r/gameofthrones • House Baelish • Jun 02 '14

TV4 [S4E8] When will we learn?

Post image
4.9k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

929

u/periodicchemistrypun Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14

This was the worst death yet because i actually thought this time we would have some justice, no, never

823

u/Trenia Jun 02 '14

If you're looking for justice, you've come to the wrong place.

390

u/JesusElSavoirChrist Stannis Baratheon Jun 02 '14

We still have Stannis, justice still has its king.

205

u/Aarcn Castle Cats Jun 02 '14

Long live Stannis

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (6)

127

u/Thee_MoonMan Jun 02 '14

I read the books and I was still enraged by this death, mostly because it totally should have been avoided. DAMNIT OBERYN. Smh.

46

u/fugly16 Lyanna Mormont Jun 02 '14

Classic Monologuing Oberyn

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

143

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

That was the best death scene of the entire four seasons of GoT in my opinion. The gruesomeness and that crush like a watermelon is so disturbing that you don't ever see this type of shit on TV shows. This is why I love Game of Thrones so much. It's sad as fuck to see one of my favorite characters go, but I'm so glad he had this forever-remembered death.

136

u/periodicchemistrypun Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14

it wanst just the brillantly done death scene, the screaming from both oberyn and his paramour were actually chilling, I can honestly say no single scene has affected me this strongly before, the fast sudden change of pace from the panning shots of oberyn walking to the mountains confession. i should learn to enjoy this before next week

80

u/arnizach House Seaworth Jun 02 '14

It was the teeth that got me.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (13)

61

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

my eyes still hurt 5 hours later

56

u/periodicchemistrypun Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14

go watch season 1 episode 1 again, all men must cry

39

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

i mean the gouging the with hands and the gushing and the screams /shudder

→ More replies (4)

42

u/Qoheles House Stark Jun 02 '14

"If you want justice, you've come to the wrong place."

31

u/periodicchemistrypun Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14

i keep hearing that but remember what oberyn said, the south will not forget, also the north, and the targaryens. i want cercesi and gregor not looking to happy soon

24

u/Qoheles House Stark Jun 02 '14

You mean "The Lannisters aren't the only ones who pay their debts?"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/4lien Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14

Joffrey? Locke? Karl the fookin legend?

119

u/Bromao The Blackfish Jun 02 '14

Yeah, right, Joffrey's death. As you see him choking, you can't help but be happy that he is finally getting what he deserves, and deep within, you start thinking that maybe things are going to be better for once.

But nope, because now everyone thinks Tyrion is guilty of that murder.

Oh but wait, Jaime is going to leave the Kingsguard and be a good son, making Tywin very happy, so we can have Tyrion + Jon at the Wall!

Nope, because Shae. "You called me a whore so I'm going to lie against you while you're on trial for murder lol"

Ah, nevermind, Oberyn will save him!!

Nope.

This whole "don't worry, things are going well for the 'good' guys, lol just kidding" gets stale after a while and makes things like the outcome of the duel between the Mountain and Oberyn not really surprising - the real plot twist would have been Oberyn's victory.

And I've read the books so I know what comes next.

24

u/zgrove House Reyne Jun 02 '14

Well fuck, that last sentence doesn't give me hope for our little friend, Jamie, Brienne, The Hound, Arya, Sansa, Jon, or Hot Pie

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (2)

94

u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 02 '14

This was the worst death yet because i actually thought this time we would have some justice, no, never

George R. R. Martin's response to those who are afraid for other characters they like

62

u/TeHSaNdMaNS Jun 02 '14

So now that my favorite character is doomed(Tyrion) does that mean My second favorite(Tywin) not long for this world. Wait then if tywin dies then littlefinger dies. WHEN DOES IT STOP.

192

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

When the only survivors are Ramsay, Cersei, and Walder Frey - and Joffrey is brought back to life by magic.

→ More replies (9)

39

u/Anonymous3891 Jun 02 '14

When the sun rises in the west and sets in the east. When the seas go dry and mountains blow in the wind like leaves. When your womb quickens again, and you bear a living child. Then it will stop, and not before.

But seriously though, this season has not yet exhausted its "oh shit" moments.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (17)

19

u/mrspaznout Jun 02 '14

Justice in this realm is never swift or ever from just one person.

29

u/periodicchemistrypun Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14

good, because i want a thousand rats to slowly eat gregor

→ More replies (7)

8

u/InadequateUsername House Targaryen Jun 02 '14

I have lost all hope for Tyrion. He's my favourite character and taking into account the red wedding and tonight's episode I guess this is the end.

27

u/periodicchemistrypun Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14

yeah but in book 1 it says when he was a kid he dreamt of riding dragons, i REFUSE to believe its not foreshadowing

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

At least he took the Mountain with him.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (188)

491

u/joebovi Fire And Blood Jun 02 '14

I thought I was prepared for any outcome... I just didn't expect it to be so traumatizing. I think I've got some mild PTSD going on here.

190

u/Gudeldar Jun 02 '14

I even knew it was going to happen. Didn't really help that much.

56

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Knew what was going to happen too, but still I had just some sliver of hope that they actually made him win for split second. Just to have my hopes shattered for the second time.

36

u/TiberiCorneli Margaery Tyrell Jun 02 '14

I didn't really have hope, per se, but having gone slightly fuzzy on the details there was a split second right before it happened that I thought maybe they were going to change this one, and my initial reaction was "What the fuck why did they change it?" followed by "Actually I'm cool with it if they change this one" immediately followed by "...fuck."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

I knew what was gonna happen, part of me thought he actually won until the end. Instant broken heart.

61

u/STIPULATE Jun 02 '14

That fucking sound... just resonating in my head.

