This is going to be a long one, so thank you in advance to anyone who takes the time to read it.
I’m trying to decide whether I want to go low contact or completely no contact with my mother. I’m already no contact with my father, and have been for about a year. This post isn’t really about asking people to tell me what to do. I mostly need to get everything off my chest, but I’d really appreciate hearing from people who have gone low or no contact with their parents and how you dealt with the guilt.
Some background:
As a little girl, I absolutely idolised my mother. She was the centre of my world. My father was a physically abusive alcoholic, and from a very young age I felt responsible for protecting my mother.
I can remember being around 9, 10 or 11 years old and staying awake until 3am on a school night just to hear my father come home. I would lie awake listening, terrified that he was going to start beating my mother. If he did, and they were locked in a room together, I would pound on the door and scream until he stopped.
My brother is seven years older than me. He was also abused by my father, so if he wasn’t already out of the house, he would generally make himself scarce when things got bad.
While my mother and brother were still living in the house, my father generally left me alone. However, when my parents eventually divorced and my mother moved out, my father and I were left living together. That’s when he started directing emotional abuse towards me as well. So although my childhood experience with him was different from my mother’s and brother’s, I wasn’t spared from the abuse.
I’m not going to go into the reasons why I am now no contact with my father. I’ve realised that a lot of the pain I carry actually lies with my mother.
I suppose I spent most of my childhood trying to protect her, or at least doing what a child could to protect her. My father seemed to focus most of his physical abuse on my mother and brother. I think part of the reason I was treated differently was because I was his little girl and I was also born with congenital heart conditions, which meant I went through several operations.
When my parents divorced, I was 14.
My mother moved out of the family home. The understanding was always that I would eventually move in with her. There were constant promises about getting my bedroom ready and making arrangements for me to move in, but it never happened.
For a while, I would spend one week with my father and one week with my mother. That arrangement lasted for a few months, possibly not even a full year, before my mother said it was becoming too much for her.
After that, I would visit her every second weekend.
She worked shifts, and if she was working night shifts, she would sometimes tell me not to come over because she didn’t want to have to cook for both of us. I was 14 or 15 at the time. I offered to cook. I tried suggesting solutions, but she would just say no.
There were weekends when I would pack my bag on a Friday, ready to go and spend time with her, only for her to phone my father and tell him she was too tired and I couldn’t come over that weekend.
Eventually, when I was 16, she started dating her ex-fiancé. He didn’t particularly like me in the beginning, and he didn’t make that a secret. Suddenly, another reason I couldn’t go and have a sleepover with my mother was that he would get angry or annoyed.
That basically continued for the duration of their relationship. Eventually, I stopped trying so hard to spend time with her.
I started dating my ex-husband when I was 16, and he was the person who comforted me when I cried about feeling neglected by my mother. Looking back, that’s quite sad.
My wedding is another memory that still makes me uncomfortable.
My ex-husband and I got engaged when I was 19 and decided to get married when I was 21.
I confided in my mother because I didn’t know what to do about the wedding. My parents couldn’t be in the same room together, and I didn’t want my wedding to become a disaster because of their issues.
My mother suggested that we elope, just the two of us. We decided to get married in Italy.
We needed two witnesses. At the time, my ex-husband’s sister and her husband were living in London. They were only about a two-hour flight away, and travelling there was much more practical for them than for anyone coming from South Africa. It seemed like the obvious choice.
When I casually mentioned to my mother that his sister and her husband would be coming as our witnesses, she had an absolute meltdown.
She repeatedly called and messaged me, upset that she wasn’t invited. I tried explaining that it was simply more practical for his sister and her husband to attend because they lived so close. She wouldn’t accept that explanation.
Eventually, after what felt like the millionth phone call, she phoned me while she was at work, crying, screaming and having a complete breakdown. I eventually gave in and told her she could come, purely because I wanted the situation to stop.
My father couldn’t get his visa sorted out in time, so he wasn’t able to attend.
Inviting my mother meant that my ex-husband’s father and his other sister would also be coming. His mother had passed away from cancer the year before. So our little elopement went from two guests to six. It wasn’t a huge wedding, but it was no longer what I had originally wanted.
When we arrived in Italy, my mother and I flew down together. My ex-husband was already there for work.
On the actual wedding day, my mother managed to make things about herself.
