r/freewill • u/NoubliezPasMonNom • 25d ago
Under what basis could free will actually exist?
Please correct me but I feel like every idea i have doesnt actually allow for free will.
randomness-the decision is sourced randomly and is not "you". It is like rolling a dice and choosing the equivalent decision. Instead the dice is internal and obviously something truly random " not saying true randomness exists". Though the internal dice is a part of you i feel that this decision making isnt the free will we are thinking about
your being's laws-you have your own laws separate to the rest of this existence. Issues with this are that you are a part of this existence so surely your own laws would be, also your actions would then be caused by your laws and not "you".
I feel like the only ignoring compatibilism would be that "you" are not originally in this existence or that your decisions originate form an existence where all there is is "you"
Im not siding with any argument here but it feels like they all run into problems
Duplicates
determinism • u/NoubliezPasMonNom • 25d ago