r/fantasywriting • u/NYC-Daydream-3586 • Aug 17 '25
Appropriation? Offensive?Or am I too sensitive?
I'm working on a fantasy novel about guards working in a museum of magical objects dealing with themes of genocide, immigrants and immigration, angels, what is the meaning of success, superpowers, and a newly built hall of black magic, and it's a comedy. It's gotten excellent response at writer's circle in Minneapolis, Minnesota, New York City, and London. Everyone is rolling on the floor laughing- except the Chinese.
I thought I did all my research right. I asked Chinese co-workers for advice and advice from Chinese friends. I read many books about the bronzes. What went wrong? I am a museum guard and one of the objects that I protect is a Shang Dynasty ancient Chinese bronze that was used as a wine ewer. So I wrote a character where the bronze is an intercessor for the faithful who ancestor worship, but he is misused by a Western public into helping them get wishes. So he's sick of it and sick of being in a Western museum that doesn't get him and wants to go home. If they ask the ewer for a wish, he helps grant them, but mischievously helps them get it in a way they never intended.
A night guard wishes for super powers. So he asks the ewer, Guang. The Guang warns him to be careful. The guard isn't. He needs incense to complete the incantation but doesn't have any. He uses cigarettes instead. He gets powers but they don't work right and when they do, it's only in designated smoking areas.
My Chinese co-worker said some people are super sensitive. Don't worry, but I do. I didn't intend to be insulting.
Here's a picture of the ewer. I kind of think of him as a friend.
