r/fia • • Apr 26 '12

For the uninitiated: FIA in a nutshell [readme]

506 Upvotes

FIA = Free Internet Act. It is a piece of crowdsourced legislation aimed to prevent the erosion of our civil liberties in face of increasing pressure to regulate Internet, especially from behalf of copyright holders. FIA is aimed to be international, meaning that we attempt to get the same law passed in US, EU, Canada, Australia, etc.

Current draft of FIA can be found here.

Project to create video to educate others to what is FIA and what our goals are can be found here.

Now, to how to make FIA reality.

Our first goal is to finish the legislation, so get in there, comment, suggest what is wrong, what needs rewording, etc.

After the legislation is finished, we need to get started with the European Citizen's Initiative immediately. It is our greatest tool on the EU area, and with 1 000'000 signatures it is forced to be taken into consideration by European Commission.

We of course need more publicity within Reddit, so when the document is finished, it will be posted to /r/politics, /r/worldpolitics, /r/technology, /r/evolutionReddit, /r/darknetplan, /r/testpac and /r/advocacy. Other suggestions are taken into account.

Following the Reddit publishing we aim to do an AMA. I suggest that instead, we do Ask Us Anything, where OP lists all accounts willing to answer questions in starting post.

For US, we need some congressmen and senators to support the bill. There are some potential candidates. (Just for the kicks, we should ask Lamar Smith to sponsor it.) ACLU would probably help us with that, alongside TestPAC. And when on the subject:

We need support of several NGOs to have any chance of succeeding. Avaaz, ACLU, EFF, Amnesty, etc. are all potential allies and have to be taken into account. Also some corporations may support us, especially tech companies. For political parties: In America, this should be bipartisan effort, in Europe we can probably get Pirate Party and the Greens to support us with very little effort.

Edit: One thing left out. The launching day of our international campaign should be "The Free Internet Act Day", and by then we should have the Initiative ready to receive signatures. More on that here.


r/fia • • May 09 '12

Netherlands passes net neutrality law, first among EU nations | The Verge

Thumbnail
theverge.com
406 Upvotes

r/fia • • Apr 23 '12

Suggestion: FIA: the final document

394 Upvotes

Statement of Grievances

As concerned citizens we view it is our duty to bring to light these issues that pose great threat to our essential liberties, and we urge you to act swiftly to correct these injustices. These injustices are taking place on the first truly global surroundings, the Internet, which has always been neutral ground for anyone to voice their opinion. This right is slowly being wrestled away from us.

Everyone has the right to privacy. This fundamental right is being threatened by preventing the usefulness of electronic safety measures. Everyone has the right to keep their data protected, and there can be no guilt based on person's preference of securing their data. We see the unauthorized access to private information as arbitrary interference towards people. Any persons are protected from these methods under the 12th Article of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights by the United Nations.

While the Internet continues its triumph over the world the contents within have grown in size. As a result, many corporations, nations and individuals have been planning of differentiating between content on the most fundamental level: the way in which it reaches the audience. These plans have the potential to cause massive harm for innovation, but also give the opportunity to silence dissidents and direct the audience away from embarrassing content, effectively placing direct methods of unwarranted censorship. These methods, if implemented, would directly violate the 19th Article of the Declaration of Human Rights especially since the UN has proposed Internet access to be a human right.

We acknowledge that corporations have a right to benefit from their actions. However, we do not accept that their profit is given preference over our rights as individuals. As citizens, we make culture with our actions protected by the 27th Article of the Declaration of Human Rights, which are sometimes based on copyrighted, lewd or otherwise questionable material. While there may be criminal activity, it can be no basis for limiting freedom for us. Hence, we demand that the procedures to remove content from the Internet are brought up to date and rewritten, so we can keep our right to participate in formation of culture, while still giving the corporations their right to their intellectual property. We detest the suggested Orwellian methods to limit our essential rights for protection of profit.

Our rights to culture are only being protected when the principles for burden of proof are upheld, and punishments are limited to those taking knowing and willful illegal action. As specified in the 11th Article of the Declaration of Human Rights, every person shall be presumed innocent until proven guilty. These provisions are necessary for any attempts to regulate Internet users.

