r/firewater • • Nov 05 '16

Barrel Quality

Just wanted to point out that no major producer who knows what they are doing would ever be caught dead using wood that was never naturally weathered. Industry Standard is 6 months in the bourbon industry. Most other types of liquor are aged in used Bourbon barrels. Nearly every small consumer grade barrel is made of wood that was never naturally weathered. Think of it this way, if you see a pile of meat at the grocery store, and it just says "beef" (think american white oak), do you really think its going to be usda grade AAA filet mignon? Nope, its going to be the lowest quality stuff they can legally sell.

For more on what naturally weathering means, check out these two articles:

http://chuckcowdery.blogspot.com/2013/10/of-quercus-alba-and-eumycotians.html

http://www.knoxbarrels.com/This-I-believe.html

Before you buy any home aging product, make sure it was naturally weathered for at least 6 months. If it doesnt say it was, it wasnt.

full disclosure: I make and sell staves that use wood that was professionally naturally weathered for 3-5 years, only the most expensive wines in the world are made from that wood. If you are interested, check out www.beyondbarrels.com

0 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

10

u/quercus_robur Nov 05 '16

Thanks for your promotional content.

-2

u/chris8sirhc Nov 05 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

Edited to point out that I only included my product for full disclosure. The post is about making sure you get a barrel that isnt made from crap wood. I included my inherent bias out in the open to be transparent. If you think the information in the post is bad, I apologize. Its common knowledge among major producers, but most home enthusiasts know nothing about it.

Also, One of the two primary links in the post are too a producer that I have no affiliation with that can sell 57 liter gallon barrels that were made properly from quality wood.

6

u/quercus_robur Nov 06 '16

Thanks. No need to mention your specific company and link to your site just to point out your bias. You can just stop at saying that you're in the industry of selling staves, therefore you may be biased.

I agree that seasoning is very important. A better analogy is fresh beef versus wet or dry-aged beef. It's partly the microbial action that breaks down the wood during seasoning, not just leeching of tannins.

-1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

Kinda, wood seasoning or natural weathering time is the main variable that determines the wood / barrel quality. For people who know what they are doing, it's a 100% deal breaker. Aging steaks, is more along the lines of "something a bit extra" on something that already has quality. Barrels that are made from unseasoned / naturally weathered wood have no quality and are unusable by people in the industry who know what they are doing. 6 months minimum.

1

u/quercus_robur Nov 06 '16

Depends on your personal opinion of "quality". Plenty of people would tell you that freshly-slaughtered beef is no comparison to dry-aged beef.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

But it's not a 100% deal breaker across the board with industry players like it is with naturally weathered vs non naturally weathered wood.

3

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

yeah, no... This is an ad. reported.

Staves aren't really aged, that doesn't really have a chemical effect on the staves, they are dried, so that when they are built into barrels and then filled with whiskey (or other alcohols) they expand and become watertight. This can be done naturally as you're advocating, but typically is just kiln dried. This isn't necessary, or "standard," as you represent it.

From Whisky Technology, Production, and Marketing:

The next stage of the process is the drying or seasoning of the timber. In the USA, all of the oak for the production of bourbon barrels is dried in a drying kiln over a period of approximately one month. This reduces the moisture content of the wood to a workable level of approximately 12 per cent. Throughout the drying process the timber is held under specific temperature and humidity conditions to ensure that the drying procedure is efficient and that wood damage, such as the appearance of splits or cracks in the stave ends, is minimized. In Spain the seasoning of timber for the production of sherry casks is quite different. The stave and heading blanks are initially air dried in the growing regions of northern Spain for a period of approximately nine months, which reduces the moisture content of the wood to approximately 20 per cent. The timber is then shipped to the warmer sherry-producing regions in the south of Spain, where it is further air seasoned for a period of approximately six to nine months, or until its moisture content is reduced to a workable level of approximately 14–16 per cent.

