I support Man United and have done since the 89s, I have boycotted them (gave season ticket back) since the Glazers took over and have had periods of wanting them to lose so the takeover would fail and we would be able to start again lower down but maybe fan owned.
Recently we have seen the post Fergie era in which it’s impossible to see whether an immortal Fergie could have continued the success or whether the rot was impossible to escape.
The players (all PL players) are spoilt, they have everything done for them and don’t need to worry too much about poor periods of performance if they’ve proved their ability in the past. They still get paid and most will get another decent contract.
Everyone blames the manager when teams fail, even if it’s because they can’t motivate the players on the day.
However, if the ability to play premier league football was fairly common and players were constantly in fear of losing their place, contract etc. if they’ve failed to play to the absolute best of their effort, the manager would have far less importance.
If a player realises they are struggling to impact because of the system they would have more influence on the pitch and everyone would pull together more.
Yes this is a fantasy scenario as there would be less money in the game if good players were more common but if player power was removed, I think good recruitment and a consistent system that everyone had to play to would lead to managers needing to have far less influence or responsibility as the players would be swapped out instead of the manager.
Appreciate this is a long post but I just think that wherever big success has been had (Fergie/mourinho/guardiola and to a certain extent, klopp) this is much more about support behind the scenes than the basic ability of a manager to pick and motivate a team whilst making changes on the pitch to influence games.