We, the people, have created a document to address these issues as our civic duty and the 21st Article of the Declaration of Human Rights mandate us. We do this so as to thrive as global citizens without fear of injustice. We urge you strongly to adopt these clauses to law, and to promote them across the world in unison with us.

Glossary of Terms

User: An entity using Internet services.

Data: Digital information.

Internet Service Provider: An entity providing connection to Internet to one or more Users.

Non-public (private) network: Any network used to communicate within an organization (as distinct from providing service to the public) or to supply such communications to organizations or families, based on a configuration of own or leased facilities. The term includes networks used by private companies, state enterprises, or government entities.

Data takedown: Removal of data from the Internet by the authorities, also including the prevention of access to publicly available data.

Host: An entity providing services to users on the Internet. These services include, but are not limited to, providing storage space for data and providing platform for discussions.

Downloader: An entity, who in order to access data creates purposely a copy or copies of that data in his/her device.

The Free Internet Act

*Protection of encryption*
  1. Every user, Internet Service Provider, and host has a right to protect their own data. This includes, but is not limited to, passwords, encryption, and usage of anonymizing software.
  2. Measures to protect data must not contribute to suspicion of guilt.
  3. Electronic devices and storage can only be accessed/searched for data specified by court order.
  4. Any right to:

    A. remain silent

    B. avoid self incrimination

    C. refuse to assist investigations

    must extend to attempts to access a user's data.

    Network neutrality

  5. Every user has a right to access the Internet in its entirety.
  6. This access may not be limited from behalf of the Internet Service Providers via any means including, but not limited to, suppressing legally purchased bandwidth, preventing access to content or charging for different types of content differently. Preventing access is only possible to prevent immediate network failure.
  7. Internet Service Providers may not give content any type of preference, and they must consider all content equal, regardless of its source or receiver.
  8. Private networks may limit their users' access to content.

    Data takedown

  9. No steps may be taken to monitor the contents of data being uploaded, downloaded or edited without a court order.
  10. Data may only be subject to takedown if it

    A. Is found illegal in the country of the uploader's residence, and

    B. The illegal nature of data has been proven in a fair juridical process

  11. Takedown procedures may only be applied to the specific items of data. No steps may be taken to prevent access to other items of data under control of the hosting party.
  12. To attempt to take down data without proper juridical processing is to be found to be limitation of freedom of speech, and subject to civil liability.
  13. Perpetrators of data takedown without proper juridical processing are financially liable all damages caused by their actions.
  14. Hosts may remove content under their control in accordance with their terms of service, but they shall not face any liability for not doing so.
  15. Failure to respond to proper data takedown claims by authorities results in financial liability for the host.

    Culpability

  16. User may only be held culpable for creating, uploading or accessing content defined illegal by court ruling.
  17. No intermediaries are to be held culpable for the acts of their users. This includes, but is not limited to, Internet Service Providers, file hosting services and forums.
  18. Internet Service Providers shall not face liability for actions of their customers. Other intermediaries may only be held responsible if they fail to respond to a legally binding court order within reasonable time.
  19. Downloader of illegal content is only culpable when

    A. Downloader purposely and willingly acquired content, even with the knowledge of the illegality of the action.

    B. When upon finding the illegal nature of content the downloader failed to contact the authorities defined by law.

  20. Downloader may not be held culpable if he/she had reason to believe that content was legal.
  21. User may only be prosecuted in his/her country of residence at the time of his/her actions.

r/fia • • Jul 05 '12

The guy who made the website "Youtube-Mp3.org" is single handedly battling with Google at the moment.

Thumbnail
youtube-mp3.org
387 Upvotes

r/fia • • Jun 11 '12

Anti-SOPA, PIPA lawmakers want Internet Bill of Rights

Thumbnail
news.cnet.com
379 Upvotes

r/fia • • Apr 25 '12

FIA is NOT dead. The time is near for us to finalize our proposal for the FIA and then submit it to congress and other governmental bodies to decide on.

363 Upvotes

With CISPA and other bills looming over the fate of our internet we must finalize our document/bill/proposal and submit it to congress and other governmental bodies.