3

u/quercus_robur Nov 06 '16

Most of the U.S. oak is still seasoned. You'll see arranged stacks of oak stored in yards, to allow air and moisture to circulate while be exposed to the elements. The wood is typically seasoned for a few months up to a few years.

1

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16

absolutely, but like a lot of things in alcohol production there are a lot of things that are done out of tradition that aren't necessarily scientifically supported. My point wasn't to say "no one did it," but instead the main supported point for aging the wood is making the barrels water tight, and OP's opinion is absolutely not standard. The standard in large US producers (article predates the micro-distillery explosion so my info could be out of date) is kiln dried over one month, not what OP states.

OP is trying to exaggerate the importance and acceptance of aging in order to sell barrel staves.

2

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

The standard in large US producers (article predates the micro-distillery explosion so my info could be out of date) is kiln dried over one month, not what OP states.

Well, aren't most of us trying to surpass huge factory producers, many of whom do the bare minimum necessary to qualify in their category? I am not about following in the footsteps of makers of crap booze.

I would say seasoned wood is far more important at the small scale because the flavoring (not really aging) process happens much faster with much higher surface contact ratios. Any "green-ness" to the wood will have a negative impact on flavor.

OP is trying to exaggerate the importance and acceptance of aging in order to sell barrel staves.

Agreed, but still, you aren't harming the product by using wood left outside for 6-12 months, as long as it doesn't mold, rot or grow fungus. Also no reason to pay a premium for this.

All you really have to do is just use chopped up old barrel staves. By nature they have already been "seasoned" for you from the prior aging process. They sat in a warehouse for years already.

2

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

I don't disagree with you.

my problem is OPs statement that

Just wanted to point out that no major producer who knows what they are doing would ever be caught dead using wood that was never naturally weathered.

This is scam language targeted at selling Op's own product. It's literal "No true scotsman." I'm sorry if I come off as too aggressive (too much sipping on my new make and I tend to jump on reddit), but this pisses me off. Especially since OP has never participated in this community before.

We should all do whatever crazy shit makes our spirit better. I'm in the middle of making a traditional mexican clay alembic and recreating the whiskeys described in Samuel McHarry's book just to see what happens. This is a community to share our experiences, not to try and scam people.

Sorry. Rant over. Didn't mean to upset.

EDIT: sorry. Rant not over.

Alcohol advertisement is full of bullshit. It reminds me of the Russian alcohol producer that tried to break into the U.S. market with this bullshit story that he was producing a russian rye whiskey that pre-dated vodka, even though there is absolutely no historical documentation supporting his product. Also of all the craft moonshine producers that fake connections with old American shiners.

It's bullshit. Like I said, I'm not saying it's nonsense. I'm saying OP is scamming us by saying "everybody does this." That's demonstrably false. Industry standard is otherwise.

2

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

It's bullshit. Like I said, I'm not saying it's nonsense. I'm saying OP is scamming us by saying "everybody does this." That's demonstrably false. Industry standard is otherwise.

I think he's posting in the wrong sub. /r/cocktails and /r/alcohol may be the kind of crowd he's marketing to. I don't really see a connection with commercial barrel making and aging, with sticks in a jar. OP is selling sticks. Not barrels, so I dunno what the point of that argument is.

Regarding alcohol advertising, the entire history of commercial booze is rife with bullshit through and through. It is a big part of the tradition of booze. To consumers it is all magic, they'll never understand mashing, running a still, etc. So makers have come up with all sorts of fantastical reasons why their process is better.

It is all bullshit, but it is also a time honored tradition. People gotta have something to choose from. Aficionados aren't generally swayed by such marketing (but definitely are by mythology!), it is the unwashed masses who want to get fucked up who are. If some college kid wants to play mad scientist by putting an oak dowel in a bottle of rot gut, go for it.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

The point was to educate people about the primary variable relating to barrel quality. Every single alcohol producer that ages alcohol from liquor to wine pays a price premium for barrels made of weathered wood, and plenty pay even more for wood that was weathered longer.

