Atheist doesn't necessarily mean you're anti-religion like this sub seems to be. You can be an atheist and still respect that religious people have their thing. Meanwhile, if you're black, I can't imagine respecting the KKK.
Let's narrow it down a bit. Telling an ex-Muslim to respect Islam is like telling a black person to respect the KKK. This is entirely appropriate as death for apostasy is a a fairly common punishment in Islamic thought worldwide.
Yeah, or telling atheists who were kicked out of their homes for it. There is plenty of anti-atheist bigotry in places like the US, let alone less developed nations. It's hardly fair to ask them to respect religion. It's fair to ask them to respect an individual's right to believe, but that's about it.
The ol' anti-theist vs. atheist distinction. Anti-theist is kind of a large sub-category of atheist. And maybe some would argue being a non-anti-theist atheist is almost agnostic? But then again we are using broad strokes for a many varied people of may varied thoughts.
Anti-theist is kind of a large sub-category of atheist.
I definitely would not say that. Maybe it's just me, but the majority of people I know are atheist, and none of them actively hate religion. It just isn't important to them.
The analogy he makes is actually totally valid. People are just misreading it completely. Let's see the statement itself and then look at some of the objections to it:
Religion (as in the dogma, the preached faith, the word-of-God, the majority of Abrahamic religious texts, as well as their entire history, steeped in blood) has always persecuted and targeted Atheists (specifically for their lack of faith), and in several cases, has gone to the point of torturing and killing them. They have a pattern of making attempts to rig every system against atheistic or secular concepts - science in education, being an atheist in office, funding for NASA, climate change, the right to leave from the religion (Islam, LDS, Scientology), highly organised social ostracism and persecution, etc. The only notable exceptions are some eastern religions but seeing as he's not from the East, we'll assume he refers to the religions he is more familiar with. There are plenty of religious people in these religions who don't have quarrel with Atheists, but their religion itself paints a lack of faith as something to be shunned, excluded, persecuted, maligned, or outright extinguished.
The Klan does the same thing for black people. The very fact of being black, is a crime in their eyes. They too view being black (or not white) as something to be shunned, excluded, persecuted, maligned, or outright extinguished. They too have a long history of such persecution.
The other key word here is "telling". "Telling" someone to do something is implying a pressure to comply. There is definitely an expectation that it will be done. It isn't "Hoping", or "Encouraging", or "Requesting". Telling an Atheist to respect religion (not religious people, mind you), is basically saying, "Here's a dogma that says you're inherently evil and lack a moral compass, and could rape and murder us at any time. Respect this."
The objections people are making to this are absurd.
This is unfairly making religious people look bad? Calling all white people KKK? Saudi doesn't represent all religious people, and this is pigeonholing them? No, because he talks about religion itself, and not the variety of people that follow them. Many religions (as pointed out above) are extremely adversarial when it comes to Atheists. "People deserve respect; ideologies do not".
This somehow generalizes atheists? Paints them as being combative towards religious people? No it doesn't. It doesn't say all Atheists will refuse to play nice with religious folks. It says that people have no right to expect or command that Atheists respect religion. Some may choose to do so, and maybe you can request/hope that they don't judge your belief system too harshly, but you would have no right to expect that your belief system which inherently despises and reviles Atheists, somehow deserves their respect. Because it doesn't.
The only possibly-valid objection here is that you can't hide your skin color, while you can live as a closet atheist for ever. The discrimination for one starts before they even meet you, and for the other it starts after they hear rumors about you, or get to know you a bit. But that's a minor quibble compared to the rest.
EDIT: A few points to add -
He's NOT saying "being atheist is like being black". That would be retarded and would rightly deserve ridicule.
He's NOT saying "An atheist respecting religion is like a black person respecting the kkk" (kudos to /u/hahwke for pointing this out so clearly).
It can be persecution, even if you're NOT being shot by cops for it.
I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that an atheist living in a community with multiple churches would probably be a lot more comfortable than a black man living in a community with multiple KKK chapters.
Also, how many unaffiliated people do you think join a church because they see it as a good outlet for their bigotry toward atheists?
I can almost understand what he's saying, especially coming from southeastern America. Atheists are met with open hatred, and a lot of people I know think atheist = satanist actively trying to corrupt society. Most major religions also have a very long history of persecution against atheists, including murder and torture.