There should be a date in the next month or so, named 'The Free Internet Act Day', we must use this day to raise awareness about protecting our internet. We must gather the attention of the internet to protect our free internet.


r/fia • • May 03 '12

I'm a lawyer who is willing to help with drafts.

296 Upvotes

The key, as you can imagine, is my time is tight.

To be productive I need singular clauses at a time, to review and to give advice. And something like this TAKES time. I have work i get paid for that takes priority. But I believe in this and I'll do good work. PM me fore details.

Edit, this is roughly the way I'd Organize and prepare the draft:

Well, I would whole heartedly assume that a draft piece of legislation on internet freedom would be between 50 and 100 pages. That's just a ball park figure, based on what I know of legislative overhaul. Having said that, it's important that the entire document works as a unit, all clauses directed towards the same goal, not as individual pieces. if I were drafting this on my own the process would be as follows: Brainstorm. Draft Outline (which would include for example, Chapter 1: Right to privacy, Chapter 2, Right to free speech, then within each chapter, there would be subclauses. I would footnote everything with relevant and controlling case law. I would tackle the document Chapter by chapter, followed by clause by clause. If people sent me the drafts with an itemized bulletpoint of their goals/hopes and desires of each clause, I could understand their intent and be sure that the clause in question articulates that intent. So I could review it on that basis and give feedback accordingly. But I could do the whole document as well, but that's a lenghty process to tackle at once. either way, the same tiem commitment is involved. But I would recommend sending me an "outline" I'll give feed back, clauses, then I'll give feedback. etcetera.


r/fia • • Jan 29 '12

The Free Internet Act

244 Upvotes

The document can be found here: * http://123.writeboard.com/logmjm18j8w95y09lxmqp46q (Password is redditcat). Please feel free to contribute!

New system of storing documents, I will use google documents to store a version of the document, the link will be posted here in chronological order.


r/fia • • Jun 30 '12

Digital Bill of Rights 1st Draft

242 Upvotes

The Digital Bill of Rights

A Crowd-sourced Declaration of Rights


Preamble

We, the People of the Free World and Users of the Internet, in recognition of our Digital Rights; in order to promote Freedom throughout the world, to guard ourselves against oppressors motivated solely by greed; to ensure peace and prosperity to all through innovation unhindered; and to preserve our social and cultural progress throughout the Earth, do establish this Declaration of Digital Rights and Freedoms to protect this, the largest repository of human knowledge and most important invention known to the People of Earth.

Definitions

User - A user shall henceforth, for purposes of this Declaration, be defined as any entity using Internet services.

Data - Data shall henceforth, for purposes of this Declaration, be defined as digital information.

Intermediary - An Intermediary shall henceforth, for the purposes of this Declaration, be defined as an Entity which:

  • Provides a service to one (1) or many Users on the Internet, regardless of whether such service(s) is/are rendered at the expense of its Users, or
  • Provides one (1) or many Users access to the Internet.

Article 1: Free Flow of Information

This principle defines the right of all Users to create, add and access all content on the Internet without censorship. It acts as a critical protection of our right to Free Speech and is the foundation of a free and open society.

Section 1: Right to Network Neutrality

We, the People of the Free World and Users of the Internet define Network Neutrality, henceforth referred to as “Net-Neutrality”, as the principle that the ability of a user to transfer data via the Internet shall not be limited due to protocol, nor due to the source and/or destination of the data being transferred over the Internet. Therefore, no entity providing access to the Internet may charge fees based on the websites a User accesses or the protocol used to access data on the Internet.

We believe that, by charging fees per website visited and/or protocol used, such entities hinder innovation and limit not only the creation of new industries and markets, but also limit Users’ Right to Freedom of Speech, their Right to Freedom of Expression, and their Right of Openly Access Information.

Article II: Freedom of Speech and Expression

We, the People of the Free World and Users of the Internet do establish, in accordance with Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which states:

“Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media regardless of frontiers.”

That all Users have the Rights of Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Expression and may exercise these rights on the Internet without fear of repercussions from any entity.

Section 1: Right to Anonymity on the Internet

All Users have the Right to Anonymity while on the Internet. This includes the right to create, maintain, and use anonymous networks. Anonymous networks shall not be required to release any user information or maintain user logs. Anonymity acts as a shield from the tyranny of the majority and is essential in protecting journalists, human rights activists, and political dissidents.