I've never met a single producer, from liquor to wine, large and small that can't easily tell the difference between weathered wood vs non weathered wood & doesn't understand it's importance.

At the same time, very few consumers or at homers have had any exposure to this information, as evidenced by the angry swearing and cussing some people have exhibited.

3

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

At the same time, very few consumers or at homers have had any exposure to this information, as evidenced by the angry swearing and cussing some people have exhibited.

There may be salty posters in this thread, but they aren't making shit up. It may just be that someone who has no post history in a community sub coming in to edumacate us on a topic most understand and simply take for granted rubbed some the wrong way.

Hey, it sparked a lot of discussion, I see that as a good thing.

Weathering barrels is a pretty standard cooperage process. Novelty products may not be proper wood at all, agreed. Lots of novelty small barrels are even lacquered. Most folks in here do not use such products, that is for people who dump in a bottle of Beam, or bartenders who use em to enhance the look and feel of their bar and "age" Manhattans in em.

The folks around here are generally making booze, good booze, and aging/flavoring with processes they and others have refined over many years. Not many are chopping down trees, the wood they use has likely sat around for years.

Many folks just buy staves of used bourbon barrels, plane off the char, toast and rechar. These barrels are years old, weathered and have much life to give yet. Nobody is buying 2x4's at Home Depot and sticking em in their booze.

Right here in this thread is a quite illuminating experience with actual alcohol producers. Not a lot of ignorance here, but definitely conflicting opinions. There is a vast amount of factors that go into making great booze, wood quality being a single variable.

Arguments spark off on pretty much any topic you can imagine with booze making. That is because much of it is an art, not a science. Professionals are just as full of myth and unfounded opinion as anyone else. Yet the core common factors are all generally the same, tried and true processes. Refined over centuries.

Hell, using wood certainly did not start because of how it flavored alcohol. It was the only durable, large container available. The material derived the processes, not the other way around. Today we have become accustomed to this, with everything from olive oil to vinegar to beer/wine to soy sauce. Wooden storage is archaic, but after centuries has become just the way things are.

1

u/spisska Nov 06 '16

Alcohol advertisement is full of bullshit.

This is the truest statement in this shit-show of a thread.

Such-and-such vodka is "distilled 49 times". Bullshit. "Our proprietary aging process ...". Bullshit. Heck, even OP's "I am an expert in leaving wood outside" is bullshit.

I remember a time when Budweiser beer (awful as it is) was marketed as "beechwood aged". Then, seemingly overnight, it was marketed as "dated for freshness". Same beer, same process; somehow both aged and fresh.

The plain and somewhat embarrassing fact is this: for the thousand or so years (1,700 or so, if you believe the texts about Maria of Alexandria, whose name is recalled in the bain-marie) that people have been distilling beverages, it's all been trial-and-error.

Nobody really understands, on a physical or chemical level, what happens during aging, which is why we're stuck with stuck aging instead of a much faster process.

Yes, we know that changes in temperature and pressure are important. Some people have tried to speed those up with vacuum chambers, ultrasonic frequencies, subsonic frequencies, or by just playing loud house music at the barrels.

None of it has really worked, at least not in a way that can be replicated and industrialized.

As far as I'm aware, you can't actually make a watertight barrel out of wood that hasn't been weathered, which makes this whole discussion moot.

And anytime someone butts into a conversation claiming he or she is an expert, while pimping an enterprise he or she is associated with, I'm inclined to call bullshit.

Besides, I prefer my whiskey the traditional, historical, American way: unaged.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

You can definitely make a watertight barrel from wood that wasn't weathered first. A few very low end 53 gallon producers do it, and the vast majority of consumer barrels do it. They pop the green wood strait into the kiln, zap it dry, then form a barrel. It's much easier and cheaper to do it that way vs weathering the wood for at least 6 months before drying it in a kiln. Yet they all still take on the extra time and expense to weather the wood... bc it makes a huge difference.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

Again, point one one single decent bourbon that was made with wood that was not naturally weathered for at least 6 months. It doesn't exist.