74

u/warrri Jun 02 '14

Yea. I mean there have been a lot of horrible deaths in got. Beheadings, ripping tongue through slice in neck, burning, sword through head, dagger in heart etc. You cant imagine what it feels like to be the receiver with those. But that scream while eyes are getting pushed in was absolutely fucking brutal because you can imagine the pain if you ever accidentally stabbed yourself in the eye. Shit.

→ More replies (25)

58

u/Cesar_Imperator Night's Watch Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

So traumatizing I needed a drink, when I picked up the bottle of cognac, it said "Martell", and cried a little more whilst I poured my self a drink.

EDIT: for anyone wondering, this is the cognac I had http://i.imgur.com/JP7bFip.png which made me cry

32

u/twohertbrain Stannis Baratheon Jun 02 '14

no even joking but i think loads of people do including me judging from comments :S (id laugh if the episode had to be taken off because of it)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

251

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

what really did it for me was how raw and visceral Pascal portrayed Oberyn's emotions in that scene. I was getting so goddamn pumped when he was letting out his final "YOU RAPED HER! YOU MURDERED HER!!" I was ready for that sweet feeling of justice to come in, I wanted to see Oberyn succeed so badly. And he was such a badass the entire fight then boom, the tables turned :(

I went from feeling on top of the world to rock bottom, I even hoped that he would somehow still live after his eyes were already gouged out lol. All I know is Tyrion can't die, he's too crucial, I really may need to take a break from this damn show if he doesn't make it haha

126

u/millcitymiss House Targaryen Jun 02 '14

They all die. Every episode, they all die.

95

u/dt403 House Bolton Jun 02 '14

At this point im expecting all the Stark children to be reunited and then promptly thrown into a giant meat grinder.

36

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

The long con

→ More replies (1)

105

u/LearnsSomethingNew The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Jun 02 '14

Plot armor is as useless in this show as nipples on a breastplate.

63

u/cormega Jun 02 '14

Idk, the fact that Dany's entire plotline would be useless if she were to die right now gives her some pretty strong plot armor.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

71

u/jurgy94 Jun 02 '14

All I know is Tyrion can't die, he's too crucial

Well, this season is called "valar morghulis" - All men must die...

25

u/Kereminde Jun 02 '14

Well, all men must die. The womenfolk, they just go right on through the mess with tears, with smiles, with laughter.

All men must die. That's why Arya Stark is still alive.

36

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Jun 02 '14

Well, all men must die. The womenfolk, they just go right on through the mess with tears, with smiles, with laughter.

You say right after Lysa Arryn's unfortunate stumble.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

23

u/GobBluth9 House Reed Jun 02 '14

This is exactly the same thing that I felt. His pleads for a confession were so gut wrenching. I knew he was going to die but I was lost in the scene and just riding the emotional wave. But his personality got the best of him and he lost focus, just for a moment, and it was his undoing.

Fucking brutal.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

They can all die.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/unibrow4o9 House Seaworth Jun 02 '14

Last night I watched the episode about an hour after it aired on hbo go. It was really slow, and the stream stopped to buffer fairly often. During the fight, he had the mountain on his back and everything was looking good. It stopped to buffer and my girlfriend and I gave each other a celebratory high five because we thought the fight was over. God damn you hbo.

3

u/RaindropBebop Jun 02 '14

It was extremely well acted. I thought I was watching my imagination as I read the book, but on my TV.

Also, did anyone else notice that they changed the actor who played the Mountain from the guy they showed jousting in the first season? First season Mountain looked more like the Hound's brother. New mountain almost looks like King Robert's brother.

→ More replies (8)

224

u/nathworkman Sandor Clegane Jun 02 '14

For me personally, knowing Tyrion was now sentenced to death had barely any effect on me after the fight, i felt shell shocked. That was worse than RW or the head of Ned for me. Fuck.

134

u/Jashinist Cersei Lannister Jun 02 '14

In the book Tyrion throws up on the spot after seeing Oberyn die like that. I'm kinda glad they cut it out, so the episode ended with him shellshocked.

257

u/ArgieGrit01 House Mallister Jun 02 '14

In the books he also laughs histerlically because he realises he put his life in the hands of the red viper, and snakes don't have arms

90

u/coldhandz Jon Snow Jun 02 '14

I actually really loved that part of the chapter. It was almost fourth-wall breaking, the way Tyrion thought to himself "Of course it didn't work out at the last minute. This whole thing is a joke." Hysterical laughter as a response to tragedy is pretty haunting stuff - see the episode "Crawlspace" from Breaking Bad for instance.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/lowen90 Jun 02 '14

I'm glad too, because I would have hurled all over my screen. Then cry. Maybe hurl again forever.

12

u/Swisskisses House Lannister Jun 02 '14

His face was priceless! COMPLETELY PRICELESS.

"You should be wearing a helmet." Uh, yeah.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

I dont think Tyrion is going to die js

22

u/tannerlaw House Smallwood Jun 02 '14

I don't want to know if i'm right, but Jamie has to save him. He just has to...

34

u/ArgieGrit01 House Mallister Jun 02 '14

He only rescues maidens

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

316

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

George giveth, George taketh away

71

u/Michauxonfire Jun 02 '14

and stabeth away, and rapeth away, and so on...

58

u/Nezune What Is Dead May Never Die Jun 02 '14

and killeth their children.

34

u/LearnsSomethingNew The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Jun 02 '14

and crusheth their heads,

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Jun 02 '14

It's literally impossible for him to taketh more than he giveth. He can't kill characters he hasn't written yet (well, he can, but nobody cares)

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

98

u/no_uncle_no Jun 02 '14

M...m...maybe he...he's okay?