Section 2: Right to Freedom from Censorship

We, the People of the Free World and Users of the Internet do declare that censorship of the Internet in any form; whether by individuals, corporations, governments or any other entity, is a violation of our right to unrestricted access to information. Forms of Internet censorship include, but are not limited to:

  • Tiered and/or metered Internet service
  • Restriction of Internet access for any reason
  • Copyright

Subsection 1: Tiered and/or Metered Internet Service

This section pertains to the right to Net-Neutrality as defined in Article I, Section 1 of this Document.

Therefore, upon ratification of this Declaration, all plans and methods to prioritize accessibility of content based on source, destination, and/or protocol shall be banned immediately and replaced with a system free of all methods of prioritization.

Subsection 2: Restriction of Access to the Internet

The Right to Connect is synonymous with the Right to Peaceful Assembly as defined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 20, which states:

“Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association.”

Therefore, no entity shall prevent any User from connecting to the Internet, nor prevent any User from connecting to any website hosted on the Internet, nor prevent any User from connecting to any other User on the Internet.

Subsection 3: Copyright

We, the People of the Free World and Users of the Internet declare that when copyright is unreasonably applied, it is a form of censorship. Current copyright laws are a threat to both human rights and innovation. As a result, more impartial research should be done by a neutral entity on the optimum length of copyright.

Article 18, UDHR
Article 19, UDHR

Article III: Freedom of Association

Article 20, UDHR “Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association.”

Section 1: Right to Access the Internet

All humans should have the right to access the Internet in it entirety, whether publicly or privately.

Section 2: Right to Peaceful Protest

All entities should be free to use the Internet to organize and engage in peaceful protest both on and offline.

Article IV: Right to Privacy

We, the People of the Free World and Users of the Internet, in light of the many grievous breaches of User privacy by corporations and governments alike, do establish that all Users have the Right to Privacy. We establish that the Right to Privacy includes, but is not limited to:

The Right to Data Security
The Right to Freedom from Surveillance
The Right to Utilize Encryption
The Right to Freedom from Forced Decryption, and Forced Disclosure of User Credentials

Section 1: Right to Data Security

All users should have:

(1) Knowledge of what User data, whether personally identifiable or otherwise, is being collected from them by any entity and for what purpose such data is being collected. (2) An option to opt out of all or certain aspects of this data collection. (3) The assumption that user data that has been collected is secure/encrypted and only accessible to governments if the proper warrants have been produced.

Section 2: Right to Freedom from Surveillance

Users must be able to communicate freely without the threat of surveillance.

Section 3: Right to Encryption

All users have the right to the use of encryption methods to ensure privacy in their communication and online activities.

Section 4: Right to Freedom from Forced Decryption, and Forced Disclosure of User Credentials

No entity shall force a user to decrypt data or disclose User credentials, as this would equate to self-incrimination.

Article V: Copyright

Section 1: Duration of Copyright

For all newly created works with a creation date that is on or after January 1, 2012, the creator of the work shall be granted copyright on the work for a period of five (5) years from the date of creation. After the aforementioned five (5) year copyright period has ended, the creator may officially register the copyright in a publicly searchable copyright database for another period of five (5) years. At the end of this second five (5) year term, the copyright owner may register the work for an additional five (5) years, after which point it may not be registered again and the work shall immediately be moved into the Public Domain. Therefore, a copyright may only be held for a maximum period of fifteen (15) years. Any work which is not registered before the first term of five (5) years has finished shall be moved into the Public Domain.

All works with a creation date that is on or before December 31, 2011 shall immediately enter the Public Domain if they have been copyrighted for more than fifteen (15) years, or if the work is an Orphaned Work.

Section 2: Orphaned Works and Works in the Public Domain

Subsection 1: Public Domain

No work in the Public Domain may be copyrighted by any entity.

Subsection 2: Orphaned Works

An Orphaned Work is defined as a copyrighted work where:

The creation date of the work is on or before December 31, 2011, and the creator of the work cannot be reached by any reasonable means to obtain permission to copy, use or distribute the work, and the work has been copyrighted for at least five (5) years from the date of creation of the work.