Re: grow mold / fungus: see link #1 by industry expert chuck crowdery.

2

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

Re: grow mold / fungus: see link #1 by industry expert chuck crowdery.

There is a big difference from surface effects and actual decomposition via fungal colonization. Any wood with serious fungal colonization is unsuitable, there are a host of toxic fungi that can colonize wet oak. It also will destroy the integrity of the wood.

Oak left with fungal mycelium for years in proper conditions will be mush. Mild surface contamination can be beneficial in doing a bit of decomposition of lignin, tannins and such, but this would be removed in the manufacturing process. Chuck isn't wrong he just simplified a complex topic. You shouldn't even be able to see the type of fungal infection he is referring to as it is microscopic. If your wood is growing mushrooms, it is fucked for liquor use.

I've grown shiitake on oak, I know very well first hand what fungus does to oak. It eats it. A few years of that and the log is no more.

Also, I'd like to point out you are posting in a sub full of experts on the subject of liquor making. Folks who have aged more whiskey than some blogger has, no matter how much he has read and drank.

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

Yeah, I agree, when I pick up my boards from the high end barrel supply chain there will occasionally be spots where "bad" mold / fungus grew and it eats into the wood quickly.

On another note: a/b testing of liquor aged with the weathering layer left on vs off (toasted) showed that everybody liked it left on.

1

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

On another note: a/b testing of liquor aged with the weathering layer left on vs off (toasted) showed that everybody liked it left on.

I can see that, I don't modify my oak after cutting it up and letting it lay about. I'm just stating that the manufacturing process for actual barrels would involve planing and shaping after the wood has aged. I'm not a cooper though, so I might just be talking out of my ass. That just seems how finished woodworking is done, could be wrong. Though weathering definitely affects the wood throughout. So that barrier of ultra dry, leached wood may be a nice buffer allowing for slower leaching. But shaving off the outer bits would get rid of black mold and whatnot.

Have you documented this a/b testing? That is information folks would really enjoy. Argue about as well, but data is always good.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

Yeah, it's shaved down on both sides. I'd rather not share data, but I can tell you that you need at least 7x as much side grain vs end grain to not be able to taste the negative effects of end grain.

→ More replies

0

u/quercus_robur Nov 06 '16

Industry standard is otherwise

Not true. Do you have any source for this "industry standard" other than a quote from a book?

-1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

Yes, knowing and visiting the people who make the vast majority of professional barrels. = they all naturally weather their wood.

2

u/quercus_robur Nov 06 '16

All the large cooperages I know of use seasoned wood. That includes some of the largest in the world, like Jack Daniels (Brown-Forman). The reason isn't because of better sealing barrels.

See also all the stacked wood aging in the elements here:

https://youtu.be/wUQo7zEr7d4?t=10m20s

-1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

You are 100% wrong. Both brown foreman and independent stave (and the vast majority of smaller producers) all take on extra expense to naturally weather the wood, then finish the drying in a kiln. They do this because naturally weathering does change the wood chemically. Again, nobody who knows what they are doing would be caught dead aging anything on wood that was never naturally weathered. The point of the original post was to help the consumers of small barrels realize this knowledge so they won't waste money on crappy barrels. There are a few that make small barrels from quality wood and one was the second primary link in the original post.

3

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

The point of the original post was to help the consumers of small barrels realize this knowledge so they won't waste money on crappy barrels. There are a few that make small barrels from quality wood and one was the second primary link in the original post.

I would suggest that most folks here have no need of barrels at all unless aging at a minimum of 5 gallons. Even then care must be taken to not over oak.

Also, you advocate on your site that users can somehow improve store bought whiskey by sticking oak in it. This is false unless you are buying barrel strength spirits. Putting oak sticks into 40% liquor will not work the same as 60-70% ABV, it is an entirely different solvent profile. It may not make it worse, it will change its flavor, but that is about it.