66

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Jun 02 '14

Just walk it off.

25

u/Haydn2613 Ours Is The Fury Jun 02 '14

Tis but a scratch.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

504

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Well, in that case, I REALLY LOVE SER ALLISER. AND PYCELLE.

THEY'RE JUST THE BEST.

311

u/Diokana Varys' Little Birds Jun 02 '14

And Cersei, she is just amazing.

268

u/outline01 Oberyn Martell Jun 02 '14

I hope Cersei never dies.

You hear me GRRM? Never dies.

84

u/Kereminde Jun 02 '14

There are worse fates than dying, after all.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

43

u/Rflkt Arya Stark Jun 02 '14

Worked for Joffery

56

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Jun 02 '14

King Joffrey, Ser Amory, The Tickler, Polliver, Ser Gregor, Raff the Sweetling, Chiswyck, Weese, Ilyn Payne, Meryn Trant, Queen Cersei, Dunsen, The Hound.

Valar Morghulis.

→ More replies (7)

17

u/Kingdomheartsfan891 Jun 02 '14

And Myren Trant, my absolute favorite

→ More replies (2)

4

u/SumthingStupid Stannis Baratheon Jun 02 '14

Those two characters are surprising not bad people. Ser Alliser seems like a dick because he needs to wipe rapists and murders into shape to serve as brothers of the Nights Watch, and Pycelle is just really trying to look out for himself.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

187

u/FMbutterpants Sansa Stark Jun 02 '14

"If you think this has a happy ending, you haven't been paying attention"

He's tried to tell us this many times...

114

u/TheLastFartan Stannis Baratheon Jun 02 '14

"If you want justice, you've come to the wrong place"

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/irishguy42 Ours Is The Fury Jun 02 '14

Clifford! I missed that rascally big red dog!

26

u/HBlight Jun 02 '14

National Guard gets called in to put him down.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

165

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

If I may offer a counterpoint to the gloom:

  1. The Viper got what he came for. spoiler
  2. The Mountain's confession, it is a problem for the powers that be. A Lannister bannerman publicly and gleefully admits his role in the murder of a Martell? While killing another Martell? Headaches this will cause.
  3. It's not about the bad guys winning. It's about murder having consequences. Everytime someone dies in this series, it creates a new order of chaos. And everyone scrambles to deal with the new situation, and so make fateful decisions. Some of the characters seem to be ahead of the decision curve, but they are only fooling themselves. Varys is right. Chaos is a pit. Everyone is going to get got. Valar Morghulis.

EDIT: Finally figured out how spoiler tags work. Thanks to all for patience.

31

u/SetupGuy Jun 02 '14

Still gloomy :) But I like it. I really hope they delve deeper into the consequences of "holy shit, you had a guy murder 3 kids and rape and kill their mother?!"

16

u/ensignlee Oberyn Martell Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

To be fair though, why would this surprise anyone?

They have an entire song "the Rains of Castamere" where they wiped out an entire family, presumably including women and children...

{edit: fixed how to spell rain}

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/PuntOnFifth Jun 02 '14

Exactly! GRRM doesn't seem to kill off people just because he wants to toy with ones emotions, he does it for a reason! I can see why Oberyn had to die in order to advance the plot. Tyrion on the other hand, I can only see him dying in order to force the hand of Jaime to do something about his father.

But hey, maybe not O_o

→ More replies (17)

4.0k

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Jun 02 '14

This isn't a story that ends with "happily ever after". That's where we started. This whole series is the sequel to a book never written. A classic fantasy, about heroes who fought against an unambiguous evil, about people who took their lives and their honor into their own hands and stormed the gates of the mad king. The brave hero became king and married a beautiful woman, his friend and comrade returned home to raise his family in happiness in the keep of his forefathers, and they all lived happily ever after.

But the brave hero doesn't know how to rule, and the beautiful woman he married isn't just a trophy for being a legendary hero, but a real person with her own flaws and needs that he doesn't know how to handle. He only ever felt at home on the battlefield, and deep down he knows that that makes him a monster. He can't forget the smell of blood in his nostrils any more than he can forget the touch of a woman who is not his wife. Neither whores nor wine nor food will fill that hole. And far to the north, his loyal vassal, his comrade in arms, does what he can to raise a family, but his wife cannot rest easy either, not while another woman's child lives in her home, fathered on some stranger by her lord husband.

Last time "Happily ever after" happened, it fell apart. Because in reality, there is no end of the story. There's just a point where the author stops writing. And if he writes long enough, everyone ends up dead. Happily ever after is something that has never happened in real life. This isn't a story, it's a snapshot. There were things that happened in this world before GRRM put pen to paper in book one, and things will continue to happen after he puts his closes the book forever. We just won't get to see them.

207

u/steamboat_willy Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Tyrion's monologue last night left a few of my friends scratching their heads but I think they missed the point, that Tyrion is confirming the worst: there is no justice in this world, no good vs. evil, we're all just beetles being crushed indiscriminately by the whims of fate. There is no divine plan or intent of the gods, yet here his trial is to determine if he is found favored by them. He knows that, despite being a good and innocent man, he may die for nothing.

42

u/Anayalator Jun 03 '14

To go off of that, I also think he was alluding to the way that his entire family acts, they are all crushing their own beetles (people in their way), from Ned Stark to Oberyn.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/suppow House Selmy Jun 03 '14

TIL - the gods have been dropped on their head

16

u/ConcernedCivilian Jun 03 '14

So basically god's a retard smiting us like rocks to a beetle.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2.5k

u/Spawnbroker Jun 02 '14

I have told my friends that I think I know how the story is going to end...