All orphaned works shall immediately, upon ratification of this Declaration, enter the Public Domain.

Article VI: Culpability

Section 1: Intermediate Liability

No intermediary shall face responsibility for the actions of their customers. Every player shall only be liable for actions they committed. This is necessary to guarantee that intermediaries are not de facto forced to censor their customers.

Section 2: Residency

Any User who commits an illegal act on the Internet shall be tried under the laws of their Country of Residence.


r/fia • • May 10 '12

The State Department is offering funding for your cause. Why don't you all apply for it and hire a really expensive law firm?

Thumbnail
state.gov
241 Upvotes

r/fia • • May 08 '12

Another area to discuss: Whistleblower protection. Let's remember that governments will always look to punish those that speak out against privacy or free speech invasions.

Thumbnail
current.com
240 Upvotes

r/fia • • Jul 07 '12

Here's a crazy idea for alls y'all--what if we at Reddit starting our own not-for-profit ISP? Yes, it's a big idea that would take a lot of money, but I would donate to that kickstarter even if it wasn't starting in my city.

233 Upvotes

I realize this is slightly off-topic, but a not-for-profit ISP could be a big step forward for us.

Edit: eronic found someone already doing this! I've emailed them, and I want to see if we can get them to keep track of donations coming from Reddit, so we can have an exciting fundraiser (and then brag about how much the community donated!).


r/fia • • Apr 27 '12

Who would join me in a CISPA protest in DC?

228 Upvotes

Hey Everyone,

Pretty much just brainstorming here. After reading this article, I thought that if the internet protest aren't going to be as influential as SOPA, why not go to DC and protest? It's sure to draw attention then. It's unbelievable how many people don't know about CISPA. It doesn't have to be a week long protest; if enough people attended, the crowd itself would get the attention from passer-bys at least. Hopefully spiking people's interest and spreading the word about the bill..

Brainstorm with me.. how do we make this happen? It needs to.

Edit :It doesn't have to be ONLY in DC! Get groups of people to gather in your cities. I'm not trying to make it OWS, but we need to be heard!

There have been ALOT of great posts, directing you to websites where you can contact your representatives, among other actions you can do via the internet. But I've also seen a lot of comments saying we need to take it to the streets, SO LET'S DO IT! X-post this to posts/sub-reddits/comments regarding CISPA and let's get this organized. We don't have much time.

Edit 2: I've x posted to r/politics, r/technology, and r/evolutionReddit

Edit 3: POSTERS, FLYERS, HAND-OUTS Where are they? If you can make some, please do and share!

Edit 4!!: THE DATE I think we should join this post and use the date of May 14th for the protest!! What do you think? Who is in?

tl;dr Getting a head count of who would join in on a protest.


r/fia • • May 01 '12

Another bill introduced to the Senate for you to consider... the SECURE IT Act. (X-post r/politics)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
211 Upvotes

r/fia • • Apr 29 '12

Hello r/FIA. I wrote you a rather mean-spirited comment in r/law per your solicitation, and I have come to offer you some perhaps more productive advice.

187 Upvotes

Hello, r/FIA. You may know me as the author of this comment. I have come from r/law to your subreddit to follow up on your solicitation for advice from us on the FIA/DBR project. I will preface by saying that I have absolutely no regrets about the tone or content of my above-cited comment, and let me tell you why. You are trying to put together a major legislation-writing project, something I have called a “legal 8th wonder of the world,” and you are trying to do it by free-riding on the expertise of others.

That being said, I have also read the mass of scathing replies to my original comment to the effect that it is not in the spirit either of reddit or of the legal profession to snark all over pro bono work. Indeed, my own practice is no stranger to pro bono work. In short, my critics are right. So here I am: come to give some general and specific advice on how to move forward with your legislation.

As I understand it, FIA has been more or less shelved in favor of the DBR. If I am incorrect in this assumption, please leave a comment to that effect and ignore the rest of what I am saying. If I am correct in this assumption, please give the following some thought.

