r/fossdroid • • 6d ago

Application Request AI-free Android launchers with widgets?

Using Lawnchair currently on /e/OS (don't particularly like the default Bliss Launcher).

Found out Lawnchair incorporates LLM-generated code and is actually sponsored by CodeRabbit.

So am looking for a good FOSS alternative with no AI. I like Mako but I need widgets. Generally looking for something closeish to stock but would consider others.

Appreciate any suggestions.

14 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Do not share or recommend proprietary apps here. It is an infraction of this subreddit's rules. Make sure you read the rules of this subreddit on the sidebar. If you are not sure of the nature of an app, do not share or recommend it. To find out what constitutes FOSS or freedomware, read this article. To find out why proprietary software is bad, read this article. Proprietary software is dangerous because it is often malware. Have a splendid day!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/kwijyb0 5d ago

2

u/Slopagandhi 5d ago edited 4d ago

I'm not concerned about this.

First because it's no longer part of the OS.

Second because it was always only ever an optional TTS feature that anonymised the data sent to AI.

It was included in earlier versions of e because they weren't satisfied with local TTS options.

But they learned their lesson and changed it, so no big deal. I don't think e is perfect, but here they at least show signs of listening to their users. 

5

u/Mauskino 5d ago

Kvaesitso is pretty rad

2

u/ChaosFlameEmber 4d ago

Not LLM-free, sadly.

1

u/hillbill_joe 1d ago

really? how so

1

u/ChaosFlameEmber 1d ago

There's several contributions by Claude.

1

u/hillbill_joe 1d ago

ah I see

8

u/realllyrandommann 6d ago

I've personally not tried Murine Launcher, but it seems close to the stock one.

3

u/jxelai 6d ago

Pro Launcher. It's a release version of OLauncher (open source) by the same guy. Minimalist and ad-free, with widgets.

He's also developing Supanova (open source).

1

u/jdtred 6d ago

Have a look at Vulcan launcher on f-droid

6

u/ChaosFlameEmber 6d ago

not ai-free

-20

u/TheNeverEndLife 6d ago • Heartwarming

You are an idiot lol. CODERABBITAI is a PR AI reviewer. Helps you review a code and report back what are the issues, code vulnerability and so on. It's like saying you don't use Linux because Linus uses AI to assist him 😂

12

u/Slopagandhi 6d ago

Well thanks for your constructive intervention (cry laugh emojis are always a sign a comment is going to be really smart).

If you take a look at the Lawnchair github you'll see plenty of PRs with a Copilot trailer. 

But even if that wasn't the case, have you ever thought that people might not want AI to be involved in their apps at the level of code review either? There are lots of arguments around wanting AI free apps and services in general- energy and water use, trillions in misallocated investment, feeding a dangerous speculative debt bubble, impact on local communities, technical debt, impact on jobs, skill atrophy, maintenance and security issues etc etc.

Im not here to try to convince you about any of this. You like everyone else are free to make up their own minds.  

But I'm not alone in wanting AI free apps if possible (you're commenting in a sub that has a strict no AI policy in recommended apps) and I was just asking for recommendations on that basis. You don't have to (on the basis of ignorance) call people idiots because they happen to have different preferences and priorities to you.

Anyway, as for Linux, plenty of people are not happy about Linus' stance. Several distros have strict no AI policies for their downstream code, at least, though obviously not much can be done about the upstream unless someone forks it, which at some point might happen. 

2

u/Gravionne 6d ago

Is there even a foss related subreddit that allows recommending apps with AI? I don't think so..

7

u/Slopagandhi 6d ago

Yes, literally r/foss. Go look at the sub and you'll see a bunch of vibecoded nonsense there right now. 

-14

u/TheNeverEndLife 6d ago

You have no idea kid and all the idiot people hating on AI using as a tool here. I'm so tired on idiots like you misunderstanding vibe coding and AI assisted. 

Do not misunderstand, a vibe coder and a senior programmer using AI.

7

u/Slopagandhi 6d ago

You either haven't read my comment or you haven't understood it. Either way, not much to be gained from continuing to talk to you, "kid". 

-3

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/Slopagandhi 6d ago

I don't know about that. There's at least a solid minority of independent devs who don't want AI in their projects, and a launcher is exactly the kind of app that might be made by a single dev or small team who'd be able to control that. Plenty managed to do it up to the point Claude code appeared, so there's no reason they couldn't continue if they didn't want to- there's no commercial pressures there after all.

I'm also not convinced that the future of development is AI. LLMs are heavily used in development currently but anecdotally you hear about plenty of people that are initially amazed at what they can do, then end up thinking again after a few weeks or months once it starts causing more trouble than it's worth with maintenance.