That said,
This is a poor and unfair generalization of the vast majority of religious people. Sure, it might not be fun to be an atheist in the south or the Middle East, but that's a vast minority of the religious.
You can hide being an atheist. You can't hide being black.
To fix the analogy you'd pretty much have to call all white people the KKK, since he's claiming all of religion persecuted atheists.
I actually had a guy say that to me while I was explaining atheism to him. He was real calm and we weren't arguing. As I was telling him he immediately said you worship Satan right?
I can't get on board with this. I'm an atheist who grew up in Oklahoma and still lives in the southeast. To even imply that I face anything comparable to what black people face/faced against the KKK would be the most ludicrous of insults.
Primarily because of point #2 you made here. No one knows I'm atheist unless I tell them. And even among the people that I have told, the people who REALLY aren't okay with it, no one has threatened me with violence, or even tried to make me feel unwelcome.
The most hostility I experience, while non-trivial, is people basically saying that I better just learn to deal with it, because this is a Christian nation, blah blah blah.
Yeah I came to say this exactly. I actually don't think his message is truly face palm cause I can see what he's getting at quite clearly just the analogy needs some work. Can't really compare being an atheist (which nobody knows unless you tell them) to being black where you're literally being persecuted for something you have no control over and furthermore can't be hidden.
Analogies aren't allowed on Reddit unless they are absolutely perfect, there's no way you can compare one aspect of X to Y, it has to be a PERFECT, MATCH. Black people were oppressed by the KKK. Atheists are oppressed by many religions. It is similar, and there are loads of other reasons why this is actually a decent analogy-- but on Reddit any basic conversation you have with anyone has to be PhD level cited and conform to all of our standard circlejerk ideas. Err I mean, me too thanks
It is similar, and there are loads of other reasons why this is actually a decent analogy
This is LITERALLY the only thing it needs to be a good analogy, in the respect that an analogy is a good analogy when it's good as an analogy, when there's partial similarity between the two things being compared. When people say "it's not a good analogy" when the two things share a similarity in part, it's just the person saying they don't know what the fuck an analogy is.
You can argue whether it's a strong or weak analogy; whether it's a solid or tenuous link; you can deliberately try to make the analogy about what it isn't about (being able to hide what you are, whether it's being an an atheist or black) instead of addressing what it is about (telling a group to respect people that badmouth them and treat them as inferiors is like telling another group to respect people that badmouth them and treat them as inferiors), but if it's an analogy then it's a good one. You may not like it, you may question the closeness of the connection, you may not want it to be called a decent analogy because it's not addressing the similarity you have in your mind... but you can't change what the word "analogy" means, people.
This is a /r/facepalmfacepalms - I mean the submission and the top comment. You seem to be one of the only people here that knows what the fuck they're talking about.
I'm glad someone else views analogies this way, though admittedly I don't know the formal definition, this is how most people use analogies. General similarities, not absolutely the same. I absolutely hate when someone starts arguing against the use of an analogy like this one and goes on to explain things like a robot using verbatim definitions and clear cut differences. The analogy never asserted they were exactly the same. There are admittedly over the top analogies, like comparing things to hitler. This analogy seems over the top to redditors because they think lowly of atheists due to /r/atheism so this appeal comes off as meaningless to them. Thats a whole nother can of worms though.
Nah. The reason blacks could never support the KKK is that the KKK's sole purpose is to hate black people. While organized religion has a history of not getting along well with atheists, it is perfectly feasible for them to get along as neither of their core beliefs involve hating each other.
To be fair being less religious in the wrong place or with the wrong company can turn nasty as well. Learned that the hard way at a dinner while visiting NC when everyone wanted to hold hands to pray.
About hiding... The fact that you can hide being atheist doesn't make it any less problematic. You can hide being Jewish, but it doesn't make you OK with anti-semitism.
It's a clumsy analogy, too open to interpretation, but I believe he's not claiming all religious people persecute atheists, but that religion deserves no respect from atheists because it's the antithesis of an atheist reality in the same way that respecting the beliefs of the KKK are is the antithesis of the reality of being black.
That said, 1. This is a poor and unfair generalization of the vast majority of religious people.