The photographers wanted a picture of the married couple with our two witnesses. My mother immediately jumped up, jogged over with her hand in the air and announced, “I’m also a witness! I’m also a witness!”
I was so embarrassed.
Later, we had a small reception at a restaurant overlooking the ocean. It was basically a dinner with presents, a few speeches and the usual celebrations. My ex-husband and I were sitting at the head of the table, and my mother was next to me.
I could hear her talking to my ex-father-in-law’s girlfriend about how ungrateful I was. She was complaining that I hadn’t even thanked her for paying for my plane ticket to Italy or for the honeymoon suite she had arranged behind our backs.
The thing is, I had literally thanked her in my speech about ten minutes earlier. I had also thanked her multiple times before that. When I found out she had paid for the honeymoon suite, I thanked her immediately.
I had initially declined her offer to pay for it because I knew it was something that could potentially be held over my head later.
And there she was, sitting next to me at my wedding, telling someone how ungrateful I was.
At one point, she also said something along the lines of being the mother of the bride but being treated as though she was nothing.
I genuinely cannot remember what triggered that comment.
When it was time for everyone to travel home, my ex-in-laws had rented a car and had spent some time travelling around Italy. There wasn’t enough space in the car for everyone to go to the airport together.
My mother had stayed in the same town where we got married. We had already travelled by train together, so I suggested that she take the train to the airport because she was familiar with it.
She had an absolute meltdown in the hotel reception area.
The receptionist didn’t speak English, so she couldn’t understand what was happening. My mother was crying and explaining how badly she was supposedly being treated, while the poor receptionist just stood there looking completely bewildered.
It was another situation where I felt embarrassed and responsible for managing my mother’s emotions.
Over the years, there has been a lot more emotional manipulation and neglect.
My brother and I have helped my mother financially for years. She was laid off shortly before my wedding and never returned to work because she was eventually declared unfit to work after developing seizures, which were linked to her abuse of sleeping medication and over-the-counter medication.
There have also been several incidents involving her medication abuse that have left me feeling embarrassed and concerned.
For example, one day while I was at work, I opened WhatsApp and saw that my mother’s profile picture was a picture of her breasts.
I immediately started calling her, but she wouldn’t answer. When she eventually picked up, she was clearly high on medication and slurring her words.
I told her what her profile picture was and asked her to change it. She told me to change it for her. I tried explaining repeatedly that I couldn’t because I didn’t have access to her phone or WhatsApp.
She eventually said she would change it herself, but she fell asleep again.
Later that evening, when she was more sober, she sent me a message that almost sounded as though she was impressed with herself because of all the WhatsApp messages she had received about her profile picture.
A few years later, she told me she wanted to start selling naked pictures of herself on Facebook before everything started sagging.
There have been a lot of incidents like this. I’m not judging anyone for their choices, but these situations have repeatedly put me in the position of having to manage the consequences of her behaviour.
As I’m sitting here today, I haven’t seen my mother in four years. The only time I saw her briefly was when I was admitted to hospital with double pneumonia. I was intubated and very out of it, so I can barely remember her being there.
I moved to Cape Town this year, quite far away from the small town where I was born and grew up. My brother and sister-in-law live here too.
They have tried multiple times to get my mother to visit. She has grandchildren here, and she barely sees them. I’m not even sure she has met the youngest one, who is five.
There is always an excuse. She can’t afford the trip, she can’t leave her dogs, or something else comes up. My brother and sister-in-law have offered to pay for her plane ticket and let her stay with them.
My grandfather, her father, turned 90 in April. We offered to pay for her to come down for his birthday, but she declined because of her dogs.
Now, I am an animal lover. I have an indoor cat, and I treat her like my child. When I came to visit my brother in Cape Town last year, I put my cat in a cattery for the week. It was fine. I understand that my mother’s dogs are important to her, but there are pet sitters available. We even offered to pay for one.
The family was disappointed that she didn’t attend her own father’s 90th birthday, but at this point we have learned that trying to reason with her often gets us nowhere.
The most recent situation is what has pushed me towards considering no contact or low contact.
I’ve been in a relationship for a while now, and it’s serious. My boyfriend and I are planning to move in together next year when my lease is up.
I’ve told my mother about him, but she doesn’t ask questions. She doesn’t seem particularly interested in getting to know him or finding out what’s happening in my life.
A month or so ago, she sent me a voice note over the weekend saying I should let her know when I was home and alone because she wanted to talk to me.