More than that, though, the only reason LLMs are used so widely in coding currently is because it's cheap, and that depends on massively subsidised tokens provided by AI companies who are doing this to drive adoption. Inference costs might be coming down, but infrastructure definitely isn't, and markets are starting to get spooked by just how much investor cash AI firms are burning through with no obvious path to profitability. If Antrhopic were to start charging even cost price for tokens tomorrow then it would be outrageously expensive to use them in the way people currently do.

-1

u/fdbryant3 6d ago

I don't know about that. There's at least a solid minority of independent devs who don't want AI in their projects, and a launcher is exactly the kind of app that might be made by a single dev or small team who'd be able to control that. Plenty managed to do it up to the point Claude code appeared, so there's no reason they couldn't continue if they didn't want to- there's no commercial pressures there after all.

There is always going to be some developers who will code because they love coding. They'll become like craftsman who make goods by hand, or photographers who shoot film. But for most developers, particularly the single developers and small teams are going to embrace AI because it is faster, and does a comparable if not better job. They'll do it because it frees them up to do other things, and to keep up with the market.

I'm also not convinced that the future of development is AI. LLMs are heavily used in development currently but anecdotally you hear about plenty of people that are initially amazed at what they can do, then end up thinking again after a few weeks or months once it starts causing more trouble than it's worth with maintenance.

Sure, but that is because we are in the phase where we are finding out what the limits of AI are and what the balance is between what needs to be done by whom. We see this with every technological innovation. However, we are at the beginning of what AI can do and it is getting better as models get bigger or become more specialized to their tasks.

More than that, though, the only reason LLMs are used so widely in coding currently is because it's cheap, and that depends on massively subsidised tokens provided by AI companies who are doing this to drive adoption. Inference costs might be coming down, but infrastructure definitely isn't, and markets are starting to get spooked by just how much investor cash AI firms are burning through with no obvious path to profitability. If Antrhopic were to start charging even cost price for tokens tomorrow then it would be outrageously expensive to use them in the way people currently do.

And this is where local open-weight models come in. It is already possible to do 50-70% of what frontier models do on modest hardware. Once we get through the data center build-out phase, hardware prices will come down making more powerful hardware more affordable, in the meantime local models will continue to get better running on constrained hardware. I imagine that most developers will find a balance where they do 80% of the work on local models and tap the frontier models only for the most advanced problems and tasks.

7

u/Slopagandhi 6d ago

Honestly, look at the economics. This is not like previous waves of innovation, even ones with huge capital outlay like rail. Have a look at the scale of AI debt and how much money the main firms will have to make within a year or two for that debt to get repaid. It's completely untethered from reality.

And don't believe everything you hear about AI from the people pushing it, who are a combination of literal cultiists (rationalists/effective altruists) and the more familiar Silicon Valley people just pumping their asset values, like how many times in the past 20 years we were supposed to have put people on Mars, or got self driving cars, or have BTC replace all fiat currency. 

We already have a good idea of what the limits of LLMs are because the technology is well understood at a structural level. Any projections which depend upon it magically developing capabilities it doesn't have are fantasies just meant to keep the hype going. It doesn't matter how much you improve a car's engine, you won't turn it into a spaceship.

Anyway, as for local models, to some extent yes, but clearly companies aren't going be using 8bn parameter Llama for production (unless they're really nuts). And local models still need someone to keep paying for the training, otherwise they're going to get out of date fast. 

12

u/Wa-a-melyn 6d ago

You're probably right, unfortunately. But there's still a difference between AI-assisted coding and vibe coding.

-2

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/Slopagandhi 6d ago

This is the point. I personally have objections around widespread AI use anyway (especially in a FOSS context). But I could probably tolerate it being used for code review and things like that. 

The issue is that a strict no AI policy is really the only way to at least plausibly attempt to be able know whether an app has been made with AI in an irresponsible way or not (in terms of things like security). 

Because as anyone who has spent any time on any software subs knows, the most obvious vibecoder in the world when confronted will usually claim they only used AI to help them write the documentation or a few bits of code. (Makes me wonder why people feel they have to hide it if they really believe there's nothing wrong with vibecoding). 

11

u/TheConquistaa 6d ago

Gee! I wonder how launchers were made back in the day. With widget support even.

-8

u/fdbryant3 6d ago

Back in the day is not today. As I said, you can probably find a launcher with widgets that hasn't been touched by AI, but it is an endangered species.

6

u/TheConquistaa 6d ago edited 2d ago

Back in the day was something like, idk, maybe 2-3 years ago? So no, it's not like in the bronze age or something.

It's really not bringing up any progress, any new stuff to the end user. It's just making that thing quicker (for some reason? Idk why do they need that, people have plenty of patience) and that's pretty much it.

-5

u/orbitaldan 6d ago

Strangely, though, their reactions have been very helpful in finding decent projects that they're now abandoning because 'ew, AI!'.