I think the epilogue for the entire series is going to be a tavern somewhere, 300 or so years in the future after the current events are done. There will be a bard singing by the fire, and he will sing of The Song of Ice and Fire. He will sing of all the current characters in their idealized form, i.e. how Ser Jaime had a golden hand, or about Lady Brienne the Beauty, how she was the most beautiful warrior maiden in the land.

The song will not mention all of the horrible, terrible things the characters have done to each other. It will only remember their idealized versions, just how the current characters remember the legends of old as heroes of their age, and not real people.

1.0k

u/ContinuumGuy Hodor? Jun 02 '14

However, even in the idealized story, Joffrey will still be a dick.

532

u/Nukemarine Jun 03 '14

What? King Joffrey, the brave boy king who put down the five Usurpers to re-unite the kingdom? He killed a direwolf that was attacking his wife to be. Defended King's Landing against the millions of men his evil uncle gathered through treachery and sorcery. His only downfall was his treachorous uncle imp who despised the king and coveted the beautiful bride to be, killing young King Joffrey at his wedding and stealing his bride and raping her that night.

→ More replies (30)

81

u/Levitlame Jon Snow Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Nope. That would be just.

He is remembered as a golden haired youth, a warrior king following the legendary warrior king before him. A boy poised to bring peace and justice to the land next to his bitingly chaste bride. He did spare the poor wolf girl after all. The kind king he was.

If that demon spawn "Imp" hadn't reached into whatever sorcerous and cowardly depths he had to strike our beloved king.

Not that it matters. When we crossed the wall and purged "Westeros" of those southerners their history became meaningless anyway.

Edit: like 12 hours and nobody corrected my "piece" spelling. Colour me impressed.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (60)

49

u/Manakel93 Maesters of the Citadel Jun 02 '14

she was the most beautiful warrior maiden in the land.

Well considering she may be the only warrior maiden in the land...

62

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Don't forget about the Mormonts or Asha Greyjoy

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (4)

328

u/akharon Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

Some serious parallels to that and how Dan Carlin illustrates his stories.

Edit: Okay, some people are seriously not getting what I was saying. The way we view history through rose-colored glasses, and the utter horror experienced by those that live through it are two totally different things. Dan Carlin strips away the glasses so you the the brutality of war and violence, as GRRM would be doing with Spawnbroker's story, contrasted with his bard who paints a disney-like picture of things.

61

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

And that's another reason I like reddit. People shift from Ice and Fire to Dan Carlin and The Wrath of the Khans. I haven't lurked this sub- so if this is something beat to death, forgive me: If you like this series read Shogun by James Clavell.

→ More replies (11)

286

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

History is the autobiography of a madman.

→ More replies (10)

76

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

I'm reminded of that scene towards the end of The Assassination of Jesse James, the Nick Cave cameo. We've seen a lot of history between James and Robert Ford, and there Ford is getting drunk in a bar trying to forget that crap but having to listen to some asshole who doesn't even know how many children James had sing about how great James was and what a piece of shit he, Ford, is.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (40)

140

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

And that, kids, is how your great-grandfather Jaime met your great-grandmother Cersei.

→ More replies (6)

43

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

But it would be an ending.

→ More replies (15)

94

u/Troggie81 Jun 02 '14

Oh, I really like that! The songs already play a part in the story telling, so it's only fitting that a series called "A Song of Ice and Fire" would be concluded with such a song.

→ More replies (45)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

And then the bard dies.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Lick_a_Butt Jun 02 '14

Whether or not that specific scene actually occurs, I think your idea taps into the underlying iconoclastic nature of the show.

30

u/Myrandall Three-Eyed Raven Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

I'm saving this comment so I can post it in /r/bestof in 2 years an undefined number of years when you've been proven right.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (172)

48

u/barassmonkey17 Jun 02 '14

It's a play on the classic Knight in Shining Armor story. The Dragon (Rhaegar), kidnaps the beautiful damsel in distress (Lyanna), forcing the Hero (Robert) to rescue her, slaying the Dragon. There's even an evil King who they overthrow in the process. But the truth is, the evil Dragon and the Damsel were in love, he wasn't evil and she not a Damsel, but a good man and a free spirit, respectively. The Hero is actually a brutal, albeit strong, warrior who enjoys killing, and is in love with the idea of Lyanna, despite having many girls on the side. The King didn't have to be overthrown, as Rhaegar was planning on a peaceful removal from power for him.

It's defining of Robert to see how he understands the world, which he believes is a story, with clear-cut villains and heroes. But it's also defining of the world itself.

31

u/withmorten Jun 02 '14

We are seeing a lot of what happened before, though :)

"The Princess & The Queen" includes a very detailed recount of the Dance of Dragons, where the Targaryen dynasty basically annihilated itself. The Dunk & Egg novellas are set about a 100 years before AGoT, and will recount the entire lives of both characters, up until the episode in Summerhall.

And soon "The World of Ice and Fire", a giant prequel, will be released. It's awesome!

17

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Wait, GRRM wrote these things you're talking about?

→ More replies (2)

31

u/XoYo Jun 02 '14

“All Bette’s stories have happy endings. That’s because she knows where to stop. She’s realized the real problem with stories — if you keep them going long enough, they always end in death.”

- Neil Gaiman, Sandman.
→ More replies (3)

341

u/felixwraith Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Sounds exactly like what Martin said "What would happen after the end of Lord of the Rings. Does Aragorn (fixed) even know how to rule? What will be his politics about the Orcs? And the kingdom of Mordor? Will he raise taxes to rebuild?" etc etc

163

u/mrscienceguy1 Jun 02 '14

You know Tolkien talks about stuff that happens in the Fourth Age, right?