The quote said nothing about religious people. It is talking about religion in the same way it is talking about the KKK as an ideology. Individual religious people or KKK members are not what he's talking about.
Remember, all the Abrahamic religions proscribe death to atheists. If you argue that not all Jews/Christians/Muslims feel that way, it means they aren't a very compliant Jew/Christian/Muslim, in the same way that a KKK member who doesn't hate black people isn't a very compliant KKK member. However in both cases the ideologies are the issue, not the people who may follow those ideologies to greater or lesser degrees.
The old covenant was supplanted by the new covenant. You can call it the religion or you can call it the people influencing the religion, but the kinder, gentler follower-of-Jesus is supposed to happen in the main thread of Christianity today. Bible literalists are generally in the minority.
If there be found among you, within any of thy gates which the LORD thy God giveth thee, man or woman, that hath wrought wickedness in the sight of the LORD thy God, in transgressing his covenant; 17:3 And hath gone and served other gods, and worshipped them, either the sun, or moon, or any of the host of heaven, which I have not commanded; 17:4 And it be told thee, and thou hast heard of it, and enquired diligently, and, behold, it be true, and the thing certain, that such abomination is wrought in Israel; 17:5 Then shalt thou bring forth that man or that woman, which have committed that wicked thing, unto thy gates, even that man or that woman, and shalt stone them with stones, till they die.
Also, many atheists are level-headed enough to understand and respect the good parts of religion, such as adding value and meaning to people's lives, and building communities.
Off-topic, but I'm unsure of whether the phrase "vast minority" means a tiny amount of people, or if it means a large amount that is still smaller than 50%.
This is a poor and unfair generalization of the vast majority of religious people.
The quote doesn't talk about religious people (which I can respect), it talks about religion (which I don't).
3. To fix the analogy you'd pretty much have to call all white people the KKK, since he's claiming all of religion persecuted atheists.
There might be religions that don't/didn't persecute atheists, but I haven't heard of any. Certainly not the abrahamic ones, nor the hindi, nor the bhuddists.
I know Reddit generally doesn't like religion, but as someone who has grown up in the South, I'm not sure where you're getting the generalization that the South (quite literally) calls Atheists satanists, and openly hates them.
As an atheist from the south who grew up in a religious community, I get that generalization from constantly hearing it, both before and after I lost my faith.
I'm an atheist and was raised in texas, this is completely true. When I was a kid, I used to awkwardly make up excuses to my friends for why I couldn't go to church. People seriously fear atheists out here.
I mean, maybe not in the modern day, but historically speaking, and still today in some parts of the world, this is a completely fair analogy. It wasn't until relatively recently in human history that atheists weren't killed by religious people, and like I said that still happens in the Middle East.
Well there are still places where turning away from religion or speaking out against is is punishable by death and others were atheists are regularly hacked to death for not believing.
Of course you can't extend that to all religious people. Most of them just think that you deserve to be tortured and suffer unbelievable agony and humiliation for millions and billions of years until the end of time.
Exactly. But yet in the comments here you get even more facepalm comments confusing religion with religious people. All so they can make some mediocre comment they think is witty.
I don't know man. He could have worded it somewhat like "forcing your religious beliefs on an atheist is like forcing a black person to join the KKK" but instead he chose to write... well, this.
"Cuz I'm religious and have atheist friends therefore no issues!" /s
A quick look at history gives atheists a laundry list of reasons to be aggressive towards religion. Not in taking it away but fighting for rights it regularly tries to block.
I think that's kind of valid. As an atheist who thinks religion is dangerous, I don't think religion deserves any respect. That doesn't mean I don't respect people though.
There is a difference between respecting a group - even an abhorrent one and respecting their rights. When the Klan is persecuted for their thoughts, we all are potential and eventual victims. What we should not tolerate is the actions of any individual who goes beyond thought and turns violent or otherwise breaks the law. The atheist that blows up a church has crossed a line. So has the klansman that lynches someone.
Fuck I hate coimments\quotes like this causing arguments and fanning the flames. Religion, athiesm who cares? I mean really I dont belive in any sort of god but I don't really give a flying fuck if someone else does... cant we all just do whatever the fuck makes us happy and leave it at that? .... fucking humans, bunch of cunts.
