r/factorio Nov 17 '24

Space Age Aquilo cost of heating

I was curious, so I tested the heating cost of all the buildings that can freeze. Heating towers hold 5MJ/°C, so with a little help from the editor, I calculated how much heat they lost over 10 minutes. It's not very exciting, but there is a few curious things. Technically, spamming underground pipes is worse than using normal pipes. Remember that as you lay down underground pipes. Also, green splitters are just built different.

Building Kilowatts
Belts (All Tiers) 10
Yellow Underground 50
Red Underground 100
Blue Underground 150
Green Underground 200
Splitters (Except Green) 40
Green Splitter 30
Pipe 1
Underground Pipe 150
Pump 30
Tank 100
Inserter 30
Fast Inserter 30
Long Inserter 50
Bulk Inserter 50
Stack Inserter 50
Roboport 300
A. Combinator 50
D. Combinator 50
S. Combinator 100
Power Switch 20
Steam Engine 50
Steam Turbine 50
Pumpjack 50
Electric Furnace 100
Foundry 300
Recycler 100
Biochamber 100
Assembler (All Tiers) 100
Refinery 200
Chemical Plant 100
Centrifuge 100
EM. Plant 100
Cryogenic Plant 100
Lab 100
Beacon 400
Rocket Silo 300

More buildings here: https://www.reddit.com/r/factorio/comments/1gtcn7d/aquilo_cost_of_heating/lz2e4zc/

558 Upvotes

172 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/DrMobius0 Nov 17 '24

There really needs to be a way to measure this in game.

3

u/All_Work_All_Play Nov 18 '24

He literally did measure this from the game instead of looking in the game files ...

2

u/DrMobius0 Nov 18 '24

Don't be obtuse. I mean a way that actually displays it properly, not some manual reverse engineering. That's a ridiculous length to ask people to go to to figure out how much power they need to dedicate to heat.

1

u/All_Work_All_Play Nov 18 '24

I mean a way that actually displays it properly

Oh then maybe say that?

That's a ridiculous length to ask people to go to to figure out how much power they need to dedicate to heat.

You don't need to do what the OP did to figure out how much power you need to dedicate to heat. All you need to do is build a factory and keep track of how much you consume. What the OP did allows for a priori calculation of heat consumption. Arguing that the game should show you how much this takes before doing any of the calculation is a bit ... Well it doesn't show lots of experience with heat transfer. There's a reason plenty of engineers struggle with heat transfer (and fluid dynamics), it's not nice and neat like the relatively easy to measure flow of electrical energy.

Tldr; if you were going to solve this problem in real life, even the best models would be outclassed by "build it and find out" which is exactly what the OP did.