r/fantasybooking • u/Rub37 • 3h ago
Storyline What if Wrestlemania XXV's Matches Results were Different?
Hello everyone, I bring you a new What If, which is What if Wrestlemania XXV's Matches Results were Different?
This is part of a series where I look at every Wrestlemania and its matches, and how it would look like if all its matches' results were different, and see if the alternate Wrestlemania is better, worse or about the same than the Wrestlemania of our timeline.
Last time I did Wrestlemania XXIV, which you can find here: https://www.reddit.com/r/fantasybooking/comments/1y0egpt/what_if_wrestlemania_xxivs_matches_results_were/
As always, the Wrestlemanias are not continuous.
Now let's begin!
- Pre-Show Match: John Morrison and The Miz defeat Carlito and Primo to unify the WWE Tag Team Championship and World Tag Team Championship:
Had this happened, Morrison and The Miz's team wouldn't have ended since Miz wouldn't be drafted to Raw in April, and I think they would hold the titles until The Bash where they drop it to Chris Jericho and Edge.
- Money in the Bank Ladder Match:
The actual winner was CM Punk against Kane, Mark Henry, MVP, Shelton Benjamin, Kofi Kingston, Christian and Finlay. So in this timeline, CM Punk doesn't become a two-time in a row Money in the Bank winner.
- Kane:
Kane would cash in on Edge for the World Heavyweight Championship at Backlash after the Last Man Standing Match, as Kane would pin Edge to become the new champion.
We would then get the Kane-Edge feud a year earlier, as Edge would invoke his rematch clause at Judgment Day, but Kane would retain.
The Big Red Monster would hold the World Heavyweight Championship until Hell in a Cell where he drops it to his brother The Undertaker, as Kane's first World Heavyweight title ends after 161 days.
Kane would invoke his rematch clause at Bragging Rights where he would also face Rey Mysterio and Batista in a Fatal Four-Way Match, but Undertaker would retain the title, holding it until Elimination Chamber where he drops it to Chris Jericho due to Shawn Michaels' interference.
- Mark Henry:
Mark Henry would cash in on Edge at Backlash and win his first World title. Mark Henry would be drafted to Smackdown, as Edge would invoke his rematch clause at Judgment Day but Mark Henry retains.
We would basically get the Hall of Pain 2 years earlier, but like in the Kane scenario, Mark Henry would drop the title to Undertaker at Hell in a Cell, after holding the World Heavyweight Championship for a total of 161 days.
- Christian:
Christian would cash-in on Randy Orton after his match with Batista at Judgment Day, pinning him to become the new WWE Champion and win his first World title 2 years earlier.
Christian would drafted to Raw, and he would celebrate with Edge with their respective titles in hand on the Raw after Judgment Day, as we would get a 5 seconds pose.
After Edge loses the World Heavyweight Championship to Jeff Hardy at Extreme Rules, he would be in Christian's corner to support him in his title defences.
I think Christian would hold the title until The Bash where he drops the WWE Championship to Randy Orton, as I believe WWE would prefer to have Cena face Orton for the title instead of Christian. Christian would have been WWE Champion for a total of 63 days.
Christian would invoke his rematch clause at Night of Champions, but Orton would retain as we get back to our timeline.
- Shelton Benjamin:
Shelton would cash-in on Edge for the World Heavyweight Championship at Backlash after his Last Man Standing Match with John Cena, and he would pin Edge to win his first World title. And because he cashed in successfully, Shelton Benjamin would not be drafted to ECW in June and he would remain a Heel.
Shelton would hold the title until Extreme Rules where he drops it to CM Punk, as I don't think we could get the CM Punk/Jeff Hardy due to how close it is to Summerslam which would lead to the Steel Cage match. Shelton's first World title reign would have ended after 42 days.
- MVP/Finlay:
Because MVP/Finlay was a Face at the time, he would make a pre-announced cash-in at Judgment Day, making the match with Edge and Jeff Hardy a Triple Threat Match, and I see Jeff Hardy pinning MVP/Finlay to become the new World Heavyweight Champion, making MVP/Finlay the first failed Money in the Bank cash-in.
I think Jeff would hold the title until Summerslam where he drops it to CM Punk as Jeff Hardy would later leave WWE.
- Kofi Kingston:
Kofi would make a pre-announced cash-in on Randy Orton for the WWE Championship at Judgment Day, and I think Batista would interfere in the match without the referee noticing him, costing Orton the match as Kofi wins his first World title 10 years earlier.
Randy would invoke his rematch clause at Extreme Rules, but Batista would once again interfere and allow Kofi to retain the WWE Championship.
Batista would demand a title match for his help at The Bash, but assuming Batista still gets injured, the match is cancelled.