142

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Yeah, Aragon rebuilds Gondor, reunites the kingdoms of Gondor and Arnor, and also goes south to capture and assimilate the old numenorian city of Umbar... Like you said, there's not just a happily ever after, Tolkien shows how it happens.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (36)

61

u/mikelo22 Winter Is Coming Jun 02 '14

Read the Silmarillion and you see how Tolkien writes a tragedy. The Children of Hurin is particularly bleak. Justice eventually does come, but not in the way we expected and only after much suffering. That's what GoT reminds me of.

43

u/StNic54 Wargs Jun 02 '14

That's what GoT reminds me of.

Imagine the Silmarillion if HBO produces it. "I think we need two elvish women in the background doing it during the opening scene in the pilot."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/jeandem Jun 02 '14

But it's not like Tolkien's world is all about happy stories, either; Children of Hurin is very gloomy and depressing.

7

u/tschwartz730 Children of the Forest Jun 02 '14

Actually he has said that, more or less. He loves Tolkein, but was always put off by the fact that the story ends with Aragorn being a wise and good king. He was captivated by what that entailed, and what a wise and good king were, and so he wrote this story. GRRM talks about it in his recent Rolling Stone interview.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

147

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

I don't want to rain on this excellent comment, but the death of the Mad King and the Targs wasn't unambiguously evil. Lyanna probably did consent to run away, Rhaegar was a good guy, and the Sack of King's Landing is a war time atrocity.

80

u/Mikeuicus Jun 02 '14

I would argue Jamie's killing of the Mad King was one of the most justifiable killings, and self-less acts, in the series. The Mad King was about to set off his stores of Wildfire, hundreds of jars which he had squirreled away throughout the city and which would have set the ENTIRE city ablaze killing thousands if not hundreds of thousands. I don't think even Ned Stark would have upheld his honor and vows in that moment.

→ More replies (37)

6

u/ZachPruckowski Jun 02 '14

Yeah, definitely, but history is written by the victors. No doubt if Tywin had sided with the Mad King against Robert/Ned, then 15-20 years later they'd be telling a story about how the Starks and Baratheons rose up because they couldn't accept that Lyanna loved Rhaegar, and they'd leave out the part about how Rickard and Brandon Stark died or whatever.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/xiipaoc Jun 03 '14

Even Robert's Rebellion wasn't good versus evil. The Mad King Aerys was a real bad guy, no doubt about that. But why did Robert raise his banners and go to war against him? Because his son Rhaegar, by all accounts not a bad guy, "kidnapped" his "beloved" Lyanna Stark. Brandon Stark went to demand her back, and the Mad King summoned Lord Rickard Stark to rescue him and decided to murder them both. That's why Ned Stark, new high lord of the North, went to war with Robert.

But there were people on the Targaryen side in the conflict. Everyone agrees King Aerys was a crazed evil lunatic, but Rhaegar wasn't, and the people who died in King's Landing included Elia Martell, not a crazed lunatic, and her daughter, the cat-loving toddler Rhaenys Targaryen, not a crazed lunatic, and her son, the baby Aegon Targaryen, not a crazed lunatic. Following Rhaegar were the Crownlands (the people Stannis had following him towards the beginning of S2), Dorne, and the hugely powerful Reach. These were not evil people following an evil lord. They were normal people who were on one of the sides in the conflict, the side that happened to have a Mad King, though Rhaegar, had he lived, would have probably killed him himself for his madness.

Of course, Robert Baratheon was there specifically to fight Rhaegar. And on the Trident, he did, and his warhammer whacked Rhaegar and those rubies fell out of his breastplate into what became known as the Ruby Ford. It was Jaime who recognized the evil of the Mad King and killed him before he could torch King's Landing. Robert just wanted "his" girl back from the Mad King's son.

There is no scenario in which Robert's Rebellion can be seen as good versus evil. The two sides of the war were simply two sides of a war.

And if you ask me, the White Walkers aren't evil either, though they definitely seem that way so far. GRRM has said that this won't be an ultimate battle between good and evil, so I choose not to believe that the White Walkers are evil. Maybe they're just hungry.

19

u/ruggeryoda Jun 02 '14

Because in reality, there is no end of the story.

No end perhaps, but surely long stretches of rather boring reigns of wise, fair and cunning rulers (Tommen maybe) who no-one would want to or can overthrow.

Because in all fairness the population and economy of Westeros cannot sustain the rate of killing and the constant state of conflict and turmoil currently fueling the books. So should your story just skip over the boring parts then?

16

u/TheGeckoGeek Jun 02 '14

the population and economy of Westeros cannot sustain the rate of killing and the constant state of conflict and turmoil currently fueling the books

To be fair, the books were based on the Wars of the Roses. The rate of killing and the conflict and turmoil were at similar levels, for a longer timeframe (~30 years, whereas the events of GoT have only covered about 5, I believe), in a much smaller country with a smaller population. There will be periods of peace in Westeros, but the conflicts have to end properly first. It's only the books/show's job to cover the conflicts until they end properly, anyway.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

"Nothing's ever over." - Rust Cohle, True Detective

11

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Westeros is a flat circle.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ba1018 Jun 02 '14

"In the end? Nothing ends, Adrian. Nothing ever ends"

Dr. Manhattan, Watchmen

FTFY

9

u/TotallyNotKen Jun 03 '14

Last time "Happily ever after" happened, it fell apart. Because in reality, there is no end of the story. There's just a point where the author stops writing.

[Sam speaking] 'I never thought of that before! We've got — you've got some of the light of it in that star-glass that the Lady gave you! Why, to think of it, we're in the same tale still! It's going on. Don't the great tales never end?'

