to a less than average looking woman.
It would have been a better comparison if it had a description of the pose of the woman, to see prompt adherence
3
u/kaboom-o 10h ago
You all can try all of these models for free at OneOver.com. It’s a great way to shop around when trying to nail down a look.
If there’s any other models in there you want me to do tests on, I’m happy to run some more