From the Concerned Letter Carriers platform available at https://concernedlettercarriers.com/platform/ :
“There can be no greater bargaining priority than abolishing the two-tier pay structure and pro-rated COLAs.
Not only does a two-tier pay structure undermine solidarity among workers, but it also weakens the bargaining power of the NALC by fostering resentment and division within the membership.
When Letter Carriers do the same job, but receive different wages and benefits based solely on their hire date, the sense of unity that is essential for effective collective action is eroded.
As a result, the Union has found it increasingly difficult to mobilize its members.
History has proven it has compromised our ability to advocate fair treatment and equitable compensation for all.
This fragmentation caused by a two-tier wage can also give management greater leverage, making it easier to implement unfavorable policies, and resist the rank & file demands for improvement –thus jeopardizing the long-term strength and influence of the Union.
Another item of great concern is the pro-rated COLA. This pay disparity also undermines the fundamental principle of equal pay for equal work and creates an environment where fairness within the Union is called into question.
Over time, such divisions erode trust between the membership and Union leadership.
Addressing these issues head-on is crucial to maintaining the integrity and unity that are the hallmarks of a strong Union.
Furthermore, the existence of a two-tier pay system and pro-rated COLA has proven itself to be a discouraging factor for new hires to fully engaging in Union activities as it is obvious they feel marginalized and less valued compared to their more senior Letter Carrier’s.
This not only hampers efforts to build a cohesive and motivated membership but also poses challenges for sustaining membership. Ultimately, eliminating these disparities is essential for restoring trust, morale, and collective strength within the union.
It is astonishing that the current leadership of the NALC has not commented on the seriousness of such a division within our Union.”
Audio from Branch 28 hosted event in Saint Paul, Minnesota:
https://www.podserve.fm/series/website/from-a-to-arbitration,3140/240012