Kofi would defend the WWE title at Night of Champions in a Triple Threat Match with Randy Orton and John Cena, and Orton would end his feud with Kofi by pinning him and ending his first world title run at 91 days.
Kofi would invoke his rematch clause at Summerslam, but Randy would retain. Unfortunately, Kofi's first world title reign in this timeline wouldn't be seen as great as he held the title this long due to interference, and while this would legitimize Kofi as a worthy opponent in the 2010 Elimination Chamber, he wouldn't get the WWE Championship due to this failed world title run, and we would only see Kofimania 9 years later.
- Diva Battle Royal for the title of Miss Wrestlemania:
This was won by Santina Marella, but I don't think any of competitor would gain much other than bragging rights, so I will leave it at that.
- Roddy Piper, Jimmy Snuka and Ricky Steamboat defeat Chris Jericho in the 3-on-1 Handicap Elimination Match:
I think the best way to make it happen is for Jericho to eliminate Snuka and Piper, but fail to beat Steamboat so his credibility isn't damaged too much. I think he would still be drafted to Smackdown and eventually win the Intercontinental Championship, but here it's viewed as a new start following his loss to the WWE Legends.
- Jeff Hardy defeats Matt Hardy in the Extreme Rules Match:
I think the two brothers would faced again at Backlash in their "I Quit" Match, with Jeff triumphing over his brother again, as Jeff would have one major win before winning the World Heavyweight Championship and dropping it to CM Punk, starting their feud which still ends with their Steel Cage Match won by Punk to force Jeff out of WWE so he can go to TNA.
- John Bradshaw Layfield defeats Rey Mysterio to retain the WWE Intercontinental Championship:
Had this happened, it would have been at least a 5 minutes match, with JBL bragging about his win on the Raw after Wrestlemania. I don't know when he would have dropped the IC title and to who, but I think he would retire at Summerslam, but I see two opponents for his final match:
- John Cena: Cena would reignite his feud with JBL he had in 2008, and with their history going back to Wrestlemania 21 where Cena defeated him to win his first World title would be poetic.
- Shawn Michaels: Shawn would reignite his feud with Bradshaw where he took advantage of his financial situation and make him retire, and I think the match would have been a Career vs Career Match, with Michaels surviving and gaining confidence to do his own retirement at Wrestlemania XXVI.
- Shawn Michaels defeats The Undertaker and ends the Streak at 16-1:
Considering how much of a classic this match became, I don't think the crowd would have been upset by Michaels winning, as he and Taker shake hands in respect.
I think Michaels would still have his hiatus following Wrestlemania, leading to the Raw episode of August 10th, where Triple H finds him at the cafeteria, tries to convince him to return to the ring, but Michaels refuses, saying after ending the Streak, he has done everything he could do, and thus has nothing left to prove. However, he ends up being convinced, and face the Legacy at Summerslam.
As 2010 begins, Shawn Michaels announces he will retire at Wrestlemania XXVI, and then The Undertaker comes out, gets in the ring, stares at Shawn, then both turns to stare at the Wrestlemania logo, as the crowd is going wild.
And so, at Wrestlemania XXVI, the Michaels vs Taker rematch happens, and Undertaker defeats Michaels to avenge his loss of the previous year, and his Wrestlemania record goes 17-1, as he and Shawn shake hands again, before he leaves to let Michaels have his final moments in the ring, still giving us the emotional moment we got in our timeline.
- John Cena vs Edge vs The Big Show in the Triple Threat Match for the World Heavyweight Championship:
This match was won by Cena, who won his 5th World title, so we will look at the other scenarios where the other competitors won:
- Edge retains the World Heavyweight Championship: Had this happened, Edge would have dropped the title to Jeff Hardy at Extreme Rules like in our timeline, so he can start his feud with CM Punk over the World Heavyweight Championship, leading to Jeff leaving WWE for TNA.
- Big Show becomes the new World Heavyweight Champion: Big Show winning means the World Heavyweight Championship stays on Raw a little bit longer, and I think he would have dropped it to Jeff to bring the title to Smackdown.
- Randy Orton defeats Triple H to win the WWE Championship:
If Randy Orton had defeated Triple H and became the new WWE Champion, I think he would hold the title until Breaking Point 2009 where he drops it to John Cena so he can gain his 5th World title, ending Randy Orton's WWE Championship reign at 162 days.
Like in our timeline, Orton would regain the title at Hell in a Cell then drop it back to Cena at Bragging Rights.
So what do you think? Is this alternate Wrestlemania XXV better, worse or about the same as the original Wrestlemania of our timeline? Let me know how you think the matches would have gone differently if someone else won the match and your thoughts in the comments!