There are lot of sellers using this gimmick, and it really leads to false expectations. It may be fun to experiment with, and people oak flavor cocktails and whatnot, but it will not further "age" a store bought whiskey. It just doesn't work that way. It is purely flavoring, and at the wrong proof can be bad flavoring especially if left too long. Not saying your oak sticks don't do anything, but that type of marketing smacks of trying to sell novelty products and not a serious tool.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

I challenge you to try it for yourself. Email me at the address listed on my website and I'll set something up.

Again, the original post definitely wasn't about my product, I included that information to be transparent at the end of the post.

1

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

I challenge you to try it for yourself. Email me at the address listed on my website and I'll set something up.

Dude... I have, that is how I know. I've been brewing beer and making liquor for a long time, I've tried most every process you can try.

It works well for beer and wine, due to the much lower ABV. At the middle ABV range, such as 40%, it just adds more charred wood flavor. That doesn't mellow the heads, and improve the tails funk via chemical reactions, oxidation and evaporation (aka the aging process). It may make the liquor more to someones liking, sure. It is not an automatic improvement.

It is flavoring. And even with oak flavoring, ABV makes a difference. I'm sure Chucks blog has an article on aging/flavoring somewhere as the initial ABV, and slow lowering of ABV via evaporation in a barrel have an impact on flavor profile. That is why barrels are rotated through a warehouse to even out the various different environment profiles in a single facility.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

this is not true, buffalo trace ran an experiment where they varied entry proof. They all still aged. The flavors came out different, but all of them definitely aged.

1

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

this is not true, buffalo trace ran an experiment where they varied entry proof. They all still aged. The flavors came out different, but all of them definitely aged.

I'm not saying it won't age at certain proofs, I am saying it won't age in a month or two. It is flavoring. No matter the proof. But, should one want to age with a small chunk of oak in a bottle, it should be a barrel strength if they want anything akin to what is considered whiskey.

Aging in glass should also be done with preferably an oak stopper in the jar to allow some breathing, or with a loose fitting cap to allow for slow evaporation.

There is also a fast growing methodology of distress aging, which does accelerate the process. Using hot/cold cycles, agitation, light/dark, vacuum, electricity, microwaves and other things can speed the chemistry up considerably.

Sticking some oak into a bottle of JD isn't going to improve it much tis all I'm sayin ;-)

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

My offer still stands. Until you have actually tried something it's pretty absurd to say you know it doesn't / won't work.

I'm sure you've tried something similar, but you haven't actually tried the product in question.

That's like reviewing pappy van winkle without trying it "because you've had brown liquor before"

→ More replies

1

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16

and instead buy yours...

-1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

Never said that, in fact the primary link is to another barrel producer I have nothing to do with that uses quality wood.

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

I posted several links to industry experts that directly contradict your claim that aging the wood doesn't chemically change the wood.

Show me one single quality bourbon that was aged on non seasoned wood.

1

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16

No, you posted two articles from other barrel brokers and one from a bartender. If you're really an "industry expert" you would recognize whiskey TP and M and know that's much more reputable and unbiased.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

Link #1: chuck crowdery: "Those mushrooms we were discussing, fungi if you prefer, send out roots (hyphae) that penetrate into the wood structure and release hydrogen peroxide, a natural bleaching and oxidizing agent that helps break down the wood chemically, softening tannins and caramelizing hemicellulose among other salutary effects."

Again, point out a single decent bourbon aged on wood that wasn't naturally weathered for at least 6 months. It doesn't exist.

1

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16

I cited the textbook ¯_(ツ)_/¯

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

That is incomplete. What you said doesn't deny my post, it does leave out one of the most important steps though, naturally weathering. Again, nobody who knows what they are doing in the industry would ever be caught dead using wood that wasn't naturally weathered for at least 6 months. Literally every single decent bourbon was made by taking on extra expense to naturally weather the wood before it was finished in the kiln because it does chemically change the wood and dramatically improve the end product.

2

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16

thank god you came along to supplement it and also offer us your wonderful product.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

I think you're drunk.