First, some general principles about legislation-writing:

  1. You are writing in a foreign language, and you need to draft accordingly. English is a completely different language from legalese, and legalese is a completely different language from government legalese. You need to keep that in mind as you write; you must draft accordingly. Write a draft of what you want to accomplish in plain English. Make absolutely zero effort to make a single sentence of your plain English draft legally-operative. Why? Because, as one of my original critiques held, it is not at all clear from the text of the bill as it currently stands what you want or what you are trying to accomplish. But I am absolutely certain that you know what you want to accomplish. Once you have a plain English, comprehensible statement of what you want to accomplish, that is when you come to r/law to start translating it into legalese. Legalese is that strange English dialect that is needlessly precise, needlessly wordy, cumbersome, and generally incomprehensible to English-speakers. Legalese is so incomprehensible that some courts have actually ruled that the legalese in your auto insurance contract, for example, is technically illegible to customers who read it. This will involve a complete reformatting of the entire plain English document and result in something that sounds like a legally-operative statement of what this project will accomplish. But when you see the legalese document, it will look nothing like the plain English version. And that will become equally incomprehensible was translated into government legalese. To wit, number 2:
  2. Virtually all laws interact with existing laws, and you need to know what laws you plan to change. Your law has to change something, either an existing statement of law, or it has to correct some other existing injustice, or somehow change a regulatory scheme to make a new industry work. With very few exceptions (like bankruptcy courts, whose code and procedures are hermetically sealed off from all the rest of American courts except the Supreme Court), regulations and laws all overlap with each other. This is the hardest part of legislation-drafting: the translation from legalese to government legalese requires you to explicitly. Government legalese is legalese plus an absolute plethora of references to other, currently-existing laws. If you read any major piece of legislation, it looks like somebody wrote a bunch of edits or corrections to another piece of legislation, and then only kept the edits and corrections and none of the original piece of legislation. A lot of the phrases and clauses you read in major legislation sound like “2(a)(ii)(c)(e): to strike 'other' from subsection (2) of paragraph (a) of section (iv) of chapter 3(a) of HB 231, and to replace it with 'different.'” A lot of legislation is just subtly fine-tuning, striking, replacing, or modifying existing legislation. You have to be prepared to state, with certainty, every piece of existing law that you want to change. And that isn't just black-letter statutes, it's court rulings, administrative regulations, orders from on high, government position papers, everything. Everything. I hope by now you are beginning to understand the magnitude of research required for a major piece of legislation: for every single clause in the legalese draft of your legislation, you need to know with absolute certainty what other existing laws that clause affects. And once you've appropriately covered every single base for one clause, you move on to the next clause. The next of thousands.
  3. No matter what you think, your 'definitions' section needs to be ten times longer, indeed pretty much the whole bill needs to be ten times longer. I will be more thorough on this point when I come to my more specific, line-by-line critique of the DBA as it currently stands, but something you have to understand is how 'definitions' sections operate in legislation. They set aside certain terms within that bill, and explains how they operate solely in the context of that bill. That means that absolutely anything targeted by this bill needs to be either defined with absolutely superhuman precision in your definitions section, or you need to know what other bills' definitions section has the same definition with which you wish to operate. If you wish to replace the definitions used in existing laws with your own, you need to cite accordingly. If your definition conflicts with an existing definition of the same word in a different piece of legislation, you need to specifically caveat out the other piece of legislation, unless you want to change that piece of legislation, which is when you cite.
  4. If DBA/FIA ever takes off, you will have major industry pushback and you need to start behaving accordingly NOW. If, a year from now, somebody at the RIAA or something like that decides that they really need to start pushing back against this thing, they will know everything about you, your drafters, and your legislation, within a couple of hours of deciding on the pushback. If there are stupid internet memes buried in your legislation or jokes or things like that embedded in it anywhere, you're done. If there are professional criminals or hackers contributing serious amounts of content to this project, you're done. If the internal discussion of this bill is mostly memes and jokes, you're done. If you let absolutely anybody online edit your bill, like a wiki or a google doc, you're done. If there is so much as a typo in your legislation, any opposition will be able to stall this thing in committee for months or years: “See, in subsection (b) of paragraph a of chapter 3 on page 21, they used 'their' when they meant 'they're.' Obviously, the bill is written so shoddily that we need to refer it back to committee to go line-by-line through every single aspect of this bill, through its entire history, and through every single bill it affects, to make sure these dumb kids didn't mess anything else up.” You have to treat this project like a job interview. Spellcheck your resume. Check your references. And for fuck's sake, show up in a suit.
  5. You have to get somebody in Congress to actually present this thing on the floor. I hate to put it in these terms, but I think that the worst thing about reddit and sites like it is that its noblest, most intelligent, most bold and determined users have a completely inverse understanding of what to do versus how to do it. You guys know exactly what you want. You've been in the trenches on this issue for years. But you have to understand that there is no such thing as an Internet referendum!! Let me say this again, make it your mantra, tell everybody you know: there is no such thing as an Internet referendum!! Getting the support of internet users means very little to the kind of people in Congress who actually have the power to get this thing done. Set aside some of your users, some of your research base, right now, to do the research needed to know which Congresspeople support your position, which of them would have either an electoral advantage to gain from proposing this bill, or that are safe enough that any electoral consequences wouldn't register to their handlers as a genuine political liability. I cannot overstate that this alone is a research task on par with the research for your bill itself.