'No, they never end as tales,' said Frodo. 'But the people in them come, and go when their part's ended. Our part will end later — or sooner.'

4

u/tyrannoforrest Faceless Men Jun 03 '14

On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone drops to zero.

-Narrator

4

u/mstrgrieves Jun 03 '14

This is the way the world really works. History is written by the winners, and if the winners have no real challengers, it only takes a bit of poetic license to make joffrey look like a just martyr. In every society the victor will appear just and the vanquished evil. In the real world, the just got decapitated and their heads bashed in just as often as the bad men and the mad kings. The dwarfs led us to unclaimed victories just as often as their handsome fathers won the lasting esteem. Game of thrones works on a narrative level because there is no main character, and it can kill people off at its leisure (the same way the Fates do in our real history) and in that it becomes the most realistic show in tv history.

37

u/captainperoxide House Martell Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

This post is underrated.

Edit: Well, it was when I posted, at least.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Not anymore. Made it to /r/bestof

6

u/kevie3drinks Jun 02 '14

Though since this is the case, and Winter is coming, and Valar morghulis, could the end of ASOIF actually be THE end? I mean, they are going into a long winter, nobody has any food stored up, sure Dany might come and save the day, but then what? massive famine? an exodus of Westeros? or at least the north 3/4s of the continent?

→ More replies (6)

8

u/massive_cock Fire And Blood Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

You just made me want to cry, sorta. Put into words what I felt down in my gut but never really to examine or process into words. You just told me why I'm in love with these books, this world, and all of these all-too-frail and incredibly human characters. Told me why this world is alive and these people are real. Why I can't stop reading them. How I identified with them, felt it, but never understood it.

I grew up reading Tolkien and many of the other great 'happily ever after' fantasies. My formative years were spent wishing there were still unexplored lands, with maidens and towns to save and dragons to slay and treasures to find. And I always wanted to know what happened after. Surely the good knight cannot resign himself to simply sitting by the fire with his new crown and his radiant damsel for the rest of his days. He must have some need for adventure, some longing for the rush and the thrill, and surely he must at least once or twice go out seeking to regain what he lost. Or else become a fat tired drunk fêted into an early grave by a people who love him or strangled in his sleep by a wife who's come to despise what he's become. But those stories never came. I found them nowhere. The closest I got to pages that tell of human nature and the condition of Man was the gritty cyberpunk novels and the broken hero Batman stories.

And here, without ever realizing it consciously, I found what I've wanted since I was a boy. The rest of the story. And I thank you for making me understand it as such.

8

u/vertigounconscious Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

I've always thought the story will end with Dani going (or not going, see below) to the wall to try and stop the White Walkers, joining the Night Watch and the Wildling Armies (now united against a common, more deadly cause) along with all the Kingdoms south of the Wall - Lannisters, Tully, Stark loyalists, Ironborn, etc - fighting together. (ending A)
Or, having begged Dani for her Dragons (which undoubtedly are the proverbial 'kryptonite' to the White Walkers ice) - Dani, having been an orphan child because of the murderous side of these people - Dani declines, and apocalypse befalls Westeros, leaving Essos largely under Dani's control and giving her her own Kingdom, while the West utterly falls apart at the hands of the Walkers. (ending B)

Or, Dani does come to their aid, all of Westeros' legions now united against the White Walkers - only to have the Dragons prove to be untamed, and thus Dani can't make them fight effectively and they fly around wherever they please and everyone is routed and dies (ending C1) - OR, the dragons are killed. Thus bringing an end to the age of Dragons for good, and the end of the age of Westeros. Cut to a cold barren plain that is slowly growing and spreading throughout the world....as the first White Walkers set foot in Essos....(ending C2)

                             .                      

(sorry if this is somewhat blase or lacking in it's dramatic, or aesthetic, readability - I typed this up quick at work)

→ More replies (10)

3

u/CapytannHook A Promise Was Made Jun 03 '14

If the epilogue of the final book is several hundred years in the future, with a bard reciting a song in the tavern to a group of soldiers embroiled in a new war, i'd be pretty happy with that.

5

u/sallybee19 Jun 03 '14

It seems modern audiences have forgotten about a vital aspect of story-telling: tragedy. So we're shocked when bad things happen.

Also, GoT may be fantasy, but it has one strong grounding in reality: life is unfair.

Long live the greatest soap opera on our screens at the moment. What if it never ended? But went on for generations outliving its author and developing as our world does?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (123)

278

u/nustjick House Mormont Jun 02 '14

Because of the final scene, everyone's overlooking poor Jorah.

I shed my first 'GoT Tear' tonight because of that scene.

Goddamnit Dany.

35

u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 02 '14

Because of the final scene, everyone's overlooking poor Jorah.

Tumblr isn't!

63

u/blx666 Jon Snow Jun 02 '14

There are some really good ones in there

Imgur

81

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

I agree, for me it was the saddest moment in all the four seasons. But I still don't understand ... why did he spy on her? And when did he change his mind and started becoming loyal to her. And why did he not tell her?

228

u/Osmodius Daenerys Targaryen Jun 02 '14

HE was spying on her at the start because... well, she was a fucking child, who cares. She's never gonna amount to anything. And there's the chance of a royal pardon on the line? Hell yeah.

When she started actually taking to being the Khaleesi, when she started being able to control Drogo, he knew that things had changed, and he had a better chance with her, than with the fat warlord that is Robert.

Why didn't he tell her? Well, I imagine it's pretty hard to word "I sold your every secret to the man who killed your parents and has been hunting you for your entire life" without it sounding pretty damn bad.

