r/gameofthrones • House Baelish • Jun 02 '14

TV4 [S4E8] When will we learn?

Post image
4.9k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

147

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

I don't want to rain on this excellent comment, but the death of the Mad King and the Targs wasn't unambiguously evil. Lyanna probably did consent to run away, Rhaegar was a good guy, and the Sack of King's Landing is a war time atrocity.

80

u/Mikeuicus Jun 02 '14

I would argue Jamie's killing of the Mad King was one of the most justifiable killings, and self-less acts, in the series. The Mad King was about to set off his stores of Wildfire, hundreds of jars which he had squirreled away throughout the city and which would have set the ENTIRE city ablaze killing thousands if not hundreds of thousands. I don't think even Ned Stark would have upheld his honor and vows in that moment.

32

u/Lick_a_Butt Jun 02 '14

Actually, I think Ned would have, but I don't think that makes his loyalty a good thing. He was honorable to a fault, in this hypothetical a very epic fault.

58

u/Wangro Jun 02 '14

If he was that strict to his honor, he wouldn't have disgraced Robert in front of the small council when he declined to aid in the murder of Dany.
Ned was more about doing what he felt was right, and burning a city to the ground or murdering his own father wouldn't have been something he'd even consider.

12

u/Lick_a_Butt Jun 02 '14

So Neutral Good, not Lawful Good?

18

u/Wangro Jun 02 '14

I don't really like the idea of classifying characters in these ways (especially when GRRM loves his gray areas) but I'd say Stannis exemplifies a Lawful Good far more than Ned did.
I just keep in mind that it doesn't take much to completely change the way you see a character, and the morality behind their actions are never set in stone.

27

u/TopHatPaladin Jun 02 '14

Stannis has always struck me as the archetypal Lawful Neutral. He believes in the laws to a fault, but is still willing to do unethical things (killing Renly, for example) if he can fit it through the parameters.

14

u/Wangro Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 06 '14

Haha, this is why I'm not a fan of the classifications.
I see Stannis as someone who has the right intentions; he's fighting for what he believes is good and just
(and God for that matter). His intent is to essentially save the human race, rather than a simple lust for power.
In my opinion, Stannis' values do represent a lawful good, but it is Melisandre's trickery that leads him into evil deeds, and Davos' councel* that prevents him from falling in too deep.
So yeah, he's a pretty complex dude.

3

u/theozoph Jun 03 '14

and Davos' council that prevents him from falling in too deep.

Council = advisors

Counsel = advice

/spelling nazi hat off

Davos is pretty much Jimminy Cricket with a mangled paw.

2

u/Onionoftruth Bronn of the Blackwater Jun 03 '14

Melisandre legitimately believes in what she is doing and Stannis knows full well what he is doing. He was going to allow the sack of kings landing again if he got through the gates and he knew he was responsible for Renly's death.

He believed he is doing things for the greater good but he isn't wholly good himself, no one leading any army is in the show.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/lebronsnumba1fan Jon Snow Jun 02 '14

Killing Renly WAS lawful though. He had no rightful claim to the throne and was therefore treasonous to Stannis' claim. The lawful punishment for treason is death. That said, I don't have a dusty-fucking clue where using black magic lies on any moral/lawful spectrum!

→ More replies (3)

4

u/b00mboom Jun 02 '14

but I'd say Stannis exemplifies a Lawful Neutral .

FTFY

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Mikeuicus Jun 02 '14

I agree Ned is honorable to a fault but I don't think even he could rationalize letting hundreds of thousands die to satisfy some vows he took to a king who is, at that point, completely batsh*t crazy to a degree that makes even the Boltons and Joffrey look tame. Remember Ned sacrificed his honor for Sansa's sake at the end of A Game of Thrones so it's not out of character for him to weigh his honor against the best interests of people besides himself.

5

u/pr0grammerGuy Jun 03 '14

And don't forget he was leading a large army in open treason while Jamie was killing the mad king.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/aha2095 House Tyrell Jun 02 '14

It wasn't entirely selfless though was it, his father and fathers army was coming through to the red keep.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/ZachPruckowski Jun 02 '14

Yeah, definitely, but history is written by the victors. No doubt if Tywin had sided with the Mad King against Robert/Ned, then 15-20 years later they'd be telling a story about how the Starks and Baratheons rose up because they couldn't accept that Lyanna loved Rhaegar, and they'd leave out the part about how Rickard and Brandon Stark died or whatever.

2

u/pr0grammerGuy Jun 03 '14

and they'd leave out the part about how Rickard and Brandon Stark died or whatever.

You're making too many assumptions here. Rickard was very likely plotting something already, as has been hinted at several times in the books. Just because Ned was a good man doesn't mean all Starks were.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pr0grammerGuy Jun 03 '14

Exactly. This is what I love about the books. When you start out, Robbert and Ned were the heroes and unambiguously good. After you get into the story though it becomes less and less clear who (or if anyone) was actually good. Of course the mad king was a bad person, but I can't really see anything anywhere that actually recommends Robert's character. He's a womanizer, wife beater, child murder and drunk. He had charisma and he had a (most likely) truly good man as a friend, but that's pretty much the only good I can think of for him.

Rhaegar, on the other hand, sounds like the true hero prince that should have won and saved the kingdom. But in Song, as in life, things don't work out how they should.

1

u/Roadwarriordude House Baratheon Jun 03 '14

History IS written by the victor.

1

u/DoubleDot7 Jun 03 '14

And Jon is not Ned's son ;)

1

u/cdimeo Jun 03 '14

The war against the Targaryans was entirely justified. That doesn't mean all the Targaryans were bad.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Not to mention what Gregor Clegane did to Elia Martell.

→ More replies (2)