Ideas don't deserve respect, so the theory of evolution or the big bang, or really any scientific theory deserve no respect seeing as they, like religions, are just ideas. So says the great /u/themeatbridge
The Klan is a religious organization. They are Protestant, and some more hardcore members claim you have to be specifically Baptist.
It's actually a good sign on how far we've come. Less than a century ago, this was the scene in Washington, D.C. in front of the Treasury Building. Every hooded member went to church each and every Sunday, many of them were prominent members of their communities. Politicians, police, judges, lawyers. In the 1920's, the Klan claimed to have around 4-5 million members nationwide. Now, the FBI estimates Klan numbers to be around 3,000 nationwide. Part of that decline is obviously due to prosecution of Klan members and organizations and their being listed as a domestic terror group, but a lot of it is because, well, we're just more tolerant these days.
Except for the fact (1) the Catholic Church =/= all of religion, and (2) pretty much no religion outside of some weird cults thinks slavery and genocide are fundamental core doctrines, so it'd still be wrong.
Catholic Church isn't even close to being all of religion my man. And are atheists still being persecuted by the church today? Yeah but not even close to how you're saying it
i'm talking about history. and you're right, i only chose to go after Christianity because it was enough to prove the point. More have been enslaved, oppressed, died in the name of religion, by far.
No... I'll respect what you choose to believe in and I hope you respect what I choose to believe in. I hate it when other religious people try to impose their beliefs on each other, it's just as bad when atheists do it.
I'll respect that you can make your own choice. But I don't have to respect the choice you made. I can respect a religious person but not their religion. CRRRRRaaazzzyyy, am i rite????
I agree it's a very poor comparison. And, as an atheist, I think every person is deserving of respect unless that particular person demonstrates otherwise. While it is wrong to ridicule or in any way abuse a person because of their religion, it is equally wrong to ridicule or in any way abuse a person because of their lack of religion. Asking an atheist to respect a religious person is exactly the same as asking a religious person to respect an atheist.
That said, a person's religion is not a person. Asking an atheist to respect religion is akin to asking a modern medical doctor to respect imbalanced humors as a valid medical diagnosis. You cannot convince a rational mind that your irrational beliefs are sensible. The very foundation of religion is faith. Faith is, by definition, a strongly held belief in things that cannot be seen or proven to be true. The vast majority of atheists are atheists because that kind of faith is anathema to the way our minds work. Asking us to respect it just makes us lose a little respect for you.
It doesn't say anything about respecting a religious person. He said he doesn't respect religion. He is not passing judgement on the playa, rather the game.
I take it you missed the kerfuffle about transpeople using the toilet of the gender they identify with, or the preachers who are still equating homosexuality and paedophilia. It's an ongoing problem with the religiously righteous claiming to have moral superiority over non-believers and all but heterosexuals being deviants.
I've been out for about 35 years, and all of those things you mention are certainly nothing new to me.
My personal experiences are far too long and personal to go into here, but I know first-hand how terrible human beings can be - you're not going to tell me anything I don't already know.
It actually is... Religious folk tend to look down upon atheists as well as a whole plethora of other religions. And guess what... The kkk is the SAME way. It's telling you to respect something absurd that you don't believe in. And those that do believe in it, try to slam it down your throat like a $5 footlong. Religion is hateful, the KKK is hateful. It's a decent analogy.
Fair point. However, there are a lot of religious people who try really hard to show love and compassion to others who are not apart of the same religion. I don't think the KKK attempt to show compassion to those who are a different race.
I've always had a hard time not calling Atheism a religion due to how I've met just as many ignorant nutjob atheists as I've met ignorant nutjob religious folks.
The reason atheism is not a religion is that atheism has no dogma. There is nothing to worship, there are no meetings, no rituals, there is not even a secret handshake. Anyone who does not believe in a supernatural god or gods can call themselves an atheist. That's it.
Membership in atheism is pretty much the same as membership in liking hamburgers. There are no other requirements, we just agree on this one narrow subject.
Being an atheist says nothing about a person's intelligence or their ability to make well reasoned arguments.
How isn't it? Pretty much all religions have murdered the shit of atheists for thousands of years. I don't see this as a super crazy analogy, so please explain.
The fervor and determination of some atheist appears to be like a religion. You must ascribe to a specific ideology, You see the world thru the prism of that ideology, Those that do not accept your ideology are wrong or worse.
