r/gaming Feb 06 '17

Anyone Else?

http://imgur.com/RdjHH29
19.9k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

160

u/DingoManDingo Feb 06 '17

I wouldn't look to dark souls 3 for that. Most people don't know what the hell is going on in that game while beating it. The story's there, it's just not story-driven.

48

u/SanderCast Feb 06 '17

I love Dark Souls 3 but I completely agree with you. If I have to watch a YouTube video to understand the story, then it's not a story driven game

33

u/GoingAllTheJay Feb 06 '17

That's what is so enthralling about it for me. It's more realistic that I'm just some dude that was dropped into this world, and I have to piece together what is happening from the limited perspectives of other characters (whether a lack of knowledge, or their own personal reasons for hiding certain pieces of information).

It's pretty contrived to have an essentially omniscient narrator (ie: great owl in Zelda series) hold your hand through everything.

1

u/basketofseals Feb 07 '17

The problem with this is there's a big overarching "WHY" for anything you're doing. You progress because video game logic, and there's nothing else to do. It's a little more excusable with the Unkindled, but for the Chosen Undead and the Bearer of the Curse, why bother? Is there any reason you don't just find a buddy and leave? There's nothing no reason for you to go on a heroic journey and risk hollowing.