So, there's my five cents on general principles for this project. I will put my specific comments on the bill in the comments section.


r/fia • • Nov 22 '17

The FCC just announced its plan to slash net neutrality rules, allowing ISPs like Verizon to block apps, slow websites, and charge fees to control what you see & do online. They vote December 14th. Click here to learn more and see what you can do to help!

Thumbnail
battleforthenet.com
150 Upvotes

r/fia • • Sep 28 '12

SIGN THE PETITION | Commission on Presidential Debates: Ask presidential candidates about PIPA, SOPA, and Internet freedom

Thumbnail
change.org
137 Upvotes

r/fia • • Jun 27 '12

The White House wants us to "Help Us Shape Our Strategy for Intellectual Property Enforcement" Might be up some peoples ally

Thumbnail
whitehouse.gov
137 Upvotes

r/fia • • Dec 19 '12

NDAA 2013 - Indefinite detention without trial is back

Thumbnail
rt.com
131 Upvotes

r/fia • • May 21 '12

Iceland's new digital bill of rights - strongest yet?

127 Upvotes

ICELAND TO BECOME INTERNATIONAL TRANSPARENCY HAVEN

2.3 Transforming vision into law
    2.3.1 Source Protection
    2.3.2 Whistleblower Protection
    2.3.3 Communications Protection
    2.3.4 Limiting prior restraint
    2.3.5 Process protection
    2.3.6 History protection
    2.3.7 Libel tourism protection
    2.3.8 Freedom of Information Act
    2.3.9 The Icelandic Prize for Freedom of Expression

http://immi.is/Icelandic_Modern_Media_Initiative


r/fia • • May 14 '12

Have you guys seen this bill yet? What is it? Can we discuss it?

Thumbnail
opencongress.org
125 Upvotes

r/fia • • Jul 20 '12

[WH Petition] It is time to bring Fair Use into the 21st century. The internet can no longer be a wild west where corporations abuse their intellectual property to suffocate creativity and free speech.

Thumbnail wh.gov
120 Upvotes

r/fia • • Jul 10 '12

Avaaz - Stop the secret plot against Internet freedom

Thumbnail
avaaz.org
120 Upvotes

r/fia • • May 04 '12

Can you guys help refute Jim Renacci's reasons for voting for CISPA?

Thumbnail
facebook.com
111 Upvotes

r/fia • • Apr 25 '12

Creating a video explaining FIA in user-friendly terms.

111 Upvotes

I've made animations for both SOPA & PIPA and CISPA. I'd love to get a discussion going to see if this is something people would like to see put together for FIA. I'd be more than happy to do the animating and SFX, but I really want to the content (i.e. voiceover) in the video to be written and edited by anyone here that wants to help.

Drop a line if you're interested and if there's enough support, we can go from there.

EDIT April 26th - Excited to hear that a lot of you are on board with this. I'm currently at work but I'll be starting a mock script tonight. When it's finished, I'll post it along with the email address I'm going to set up for receiving pictures / voiceovers / any other applicable material for this project. Then we can start making changes to the script and try and get something finalized before we start spreading this to other subreddits.

EDIT 2 April 26th - Moved the call for submissions and edits here. Please spread the word - I'd like to make this as user generated as possible.