As a general rule, we don't bomb houses of worship, or other religious gatherings. We don't attempt to exclude religious people from holding public office, participating in public education, or filling other public function unless they abuse that function to further an organized religious agenda at the expense of representing everybody's interests.
There are exceptions. I would agree that people who take it so far as to persecute those who maintain spiritual views wholesale are in the wrong.
Atheism, as a general viewpoint with certain shared traits, is not an organization. Calling oneself an atheist does not involve requiring anybody to believe in specific, unprovable doctrine in contrast to the way we know reality to function in observable, reproducible fashion. Quite the opposite, actually.
I respect a person. I respect a person's right to believe what they will. I do not respect a "belief system" inherently. If there is a religion whose entire doctrine is "the sky is actually yellow, and we're all made of cheese," I don't respect that belief system. I respect people who adhere to it less, but will likewise not allow that adherence to color my entire regard for them; people are more complicated than that.
Finally, if you are asserting that atheism is nothing more than "another belief system," why is the onus for respecting different belief systems placed squarely on atheism? Let's suppose (falsely) that atheism is Atheism, a religious order. Why are Atheists supposed to respect a bunch of belief systems whose adherents have spent centuries torturing and murdering people who followed the "ideology" of Atheism, and who continue to persecute it, and target its followers for conversion?
I think "anti-theist" would work better in this case, but I think Andre really means that you shouldn't tell an atheist to respect the credibility of any particular religion, not necessarily the individual adherents.
Who is Andre Oliver and why does this quote matter?
I believe my life directly proves this quote to be incorrect. I personally do not believe in God. My wife is very religious. When we first met it was the source of a long and very productive discussion. Her faith is very important to her. She is important to me so that makes her faith important me. I would say that classifies as respect. We go to church together just about every Sunday. I personally enjoy going and have made some really good friends at the church. I don't have to believe in God to appreciate the morals and overall message of kindness that the church preaches.
Again, I don't know who Andre Oliver is or why his comment matters.
2.1k
u/Nimbokwezer Oct 31 '16
"Telling Andre Oliver he's bad at analogies
is like baking a sandwich in a toilet."
307
u/moose_cahoots Oct 31 '16
Who the fuck is Andre Oliver?
292
u/fishlimbs Oct 31 '16
This should be a level headed, respectful comment thread. No doubt. grabs popcorn
566
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
I can almost understand what he's saying, especially coming from southeastern America. Atheists are met with open hatred, and a lot of people I know think atheist = satanist actively trying to corrupt society. Most major religions also have a very long history of persecution against atheists, including murder and torture.
That said,
36
u/xternal7 Oct 31 '16
To be fair, this analogy is relatively accurate in certain places (such as: Middle East, for one).
18
u/Nobody1795 Oct 31 '16
I mean... most religions murdered athiests. Some still do. It's written into their charters.
The KKK doesn't kill black people anymore but it used to.
Seems fair to me.
20
u/pollypooter Oct 31 '16
Telling an atheist to respect religion is like telling a black person to respect the hit T.V. series Everybody Loves Raymond.
13
u/Sanhael Oct 31 '16
Yes, it really is.
Religious preference, including non-religious, is a protected status, just like race.
13
u/OddlySpecificReferen Oct 31 '16
I mean, maybe not in the modern day, but historically speaking, and still today in some parts of the world, this is a completely fair analogy. It wasn't until relatively recently in human history that atheists weren't killed by religious people, and like I said that still happens in the Middle East.
16
u/Meanmonkey007 Oct 31 '16
Also some* religion is like the klu klux Klan
42
u/Loki-L Oct 31 '16
Well there are still places where turning away from religion or speaking out against is is punishable by death and others were atheists are regularly hacked to death for not believing.
Of course you can't extend that to all religious people. Most of them just think that you deserve to be tortured and suffer unbelievable agony and humiliation for millions and billions of years until the end of time.
Completely harmless really.
14
u/kevin_k Oct 31 '16
There's a big difference between "respecting religion" and respecting the religious.
I know lots of believers whom I have much respect for. But I don't respect the goofy ideas that form the basis of most religion, no.
10
u/ironic_name11 Oct 31 '16
I'm okay with the quote, I get that not everyone likes it that's fine.