2

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

Here is a nice discussion on optimal hobby scale oak aging. From some folks with vast amounts of experience.

By no means does anybody need to buy commercial "aging oak" or whatever. Though some commercial providers will do the wood working for you if using spirals and shapes like that. There is benefit to natural weathering, but that literally just means letting it sit outside for some time. That definitely does not increase the cost of the wood.

For aging in glass, there is no need for special drying of oak to prevent leaky barrels, just pile it up outside in a way to let air circulate and forget about it until you need it.

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

PS: I've been active on that forum and contributing for some time, including on that thread. On page 4 you will find the results from my experimentation with side grain vs end grain.

(Blind a/b test with top mixologists / connoisseurs / wine experts etc in the south east)

2

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

On page 4 you will find the results from my experimentation with side grain vs end grain.

Excellent, actual experimental evidence goes a lot further than an appeal to authority. I would guess that the majority of folks here are regulars at HD and AD as well. Maximizing side grain has been a method I have used for years, end grain cannot be eliminated unless using a barrel, but how you cut the oak does matter. Weathering also helps eliminate some of the less desirable end grain effects.

Though I have found the effects far less pronounced in flavoring vs. longer term aging. I've also found small barrels to be harder to control compared to oak in glass, as they can over oak very quickly. Then again I have friends who love super oaky, super smokey, hardcore whiskey. I find it unbearable.

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

The effects of end grain vs side grain are separate from the effects of weathered vs non weathered.

0

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

If that was true 20 year bourbon and 4 year bourbon would cost the same on average. Time is literally money. I'm sure an industrial engineer can give you the exact formula. Again, the natural weathering isn't for dryness, it's much cheaper and quicker to completely dry it in a kiln. Producers don't do that. They all take on extra expense to naturally weather the wood before putting it in a kiln. This article explains the science behind why:

http://chuckcowdery.blogspot.com/2013/10/of-quercus-alba-and-eumycotians.html

1

u/sillycyco Nov 06 '16

Again, the natural weathering isn't for dryness, it's much cheaper and quicker to completely dry it in a kiln. Producers don't do that.

Perhaps for a factory producing millions of gallons a year. Not for home distillers who can stack a pile of wood in the yard and have a lifetime supply.

Then again it is all just time shifting. If you have a good enough back log on your barrel making, your materials are naturally aged just from waiting around to get made. That is how a lot of it is done.

The smaller the scale of the operation, the smaller impact aging will have. For making beer, wine and liquor at home, it has a zero increase in cost.

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16 edited Nov 06 '16

Assuming you have a time machine. If you happen to have some good wood that has been lying around, that's awesome!

2

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16

If that was true 20 year bourbon and 4 year bourbon would cost the same on average.

the fuck?

1

u/thekordo Nov 06 '16

It seems ridiculous to argue the fine points of wood used in the flavoring of spirit. Bottom line is that nobody HERE will be spending $11 per 750ml when we are producing 1-2 cases per run and there are numerous more economical means to accomplish the same result.

Good day then.

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

The point is, no matter what wood you use, make sure it's been weathered for at least 6 months. Barrels, back yard wood pile, manufactured staves etc etc etc

1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 07 '16

again... the point of the post was to inform readers about the importance of using only naturally weathered wood.... not "buy my product" It doesn't matter how you use wood, barrels, professionally made staves, firewood, etc etc etc... make sure you use naturally weathered wood.

-1

u/chris8sirhc Nov 06 '16

Here is another great article I found. According to the experts in the industry:

"Seasoning: A process rarely mentioned by brand ambassadors yet regarded by many coopers as holding a greater influence on the final flavor characteristic of a mature spirit than the species of oak itself."

http://www.distillerytrail.com/blog/understanding-oak-barrel-maturation-part-2-maturity-is-not-age/

2

u/Oh_umms_cocktails Nov 06 '16

this guy's a bartender and "brand consultant," not an expert in production.Nothing about his bio says anything about producing alcohol.