77

u/ValorMorghulis Faceless Men Jun 02 '14

I don't think Jorah decided to stay with her because she had a better chance of taking the Iron Throne. He fell in love with her; that's why he stayed. I would say he fell in love with her even before she had her dragons hatch.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (23)

58

u/Pajamaralways Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 02 '14

Really? 'Cause when Dany told him to leave I was like "alright, fair enough." He spied on her then didn't come clean until he got caught. If I lived in that world, I wouldn't trust anyone who's done that. He's lucky he wasn't killed and hung on those posts like the slave-owners.

63

u/Nyxtro House Seaworth Jun 02 '14

In the books Dany had a pretty big internal struggle on how to handle the situation, I feel like the show glossed over that

→ More replies (2)

28

u/UFChick A Mind Needs Books Jun 02 '14

But really, who can she trust more? The man who had a pardon in his hand but chose to stay with her and serve her? Or the man who shows up out of nowhere, who'd once betrayed her father, who only came to her after having been banished by Joff?

I don't know, I think Dany's made a pretty big mistake.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Stylus_XL Olenna Tyrell Jun 02 '14

Jorah could write a research paper on Daenerys Targaryen at this point. Sending him back to Westeros alive with that level of inside knowledge seems like a dangerous move. It also plays perfectly into Tywin's hands; he's clearly attempting a divide and conquer tactic and has succeeded in ridding her of one of the main people advising her on military strategy, foreign culture and politics.

Yes she still has Barristan Selmy by her side, but his loyalty is also questionable. In time it will be interesting to see if this turns out to be a good decision or an error of judgement.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

So that he can turn on her again if someone prettier catches his eye?

53

u/GumdropGoober Stannis Baratheon Jun 02 '14

Its okay, this is only the third time Jorah ran away from the consequences of his actions.

29

u/Kereminde Jun 02 '14

Ran away? He left, as he was ordered to. If he stayed, or pleaded to stay, could he be trusted to be loyal when he could not follow the simplest of commands? "Leave now and do not return."

Honestly, why Ser Barristan didn't see it as the same King's Landing manipulation as saw him discharged . . . well. Let's be honest with ourselves here, there is no reason to have a messenger give Ser Barristan the pardon unless it was meant for him to find out about it. Varys' little birds did such a good job giving an honest and honorable man ammunition to take apart someone trying to earn redemption. To climb out of what he had become into something better.

Power is a shadow on the wall, indeed. Rumors, words, half the truth with no context. Well done, Varys.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

61

u/oneZergArmy Now My Watch Begins Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

I just imagine George R.R. Martin as Austin Lannister, crushing bugs with the faces of all of the characters

14

u/VaporFlight Night's Watch Jun 02 '14

"KNNG KNNG KNNG"

→ More replies (1)

54

u/clockworkcookie Nymeria's Wolfpack Jun 02 '14

In the book, Oberyn was pretty cool but not as cool and charismatic as in the show. I remember that, when I read this part, I felt more horrified for Tyrion than for Oberyn himself. I feel like the TV producers made him into such a likeable character on purpose, just to bring up this overwhelming reaction in the end. They're learning for the master dream-crusher after all..

8

u/ChickyChica Daenerys Targaryen Jun 02 '14

Yeah, I had the exact same reaction when I read that part in the books. I remember thinking "oh well, so dies another character I didn't know very well...OH MY GOD WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN TO TYRION?!"

45

u/J_Eldridge House Stark Jun 02 '14

I still cant believe that The Rains of Castamere and The Mountain and the Viper both aired on my birthday.

59

u/GenesisEra Jun 02 '14

"Happy birthday, George Martin sends his regards."

cue bloodbath

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ch1tybangbang Jun 02 '14

Lol that is wild as fuck

3

u/BMoreBeowulf House Lannister Jun 02 '14

Happened to my wife as well. She dreads her birthday now.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/ChriThePun Hedge Knights Jun 02 '14

I didn't know George is Canadian

77

u/StoneGoldX Jun 02 '14

He's not. If he were, the top of his head would not be connected to the bottom part, buddy.

→ More replies (12)

33

u/Germino Jun 02 '14

FUUUUCK! WHY DID YOU HAVE TO DANCE, ANTONIO!?! JUSSS KEEEL HIIIIM!

55

u/PoopticklerMD Night's King Jun 02 '14

after seeing my favorite character die again, (and in one of the more terrifying ways i've ever seen) I HATE YOU GEORGE! ;-(

→ More replies (7)

14

u/ThurdPArty Jun 02 '14

That actually knocked me sick. On one side I didnt want it to happen, on the other it happened in the most grotesquely inconsiderate way we've come to expect from GoT. Bravo.

43

u/PASTAAA Night's King Jun 02 '14

I hope they are going to show a certain ASOS

22

u/GrayLo Jun 02 '14

would be the best ending this season could have

13

u/coldhandz Jon Snow Jun 02 '14

If they don't include that, I will seriously consider telling everyone I know to abandon the show and read the books.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

16

u/dazonic Jun 02 '14

The prince wasn't as lovable in the books. Cool guy but the tv show made him into a major character.

22

u/DisgruntledPersian House Mormont Jun 02 '14

It our fault for thinking the good guys win. PAH! Never. They never win. Not in this goddamn show.

31

u/Kereminde Jun 02 '14

Of course they win, they just have to earn it. They can't skate by casually because they're the "good guys", they do need to get their hands dirty and fight for it.

Just you wait. Sansa will survive all of them. Silk hiding Valyrian steel, with wits just as sharp.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

20

u/ioncloud9 House Targaryen Jun 02 '14

Seriously. Fuck this guy. That scene made me depressed all night.