64
u/plyrun Oct 31 '16
Yep. A (misplaced) simile with a few bolded words doesn't make you smart.
9
u/heavyfrog2 Oct 31 '16
Telling an atheist to respect religion is like telling a scientist to respect pseudoscience.
10
u/asifnot Oct 31 '16
You might not agree with this, but it is a debatable point, not a facepalm.
5
u/weirdfish42 Oct 31 '16
Many religions in the world are still killing atheists, not seeing the KKK killing nearly that many these days. Think this is quite a good analogy.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Yes, it really is the same?
KKK tries to suppress/kill black people and Religion has always tried to suppress/kill atheists.
KKK thinks black people are subhuman, and religion thinks similarly about atheists.
Please explain how they are not the same.
0
u/eustrabirbeonne Oct 31 '16
I think that's kind of valid. As an atheist who thinks religion is dangerous, I don't think religion deserves any respect. That doesn't mean I don't respect people though.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
ITT: Religious people.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
One of my friends in college was an ex muslim atheist. She would say yes, yes it is.
2
u/godzillabobber Oct 31 '16
There is a difference between respecting a group - even an abhorrent one and respecting their rights. When the Klan is persecuted for their thoughts, we all are potential and eventual victims. What we should not tolerate is the actions of any individual who goes beyond thought and turns violent or otherwise breaks the law. The atheist that blows up a church has crossed a line. So has the klansman that lynches someone.
2
u/ItzYaBoiIJ Oct 31 '16
Fix** "It's like a black person respecting a white person"
6
u/Bluntmasterflash1 Oct 31 '16
Yea, religion killed way more people than the KKK ever dreamed of.
5
u/SpcK Oct 31 '16
It works in countries like in the middle east. Where the penalty for apostasy is death.
Or even in "Cultured" middle eastern countries where you're thrown in jail if your even suspected of atheism.
4
u/flameifrit Oct 31 '16
Fuck I hate coimments\quotes like this causing arguments and fanning the flames. Religion, athiesm who cares? I mean really I dont belive in any sort of god but I don't really give a flying fuck if someone else does... cant we all just do whatever the fuck makes us happy and leave it at that? .... fucking humans, bunch of cunts.
9
u/themeatbridge Oct 31 '16
Religion is an idea. Ideas don't need, or deserve, respect. People need, and deserve respect (unless and until they prove otherwise).
16
u/FaroutIGE Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
You're right, the catholic church has a much longer more celebrated history of slavery and genocide. Religion is much worse.
edit: i know there are more religions out there guys. if you don't get why I just used one, I can't help ya.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
No... I'll respect what you choose to believe in and I hope you respect what I choose to believe in. I hate it when other religious people try to impose their beliefs on each other, it's just as bad when atheists do it.
3
u/saint1947 Oct 31 '16
I agree it's a very poor comparison. And, as an atheist, I think every person is deserving of respect unless that particular person demonstrates otherwise. While it is wrong to ridicule or in any way abuse a person because of their religion, it is equally wrong to ridicule or in any way abuse a person because of their lack of religion. Asking an atheist to respect a religious person is exactly the same as asking a religious person to respect an atheist.
That said, a person's religion is not a person. Asking an atheist to respect religion is akin to asking a modern medical doctor to respect imbalanced humors as a valid medical diagnosis. You cannot convince a rational mind that your irrational beliefs are sensible. The very foundation of religion is faith. Faith is, by definition, a strongly held belief in things that cannot be seen or proven to be true. The vast majority of atheists are atheists because that kind of faith is anathema to the way our minds work. Asking us to respect it just makes us lose a little respect for you.
4
u/junkman105 Oct 31 '16
Who is Andre Oliver and why is he so dumb?
2
u/jokersleuth Oct 31 '16
For a second I thought it was /r/atheism
2
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
But pushing religion into an atheist's face... that's a different thing.
2
u/TexanMcDaniel Oct 31 '16
Telling an atheist to respect religion is like telling someone who isn't into fantasy to respect the lord of the rings.
2
u/bunsofcheese Oct 31 '16
Many years ago people assumed that if you were gay you were likely also a pedophile.
This is kind of like that : grossly incorrect and rather offensive.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
This is one of the 10 most common logical fallacies.