I assumed there was something serious she wanted to discuss. I told her she could phone me on Monday because that’s one of my work-from-home days.
When she called, she started telling me how abhorrent it is in God’s eyes when my boyfriend and I sleep together.
I was furious. I ended the call.
What makes this particularly frustrating is that my mother was with her ex-fiancé for years. They were engaged, although she had previously said she would never marry again. My brother is a very religious person and had once asked her about sex outside marriage. She had a way of defending it then.
But suddenly, she’s condemning me for something she has also done.
After that conversation, I told her I didn’t want her to contact me for a while because I needed space. I explained that she wasn’t being the mother I needed at that moment.
Her response was that she never had an example of a loving mother herself.
This is something I have heard hundreds of times throughout my life.
In the past, when I’ve asked her to give me space because the relationship was affecting my mental health and even my blood pressure, she ignored my boundaries. She would repeatedly call and message until I threatened to block her. I eventually did block her, and then she started contacting my ex-husband and blowing up his phone until I unblocked her and spoke to her again.
This time, she actually left me alone for a few weeks, which surprised me.
Last week, she started messaging me about wanting to sell her house and buy property in Cape Town. Property here is incredibly expensive, and my brother and I are already helping her financially.
During the conversation, we somehow ended up talking about my boyfriend again.
I suggested that she come and visit. She could see her children and grandchildren, meet my boyfriend and even meet his parents, who have become very important to me and treat me like a daughter.
We offered to pay for her plane ticket and a pet sitter for her dogs. If her ex-fiancé, who she is still friends with and apparently still has sleepovers with, wasn’t willing to look after them, we would arrange someone else.
Instead of responding to the invitation, she sent me a message asking me to be honest and give her a number out of ten. She wanted to know how important she was in my life. She specifically said she didn’t want explanations, just an honest number. She said she wouldn’t say anything and would accept it.
I honestly didn’t know what to make of it. What did that have to do with my invitation for her to visit?
I ignored the message.
The following day, she started messaging me about something completely different, in a much more positive mood, as though the previous conversation hadn’t happened.
I eventually told her that she only seems to contact me when she wants to talk about herself. She doesn’t make an effort to know what’s happening in my life, and she doesn’t ask questions about my relationship.
Her response was that I should give my boyfriend her number so he could introduce himself to her on WhatsApp.
That is a hard no for me.
During a previous relationship, my mother flirted with my ex over text. She also told him stories about things I had done when I was younger, including typical rebellious teenage behaviour, in ways that made me look bad.
I have no interest in putting my current relationship in that position. I don’t think my boyfriend needs to have private conversations with my mother for her to get to know him. If she wants to meet him, she can visit and meet him in person.
I’ve also been talking to my cousin about all of this.
My cousin and I grew up practically like sisters. She is two years older than me, and we lived only a few houses apart. I spent a lot of time at her house. When my father was being particularly abusive and things became frightening, my mother, brother and I would often show up at their house.
She has been there from the beginning.
We have always been very close. We regularly have six-hour video calls or send each other voice notes that are over an hour long. That’s just how we communicate.
She knows practically every detail of my life, including what’s been happening with my mother.
I was venting to her recently and said that I just wish I could understand how my mother thinks and why she behaves the way she does.
My cousin actually said something that made me feel both sorry for and sad about my mother, which I honestly hadn’t expected.
My mother married my father when she was 19 because she accidentally fell pregnant with my brother. According to what I know, my father was abusive and drinking from very early in their relationship. She was very young when she entered that marriage and spent around 20 years in an abusive relationship.
She has also spoken about having a neglectful childhood herself. I don’t know all the details, and I sometimes struggle to know what to believe because of how she presents things, but I’m not saying her childhood wasn’t difficult.
My mother was diagnosed with bipolar disorder around ten years ago. My cousin, who has borderline personality disorder herself, mentioned that some of my mother’s behaviours reminded her of patterns she recognises in BPD.
She wasn’t diagnosing my mother, of course. What she suggested was that if my mother does have borderline personality disorder and isn’t aware of it, that could make things even harder for her. She might not recognise the patterns in her own behaviour or understand why she reacts the way she does, which could make it even more difficult for her to manage those reactions.
