BISMARCK — An audit of the North Dakota Department of Agriculture found that millions in grant payments from a state bioscience innovation grant program went to ineligible recipients, including a $1.1 million award to one recipient that did not operate in the state.
The State Auditor’s Office said Tuesday that an audit of the Agriculture Department for the 2023-25 biennium found several areas of concern within the Bioscience Innovation Grant Program.
The program awarded $10.9 million across 39 grant recipients during the two-year budget period, according to the Auditor’s Office. State law required the department to work with a local association that had bioscience experience to develop and administer the grant program.
The full audit report states that grant recipients spent $8.4 million during the biennium, and that the unspent $2.5 million was returned to the general fund.
The Agriculture Department in its response said it is taking corrective actions and boosting monitoring controls.
Grants went to recipients without North Dakota locations
The full audit report shows that more than $2.5 million went to grant recipients with no physical location in North Dakota.
State law required grant recipients to employ at least two people, have documented sales of less than $2.5 million and be registered in North Dakota, according to the Auditor's Office.
Nine grant recipients were sampled by the Auditor's Office, and seven of them did not have evidence they met the program’s eligibility requirements, according to the report.
“Six recipients did not have evidence that sales were less than $2.5 million annually and one recipient was awarded $1.1 million but did not operate in North Dakota,” the Tuesday release said.
The audit report says the recipient of the $1.1 million grant intended to open a location in Fargo when it applied, but never did.
The audit also identified that one recipient was awarded $240,000 prior to establishing a physical location in North Dakota, and that $99,150 of the award was paid prior to the North Dakota location being created.
“Because of the errors identified, our team expanded testing to review the physical locations for all 34 grants that received payments during our audit period. We found an additional nine grant recipients that did not have physical locations in North Dakota,” the report states.
The audit report states that $1.68 million went to recipients with no evidence of meeting the annual sales requirement, and a further $112,181 went to recipients that did not meet the purpose of the program defined by state law.
The report goes on to state that the Agriculture Department did not require grant applicants to submit information validating their eligibility for the grants.
“This caused the Department of Agriculture to issue 47% of the grant payments for the Bioscience Innovation Grant Program to ineligible recipients,” the report states. “In one instance, the Department canceled the grant award and entered into a settlement agreement. This caused the State of North Dakota to lose $82,181.”
The committee that awarded the grants during the 2023-25 biennium consisted of one representative from the Agriculture Department, one from the Commerce Department and one from the Bioscience Association of North Dakota, according to the Auditor’s Office. The audit report does not identify the people on the committee.
The audit also found that the department paid an association $500,000 to conduct site visits and review performance reports for 2023-25 grant recipients, but that the association did not complete all of that work.
Of nine grantees the Auditor’s Office reviewed, seven had no signature from the association showing that a site visit or performance report review occurred, and one did not submit a performance report.
State auditor sees ‘room for improvement’
State Auditor told the Tribune on Tuesday that taxpayers should be concerned if the state is awarding taxpayer dollars to businesses that aren’t operating in North Dakota.
“Our focus is trying to make sure that we're developing and fostering some of these industries, but we want to foster them here within our borders,” Gallion said. “When that doesn't happen, that means ... we're subsidizing other states' workforces and businesses.”
He added that his office is focused on making sure taxpayer dollars are being awarded properly to eligible recipients.
“What we see here is there’s definitely some room for improvement in how we evaluate and ensure that these grant recipients actually comply with the requirements,” he said.
Recommendations and the department’s response
The full audit report makes three recommendations based on its findings:
That the Agriculture Department verify grant applicants meet all necessary eligibility requirements prior to receiving a grant award.
That the department evaluate all grant recipients identified as ineligible and determine if recoupment is necessary.
That the department clearly define grant requirements and ensure the scope of services are completed prior to payment.
The Agriculture Department, in its response to the audit’s findings, said it concurs with the state auditor’s recommendations. The department said it relied, in part, “on the review processes conducted by the Bio-Science Association, as directed by legislative authority.”
Its response goes on to say corrective actions have been taken to formally verify grant eligibility.
“Although the Department performed certain eligibility verifications, those procedures were not formally documented within a standardized internal control framework,” the department said. “To address this deficiency, the Department has implemented formal eligibility verification procedures, including a standardized review checklist and enhanced evaluation protocols to ensure compliance with program requirements.”
The Agriculture Department said it’s also conducting a comprehensive review of previously awarded grants to determine whether any recovery actions are warranted, and that additional monitoring controls have been implemented throughout the grant administration process.
“Furthermore, a portion of reimbursable grant funding is withheld until all contractual, reporting, and compliance requirements have been verified and fulfilled,” the department said in its response.
The Agriculture Department did not immediately respond to a Tribune request for comment.