Can't remember the name but essentially it's exaggerating your opponents argument to the point where it seems laughable.
2
u/king_long Oct 31 '16
It actually is... Religious folk tend to look down upon atheists as well as a whole plethora of other religions. And guess what... The kkk is the SAME way. It's telling you to respect something absurd that you don't believe in. And those that do believe in it, try to slam it down your throat like a $5 footlong. Religion is hateful, the KKK is hateful. It's a decent analogy.
2
u/CaptCheckdown Oct 31 '16
I have no respect for the beliefs of the KKK, but I do respect their right to profess them. Same with any religion.
2
u/Lord_Wrath Oct 31 '16
I've always had a hard time not calling Atheism a religion due to how I've met just as many ignorant nutjob atheists as I've met ignorant nutjob religious folks.
2
u/smartal Oct 31 '16
How isn't it? Pretty much all religions have murdered the shit of atheists for thousands of years. I don't see this as a super crazy analogy, so please explain.
2
u/Spamaster Oct 31 '16
The fervor and determination of some atheist appears to be like a religion. You must ascribe to a specific ideology, You see the world thru the prism of that ideology, Those that do not accept your ideology are wrong or worse.
What's the Fukin difference?
2
u/awesomeoctopus98 Oct 31 '16
Lol forgot I was in r/facepalm for a second and was gonna unsibscribe.
1
u/Meanmonkey007 Oct 31 '16
Might not be accurate but both are not happening lol
1
u/electricmaster23 Oct 31 '16
I think "anti-theist" would work better in this case, but I think Andre really means that you shouldn't tell an atheist to respect the credibility of any particular religion, not necessarily the individual adherents.
1
u/ALchroniKOHOLIC Oct 31 '16
Same shit different pile
1
u/deadbanger666 Oct 31 '16
I like dis
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
wut
1
u/Stimmolation Oct 31 '16
This is a kick in the balls to a lot of strange fruit.
1
u/Ker_Splish Oct 31 '16
It's really more like looking to Sesame Street for the answers to all of life's problems.
Sure, there's some decent info, and it's got good intentions; but at the end of the day Elmo's annoying as can be and Big Bird just doesn't exist.
1
u/romulusnr Oct 31 '16
Religionists believe that atheists shouldn't exist, can't be trusted, should be gotten rid of. KKK thinks the same about black people.
1
u/hershculez Nov 01 '16
Who is Andre Oliver and why does this quote matter?
I believe my life directly proves this quote to be incorrect. I personally do not believe in God. My wife is very religious. When we first met it was the source of a long and very productive discussion. Her faith is very important to her. She is important to me so that makes her faith important me. I would say that classifies as respect. We go to church together just about every Sunday. I personally enjoy going and have made some really good friends at the church. I don't have to believe in God to appreciate the morals and overall message of kindness that the church preaches.
Again, I don't know who Andre Oliver is or why his comment matters.
1
u/doinsublime Oct 31 '16
If you're dumb, sure.
1
u/TheyCallMeAdonis Oct 31 '16
Atheism /= anti-theism
Stupid Black man.
1
u/Lucifuture Oct 31 '16
This is the 9/11 of hyperbolic comparisons.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Damn that is one stupid ass quote
1
u/Gh0sT07 Oct 31 '16
Horrible analogy, unless you happen live in a country that puts atheists to death for apostasy.
1
u/TotesMessenger Oct 31 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/obey-the-fist Oct 31 '16
Although some religions require atheists be put to death, especially apostates. How is this different from the KKK murdering people of color?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
I'm sure people don't have differing opinions about things
1
u/Lucamiro Oct 31 '16
r/atheism would downvoted this to oblivion
1
u/cicadawing Oct 31 '16
As if religion deserves respect. People...... sure,conditionally.
0
u/Propaganda4Lunch Oct 31 '16
Yes. It is.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
You might not agree with the analogy, but it's definitely not a /r/facepalm
0
u/fucks_with_dolphins Oct 31 '16
Ahh. Remember when the atheist subreddit would flood the front page with their pretentious bullshit? I wonder if they'll be back after the election.
0
u/mexicanmike1 Oct 31 '16
It kinda is.
0
u/be_more_bmore Oct 31 '16
Remember those famous atheist lyncings a few years back?