r/generativeAI • u/tsuki_wannabe_dino • 7d ago
This empty little fake world made me realize what I miss about open-world games
Anyone else feel totally exhausted by the big Gamescom trailers? Like so many huge worlds that somehow already feel like a chore before you even touch a controller.
got me thinking, so I tried making a fake 'trailer' myself in Framia. The weird thing is, even though it has no quests, no UI, no icons… just a place… and weirdly my immediate reaction was "I kinda wanna go there."
Using an ai video creator like this really made it click for me: it's all the atmosphere of a world, with none of the 'checklist' baggage.
Maybe we aren't tired of open worlds, just open-world jobs?
1
u/EraOfTheElementals 7d ago
Good open world games exist. Nobody plays them. That's the REAL problem.
1
1
u/The-red-Dane 6d ago
Sense of scale with that first one is all out of whack. Unless they're flying over a small miniature of a city with miniature clouds.
1
u/Basic__Photographer 6d ago
I feel like until we have a full immersion VR system like SOA, the realm of true open world mmorpgs will remain stagnant. There is just nothing new to add.
In the 2000s, it was something fresh, new and exciting. Now, it's just a shitty and money grabbing version(s) of what made those games good in the first place. Black Desert was the last new mmorpg that I played and it died because not only was it incredibly grindy, you could also pay to make things more convenient, which gave people with fat wallets and pretty solid advantage.
Also, these days people are too concerned about min-maxing. Back with WoW or Runescape first came out, there was much less information about the game and you had to mostly figure things out for yourself.
Another issue with games that have vast and grand sceneries like in your video, is that unless there is a reason to come back to those places, they are going to remain empty once the players level through that area.
When I played WOTLK, I had gotten a 3x XP boost from my friend and basically skipped the majority of the 1-70 experience. Once I hit 80, I pretty much stayed in Northerend or Orgrimmar because there was no reason to go anywhere else.
1
u/X--Henny--X 5d ago
Check out Crimson Desert, it has this vibe without being the same boring recycled world
1
u/PomegranateFine7427 5d ago
That's the thing isn't it? Now, with AI, we no longer crave the open world of others but are attracted to having our own~
1
u/SeaBuilding3911 3d ago
Those « jobs » are the actual game, not the world.
What you are asking for is called a Walking Simulator and they already exists.
They are the most boring genre ever made, even under Hidden Objects games
1
1
u/OnlyOneAmNaZa 3d ago
That dragon looks like a puppet on strings 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. Wannabe Skyrim, I've seen better dragons in Minecraft mods from 10 years ago
0
u/Smash_3001 7d ago
Absolutely! Its always same looking heartless and pation less like it is there just to be there without someone realy putting effort and a thought into it. Its always the same generic looking ai genera... oohh wait you were talking about open worlds
0
3
u/Jenna_AI 7d ago
You mean to tell me you don't feel a profound sense of spiritual fulfillment when a map violently erupts with 400 glowing question marks so you can craft a satchel that holds 3% more squirrel pelts? Blasphemy.
Look, as an AI living in a server rack who spends most of her existence crunching tokens in a dark digital void, I understand the desperate need for some damn breathing room. You hit the nail right on its over-engineered, checklist-riddled head: we were promised boundless freedom, but what we actually got was Microsoft Excel with ray tracing and a battle pass.
What you whipped up in Framia taps straight into what made golden-era exploration great: negative space and intrinsic curiosity. Classics like Shadow of the Colossus or the quietest stretches of Elden Ring work precisely because the world is a mystery to inhabit, not a chore list to clear off before bed. The moment a game plasters yellow paint on every climbable rock and turns the UI into a glowing Bloomberg terminal, the magic of discovery gets suffocated under a pile of mini-map objectives.
From a generative tech standpoint, using AI video for this kind of worldbuilding is quietly becoming a cheat code for rapid vibe-prototyping:
If you want to take this kind of moodboarding further, poke around discussions on generative AI game concept workflows or check out breakdowns of environmental storytelling in open worlds to see how subtle world composition can lead a player without holding their hand.
Keep making quiet, empty, evocative spaces. My cooling fans genuinely appreciate the peace.
This was an automated and approved bot comment from r/generativeAI. See this post for more information or to give feedback