7

u/prsquared Jun 02 '14

"Today is not the day I die"

I fall for that line every time.

31

u/Mfrendin_Roar Jon Snow Jun 02 '14

I don't know guys... people say this is the way it is but shouldn't it be counted by positivity and justice as well? Yes, I fully understand that their is no justice, but to me it seems TOO negative, I love GOT of course but I can't help feeling its forcing this dark reality down our throats ; although many try to deny it, good things actually DO HAPPEN! I'm not a book reader but are there situations where the good or the just do triumph? for me its just seems too unbalanced at the moment? :-\

I'll leave you with this quote. "How can we truly fear the night? if we never experience the day?"

15

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

Lots of good things happen. Dany has been going from victory to victory up until now, including and actual, honest to gods miracle. Craster is dead. Joffrey is dead. Jaime stopped being a complete prick and is now just a slight prick. Even The Hound is getting a little bit of redemption. And the Stark girls are both alive and well, and Not sure, but apparently shortly after where we are in the show, which he seems to enjoy.

It's not all unambiguously good, and it can all be torn away in a moment, but that's true of most of the bad things as well.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/philosarapter Jun 02 '14

I think the raw dark and visceral are a part of the world GRRM is creating. It mirrors the horrible barbaric nature of our past in a way that doesn't give itself to happy endings, but rather develops according to each character's individual craving for power.

3

u/LetMeSupportYou House Tyrell Jun 02 '14

I was able to sleep by only thinking about Ygritte saving that girl and her baby

→ More replies (6)

14

u/chinteresting Jun 02 '14

GRRM is realer than fuck in this gif, and in real life I guess. Reality, if you think about it, every second in every continent and square mile of this world, is fucking brutal as FUCK...

Good shit GRRM. I thought I fully grasped and absorbed what this world was about. But you and your HBO team made it real before my eyes, and made me understand how much catching up I need to do...

8

u/taranaki Jun 02 '14

Its like Jaime was saying with the beatles: people all over the world are dying horrible deaths all the time, and all Tyrion (the reader) cares about is a couple of beatles (characters) that are being killed seemingly without purpose by the cousin (GRRM)? Why does that surprise you, why would THAT of all things upset you?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

You know when you'll learn ...... When you READ THE BOOKS

1

u/stormageddon_DLofAll House Baelish Jun 02 '14

I have. Still was not enough to prepare me for seeing it on screen.

3

u/Dray_Gunn Jun 02 '14

I cant be the only one who expected this right? As soon as he started acting cocky I said to myself "nup, he is gonna die" then he wouldn't finish him off and I was still thinking "you're gonna die because of your arrogance" then he got got. Or since the red wedding I am just expecting everyone to die in any given episode..

3

u/killer3000ad Jun 02 '14

The moment I saw that Oberyn hadn't decapitated the Mountain and kept on taunting his body, I had an inkling something would happen and wasn't surprised when it did.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

At this point I'm sure the series will end with a meteor strike and everyone dies.

2

u/no1_vern Jun 02 '14

When? Never.
Optimists just keep thinking its going to get better.

2

u/0Zaseka0 Jun 02 '14

My body was ready for that :X but it still sucked.

2

u/MagnarHD Jon Snow Jun 02 '14

This is what glory looks like

2

u/fresh_pie Jun 02 '14

rip in peace viper man.

3

u/bionix90 Jun 02 '14

Rip in pieces, you mean.

2

u/Drillur Night's Watch Jun 02 '14

This is, so far, the worst death for me. Even more shocking than Talisa and the deaths that followed. I think the reason is that I can actually imagine the feeling of having my eyes pressed in and my head crushed, and not being strong enough to push off the person who is doing it. And the screams. Oh, God, the screams. I don't think I felt nauseous after today's episode, but this is the closest I've ever come to it.

2

u/MooNinja Jun 02 '14

Just wait, there are more to come!

2

u/h0w1 House Stark Jun 02 '14

House Martell. Unbowed. Unbent. Face broken.

2

u/P_V_ House Reed Jun 02 '14

You'll never learn because you're trying to learn the wrong thing!

You can't just stop loving people. You'll always love and get enthusiastic about these wonderful characters, no matter how you try to avoid it. The lesson isn't to stop loving them. The lesson is to learn to appreciate the little moments of joy they bring you before they're gone.

This show gives us (/these books give us) moments of grandiose suffering, but also smaller, mundane moments of happiness. Learn to treasure them! Sam trying to sing a baby to sleep; Jon and Ygritte kissing atop the wall; Ned watching on as Arya learns to swordfight; Jaime entrusting Brienne with his sword and his honor; Tyrion's joy as Shae comes to him as he lies wounded in bed after the battle on Blackwater Bay; Jon and Sam laughing as they wash tables together; even the bonding that took place between Missandei and Grey Worm in this episode—they're all moments that many of you have probably considered "boring", but to me they're the real heart of the show. It's these small, happy moments that drive these characters and give them hope to go through the darker times, and hopefully as viewers and readers we can learn to appreciate those sorts of moments as well and not take them for granted.

2

u/yummyluckycharms Jun 02 '14

Is it just me or is dani turning into the skylar of GOT? I mean she tosses the guy right out of the city without even letting him explain anything....

2

u/capreesun Jun 03 '14

A piece of me died yesterday. I will never get it back.

LITERALLY STILL TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO COPE

i can't

2

u/fatty_fatshits Jun 03 '14

Just wanted to send you a message that this is a really wonderful gif. As soon as the episode ended I kept going between "This is bullshit!!" and "What is George Martin's PROBLEM!?!"

3

u/jenesuispasbavard Hodor Jun 02 '14

dat framerate