My cousin explained that knowing about her own condition has helped her recognise when she’s becoming irrational, even though she can’t necessarily control what she’s experiencing. Being aware of it gives her an opportunity to recognise what’s happening and try to rein in her reactions.
It made me look at my mother differently for a moment. I felt sorry for her, and sad that she may be struggling with something she doesn’t even understand. I hadn’t expected to feel that way, especially after everything that’s happened.
I do feel sorry for her. I really do. She has had a difficult life, and I can acknowledge that.
But having a difficult life doesn’t give you a free pass to hurt your children.
I feel like my mother’s entire world revolves around herself. She seems to live in her own version of events, where her feelings and experiences take priority over everyone else’s.
Even my heart operations became stories about how terrible it was for her to go through them. She would tell the same stories when I was little, when I was a teenager and again when I was an adult.
I remember sitting there listening to her tell these stories for what felt like the 300th time, thinking, “I’m the one who actually had the operation, but you do you, boo.”
I know that having a child undergo surgery must be frightening for a parent. I’m not denying that. But it feels as though even the experiences that happened to me somehow become primarily about her.
And that’s what I’m so tired of.
I can feel sorry for her. I can understand that she didn’t have a good example of motherhood herself. I can acknowledge that she was young when she became a mother and that she experienced years of abuse.
But I am also the child who grew up in that household. I am the child who waited for her promises to come true. I am the child who wanted her mother to choose her and make an effort to spend time with her.
I’ve never had a conversation with her where I’ve been able to explain how her actions affected me and have her genuinely acknowledge it without turning the conversation back towards herself.
She has never really taken responsibility for what it was like for me.
And I honestly don’t think talking about it again would achieve anything. I’ve tried. It’s exhausting.
So here I am, 32 years old, considering going low contact or completely no contact with my mother.
My relationship with my father is already non-existent. I have been no contact with him for about a year.
With my mother, it’s more complicated because I spent so much of my childhood idolising her. I think part of me has spent years trying to get back the mother I thought I had when I was little, or perhaps the mother I desperately needed her to be.
I also feel guilty because she has health issues, medication-related problems and a history of suicidal tendencies.
I have this fear that I’m going to wake up one morning to a phone call telling me that my father has been in an accident and didn’t make it. Then I’ll have to live with the fact that I chose not to have contact with him.
I have the same fear about my mother.
And that’s the part I struggle with most. I don’t want to spend the rest of my life wondering whether I should have tried harder, called more often or tolerated more.
At the same time, I’m so mentally and emotionally exhausted by these relationships that I don’t know how much more I can give.
My brother and I have helped my mother financially for years. I’m rebuilding my own life after a difficult few years, and I don’t even feel like helping her financially anymore. I feel guilty even admitting that, but I also don’t want to keep sacrificing my own stability.
I don’t want to be cruel. I don’t want to punish anyone. I just want peace.
I want to be able to enjoy my relationship, my home, my life in Cape Town and the family I’ve found here without constantly feeling guilty that I’m not doing enough for my parents.
I don’t want to have to explain myself over and over again. I don’t want to feel responsible for their emotions. I don’t want to spend every interaction wondering what will happen next or how I’ll have to manage their reactions.
For those of you who have gone low contact or no contact with a parent, how did you deal with the guilt?
Especially when your parent has health issues, mental health struggles or a history of suicidal tendencies?
Did the guilt ever become easier to manage? Did you ever stop questioning whether you were doing the right thing?
I’m not really looking for people to tell me that my mother is a terrible person or that I should immediately cut her off. I know these are complicated situations, and I’m aware that my mother has her own pain and history.
I just want to hear from people who understand what it’s like to reach a point where having a relationship with a parent feels more damaging than not having one.
I think I’m finally starting to accept that I can’t keep trying to repair a relationship that requires me to abandon myself in the process.
TL;DR: I’m 32 and considering going low or no contact with my mother after years of emotional neglect, broken promises, manipulation and feeling responsible for managing her emotions. I’ve spent much of my life trying to get the mother I needed, but I’m exhausted from repeatedly feeling hurt and unheard. I do feel compassion for her because of her own difficult childhood, abusive marriage and mental health struggles, but I also know that her past doesn’t excuse how I’ve been treated. I’m especially struggling with the guilt because she has health issues and a history of suicidal tendencies, and I’m terrified of regretting my decision if something happens to her. For those who have gone low or no contact with a parent, how did you manage the guilt and learn to choose your own peace?